48: Screw Parenting Rules, You Need Parenting Values with Rachel Nielson

Honestly, this is a topic for everyone. Today’s show applies to all of us, whether we are parents, future parents, or someone who needs to heal their inner child. I’m excited to be joined by Rachel Nielson, the host and founder of the 3in30 Podcast. She interviewed me on a recent episode, and she’s returning the favor by joining me for this important conversation. Join us!

Show Highlights:

●  The structure for Rachel’s 3in30 podcast: 3 actionable takeaways in 30 minutes

● Why parenting values are far superior to parenting rules

● Why success in motherhood is most definable by the connection we have with our kids

● What Rachel teaches in her program, Self-Assured Motherhood

● Why there is an opportunity to parent your inner child by identifying your core parenting values

● How you can have different values for different seasons of your life and family

● How Rachel’s program helps women identify and uncover their values by looking inward and outward

● Why our values might be in conflict with each other

● How parenting partners can handle conflict in their individual parenting values

● Takeaways from Rachel about embracing your values, accepting them, and living into them authentically

Resources and Links:

Connect with Rachel Nielson: Website and Podcast

Find Rachel’s list of parenting values: www.3in30podcast.com/values

Mentioned in this episode: The Family Firm by Emily Oster

Connect with KC: Website, TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust, this is struggle care. And I'm your host, Casey Davis. And this is going to be another podcast about parenting. And as always, I encourage you to listen, whether you are a parent or a child. And that's all of us, like all of us have been children at one time. And I do my best to talk about parenting in such a way that if you are a parent, you are getting some really valuable information to us. And if you are an adult child, that you maybe can have an experience of healing your inner child listening to the kind of parenting that you deserved. So I have an awesome guest today, I have Rachel Nielsen, who is the host of the 3 in 30 podcasts that I was on recently. Rachel, hello,

    Rachel Nielson 0:44

    hello, thank you so much for having me.

    KC Davis 0:46

    Absolutely. So tell us a little bit like introduce yourself a little bit, what would you like people to know?

    Rachel Nielson 0:51

    Yeah, so I am a former high school English teacher turned podcaster. And stay at home mom. And from my experience, teaching teenagers how to take big complicated ideas and boil them down into thesis statements. I sort of do that now with parenting topics. So all of my podcasts are three actionable takeaways in 30 minutes, because I know moms don't have a lot of time to listen to parenting resources. A lot of them certainly don't have time to read these big full parenting books that get put out on the market. And so I'm like, I'll just give you the three takeaways make it as actionable and direct as I can. And Casey, everyone loved your episode that you recently did about rethinking housework, and three takeaways for that. And I live in the mountains of Idaho with my two kids, and my dog and my husband, and I love where I live. And I love what I do.

    KC Davis 1:48

    I'm so glad you're here. Because when you reach out to me with your idea for a topic of parenting, according to your values, I was excited about that. Because there's something that I've always said is like, when I became a parent, I had so many ideas about how I was going to raise my kids and I read like every blog there was, right, like I was like, okay, the best way to feed is breastfeeding, and then baby led weaning, and the best way to give birth is ABCDEFG. And the best way to to play is for wooden toys that we rotate out every three, you know, days, that don't do anything electronic. And then No, I'm not going to speak in a baby voice because you're supposed to speak like a normal voice to your kids. And I'm gonna read a lot to them. I mean, we're not going to do any screen time. And then we're gonna go to a Montessori school. And I mean, I just had, it's like any decision that you need to make in parenting, there is a blog out there that exists about the best way to do it. But what I found is that there is no blog that tells you how you're supposed to follow all of those blogs at once. And it was really disillusioning to go through the first few years of parenting and watch myself like, feel incapable of keeping up with all of these commitments about this idealized version of how he was going to be the perfect parent. And that kind of more for me, and this idea of like, I don't need parenting rules, I need parenting values, so that like I can make the decision about what's important right now. Like I realized I had to prioritize things. And the truth is like when I prioritize things, wooden toys and screentime and baby led weaning, like, didn't really ever make it to the top.

    Rachel Nielson 3:33

    Yeah. And you're so right, Casey, that there's no blog out there that captures it all. And also that that can tell you how to parent your unique children with your unique values and contexts that you're coming from as an individual Mother and I have found that my values are what matter the most in how I raise my children, the lens through which I can do the best job for them is by being true to my values and bringing to them who I actually am and what I actually care about, instead of what I think I should care about, or who I think I should be. And that took me a while to figure out to my first few years of parenting, I had oh so many shoulds that and I was miserable, because I wasn't living up to them. And I finally realized that I'm the only person who can give my kids a happy and fulfilled mom. And the way to do that is by being myself within my motherhood and bringing myself to them. And it's made all the difference in my level of fulfillment in day to day life as a mom and also I think, in the success quote, unquote, that I'm able to have as a mom because that is not definable by a set of rules or a standard it's really definable by the connection that I have with my kids. That comes from showing them who I am.

    KC Davis 4:58

    Yeah, I like that. And you know, this idea of values it like sounds really good. But I never got past that point of like, but how do I figure out what my values are? Because I feel like when we ever have that conversation with people, we automatically go to kinda like the fluffy stuff like kindness is a value and honesty is a value in it, right? But I have a feeling that you're gonna help us flush out something a little more actionable than that. Because like, how do I do with my kids toys? If I'm like, kindness is my value, like, I need a better like, kind of rubric to look through to know. And also that, like, whenever we talk about values being like kindness and honesty, like nobody would be like, Well, I think I'm not going to choose kindness as my value. But in reality, like, there's actually a lot of kind of almost morally neutral values. And we don't all have to have the same ones.

    Rachel Nielson 5:47

    Yes, 100%. I feel I teach women in a program called self assured motherhood, we do an entire month about values. And one of the first things that I tell them is that we're talking about the morally neutral values. We're not talking about like whether or not to kill someone, which I'm pretty sure we all agree, is not a good thing. And we all have a value against, we're talking about things like adventure like is that one of your values that is morally neutral, if you really value adventure, and that brings you joy, as a mom, and you want to take your kids on lots of adventures, wonderful. If you don't, and you value routine and stability, that doesn't make you any less of a good mother, you just value different things. So these are morally neutral, they are not tied to religion, or any religious principles. And you're right, Casey, that if you looked at a list of them, you might think, well, these all matter like, you know, kindness matters, and so does honesty and loyalty and productivity, yes, they all matter. And also, some do matter more to you than others. And that's okay. And sometimes it takes a level of self awareness to be able to sort through and sift out and figure out, I'm not saying that kindness doesn't matter to me at all, it does. But what really makes my heart sing is adventure. And so yes, of course, we're going to have like, we're going to be a kind family. But when it comes to prioritizing day to day life and activities, it doesn't resonate with me as much to think about kindness as it does to think about adventure. Whereas another mom might much more resonate with kindness. And she is like consciously thinking about taking our kids to serve the neighbor, or to go and sing Christmas carols at the nursing home or teaching them to be very aware of the people that they're interacting with at the grocery store and making eye contact and chatting with them. Again, not that the other mom is saying, We don't care about being kind, and we're going to be mean to everyone around us. But just that what really kind of gives them that zing of joy and excitement within their day to day life is different, because they have different things that they value.

    KC Davis 8:04

    And I wouldn't even say that's necessarily kindness as the value, it's almost like altruism is the value. You know, and the other thing I love about this, Rachel is that I'm seeing so much potential for me to also parent, my inner child in this like, and there's some conversations that I think are important about, like, we don't want to swing too far in the opposite direction. Like if you had a parent that yelled a lot, and you decide that like, I'm never gonna get angry, like, obviously, you know, we don't and then we just never set any boundaries, because we're afraid to set boundaries or be angry or punish or do any of this like, okay, at the end of the day, we need to be the parent that our kids need, not the parent that we needed. However, this week, when you talked about a spirit of adventure versus a spirit of I want to say like coziness and familiarity, my heart automatically, like leapt at one of those, and I know it came from kind of like a place of woundedness of like, there might have been a little too much chaos in my childhood for me to like, want adventure to be it right. And like I would sort of even like adventure is to me wouldn't just be like, Oh, hiking, it also be like, Oh, we're enrolled in so many sports, that like, every day, we're out of the house, always on the go. And so like that resonated with me where it was like, No, like coziness, and home and meals at home and predictability. I mean, is that part of it? Like, do you see that in parents? I mean, not that I would never tell my kids that can't be adventurous, but that like it's totally okay for me to lean into the one that is going to be more healing and more whole for me.

    Rachel Nielson 9:41

    Yeah, I mean, totally okay for you to do that. And also, I think that it's part of the work of healing your inner child to figure out if what you think is a value is actually a trauma response, and it's something that you want to work to let go of, and it's fine either way. way, you know, so you might say no, really the desire for coziness and stability and routine. It's not just that it makes me feel good because of the trauma from my past, it's that it actually makes me feel connected to who I feel I deeply AM. And that wasn't honored in my past. And so I want to lean into that with my own family versus you do feel a pull to adventure, but you are tamping that down, because everything in you is saying like, no, that's dangerous, you don't want to give your kids an experience that was similar to what you had. So that's more of a trauma response, if that makes sense. And only you can sort of sift that out and figure out what is truly a core value versus what may have become a core value, even though it's not really you because of negative things that happened in your past. And I wish that I could give like a formula for how to figure out the difference. I just think that so many of us are not even aware of the values conversation. And so even just listening to this podcast, some listeners are going to start looking for and thinking about their values in a different way. And it's a lifelong exercise in getting to know yourself and thinking, you know, I always thought that I really valued this. But I think that's actually because of hard things that happened to me in my past. And now that I've healed to a certain level, I want to start experiencing and experimenting with other ways of living. And I may come back to the thing and see it really was one of my core values all along. And it wasn't just a trauma response, or I may be ready to embrace something different that I previously had not realized was one of my core values, because it had been so buried by all of the hard stuff in my past, if that makes sense.

    KC Davis 11:50

    Totally. And I think I'm gonna we're gonna get into like some more specifics on how we kind of dig in. But I have kind of two thoughts as we're talking now. One is, I read Emily Foster's book, the family firm. And she talked a little bit about this concept, but just not the one example always stuck with me. She talks about how, you know, they have family dinner every night. And I think that what our society has done with the idea of family dinner is very much like over moralized it like it is the only right thing to do. And it's has all these benefits. And you know, if you don't do it XYZ, and I just really finally figured out that like just because something has benefits, doesn't mean that your child is going to be harmed if they don't get it. Mm hmm. Like, yes, there are benefits to having family dinner, and she decided that that was a value for her over, like being enrolled in extracurriculars. But extracurriculars also have value and like it would be perfectly okay for a family to say actually, like we value, what's it called, like team sports and being a part of a team and commitment and follow through, and discipline and hard work. And we can do all that obviously, with kindness, or you could do it with, you know, competition. But the idea is kind of mind blowing that when you're looking at a choice, that it may not be what does a good parent do? And what does a bad parent do? It might be? Here's a really good thing. And here's another good thing, and I can't have them or do them both at the same time, at least right now. And that I get to pick whichever one is sort of calling to me. The second thing I thought was, Do you think there's also room for like, having different values at different seasons? Like if I pick adventure? Am I stuck with that forever?

    Rachel Nielson 13:35

    No, absolutely not. I tell women in my program, I'm not saying I'm saying Try these values on so I have them actually identify, go through an activity, which we can talk a little bit about, because I would love to give your listeners some concrete takeaways for how to find their values. So I have them do that. And I tell them, you know, come up with five, and you're trying them on. And this is not going on your tombstone. So try it out for a while. And often we'll find that like, actually, the word kindness doesn't resonate. It's more compassion. And there's such a subtle difference there. But it's the word that resonates in your soul. That means something different to you or Casey, you've mentioned, like, that sounds more like altruism, like someone might think, oh, yeah, it's more altruism than kindness. But you have to start with a framework of identifying a few values and trying them on and then you sort of shift and change. And you may find that in a few years when your kids are in a different phase, that you do uncover a different value and that things sort of shift and change and that's totally okay.

    KC Davis 14:41

    Okay, let's take a short break for a sponsor, who we are very grateful for, and we're grateful for all of our sponsors, and we will come back. Okay, so we're back with Rachel and we're talking about how would I go about like, what if I'm listening to this and I'm thinking like, Wait, this seems like such a much better way of of parenting and frankly, like as you're talking I'm like this is just a better way of living? Yes, yes. Like, because it's not just parents who are stuck in this, like, you know, optimize everything all the time make every right parenting decision or you're a piece of shit. Like, I feel like humans in general, a lot of us are stuck in that place of how do we decide this job? Or this job? Or how do we decide to go here? Or go there? Or what do we do? How do we decide what our values are? If we want to move past the sort of fluffy, ambiguous stuff?

    Rachel Nielson 15:28

    Mm hmm. Yeah, for sure. So I mentioned that I have a an exercise I have women in my program do and I've actually made that available for your listeners, if they want, they can download it is the exact exercise I lead women through. And I'll put that at three and 30 podcast.com/values. So you can go and pull it up. And the first half of it is sort of brain storming, freewrite questions about what you loved as a child? And what made you come alive? And what sort of made your heart sing, I asked a question in there about, have you ever been involved in a group project or a job? Something that like you felt incredibly fulfilled doing it? And can you identify what it was about that particular project or role that really fit you? And so you go through these kind of brainstorm questions, and you try to pull out some themes of words that can capture, you know, and bring together the common threads between your answers to these different questions. So you're really looking inward, to try to figure out because your values have been with you your whole life, whether or not you were aware of them. So it's more of an uncovering than like a deciding on what your values are. Like, if I were told to decide what I wanted my values to be, it might be a different list, then truly getting honest with myself about, but who am I and who have I always been, and what has been important to me. I remember, as a child, middle schooler, noticing the kids that sat alone at lunch, and really worrying for them and trying to sometimes I'd actually, when I was at my best, I would actually go and sit with them and make an effort. Other times, I wasn't at my best, I wasn't confident enough to do that. But I noticed them. And now in my adulthood, I realize that that's a little unusual for a child that young to be noticing people like that. And that's something that I kind of wrote down in my brainstorm of, I've always just had a tender heart for the people who maybe are on the margins. And that is a sign that one of my values has something to do with compassion, kindness, service, like the divinity of other people inclusion, yes. And so I can play with those words a little bit. But recalling those specifics from my childhood helps me to get there. And so that's the first half of the exercise is really looking inward and seeing what you can uncover about yourself for yourself.

    KC Davis 18:03

    Well, before you do the second half, I want to play around with this for a second. So when you said that my thought immediately went to Thanksgiving, growing up, every Thanksgiving, I would go see my family that lived like a state away. And I had a cousin that was my age. And we had a bunch of older cousins, and my mom had two sisters and a brother and both of her parents and literally like everyone came. And we would sit around and play dominoes and eat Thanksgiving food. And it was like that was literally every Thanksgiving up until I was probably 16. And for some reason, that's right, where my mind goes. So if that if that's where my mind goes when you said like, think about something in your childhood that kind of like you enjoyed or made you feel alive, or has that comfort, like, how would I tease a value from that?

    Rachel Nielson 18:52

    Mm hmm. Well, I think I mean, I can just throw out a bunch of different words that you could try on sort of based around that like, to me it feels like family, connection, togetherness, coziness, which you already mentioned, traditions, I don't know. But those are some of the words that come to mind. For me, that can be teased from the fact that those times with your family meant so much to you, there's a value there. Can you think of any other words based on that? On your experience?

    KC Davis 19:26

    I think maybe the word community comes to mind because definitely family like that's part of it. But it kind of extends a little more than that, that that community of just like right where you fit in where there's people around and everything is kind of easy, like nothing is pretense if that makes sense. Like it's not always easy, but that idea of kind of just being surrounded by people.

    Rachel Nielson 19:51

    Yeah. And you just said there were nothing's pretend. So maybe from that you tease out like authenticity is very important to you feeling known and know seeing and loving the people around you in a deep, intimate way that's not fake is very important to you. So you and it's super helpful to talk this out. So to do this with a friend, or someone who knows you well, or a sister or a therapist, and say, you know, ask them say, this is the moment that stands out to me, what threads or themes do you see? And then when they give you some ideas, you always have to come back to yourself and say, nobody else can tell you what your values are, you have to be able to say what words resonate and give me that little zing inside. I sometimes think about Marie Kondo, who did the life changing Magic of Tidying Up and she'd say, when you hold your possessions, they should give you a little like King mark of joy. Yeah, spark joy. And that's how it should be with these values of like, hold these different words, kind of metaphorically. And ask yourself, does it give me a little zing, a little spark of joy? If so, then there's something there that I can explore as value.

    KC Davis 20:59

    You know, what's kind of wild is that you mentioned earlier, you know, these aren't necessarily like, we can look back and realize these have always been our values. And I'm already realizing the things that I've done as a person. And as a parent, according to that value. I mean, like, literally, we ended up moving to a different city for my husband's job. And like, pretty quickly realized, like, Oh, I'm not thriving here. And we talked about moving back where family was, but that kind of came in conflict with some other values that we had about where we were and why. And we ended up moving to a suburb, and specifically to live two miles from a good friend of mine, who was like, come here, live near me, we will be community with each other. And then shortly after that, actually talked to my mother about moving down, and she moved down. And we found we went and found a home for her, and helped her through the process of moving, she now lives 10 minutes from me, I see her multiple times a week, like my friend just stopped by to get my vacuum cleaner to try it. And like we sent our kids to school based on the idea that we could know our neighbors. And I'm like, oh, like, okay, so that makes sense on a big picture scale, right about like making those decisions. But, you know, even earlier when I was like, How do I decide what to do about the toys? Like, how would I decide how community applies to our toys? You know what I mean?

    Rachel Nielson 22:24

    Yeah, well, I love that you were just able to parse out how the memory from your childhood connects to the things you love in your current life, that's beautiful to hear how it all connects together. And I think that not every value is going to apply to every situation like Could your value for community connect back to what you do with the toys in your home, maybe, maybe you decide like, Oh, we're gonna have, you know, I'm keeping all these toys, like I'm keeping more toys than maybe another mom would, because I love to have my kids have their friends here. And to have lots of toys available so that it feels like a community place where people can gather. And that's why you know, my physical things reflect the center value. And also, maybe your value for community has nothing to do with your toys, and you decide to get rid of a bunch of them, because you also have a value for simplicity and order. And that's okay, too. And sometimes our values do get, they do sort of contradict each other. And that's when it gets tough. Like when women say to me, I have a value of connection. But I also have a value of productivity, or I have a value of connection. But I also have a value of order. And so my kids want me to play with them. And my connect my value towards connection says you should do that a good mom would do that. But I'm like dying over the messy kitchen. And my value of order says I desperately want to clean this up right now. And again, I wish there was like a magic formula I could give you of how to decide which value wins out in that moment. But I think it's a constant, give and take. And you just have to say like, right now, I am prioritizing connection. And order can wait. Or right now I'm going to clean my kitchen because I recognize we spent all morning together at the library or whatever. And that value has been fulfilled. And it's okay for me to lean into this other value without feeling guilty about it.

    KC Davis 24:27

    Yeah, I mean, as long as you're picking both right, like not that you can't pick them at the same time, but you could certainly have them in the same season. Yes. And get the benefits of both and even get the benefits of not choosing the other one from time. Like saying no to playing is good for you and your kids. Yeah, it wouldn't be good if that was all you ever said. And you know, saying no to the kitchen is good for you and your kids, but it wouldn't be good if you always said no to it.

    Rachel Nielson 24:52

    Mm hmm. Yeah. And again, just having the words and the understanding around values. I feel like gives you So much more self compassion and ability to coach yourself. It's a win win situation. Yeah. And to say to yourself, this is hard for you, Rachel. And I do I kind of have this like inner voice that talks to me and is this compassionate cheerleader. And it kind of talks to me in the third person, and says, this is hard for you, Rachel, because you really value order, but you also really value connection, and your best friend needs you right now. And so you do not have to feel bad about leaving your house in disarray, because you are following another value. And so it just gives you this sort of like, way to comfort yourself and cheer yourself on. So you're not shaming yourself for the things you're not able to accomplish at every moment of the day.

    KC Davis 25:40

    Let me tell you that I value rest, and sleep. Yes, I don't mean in like a, you know, a ha weight. I mean, in like a legitimate there are major decisions that I have made around valuing rest and sleep. And it's a big value to me because of how connected it is to my mental health, of how connected it is, to my physical health of how connected is to My psychological health, and just the acknowledgement of like, that's one of the biggest ways that I, as a mother choose myself. Mm, yeah, amidst sort of the chaos of parenting. And I mean, major decisions that people might not agree with. And I sleep, train my children, I am one of the biggest kind of attachment parenting people, and they're always so surprised to hear that I sleep train my children. Because the value of sleep one,

    Rachel Nielson 26:28

    yes. And the value of rest, I actually have never considered the word rest as a value until just now when you said it. And I think that's a beautiful value to hold. Like, think of all the different ways that rest can manifest itself in your whole life, not just talking about sleep, but in your in the way you set up your home, and the way you engage in your relationships, where people feel very at ease with you, they feel restful in your presence, because of what you bring to their life. You know, I think that's an incredibly unique value that you could bring into so many areas of your life, and that it sort of takes a big level of self acceptance in our productivity obsessed culture, you know, to say, actually, I don't value productivity, I value rest. And that is not a moral failing. That is an incredibly beautiful thing that I bring to my life and the lives of other people.

    KC Davis 27:22

    Wow. Yeah, because I do and have fun. You know, we talking earlier about you know, nobody prepares you how to parent your own children. And the truth is, is like my kids, they came and I was like, oh, no, your people, you're not ideas or blank slates, like you are people with your own brains and personalities. And, you know, I wasn't expecting to have neurodivergent kids, but here we are. And, you know, I have been doing for some time now, what I refer to what others refer to as low demand parenting. We don't have a lot of rules in our house. I mean, obviously, safety is important. And we do believe that boundaries are important. And you know, because I value Sleep, my kids actually go to bed at 730 Every night and will for a long time and rest, right? So that's value for them and me because I need that time as well. So I don't want to sound like you know, nobody, there's no structure in our home. But if I can say yes, I do, right, I don't care where you eat, I don't care what you're wearing, I don't care if you color on yourself, I don't really mind for color on the wall, right? Like, I'll tell you which wall to color on. But I'm now realizing that that is connected to probably a lot of values, but is connected to rest. Yeah, everyone just rests like it's just a restful place.

    Rachel Nielson 28:33

    And when you are tied into your values, when you are clued into your unique values, I feel like you are less judgmental of other people, which is a beautiful way to live. You can look at other moms and say they value something different than I do and I don't need to judge them or downplay that. I also don't need to judge myself. You know, I, you mentioned sleep training. I have had a whole conversation with a young mom that I love who's gone back and forth on whether or not to sleep train her baby and I've just said to her look, what do you love about motherhood, if you love you know co sleeping and having her with you and not you know, you do not have to sleep train your baby. But if you are miserable and unable to function during the day, because of the co sleeping you can sleep train your baby and it's she will be okay she will be okay either way, as long as she has a mom who is honoring herself and her needs as well as honoring her baby at the same time. And building a home life where the mom is happy and at ease or at least as happy as she can be. You're never going to be perfectly happy as a mom or a human. Because life is hard and there's hormones and postpartum depression and everything else. But you it's okay to build a family life around what you need and value as a mom and it could look totally different than another mom and you don't need to judge that other mom for the way she does it.

    KC Davis 30:00

    Okay, let's take another break to hear from a sponsor, we'll come right back. Okay, so you were going to tell us what the second step is?

    Rachel Nielson 30:07

    Yes, yes. So in the first part of my exercise, you're looking inward to see what you can, you know, tease out about your values in the second part, you can look outward and start looking at lists of potential values. So I actually have a list of 100 values on this worksheet. And you can either just go through the list and circle instar. Or if you are more of a hands on learner, you can actually cut them out. So they're little slips of paper, and then you sort of sort them. And you can sort them any way that you want. But the way that I often tell women to do it is to make three piles. One is not that important to me, one is important to me, and the other is most important to me. And so you take these words, and you put them in the three piles. And again, I remind women that you know, the pile that you're basically tossing out, you're not saying is not important to me at all, you're just saying is not as as important to me

    KC Davis 31:07

    wouldn't win in a cage match with a different value? Yes, exactly. I

    Rachel Nielson 31:10

    see, you're not saying like that you don't value health at all, if you put that in the category, but maybe that's just not one of your top values or priorities, and you don't build your life around, you know, your physical health, like some other people do. My husband is incredibly active and loves to, you know, eat lots of vegetables, and he has a different level of value around health than I do. And that's okay, like that would never be in my pile of top values. And it would be in his and that's okay.

    KC Davis 31:40

    You know, what's crazy about that is that I don't think it is for me either. And I've always felt really a lot of shame about that, because I know that like, I'm setting the stage for my kids and their health. But one of the things that I've never ways that I've never thought about it that I'm realizing and talking to you is that it isn't that I don't prioritize health, it's that I don't prioritize it above other values that are more important to me. But that's only in instances where health intersects with a different value. Like, if it's I'm going to puree, you know, the most organic, nutrient packed homemade baby food. I'm not going to do that, because I value rest. But rest is not always in the picture. When I'm deciding, do I grab this donut? Or do I grab these carrots? Like they're both right there, like I do multiple times a day make the decision? Hey, let's grab the carrots. And I mean, I'm not to say that doughnuts are not healthy. I'm just saying like in terms of, okay, am I going to feed them doughnuts all day? Or, you know, Hey, it's 100 degrees outside. So I'm not going to go outside and walk when my kids asked you because I'm not doing it. I don't know what but like, when it's 70 degrees outside, and they want to take a walk. I'm for it. And now and I feel like yes, let's do it. Let's get outside today. And oh my gosh, Rachel, the self compassion that just released inside of me realizing that I don't ignore health? Yes, I just I choose it in situations where it does not conflict with other values that are more important.

    Rachel Nielson 33:14

    Yes. Isn't it amazing the self compassion that it brings, as well as the compassion for other people that it brings the clarity that it brings? It's brought for me in parenting, like in co parenting with my husband, so much clarity around? Why is he so like adamant with them about certain things that I don't think are that important? where there might be conflict between us? Once I started thinking more about values, and I actually had my husband do this activity that I do with the women in my program. And once I knew what his values are, I could see like, oh, this really matters to him. That, you know, one example is that he really values he played tons of team sports growing up he but because he values, health and activity and all those things, and my son is not into it. And I was always like, why is he pressuring Noah to join these teams that Noah doesn't want to join? So then I had a conversation with Ryan and said, What's the values underneath that? And he said, Well, I want him to be active and move his body. I want him to build friendships and learn about teamwork. So we kind of identified the values underneath and I said, Okay, our son doesn't want to be in team sports. But I can tell that these values really matter to you. And they matter to me too. So what are some different ways that we can honor who our son is, and also bring these values in, and we came up with a plan and we brought my son and he's 12. So he has can have a lot of say in his life now. And we brainstorm together ways that he could work with a team. And so like joining the Lego team at at the middle school, the engineering team, and that he could move his body by riding his bike at the pump track and So we're meeting the values, while also diffusing the tension around specific activities that we sometimes as parents can get. So, like, caused so much conflict in our family, when really it's just a values issue underneath it.

    KC Davis 35:14

    Wow, Rachel, that is incredible. Because how many times do we do that we push our kids to do something. Because we know that there are benefits that we feel like are really important. But if we don't stop to realize, okay, it's not the soccer. Yeah, in and of itself, right. You know, it's the value underneath and like if your value and because as soon as you said that, where you said, as a team moving your body, I was like, well, theater does that,

    Rachel Nielson 35:38

    yes, so many different things can do that.

    KC Davis 35:42

    That's wild, it's, it reminds me of a conversation, I had my husband one time, he was a part of a fraternity and you know, fraternities have come under some hot water. And many, many years after he was gone from college, his own fraternity kind of gotten in trouble. And he was talking about, like, feeling those mixed emotions of, hey, I'm glad that like, things are changing, and things are going to be safer for women. And that, like parts of that culture are getting kind of snuffed out, like the dangerous parts of that culture and the gross misogynist parts of that culture. But I still find myself sad, because there were so many things that I valued that I got in that, you know, the feeling of brotherhood, the feeling of having someone to come home to the feeling of tradition, the feeling of sort of friends that are friends forever. And it was similar to that conversation, where it's like, okay, we can value those things. But when we identify what the values are, we can much more easily let go of things that might have kind of a net negative and go well, how can I find these values elsewhere?

    Rachel Nielson 36:46

    Yes, absolutely. And it can become such a connective activity for you and a partner to talk about it diffuses tension when you start talking about what's underneath the deeper person, why does this matter to you why, let's talk about it. And then you're then you know each other, it's intimate to know each other better. And then you're like, let's figure out together how to build our family life around these things that matter to both of us. And let's figure out what our shared values are and where we differ and respect that about each other and build a life around with an awareness of values underneath it.

    KC Davis 37:22

    Gosh, Rachel, I just think about how many parents are burning out because they are attempting to have every single value and the number one spot? Yes. Okay, we're gonna wind down a little bit. But I wanted to share with you something that I think is kind of funny, I heard someone say one time, you know that they don't have family rules, they have family values. And it was somewhat similar to this conversation. But they kind of said, you know, we have these four family values. And whenever my kids is they're getting older, like want to do something, you know, we don't have a rule about what time you need to be home or what things you're allowed to do. But we go to the family values and make the decision based on that. And so kind of similar to what you're talking about. But what was funny about it was I had just seen a tweet by this very bizarre there's this really funny account on Twitter called time scanner, and they sometimes tweet the most random things. And this was the tweet it said, be a Kermit the Frog, have a creative vision and no ego. Recognize the unique talents of those around you attract weirdos, manage chaos, show kindness Be sincere. And ever since I read that, for some reason, it is just stuck in my brain where I was like, that's what I want my family to be about. Those are the values attract weirdos, manage chaos, show kindness be sincere Hmm, that's beautiful. And anyways, I just wanted to share that with everybody because I was like, never has like a four sentences summed up what I care about about life before.

    Rachel Nielson 38:49

    Yeah, it like gave you that little zing in your heart. That's when you know, this resonates these are my values and like you could put that on your wall or frame it and put it in your kids rooms and, and talk about it a lot that we are a Kermit the Frog family. And this is what we value.

    KC Davis 39:04

    So Rachel, what do you want our listeners to know as they log off today,

    Rachel Nielson 39:09

    I want the listeners to know that whatever your values are, are good. And okay. And the more that you embrace the things that innately matter to you and start accepting who you actually are, instead of who you think you should be. The not only the more happy and fulfilled you will feel but the world will be blessed by it by you bringing who you actually are and owning it to the world. Whether that's just in your home or it's in your workplace. It's in the larger world and community. All of us will be blessed when we become more aware of our values, and we accept them and live into them.

    KC Davis 39:48

    I love that. Well Rachel, thank you so much. We will link that website that you mentioned earlier in the show notes for everyone. And I wish everyone a great day take care of yourselves and toodaloo

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

Christy Haussler
47: Best of Gentle Organizing with Alison Lush

Do you have too much stuff? As you look around your home, is it crowded and cluttered? Does your space make you feel burdened, unhappy, and frustrated? If you said–or shouted–YES, you can’t miss today’s show. Join me to learn more about gentle organizing. 

Alison Lush is a Certified Professional Organizer, Certified Virtual Organizer, and Master Trainer. After a 20-year catering career, Alison knew she needed better organization and management skills for her home and personal comfort. She learned to live and shop intentionally, creating and protecting the space in her home. Now she puts her expertise to work in helping others by empowering them and teaching them to put themselves at the center of their organization efforts. 

Show Highlights:

  • How Alison became an organizer with a gentle spirit

  • Why our interactions with our home, space, time, and belongings form the foundations of our lives

  • Why Alison’s focus is on “organic organizing”

  • Alison’s answer to a question sent in by Samantha about dealing with clutter, letting things go, and the functionality of her space

  • How to organize your space by using Zone 1, Zone 2, and Zone 3—and consider the frequency of access for each item

  • Ways to keep, honor, and display memorabilia by identifying the risk level in letting items go

  • How to consider the purpose of items in our lives in deciding to keep them or let them go

  • Alison’s answer to a question from Kitty about decorating, a sense of style, and learning to feel good about her space

  • How to reframe what might look crappy and rundown to you as a life well-lived, meaningful, and full of love

  • Why your decor should fuel you and recharge your batteries

  • Alison’s answer to a question from Aria about separating and managing work life and home life

  • How to legitimize, categorize, and systemize your space for the best functionality

  • Why the professional organizing industry has the reputation of telling people to “just get rid of your stuff”

Resources:

Connect with Alison: www.alisonlush.ca and TikTok   

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello sentient ball of stardust. Welcome to struggle care. I'm your host, KC Davis. And I'm taking a break this August, but I'm replaying for years some of my most downloaded episodes. And today we're going to talk about professional organizing. Doesn't it feel like something that only really rich people who have their life together do? Well, it's not. And I want to talk today about that with Allison lash. Since 2010, she has been studying everything related to how we manage our belongings, ideas about what we need acquisition, ownership, organization, lifestyle habits, decision making emotional attachments, and letting go. She is a professional organizer that certified in chronic disorganization, she brings a person centered approach to organizing, and it's really a different take on organizing than I've ever heard before. So if you're someone who struggles in your home, and you really wish that you could be a little more organized, but you need a gentle approach, this is for you, grab a drink of water, take your meds and take care of yourself. Well, I can't tell you how excited I am to have you on today. Because when I started my tic toc channel and I started talking about you know, cleaning being morally neutral and having your home serve you and not the other way around. I remember stumbling on your content, and being like, oh shit, she gets it like this is someone who I could totally see, I would invite her in to organize my home and you just had such a kind and gentle presence. And I feel like that is not something that I see a lot in organizers like usually you think of, you know, Personal Organizer, or professional organizer as someone who is like, let's get it. Let's go. You know, we're going to organize these books into rainbow color. And you but you just had such a different presence. And I wondered if you could talk just a minute about you know, how did you get that way?

    Alison Lush 1:52

    Well, I have to start by saying I'm going to take a little pause here and say I'm absolutely thrilled to be here. I am a massive big fan of yours. And I send everybody to your page, I say if you're following me, you have to be following KC. She is the bom b. There's it's amazing of the voice that you've created in the platform you've created. And I'm so grateful for your presence on social media, because people obviously need to hear what you are saying. And you add weight and volume to what I'm saying. So I want to say thank you and congratulations, just need to get it's really important to honor what you've done. It's tremendous amount of work. So oh well, it's all very true. I'm so thrilled that we found each other how did I get to where I am the short story because people can read a little bit about my background on my website, I don't let's not waste time getting into that I fell into the world of professional organizing. And I landed quite quickly in 2010 in a school, a professional school for professional organizers called the Institute for challenging disorganization. And I just felt comfortable there that's like those people, they just resonated with me in the way that they were talking. It's like I wanted to buddy up with them. And I wanted to invite them into my home, the vibe was just like all about where I felt comfortable. And the way I describe it today, my industry is that there's a spectrum. And on one end of the spectrum are people like me, and on the other end of the spectrum are people who are mad crazy about organizing the stuff. And there is nothing wrong with that. Because there are clients who want that there are clients, that's all they want come and make my house pretty. And that's what I want. And because that's a it's an open market, and there's people who need that the fact that organizers specialize in that more power to them. But there's this other end of the spectrum where what I'm focusing on is people, I'm not really very concerned about the books and about the boxes, and about the cups and all that stuff. What I'm concerned about is the person and how they feel in their home. Does the person feel okay in their home? Do they feel comfortable in their home? Do they feel functional in their home, because if we don't feel good in our home, that launches us for the whole rest of our life. And it impacts on how we can accomplish whatever it is we want to accomplish in our lives. Whether we're a full time parent or working full time, or volunteering, or we're retired and just wanting to have you know, spend time doing record doesn't matter what we're trying to do in our life, our home, and the way we interact with our home and our belongings and our stuff and our space and our time. The way we manage that is our foundation for the rest of our life. So the better we manage those things, the better able we are to accomplish our goals in life, which is what is the target?

    KC Davis 4:32

    I feel like that's where you and I really resonated with each other was that we're both focusing on a person's relationship to their space, right, not just their performance in their space or the aesthetics of their space, but that the real work and the real reward is the relationship to their space.

    Alison Lush 4:53

    And the measure that I use to identify where are the issues is literally how do you feel like I see the way your desk is you showed me a picture of your desk? I don't have any judgment about that. I don't care if it's piled up to the ceiling. My question is, how do you feel about your desk? If you feel fine about your desk, and it's working for you, let's talk about something else. If you're unhappy about your desk, and it's causing you problems, do you want to talk about it? Do you want to talk about it? Because even if it's a problem for the person, that doesn't necessarily mean that they're ready or willing or able to deal with it?

    KC Davis 5:26

    Yes. And if you push that, they're more likely to kind of go to this protective space, where they're not going to be honest, are not going to be open, they're not going to call you back for the second session. And, you know, what you're describing about, you know, does it bother you is similar to when I talk about, you know, does it work, that's all it does it function. And that changes over a lifetime to because I'm someone who has almost always function just fine with clothes strewn about the floor, and dishes being done every three days. And you know, nothing really having a a formal organization. But I always kind of knew where everything was, that worked. For me for most of my life, it really wasn't until I had my second kid, that all of a sudden, those sort of pseudo systems began to sort of grown under the weight of the extra family labor. And that's when you know, my platform launched was me going, Oh, my God, I have to go back to the drawing board. Like I have to figure out some new ways existing in this space, because things that were working are now not working.

    Alison Lush 6:26

    The way that that shows up in my work is what I say to people is organizing should be organic. Our lives are changing all the time, the things that we own are changing all the time, our interests, and habits and lifestyle and daily routines are changing all the time. And so if we focus on the stuff in the space, we're only dealing with today's problem, what about next year, what about two years from now, so what I try to focus on is the human being and their understanding of themselves because they carry themselves in where whatever situation they're in whatever time they're in, whatever needs they're in, they carry themselves. So if they can focus on their own understanding and their skills, they carry that wherever they go, and it empowers them to be able to face whatever challenges they have in the future. I don't want people hiring me now to organize their cupboard. And then for them to have to organize hire me again next year, when they change what's in the cupboard. I want them to be able to organize their cupboard next year.

    KC Davis 7:20

    Yes, that's awesome. Okay, I feel like we could talk forever. But I really want to get into some of these questions. Because I've had people writing in, and I picked out a few that I felt like it'd be really good for us to talk about, and here we go. So this is from Samantha, and she says, I grew up moving around. And I have a lot of emotional issues and shame around resisting getting rid of stuff and decluttering. But I also have ADHD, and I feel overwhelmed by the clutter and an effects by functionality, any tips, both in terms of practicality, so ways to make it easier to let go of things I need to let go of. And in terms of philosophy, your mess is morally neutral mantra has already been such a difference. So I love this question. I feel like this is right up your alley. And I would love to hear your thoughts.

    Alison Lush 8:04

    It touches on a couple of really big issues. What is the meaning of our stuff? How does our physical stuff from our past add value to our life today? So there's our memorabilia type stuff. And then there's the stuff we're actually using today? And how do they actually live in our physical space. I encourage people to develop a personalized environment so that they have what they need. So if they need it in front of their face, it's in front of their face, if they need peace and quiet in front of their face. That's what they have. So it I encourage everybody to look inside pay attention to how you respond to your space. Does it help you and make you feel calmer? When you can see all your stuff? Or does it make you feel calmer when you can't see all your stuff? For example, that's the first thing are you hypo visually sensitive or hyper visually sensitive. And the same thing with space and with touch, if we can pay attention to how we react physically, personally to everything around us, we gather information that helps us therefore create personalized solutions. So that's one element. Second of all, the ADHD thing is a whole package unto itself. And there are so many specialists who talk specifically about ADHD, I talk about it a little bit on my platform, but not because there's so many people out there who that's all they talk about, I tend to defer to them. It is a personal path. And it's real. And it affects the way that a person interacts with their space and their time and their focus and their attention. And learning about yourself is the number one powerhouse thing that you can do and it will change over time. So this year, whatever you learn about yourself and your ADHD, it could be different six months from now or two years from now be ready for paying attention to change.

    KC Davis 9:45

    So she says she grew up moving around and that gave her a lot of emotional issues about getting rid of things.

    Alison Lush 9:51

    Right. So that's an issue that is like a really big topic of conversation on my page because I hear and I see people and the issue of shame and expectations and judgment. And I think that our society in general does us a tremendous disservice by setting up this notion that life is supposed to be like anything specific. It's supposed to be like this for all of us. I reject that. And I encourage everybody to reject that. I don't think it helps us, I think what helps us is to figure out what works for us. So when people come to me, and they say, I have all of this stuff, and I don't know if I should be keeping it or not, I ask them digging it, we delve down, we dig down and ask questions about what value is it adding to your life isn't actually adding value to your life? That's really super important. The second question is, what is it costing you? Does it cost you anxiety and stress every single month that you've got those 12 boxes of memorabilia sitting there? Or are they just sitting there and they're not bothering you at all? So the more we can get clear about the costs of holding the stuff and the benefits of owning the stuff, the more it helps massage us towards finding our own personal answer of just to what extent it's problematic to be owning that stuff. Because we, I do not believe that we should be allowing other people to be pressuring us to get rid of our stuff. That's not an answer, that's helpful. It's just not,

    KC Davis 11:16

    I kind of love where you're going with this, because that's where I always start with people too. Because we do have these sort of external ideas. You know, like, minimalism is really big right now. And people talking about, you know, you just you have to have a peaceful space, but they're sort of saying that the only way to have a peaceful space is to have a minimalist space. And so I do think there are people out there thinking, Oh, I've got to declutter, I've got to declutter. But you know, if you jump right to teaching them how to declutter, you can sometimes miss what you're talking about, which is, is this even a problem? Exactly. Some people love to have their stuff around them, some people have a peaceful place. So I want to give kudos to Samantha because she was able to say that she feels overwhelmed. And it affects her functionality. So she's kind of got that piece. But But you're so right. And that's why I really want to encourage people to always start with the functionality like is it working? Is it even a problem that you don't ever called your laundry? Is it even a problem that you do your dishes every three days? Is it really affecting you? Or are you going off of some external messaging about how your house should run

    Alison Lush 12:23

    100% could not agree more.

    KC Davis 12:25

    So if Samantha says to you, you ask her these questions, she says, Yes, it is actually a problem, it actually affects my functioning. And I would like to get rid of some of these things. But I don't even know where to start.

    Alison Lush 12:36

    It depends on what kinds of things we're talking about. One of the cores, elements of the work that I do with clients is I talk about Zone One, two, and three. And I find that this is a concept that is almost universally helpful for people to think about, I talked about in terms of the human being as being zone one, anything I can reach with my arms from wherever I am. So right now I'm sitting at my desk, anything I can reach with my arms without getting out of my chair, that's zone one space. And for my functioning, I should be prioritizing only things in my zone, one space that are contributing to whatever it is I'm trying to accomplish in this space. What however, I define that for myself, it's up to me, so only things that are contributing to what I'm trying to achieve here. Same thing at the kitchen counter, when you're standing at the kitchen counter, what are you trying to accomplish? Most people at the kitchen counter most people and I don't even make any assumptions about that. Most people at the kitchen counter are trying to either make food or clean up most of the time. So if that's the case, the only things that should be right there in that space is only one space prime real estate should be the things that are contributing to making the meals or cleaning up, if that's what you've just defined your use of that space. Right? Some people might do their podcast on their kitchen counter, and therefore it's a completely different conversation. Every person has to decide for themselves. So that's zone one. And we're going to start with one right always, because you start with the human being the human being is the center of the story. That's the thing that's kind of like the core of my philosophy. Because we typically start in our society with starting with the stuff, where does the stuff need to be? I flip that on its head? What does the human need?

    KC Davis 14:13

    Because I feel like a lot of people would start with the attic or the garage, right? The place where things are piling up, or oh, I have this extra bedroom and there's we just throw everything in there. I feel like that's where a lot of people think they're supposed to start because that's what they would say is the quote unquote, problem area. But you're saying no, it's how are you functioning in your home? And so if I'm sitting at my desk, what do I do at my desk? If I'm at my kitchen counter? What am I doing here? If I'm in my playroom, what are we doing there? I love that, okay, what's on two

    Alison Lush 14:42

    That's zone one. And in order to help us keep zone one, purified and functioning and minimalists so that we have just the things that we need, whatever that means, and it could even mean memorabilia. I'm not saying you shouldn't keep pictures of your family on your desk, if that contributes to you feeling good as you're sitting at your desk. Trying to get whatever it is you're trying to get done, then that's perfectly valuable. Every person decides for themselves what they need. That's like rule number one, every person decides for themselves. So zone two is the space that like, I have to get up from my chair and walk across the room to get to that zone two storage, it's totally easy to get to. But I wouldn't want to have to stand up 25 times a day and go to my zone to to get something that I need 25 times a day. So it's frequency of access decides what should be in Zone One. And what should be in Zone Two, Zone Two, it's hugely valuable storage space, but it's across the room, I have to get up from my chair.

    KC Davis 15:35

    So this is why I intuitively keep my vacuum cleaner out in my kitchen, because I have small children,

    Alison Lush 15:43

    And you reach for it 50 times a day,

    KC Davis 15:45

    50 times a day, right? I had it in the closet, I was trying to make it a zone two. And you know what, for most of my life, it was a zone to object. But then my life season changed. And now it's a zone one object, and that's why it's in the kitchen, okay?

    Alison Lush 15:59

    100% your instincts are right on the market, on the ball. And the third zone is longer term storage. And I the perfect example of what we I put I use it as a visual example to help people understand what zone three storage is, it's a pain in the butt to get to, it's like you have to go all the way down three flights of stairs to the basement, maybe you have to use a key to get into a storage locker, maybe it's in your parents basement, maybe it's up in the attic, and you have to climb a ladder, it's a pain in the butt to get to you only want to go there a few times a year. So what do we keep in zone three storage, we keep things like Christmas decorations. We keep things like our seven years of taxes, we keep things like childhood memorabilia, we keep things that we don't need to access on a frequent basis. Again, it's all based on frequency of access, how often am I going to reach for this thing? And therefore does it deserve to be in Zone One? Should it be in zone two? Or should it be? Could it be relegated to zone three?

    KC Davis 16:50

    Okay, so is in terms of decluttering? Can you almost reverse engineer this and say, Okay, here's this, you know, earplugs sitting on my desk. This is not something I ever need at my desk. And so then go well, is it something? How frequently do I need this? What do I need it once a year? Do I even need it there? Like is that a way that you can sort of begin to sort of ripple effect clear out and declutter some spaces?

    Alison Lush 17:17

    Yeah, absolutely. I visualized it in my own head. I don't know why. But I've always used the term massaging, I'm massaging my belongings, I'm pulling closer to me, things that are more important and meaningful, like your vacuum, your pulled it closer to you because you need it more often. And pushing away things that are less instantly necessary in order to make room for because one of the things I have 20 years background in the catering industry, I was a myth for the hotel. And I managed the floor of dining rooms and catering events. And one of the key things that I learned from that is humans need space to move and to do stuff. And we frequently forget to leave space for the humans. And so we have to factor that in. It's valuable to push things away so that there's more room for the humans to function.

    KC Davis 18:01

    And will you is that the zones? one two and three.

    Alison Lush 18:04

    Yeah. And then when you get to the end of zone three, it's like, do I even need to own this.

    KC Davis 18:09

    So when people talk about so let's say they get the end of zone three, and they're going to even need to own this. And if they're still having trouble letting go. There's a couple of things that I've seen you talk about that I thought were genius on your channel where you talked about memorabilia, and ways that you can keep honor and or display parts of memorabilia or your memorabilia without it, you know, maybe just living in its entirety and a Rubbermaid bin or whatever. Can you talk a minute about that?

    Alison Lush 18:39

    Yeah, there's two things I'd like to say on the memorabilia because it is such a huge issue. One is the example that you're giving is my daughter's Playmobil collection. It was a massively important part of her childhood. If we all had to choose one thing that was like significant of her childhood, it would have been the Playmobil. So I took a selection of it and put it in a shadowbox and it's literally hanging on our bathroom wall. And it's so cheerful and beautiful. And it honors her childhood and you know, our parenting and it honors a whole bunch of things on many different levels. And it means we don't have to keep that great big tote of Playmobil. That's one thing so keeping a sampling. Some people call it a sampling. Some people call it I forget something else. There's other terms. I learned that from Judith Kohlberg, who's an amazing person. She has a book called chronic disorganization, and it's available to the public. She has two versions, one for professional organizers and one for the public. Anybody who's interested in chronic disorganization can easily find her little book available on the internet and they might be interested in buying it. The second thing I want to say about memorabilia that I think is hugely important is a measure that me personally I use to help me decide sometimes is it okay for me to actually let this thing go or not? When I'm when we're sitting on the fence and we're feeling ambivalent, oh, I've got this thing. I wonder if I should be letting it go or not. I want to let it go. But I'm afraid to let it go. That we so often find ourselves in that position and it's very uncomfortable. So I came up with this visual, that I think, is really helpful. And people seem to get if it was a white t shirt that I was debating about, should I keep this white t shirt or let it go, Oh my gosh, I don't know what to do. If I let it go. And tomorrow morning, I wake up and I go, Oh, my God, I should have kept that white t shirt, I could really use a white t shirt. How difficult is it for me to go out and replace it. It's super simple. I could even go to a thrift store. And for four bucks, I could get a white t shirt like they're everywhere white t shirts, right. And if we're just talking about a white t shirt, it's just a thing, I can easily replace the thing. It sort of echoes the minimalists advice that if you can replace it for 20 bucks or within 20 minutes, then let it go. I like having guidelines like that so that we don't hang on to just everything. The other example I give like to complete the imagery is okay, what if I'm sitting on the fence and we're talking about my grandmother's pearls, she gave me her pearls when I got married. It's a necklace and a pair of earrings. I've worn them a few times, they're sitting in my jewelry box. But the reality is, they don't resonate with me, I don't feel comfortable wearing them. It's not my style. It's strictly a piece of memorabilia that was meaningful to my grandmother and meaningful for our relationship, I will probably never wear them again. So if I'm looking at that set of pearls, and I'm sitting on the fence, and I asked myself the question, if I let these go, when I wake up tomorrow morning, and I regret the decision, how easy or difficult is it going to be to replace them? The reality is, it's impossible to replace them because they came from my grandmother, they're one of a kind. So what that identifies using the example of the white t shirt and my grandma's pearls that identifies the level of risk. So the level of risk, if I make a mistake is not the same for every item, this is a mistake that we make, we simply often look at everything, and only think of the money value, or its memorabilia, therefore I have to keep it we put so much value on belongings it makes it so that they're like a ball and chain, and we can't let them go. So anything that we can do to identify ways that we can loosen our grip and let go of things that are less important. It means that we can hang on to things that are more important with a higher value and a higher risk value if we let them go, because we can't keep everything.

    KC Davis 22:08

    I like that what it also reminds me of is that I think sometimes when people are getting rid of things, maybe they don't want them, they don't need them. It doesn't function in their life. But it's not that having it is bringing value to your their life. It's that they feel as though the act of getting rid of it is somehow betraying it, or disrespecting it or you know, it's just so hard to get rid of something. And I think that's a part to look at too. Because in your example, like let's say you decide, okay, you know, you I don't want the pearl earrings, I think talking about then where are they going to go is different? Because of the choices? Do I keep the pearl earrings from my grandmother? Or do I throw them in the trash? Like, obviously, I'm not gonna throw those in the trash. But if it's do I keep them? Or do I take them to a secondhand shop? Or do I donate them to a dress for success for lower income women that can't afford me, then I feel like well, that's really honoring to my grandmother, actually. And I'm going to take sort of one of the Marie Kondo tips where she talks about, you know, has this item given its gift to me, and that gift can't be taken away, even if I pass on, and maybe it's honored if I pass it on. And in that vein, I sort of wanted to share a story that I found when I was younger. So I think everyone has had an experience with their first love. Right? Maybe you were 1516 20. And I had this box of memorabilia from my first love, right? This is the you know, just life changing, you know, you'll never forget that person. And pictures and love letters, nice things. And when I got engaged, I said, you know, I think as we move into this new space, I don't want to bring this box, right. Like it was a sweet relationship. And it gave me so much. But I don't need to keep hanging on to, for lots of reasons we could go into what the emotional significance of these things are for me when I move into this new space with my husband and my you know, like that. And but the stopping point, Allison was that I couldn't bring myself to throw it in the trash. And it's not like somebody I can't read gift pictures of me and my 16 year old boyfriend. And you know, what I ended up doing was I had a good friend at the time, who was sort of mentoring me. And I said, you know, I'd really like to sit down with you and show you my box. And I want to show you every picture and I want to read you every letter and I want to tell you about this relationship that I had that shaped the course of my life and how sweet it was and how bittersweet it was, and the things that still mean something to me today. And I want you to know I want to tell you the story. And when I'm done telling you the story, I want to give you the box and I don't ever want to hear about what you do with the box. And I mean I know logically she threw the box in the trash. She's not keep hitting this box, but I was removed from the significance of putting in the trash. That's not what I did with it. I told the story, honor the story. And I handed the box gingerly over to her. And she said out loud to me, I will take care of this for you. And I will honor it. And obviously, it didn't need to go somewhere. And I don't even like to say out loud that I don't want the trash. But it was such a cool way of honoring this thing. That was this memorabilia, but it didn't serve my life anymore. But I didn't want it to go in the trash. And so I'd love to share that story. Because it was one of my better strokes of genius about how to kind of get rid of something that had that weight to it.

    Alison Lush 25:37

    It's so powerful that story. It's a very, very beautiful, elegant and just infused with honor, what you did for yourself for the relationship for that other person for that collection. on every level, it was just filled with honor. And you found your solution, which is beautiful and phenomenal that you liberated yourself from the weight of that ownership of that thing. It takes a lot of courage to do that a lot of the people that I'm dealing with, that I'm working with that I'm conversing with, haven't yet gotten to the place where they could have that confidence or that courage to do that. So what we're doing is always just exploring anything that they could possibly do to liberate themselves, could they reduce the collection, I often encourage people to explore the meaning of the thing. So the meaning of the relationship, the meaning of the pictures, what might you do in the future, I still have my tiny collection, I've reduced it down to very minimal. But that collection that you were just talking about, I've still got mine. And I've still got it tucked away because I haven't been able to let it go yet, but it's very small. One thing I did get let go of was my collection of journals, I had a whole years and years of books that I had filled with writing years and years from about age, I don't know 16 to 25, or something like that. And when I started going on my real journey of decluttering. For myself, it's a whole process. I've been on this journey for 11 years now. And in about year five, I actually hired a professional organizer to help me get past some of the things that I was struggling with. And just by having her working with me off on my own, I went off on this tangent, I said, I want to deal with my journals. And I did it and I shredded them, all of them. I ripped them out of their books, I shredded all the paper through the covers of the books into the garbage. And I feel fantastic. Because what I realized is the purpose of those books, and this gets back to the meaning of the belonging. What was the purpose of those books, the purpose of those books was to help me in that moment to work through issues, and to learn and to move beyond whatever issues I was struggling with. They were like work papers, working through issues. And now it's like five years, 10 years, 2030 years later, I don't need to go back and see the work that I did on those issues. I've moved way beyond those issues, you are the work that you did exactly. So the books served their purpose. That's one of the things that I do love about Marie Kondo philosophy is thank the thing for what you got from it, and then move on and let it go. And that that was one of the examples of how I applied that philosophy. Absolutely.

    KC Davis 28:03

    Well, so when Samantha talks about a group moving around, I think it's really significant that that's how she starts it, because she's telling us that the emotional issues around getting rid of things probably has to do with the sense of either instability or impermanence that she felt when she was younger, you know, we typically associate the stability or the permanence of being in one place with the concept of home. Right home is not transient home doesn't change day to day, we're going month to month. And I think a lot of people who either it could be that you had a great, wonderful family and you moved around a lot, it could be that you experienced some adverse childhood experiences, whether that's abuse or a loss. And I think that brings a new level of complexity into our things. And I think it's important to recognize that and I think it sounds like Samantha does and and to honor that, like we've been talking about where we say, okay, you know, this broom, that, you know, is falling apart? What is that bringing up for me that fear of getting rid of that? Is it that I used to not be able to afford another broom? Is it that we grew up poor, and I can hear my meme on my head saying, you know, don't waste things, you know, good people don't waste things. Is it that the transient nature of getting rid of things, you never got to hold on to anything long enough to feel a sense of home? And there's no easy answer to that. But just being willing to say these are valid things to experience around my stuff. And I think that there are also some things you can do. First of all, I always want to say like, there's nothing wrong with recognizing that's why I want to hold on to things and so I'm going to hold on to them, hold on to them, if that's where you are in your journey, and you need that comfort that reassurance hold on to them. Now, if maybe it says well, it is affecting my functioning well, but maybe we can find ways to keep those things in a way that doesn't affect your functioning, right? And that's where we get creative. But maybe she does say no, I really do, you know, kind of need to get rid of it. And I think that sometimes we don't have to meet it head on. Like, I have this picture in my online shop, and you can buy it as a print or you can download it for free. And it says this home is a safe home, and I am safe in it. And I think sometimes we need these visual reminders. This is not my childhood home, I am safe here. This is my, you know, stable home. And I think there's a lot of things we can do in our environment that can help us kind of gain that reassurance we need so that we can maybe sometimes let go of an item we need to.

    Alison Lush 30:40

    Yeah, that's an excellent point. I don't think I've ever heard anybody talk in that in those terms about comparing the childhood home versus the today home and how we can create our today home to feel more secure. That's very beautiful. The way you just describe that.

    KC Davis 30:54

    Well, thank you. And it kind of brings just because I talked about hanging a piece of artwork. This question I thought was really interesting. This is from kitty. It says one of my struggles is decorating, which sounds stupid as I write it. But when I look around my house with its crappy mismatched decor, and it's dirty walls, Kid destroyed couch hand me down furniture and lack of any style. I'm defeated and deflated. Not talking about high end interior decoration, although what? What I wouldn't do to win the lottery. I would like my house to look more like a family lives here and less like squatters do. How do you hang photos? How do you paint walls? How do you feel good about your space? And this question almost makes me have tears in my eyes. Because I feel like when you're talking about our relationship to our space, and how do we make a home. And I was just curious if you had any thoughts on that.

    Alison Lush 31:44

    I certainly don't specialize in interior decoration. But I have got an image that and a notion that I had developed a several years ago, which I think might be helpful here. You've probably heard of home staging, when people are putting their house on the market, they want to sell a home. The real estate people want to be able to bring strangers in and walk them around and show them the place and we want what you want is for anybody walking in to be able to imagine themselves being able to live there. Therefore, it's important that the decor in the space be neutralized so that anybody can imagine themselves living there. That's the goal. So in staging, and I'm not a home stager, I hope I'm not speaking out of turn here. But my understanding of home staging is neutralizing the environment taking out the personal the over personal from the environment. And when I realized that a number of years ago, what I realized is my personal goal working with clients is to do the exact opposite. My goal is to reach inside of the human being, reach inside of the human being and help them extract and pull out whatever is personal and meaning for them and then infuse their environment with who they are and what's meaningful to them. There's no such thing as it should be this way it should be that way. Don't have to worry. I personally don't think the focus needs to be on how to hang a picture. The focus could be perhaps better invested in what do I want to be looking at it every every day, that makes me feel good. That reinforces my feeling of pride about my family, and I'm a good mom and I love my beautiful kids and my kids love each other and look at them having a great activity in this picture that picture. That's what matters. It doesn't matter what frames they're in. It doesn't matter what wall they go in. It doesn't matter how they're hung. It's the images. It's the life inside. It's the personal connection, and the resonance with the person and their life. That's what the value of home decor is. Whether it's color whether it's I want to have a yellow wall because yellow makes me feel cheerful, then that's the right color to have on the wall. There's no right and wrong the answers are inside of us. That's my view. .

    KC Davis 33:48

    I love it. And I think obviously if we're worried about oh, is it aesthetic, does it look right together? There are obviously people you could ask to come in and tell you that there you could get a handyman to hang photos. But I think I mean I hear kitty asking the deeper question that you're really answering which is we don't have to worry about creating some sort of aesthetically cohesive look. If you want that you can do that. It's more about as you say kind of unstaged the space and getting into you know when she says the crappy mismatched decor the dirty walls, the kid destroyed couch. Some of that is just changing the way you look at those items.

    Alison Lush 34:26

    It's a life that's being lived in when I look at my sink of dirty dishes. If I get up in the morning and I look into my sink of dirty dishes, I can either say oh Ellison you know you lazy slob. You should have to wash the dishes last night or I can say aren't we lucky? We had a wonderful dinner last night

    KC Davis 34:40

    Yes and that like I have a crappy kid destroyed couch. I have cats my couch is gross to look at. I mean there are stains on it. There's cat hair on it. But you know the meaning of that couch is a life well lived and now it's not pretty to look at but what I did was right above that couch on our window sills are hung these handmade ladybugs that my three year old made, and I feel like it's the perfect representation of okay, we don't love the couch, we'd like to get a new couch the couch isn't nice looking. It doesn't. I don't feel warm and fuzzy when I look at it. But in conjunction with these handmade ladybugs, there's something about them together. I mean, they're holed, they're up there with scotch tape, there's something about that picture together. That gives that couch meaning, right? It's not squatters that live here. It's little kids.

    Alison Lush 35:28

    I think that it's really important that we recognize that every phase of life that we're in, has different needs. And we're focusing on different priorities right now, anybody with kids growing up, like in Kitty's house, the focus is raising a family supporting those kids so that they can go out and have friends supporting those kids. So they can go out and get an education, supporting the parents so that they can support the kids. That's what it's all about right now in the family. My personal home, for example, right now, my kids have moved up, moved up, grown up and moved out. And so now it's just my husband and I, the phase of life that we're in is completely different. Our home, we have more space, we have more peace, there's fewer dirty dishes in the sink, it's a different phase of life, if we aspire to a style or an aesthetic that is beyond our reach, because it's not appropriate for the phase of life that we're in, we're guaranteeing ourselves to be dissatisfied. If we rather like you did with your coach. And with the ladybugs, if we rather say this is this phase of life I'm in right now and honor it and say I want to be a great parent I what's important to me is to have a comfortable, warm, fuzzy family home and couch where we can all cuddle up together. And we're not going to be stressed out about spilling the chocolate milk on the couch or whatever. What's more important is our time together, then the stains on the couch become much less important. And then later on, when the kids are grown up and moved out, you can get a pretty couch or you can always put a cover over it or something if you want to.

    KC Davis 36:49

    And when she says the mismatched decor, I want to bet money that that decor is something that she got off of a shelf somewhere because she thought to herself, that's looks like something that would be hung on an adult's wall, right, as opposed to something meaningful. And I think what you're saying can go hand in hand with what I'm about to say, which is sometimes when we are in the trenches of little kid life sometimes or thinking about decor, you know, we do want to be reminded that we are people outside of this phase of life. And one thing that comes to me is I mean, you know, I'm thinking kitty, do you have a favorite band? Do you have a favorite band? Do you have a favorite painting? Do you have something you loved? Maybe because when you were in college before kids, maybe you had those band posters on the wall. Now, you may not want to tack them up on the wall, but you can frame it, you can make it look like an adult lives and have these representations of you know, this is this is who I am. And that makes me happy to look at, you know, if you've got some sort of live, laugh, love nondescript scones on the wall, because that's kind of what you thought adults put on the walls. Maybe that's why it's not speaking to you. So I would lean into both like lean into Okay, let's put the ladybugs on the wall and lean into this is my favorite band. Why did I ever take that poster down? My husband and I have this was supposed to be a game room. But it was sort of our guest room slash where he was working for the longest time. And it just kind of became the Doom room. We dumped everything there. And we decided that, hey, when we sell this house, we will have to stage this area. And then we will be mad at ourselves that we waited until we were leaving to make it like a nice cool area. So we redid the area. And we didn't do anything like we didn't paint anything or do any construction, just simple, you know, got rid of some things brought a couple of little bookcases and chairs and, and when we stepped back, we looked at it and it's our favorite place in the house. Because it's the only place in our house, the kids don't go. And we find ourselves hanging out here all the time. And sometimes my husband even sleep up here, because it just it almost feels like a little bachelor pad. It feels like a little one room loft. We didn't want to buy new pictures. So we ended up putting some pictures of some renderings that I did when I was in college as a costume design student on the walls. We have a throw that says I wait here for you forever as long as it takes and we just tacked it up on the wall. And so we joke with each other that like we come up here to sort of cosplay like single people living in a loft in New York. Because, you know, the majority of our house is dedicated to sort of a kid centric space. And so I think there's a way to sort of lean into both of those things at once. You know what makes me happy because if you put something on the wall that makes you happy to look at all the sudden it doesn't bother you as much that it doesn't match the theme. 100% Yes, anything that we can do to recharge our batteries and fuel ourselves so that we can continue giving to other people and doing whatever it is that we're trying to accomplish. That's so valuable. Okay, I feel like we have question time for maybe one more question. And that's it. This one was interesting. This is from Aria, she says, my home life and my work life blur into endless chaos. Do you have some tactics for how to separate and manage the mental and physical clutter? When that clutter meshes into inappropriate times, ie I cannot turn off work on off days, because I'm very available to my clients, or I'm at work, but I'm worried about the mess in the kitchen. And you know, she's kind of talking about mentally, how do I turn it off. But what I was reminded when I read this, is that throughout this pandemic, we've had more and more people staying at home. And where it used to be, well, home is my home life, my family and office is my office. And you know, the bar is my social life. And then I go to the library to knit, like, all of a sudden, everything's at home. And I'm curious what any kind of insight you have on when we think about organizing our stuff, is there a way to organize our stuff that helps us with those boundaries and delineations. And I'm thinking particularly for someone that doesn't have the obvious option of Oh, yeah, just put it in your home office, right, because not everybody has a home office

    Alison Lush 41:02

    Reminded of the notion of what's enough. So for example, typically, well, one of the themes in people feeling absolutely overwhelmed and being very ambitious in their career or whatever, trying to squeeze in so many things in 24 hours, there's a density to what they're trying to pack into 24 hours and things over overlap, and they don't get time off. And I find it very helpful to pull it back and try to identify what is enough, if I give support to my clients, what is just enough support to my clients, what is just enough housekeeping, it's very much resonating with all of the language that you use, which is just enough to get myself you know, started on the next state, for example. Because when we're being ambitious, professionally, and out in the world, it's sort of like a black hole, it will suck out everything that you will give it, we have to make the boundaries ourselves. And we only have 20k. Here's another thought, and I'm bouncing a little bit on this one, too, I will confess time management, productivity is not my zone of comfort. And it's I don't specialize in it, because it's not something that I feel that I master on the one hand, and it's not a place where I feel comfortable speaking, my zone of comfort is physical stuff, and emotional attachment and skill development and getting people unstuck. That's where, especially with their physical belongings and helping people get refocused. But this comes up a lot people who are stuck with feeling overburdened with their met, how they manage their time in their space, one of the most powerful things that any of us can do is to remember that we only have 24 hours in a day. It's just like money, you only have so much we're accustomed to talking about money and money being a finite resource, you only have so much money to get through the month, or to get through the year. And we function with whatever money we've got. Or we keep sliding into debt. And it's obvious, we can see it right there on the balance sheet. But what we forget often is that we only have 24 hours in a day, and we only have so much energy and time. But we spend our energy and our time as if it was an infinite, as if they were infinite resources, and they are not. So anybody who's struggling with time and energy management, it's recommended that they spend a little bit of time doing, I just sent one to a client yesterday. It's a sheet like a spreadsheet. And you basically note down how you're spending your time there 24 hour period over a week. And you do that for like two weeks. And it gives you feedback about how you're actually spending your time and your energy. Because frequently when we're feeling overwhelmed and like we our boundaries are all intermeshed and we're not taking care of our fundamental needs. It's because we're spending our time and energy more in places where maybe it's not the best and less where we actually need it. And so we need to get a portrait of where we're actually spending it. And this is based on the concept that any financial adviser would have us do. If you're trying to get your finances under control. First, start by identify where are you actually spending your money. Let's start there. And then massage and put more here and less from there. And it's the same thing with time and energy, because they're finite resources.

    KC Davis 44:28

    What it also reminds me of is it be interesting not only to look at how I'm spending my time, but also mentally where am I? How much of the day do I spend thinking about those dishes? How much of the day am I spending thinking about those clients? And I'm reminded of a couple of things that have really worked in my home is I sort of famously have the dirty dish rack right because for reasons that are not important to this podcast, I sometimes have a difficult time taking a dish using a dish rinsing it off putting in the dish. I mean, it's just a lot of steps for me, right I can do about half those steps with ease So I got a dish rack, because what was happening was that when when the dishes were piled up in the sink, it was very overwhelming to me, I couldn't have access to the sink. And now I'm thinking about what a huge mess it was, when I got a dish rack and put it next to the sink and started stacking up the dirty dishes. For some reason, the same amount of dishes stacked, organized on a rack seems so much less intimidating and fewer dishes actually even then when they're bundled in the sink. And I'm also thinking about, you know, when we are looking at how much time am I spending thinking about these things versus doing these things? I'm wondering if there are these small organizational steps that someone like ARIA could take where, okay, you don't maybe have 10 minutes in the morning to do all the dishes. But do you have three minutes to put them on a dish rack? Because then maybe you won't think about them so much, because they're not cluttering the space? They're not, you know, oh, it's such a mess. It's like, no, it's staged, right, it's there ready to go when you have time. And maybe there would be a comparable way of sort of, it's almost like when she needs to work, she needs a way of triaging the home stuff. And when she's at home, she needs a way of triaging and there's, I can't help but think that there's got to be some visual and organizational systems that can help her feel as though Okay, these things have been bookmarked to be taken care of. And I don't have to sit here and think about them.

    Alison Lush 46:25

    So what you've just identified with the dishrack is, it's a container, you have given a specific container that has been earmarked for a purpose. And so you've legitimized the dirty dishes, which is the perfect solution in your situation, it's a perfect solution, when they were sitting in the sink, they don't really belong in the sink, because it makes the sink, not functional, it makes the sink difficult to access. So when you want to fill up that big pot of water to make pasta at lunch, you can't do it, because there's all kinds of dirty dishes. So to make the sink functional, you created a reserved specific space for the dirty dishes. And that was a perfect solution. So if anybody like for example, Aria, looking at something that's dysfunctional, the bothering her, if it keeps bothering her, I would encourage her to look at it and try to ask herself the questions. In what way? Is it bothering her? Is it that she's reminded of it all the time? Is it that there's some guilt associated with it? And if there's guilt, where's the guilt coming from? Is it some old cassette in her brain that was, you know, doesn't need to be there that she could replace with something else? Is it reasonable to feel guilty about it? Or is it perfectly normal to have dirty dishes, for example, and what other options might exist? So it's when we take any individual specific little thing exactly as you did with the dirtiness and the sink? And look at it and ask ourselves what is necessary here, and what don't I need, and then what is a simple solution to containerize and legitimize the thing

    KC Davis 47:55

    That is awesome, we get away from the scripts about what should be in our home. And we just look at what is actually in our home, if we we can make the decision to get rid of some things that aren't functioning, but when things are in our home, just legitimizing it and giving it permission to exist, allows you It frees you up for the creativity to go okay, so then we need a system here, we need a container, we need a place for these to exist that doesn't impede the functioning of the sink that doesn't have it always on my mind. I love that because I'm thinking of so many things in my home. That, you know, it reminds me of when I used to like it was a newborn and I would change her diaper. And we soon found that because the doors closed all the time for nap, the dirty diaper been made the room smell, and we're like, oh, she can't sleep in there. So we started we moved it out into the hallway. Well, when you're changing a baby's diaper, and then you grab the dirty diaper. Well, but now you have to put the baby into the crib. You're not just like walking out with it. And so I would toss them into the hallway, thinking well, I'll toss them into the hallway, and then I'll pick it up on my way out except I never picked it up on my way out. So I always had this pile of peepee and poopoo diapers right outside the nursery. And then I walked by they're like, ah, such a piece of shit. I can't believe I've done that so disgusting. But one day, I really did look at them and legitimize them like you know what this is what's happening right now this is like low on the totem pole of things that need to be solved in my life. And I just put a wastebasket there, right where the pile was. So that as I tossed them out of the room, they were going right into a little trash can. And now I can empty the trash can when it's full, and I just legitimized the pile of dirty diapers and gave them a container. And you know what, it was a short season of our life and it's not an issue anymore. And I'm glad that I didn't beat myself up or make myself sort of do what I should have done with them. Because at the end of the day, who's got time for that?

    Alison Lush 49:50

    I have three other echoes on that on the theme of categorizing and legitimizing when I'm working with clients, we always come across things that they're not ready to make a decision about yet, decision making is very, very difficult. I don't know what to do with this thing, whatever this thing is, I don't know if I should keep it or if I should let it go. If a person is really stuck on it, the worst thing that we can do is just put it down. Because then we're just creating chaos, if we're really close to like, I've got a lot of categories and things are going well. And I have this one thing I don't know what to do with. If I have a box called something like the ripening box or the indecision box or something, a space, that is actually a container, we can put things in there that we have no idea what to do with right now and then come back and revisit it later. And frequently, just the passage of time, when we come back, and we look at that thing in the future. Sometimes it's obviously, but we're ready to make a decision, because we've just let some time pass. So that's one. The second one is, when we're organizing and creating categories and putting labels on all kinds of categories, frequently, we ends up with things that they just don't fit into a category, they just don't. And so we use this word called Miss kibble. So the Miss kibble box is just like all the random stuff, it's like, rather than calling it the junk box, it's the Michigan kibble box. And we don't know what to do with it, just toss it in there, it'll be safe, you know, it's not lost, if you need it, you can go and look for it, it's a safe place to put things. And the third one is, many of my clients are creative types. And they have bits of pipe and bits of leather and bits of fabric and bits of plastic and all these things and they say, but I might be able to use it one day, which is totally legitimate, but they don't know what to do with it. And they feel everybody's always saying, Oh, just get rid of it. It's just a piece of junk. But they're creative people. And they see things in terms of possibility. So they see they know that they need raw materials in the future. So we create a category called raw materials. And that gets the name and legitimacy. And we can create a box for it and put all the stuff in that one box all mixed up. And they're happy, and they get to keep the stuff that they need. But it's got walls in a container, and it doesn't take over the whole house.

    KC Davis 51:56

    I love that there. I think that there are probably a lot of people here and we will wrap up with this. But I just there's probably a lot of people that resist reaching out to an organizer, because they know they're not ready to purge things, they're not ready to get rid of a bunch of stuff, they're not ready to, you know, go through that emotional process. And what I'm hearing is that you would be a safe person for someone to reach out and say, I'm not ready to do some big declutter, overhaul, get rid downsize. But I need some help. And I love that because you deserve to function in your space. You deserve to have someone that can meet you compassionately with creative solutions on how you can raise your quality of life. Even if you're not ready to do some big purge,

    Not everybody needs to purge stuff. What I focus on is helping people get unstuck. That's the way I think of it, people come to me and they say, I'm stuck. I don't know how to get past this thing. It's like this big boulder in my way, and I can't get past it. So we focus on what can we do about the boulder? Does it need to be, you know, blown up and event? It's going to be a whole bunch of little pieces? And you can just step over it? Or can we figure out a way to get around it? Or can we figure out a way to look at it differently. And it'll be see through, that's what we do is we focus on whatever is blocking the person, I sometimes do sessions with people. And we do one session or two sessions. And that's all they need in order to get unstuck. And then they're often they go on their own. We don't necessarily embark on a process where we're working together weekly for the next year or something like that. Every single person has different needs, and I adapt my services. And for whatever the person needs. It's totally, totally flexible and absolutely meets the person where they are. Not everybody needs to get rid of their stuff. That's a very dangerous assumption. I think that that's one thing about the professional organizing industry that is a shame is that we've got this reputation of being we're going to tell everybody to throw it all their stuff. I absolutely do not agree with that. Not helpful.

    Well, Alison, where can people find you if they want to find you on social media, if they want to work with you?

    Alison Lush 53:59

    The easiest thing to do is just to Google me and find my website. That's the absolute easiest thing to do. Alison lush.ca is my website. So you will find me. And there's information there. There's answers to questions. There's a link to a 20 minute introductory exploratory call, which is free I phone the person, we have a 20 minute phone call to see what their needs are and what services I'm offering and figure out if we'd make a good team together. So if people are curious about my services, they'll get information there and they can reach out to me and I'm on social medias as well. But that's the main place is my website or my tic toc alongside KC,KC news. And

    KC Davis 54:34

    Alison is with one L.

    Alison Lush 54:36

    Yes.

    KC Davis 54:37

    Okay. And she's also linked on my website. So if you go to struggle care.com And you click on Resources and homecare, she is one of the resources that I listed there if you want to check out her website and what is your Tiktok handle?

    Alison Lush 54:50

    I think it's Alison lash underscore enough. Pretty sure that's what it is. Alison lash underscore enough.

    KC Davis 54:55

    Great. Well, Alison, I can't thank you so much. This has been an awesome conversation. And I hope that everyone goes and follows Alison. But if you don't follow me, come follow me too. And Alison, it's been a joy. Thank you so much.

    Alison Lush 55:10

    It's been such an honor. Thank you very much and congratulations again.

    KC Davis 55:13

    Thanks.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

Christy Haussler
46: Best of Is Too Much Self-Compassion a Bad Thing? with Dr. Lesley Cook

In our first episode, you heard my conversation with Dr. Lesley Cook about executive functioning. Because she has so much great information and wisdom to share, I decided to bring her back to discuss self-compassion. Is it a bad thing to have TOO MUCH self-compassion? Join us for the conversation with Dr. Lesley!

Dr. Lesley Cook is a psychologist who does a lot of work with ADHD and other neurodivergencies. Born and raised in Hawaii, she now lives in Virginia and works with children, adolescents, adults, couples, and families. 

Show Highlights:

  • How to find the balance between the message of self-compassion and the need for better life management and progress

  • A basic understanding of self-compassion from Dr. Kristin Neff’s writings

  • A closer look at shame and how we experience it in relation to self-compassion

  • How to gently shift shame into self-compassion

  • How self-compassion can become a learned behavior that we pass down to our children

Resources: 

Connect with Dr. Lesley: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to struggle care. I'm your host, KC Davis. I'm taking a break this August, but I wanted to play for you some of my most downloaded episodes. This episode is with Dr. Leslie cook. She is an amazing psychologist who has experience working with children and adults. She specializes in ADHD, autism spectrum disorders, learning disabilities, and the like. She has extensive experience providing professional trainings in this area, and has a lot of really great things to say. So in this episode, she and I got together to talk about self compassion. And in particular, it's too much self compassionate thing. Can you enable yourself or enable others by giving too much compassion? If you've ever wondered this, stay tuned. Get a drink of water, take care of yourself. I'm here with my good friend, Dr. Leslie Cook, say hello, Leslie.

    Lesley PsyD 0:50

    Hey, it's nice to be here. Again,

    KC Davis 0:51

    if you're tuning in with us, you probably heard Dr. Lesley cook last week because I had her on to talk about executive functioning. And I invited her back and I had this great idea that we were going to talk about weaponized incompetence. And then as we got closer to the recording, I remembered we already did a recording on weaponized incompetence. And so I'm going to call an audible and pepper Leslie with Q and A's that we're going to answer together about that.

    Lesley PsyD 1:18

    It sounds great. I cannot wait.

    KC Davis 1:19

    Excellent. Okay, so I just want to jump right in because I've got some fascinating ones. Here we go. So as you know, much of my I'm just going to start with a real spicy one. Is that okay? Yeah, that sounds great. Alright, so as you know, my my content on tick tock is primarily about home care, self care, mental health, and self compassion, right all about sort of recognizing how many things in our life we feel like failures about and then being able to internalize like that struggling with that thing doesn't make me a failure. What often happens when I talk about this, is I get a lot of feedback that says like, Oh, thank you, I feel so much better. Thank you. I'm operating so much better in my home. Thank you. This really helps. But I occasionally will get people that have a similar reaction to this commenter. Okay. And so she actually commented twice. And the first time it was when I asked for people who wanted to do q&a, and this is what she said, I think it's great to help people get past feelings of failing for not doing maximum levels of housework. But I hope you also teach that when someone is using the struggle care techniques to survive, they need to also be facing how to get out of crisis, not having more kids or adding to their load, while they forgive themselves for mess and allowing for doing less, they need to also get real about getting their life to a more manageable place. All right. So here's the second comment, this was on a different video. Your videos have me spiraling this week, because I'm worried some people not you are getting the message to forgive themselves too much, and really not doing enough really failing their kids, I hope you'll keep reinforcing the part about how to do what needs to be done, versus doing too much or nothing. And this comment, first of all, thank you to this commenter for commenting this because I can tell that she's having a legitimate sort of emotional reaction. She's not trying to be any type of way, right? And I just, it's been rattling around in my brain. And I've been having trouble finding the words for what it brings up or what I'm seeing in it. So I'm just curious, your thoughts off the top of your head?

    Lesley PsyD 3:31

    I think in both of those comments, I do I do a lot of parenting work. And I almost feel like I hear a version of some of these early parenting messages that perhaps people receive when they're younger. And when we are under stress, a lot of those early messages tend to just come out all of a sudden. So when I hear that I almost hear, you know, it's okay to take a break on your homework today. But don't forget, you can't get too far behind. So you need to keep going to reach this optimal level. So part of me wonders if that's an old message. And the other part of me wonders, when we work with very young children, especially during their developmental period. We always meet them where they are, right. So if a child is learning to walk, our first statement isn't, you know, it's okay that you're crawling. But we got to we got to get to this walking phase, we have this understanding that crawling, enrolling leads to creeping leads to crawling leads to walking. But as adults, I think sometimes we forget that, that it's okay to meet ourselves with compassion, where we are today, even if where we are today is non functional. That doesn't stop our progress. In fact, it's an incredibly important starting point and it can be freeing to do that.

    KC Davis 4:46

    I hear a lot of fear in this comment. And my initial reaction when I saw this comment was that this person is perhaps either a child who was If not cared for in the way that they deserve by their parents, or is perhaps someone that knows someone who is not giving an adequate or functional amount of care to their children, right? Like, I really didn't read this as someone who's like, I really want permission to be judgmental, because sometimes that's what people mean, right? They feel like it's okay to extend compassion or teach people self compassion up to a point. But they have this like line in their head where it's like, but if you're doing X, you are you should not be using self compassion on yourself. You shouldn't be feeling shame, which I think just goes back to this idea that ultimately, as much as we say that shame is not a good motivator long term. That, that shame isn't the best change agent that we have. And in fact, it most often backfires, and stalls out change. That I think underlying belief is really hard to root out. And I feel like this is where it comes to the surface is like, okay, it's okay for us to be self compassionate about not getting our dishes done. But what about that mom who just left their kid in a dirty diaper for 12 hours, and now they have, you know, open sores on their bottom? Like, they're not allowed to be self compassionate, right? And so we get into this place of well, what do we mean by self compassion? What do we think self compassion does? And that's kind of where my brain goes with it.

    Lesley PsyD 6:31

    Yeah, I think I think what I'm hearing in what you're saying too, is there's some belief that's tied up with fear, if I have compassion for myself, I'm afraid that I could become that person, if I let myself versus I think one of the messages from from your content across all platforms is giving yourself Self Compassion, radically, unequivocally where you are, is less likely to lead you there that it's more likely to free you to imagine where you could be next.

    KC Davis 7:05

    So let's just take a minute and actually talk about like a definition of self compassion, because probably there's people listening that are going well, I don't even know what that is. Okay. So I'm gonna read you a definition of self compassion. This is from Dr. Kristin Neff. She's sort of the pioneer of self compassion research. Let me see Here she talks about the three elements of self compassion. So number one is self kindness, versus self judgment. It says self compassion entails being warm and understanding towards ourselves when we suffer, fail feel inadequate, rather than ignoring our pain or flagellating ourselves with self criticism. Self compassionate people recognize that being imperfect, failing and experiencing life difficulties is inevitable, so they tend to be gentle with themselves when confronted with painful experiences rather than getting angry when life falls short of set ideals. People cannot always be or get exactly what they want when this reality is denied are fought against suffering increases in the form of stress, frustration and self criticism. When this reality is accepted with sympathy and self kindness, greater emotional equanimity is experienced. Number two, common humanity versus isolation. So first raishin at not having things exactly what you want is often accompanied by an irrational but pervasive sense of isolation. As if I were the only person suffering or making mistakes all humans suffer. The very definition of Being human means that one is mortal, vulnerable and imperfect. Therefore, self compassion involves recognizing that suffering and personal inadequacy is part of the shared human experience. It doesn't just happen to me alone. And then number three, mindfulness versus over identification. Self Compassion also requires taking a balanced approach to our negative emotions, so that feelings are neither suppressed nor exaggerated. This equilibrium stance stems from process of relating personal experiences to those who are also suffering and thus putting ourselves in a larger perspective. It also stems from the willingness to observe our negative thoughts and emotions with openness and clarity, so that they are held in mindful awareness. Mindfulness is a non judgmental, receptive mind state in which one observes thoughts and feelings as they are without trying to suppress or deny them, we cannot ignore our pain and feel compassion for it at the same time. At the same time, mindfulness requires that we not be over identified. So self compassion, I think part of what I'm sort of hearing in this is that I think some people misconstrue that self compassion means permission for the behavior you're experiencing.

    Lesley PsyD 9:41

    And when you think about permission, that's an attachment to something not this kind of observational lens that we're talking about. So if it's, there's cups all over my house that have old coffee in them, and I'm allowed to do that, and I give myself permission and I don't care what impact that has a me or anybody else that's a that's an anxious attachment to that as a way to not have to feel as a way to get away from my feelings, or standing back. And being an observer that is not attached to that I can come from a place of compassion, which is like, wow, this is really a challenge for me. Here's the story of how this impacts me and other people. And there's no attachment. There's no end to that story. I'm free. So I love that. That detached observer.

    KC Davis 10:28

    Well, and I'm just curious, like the actual definition of compassion. Let's look it up. Okay. Let's see, let's see. All right, sympathetic pity. I don't love the word pity. But let's go with it. And concern for the sufferings or misfortunes of others, who I love that sympathetic concern for the sufferings of others. So what, what we're talking about when we say self compassion is a sympathetic and I would say, sympathetic by nature is gentle, right? A gentle concern for the suffering of ourselves. Right. And I also just think about compassion in general, like this idea that compassion has to be permission or that it will give permission if we're too compassionate. But like, I have felt compassion for people and permission at the same time, right? Like I've looked at moms who are struggling, or young men who are struggling, really anyone and been like, they're giving themselves too hard of a time, they actually should be giving themselves permission to rest, right. But I think sometimes we don't recognize that we're doing two things at once I'm having compassion for their struggle. And I'm feeling sort of permissive or wanting to give them the the, quote, unquote, permission to rest or do whatever or let go of the dishes in the sink, right. But I don't know about you, but like I can, I have had compassion for people that I was not giving permission to. I've listened to actually just heard one recently. And I don't know how accurate the facts of the story is. But I'm just reacting to as if the facts of the story were what I heard. It was this woman who was talking in a court case, and I'm gonna do it just trigger warning, because I'm going to talk about some child abuse, but I'm not going to be graphic. She was describing to the judge in graphic details, how she had abused one of her children, and horrible ways. And she's crying as she says it. And at first, you're just like, horrified. And then you learn that what's happening is that this child was doing the same things or abusing her younger baby, like in really horrific, sadistic ways. And this mom is sort of like, crumbling in the courtroom saying, like, I was trying to say, you know, you don't like it when someone does this to you, and then doing it to him. This child eventually died from the abuse. Now, no part of that do I feel is acceptable, permissive. Okay. And yet, I found myself listening to this mom, who was clearly in pain, who was like thinking about her infant being harmed and tortured continuously, and was kind of at her wit's end and was clearly not equipped, mentally, not support it, like, I felt compassion.

    Lesley PsyD 13:24

    I think that that's an area that we really struggle with, at least in our culture at this time, is the duality of many things that you can be this and that at the same time. And in fact, that's important to be able to separate our compassion, and whether we are signing on to something or saying, oh, yeah, we throw our hands up, that's fine. I do find it. A lot of folks are really struggle with that with others, but especially with themselves.

    KC Davis 13:51

    Well, and I mean, I also felt compassion for that child that had passed away. Right? Like that should not have happened to him. He deserved better. Right? And you have compassion for this tiny little infant, right? Who has no one to protect them except the person that's protecting him in a way that's like not functional at all?

    Lesley PsyD 14:10

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 14:11

    So those are kind of the things that it brings to mind. And specifically going back, like, let's talk about, I saw a video recently of a person who kind of was saying, Gosh, I'm my neighbor's kids, like, keep hanging out outside on the stairwell. They're like two and three, and nobody's watching them. And she goes out with her video camera and sees and one of the little boys has a diaper that's kind of almost falling off covered with fecal matter, and you're just thinking What mother could do this. And I think that's where people's minds go when they go. We can't give that mother permission to be self compassionate.

    Lesley PsyD 14:47

    Yeah, but I think that one of the points you made earlier, so important that that focusing on permission separates us from other people. It does protect us a little bit from having to contemplate that I could never be I could never do that. I don't give permission, I don't I don't make excuses, because that's a whole other thing that I'll never do. Compassion requires that we see our connection. Compassion requires that we see ourselves in that person and imagine what would have had to have happened to take place in order to end there. And I think that that's hard. If you didn't learn that, as a child, or an adolescent, it's hard to be asked to find yourself in someone who is struggling at that level.

    KC Davis 15:27

    Well, and the idea that compassion and accountability can't be together. And here's what it also brings to me. There are people out there, that for whatever reason, whether it is psychological or moral, there's a and it's probably a small percentage, but like, they're just they are doing outright evil things. And they do not care whether they do not care, because they have some sort of psychological, whatever going on, that prevents them from tapping into that empathy, or they just don't, that exists. And I think what a lot of people worry is that what if you know my mother who mistreated me horribly, what if she was listening to Casey Davis and Casey Davis was saying, Oh, let yourself off the hook. Not all moms are perfect, you know, you're doing your best like, then that would have given my mom permission to like, feel right. But in my experience, people who are doing like evil, abusive things to people don't need permission to do them. Not only do they not need permission to do them, like they're going to do them either way. But, you know, they also weren't stopped by shame. They aren't permitted by permission, and they're not stopped by shame. So at some, at some level, like, I don't actually worry that much about some sociopathic person, you know, getting permission, quote, unquote, because like, they're gonna get that permission from themselves from somewhere else, it doesn't matter. I worry more about the person, like the woman that was my client a while back, who relapse on heroin while she was pregnant. And she sat in that group therapy every day, and she could not stop beating herself up, she could not stop being consumed with a feeling of failure and worthlessness. She recognized I have done this horribly harmful thing to my child, she recognized Yes, I have a brain disorder of addiction. And she felt 100% accountable. And I can tell you that sitting in that group over and over and over the majority of the way in which she was not able to show up for her child, the way her child needed at that time, was not related to the fact that she used heroin when she was pregnant. It was related to the fact that she now hated herself to such a degree. She had basically frozen herself psychologically, with how worthless she felt. And we all know what kind of life choices we make when we feel like we're worthless, right? We get with the wrong people, we self sabotage ourselves at work, you know, we don't put in effort to maybe making progress in therapy, because at some point, that motive of I want to get better. But when you're saddled with I don't deserve to be better, right? And so that, of course, is compromising her sobriety. And putting at risk not only not showing up for her kid the way she needs to, but dying, if she relapses again. And I'll never forget her because we're so afraid that if we were to give this mom permission, to have self compassion on herself, to gently look upon her suffering with concern, and kindness, that would lead to her sort of quote, unquote, letting herself off the hook, not taking accountability, not learning how to change her behaviors. But in my experience, we've really got it flip flopped. It is that radical self compassion that allows that mom to stand up and start to recognize what her values are, how her behavior in the past hasn't matched to those values, and not be too ashamed to ask for help changing herself so that she can live up to those values in the future.

    Lesley PsyD 19:35

    Yeah, thank you. No shame is a closed door. It's a period at the end of a sentence. There's nothing that comes after shame. Shame is the reason right because I'm bad because I can't help it because I'm broken. But self compassion leads us to questions like How did it get here and what would have to happen for this to be different? It's an open door. It's it's multiple open doors, in fact, and if we can Learn to view ourselves in that way and each other. I think we start asking the questions that actually do get us moving and are motivating. It's interesting shame really does feel motivating, even though it isn't, that's an interesting phenomenon. It always has been for me. And so it can be hard to break away from that pattern.

    KC Davis 20:19

    You know, I have this weird theory about shame if I ever told you this. So most of the therapists that I practice with talk about how there's really only seven primary emotions, I can think of like a color wheel, there's like, untold, you know, different cues. But they all kind of come back to one of seven emotions. So there's fear, anger, pain, loneliness, joy, guilt, and shame. Now, I actually would replace shame with disgust. Right, like disgust because we feel that for lots of things, and Disgust is this really interesting beast? Because it's both an emotion and, like a sense, like, you know, like, touch, smell disgust. And so when we think about, like, what the role of disgust is, when I think about things that disgust me, you think of like, poop, and vomit, and pus and open sores? And like, what's interesting about that, and is that almost exclusively like, or almost a unanimous, whatever word I'm looking for? It's like all human beings of all cultures experience disgust at these things, almost like it's biological, right? Yeah. And it's smart. Because when I feel disgust, I want to get away from something. And it's really smart for human beings to have this sense of disgust towards things that could get them sick. And I think that some of that overlaps socially, right? Like, what we feel disgust at socially, is typically what society is rejecting or pushing out. And so we don't want to associate with that we don't want to mate with that we don't want to get sort of lumped into the same category. And this is why like, I think when you look at a lot of the phobias, like homophobia, fat phobia, there's a real element of disgust in it. And we want to get out, we want to put that thing as far away from we want to separate ourselves from it, because that's the thing that is going to be pushed out. And we don't want to do that. And I really believe that shame is just disgust at oneself.

    Lesley PsyD 22:31

    And but you can't get away from the thing you're disgusted by,

    KC Davis 22:35

    exactly. You cannot get away from yourself. You believe yourself to be something that is, should be put out should be rejected. And yet, the other part of you is fighting for what is on a very basic level life and death, which is inclusion in your pack. Yeah. And, and so it feels like it feels motivating. Oh, God, I gotta, I gotta stop this, I gotta get away from this, I gotta fix this, or I'm gonna, it's not motivating. It's just panic, panic feels like motivation. Yeah. But I haven't really seen, I mean, you can get a little movement, right? Like, when I scream at my kids, and I feel shame afterwards, there's that this isn't my values. Like, that's like the gift of shame is it tells me when I'm not behaving in line with my values. But that's it. Like, it's just information, shame can give you information. And if we take that information, and then practice self compassion, we can then do something with that information to actually change. But it can only give you information, it can't give you momentum, it can't create change. And so what we do with that information matters, right? Like we depending on what we believe about ourselves, we can either bury the information, oh my God, I don't act within my values, I must be a piece of shit. I just screamed at my kid, I can't let anyone know that I do this, I'm gonna go drink to not feel about it, right. And then it gets worse and worse, or we can go, wow, that's not the kind of parent I want to be. And I'm probably experiencing a universal experience right now. And I'm gonna reach out for help. And I'm going to get support, and I'm gonna figure out what's going wrong so that I can be different.

    Lesley PsyD 24:21

    And that's the small shifts, I think that compassion allows us to have and maybe that's another piece of this is I think it may be difficult for folks to imagine going from a place of shame based behavior, to a place of self compassion. I mean, those seem like polls, but in actuality, self compassion just enables you to make 1000 Tiny shifts, and they don't always have to be in one direction. So I still experience I do this for a living. I talked to amazing people like you I still experience shame. I'm looking at a side of a room right now that does not bring me joy. But when you practice of compassion enough, that shift becomes was very quick and what you what happens starts to happen is I noticed the shame. And I gently shift towards self compassion. It becomes just a learned behavior that you can then pass down to children.

    KC Davis 25:11

    I love it. Thank you so much. This was so wonderful.

    Lesley PsyD 25:14

    Thank you for having me.

    KC Davis 25:15

    Of course.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

Christy Haussler
45: Best of You can't save the rainforest if you're depressed with Imani Barbarin

I’m excited to introduce you to today’s guest. Imani Barbarin is a disability rights and inclusion activist and speaker who uses her platform for conversations around the disability community. I’ve followed her for a while on TikTok and appreciate the way she expresses her opinions and helps educate the rest of us. Come join us now!

Show Highlights:

  • How Imani explored and discovered her passion for advocacy for disability and inclusion rights

  • How climate change and disability are linked

  • Why environmental ableism is a real thing

  • How people have become victims of their non-nuanced thinking, only wanting to be on the “right” side

  • Why the COVID pandemic has become a “mass-disabling” event, especially regarding mental health

  • Examples of ways in which the environmental movement has left those with disabilities behind

  • Why society has a general disdain for disabled people and believes that they don’t (or won’t) contribute to society

  • How the luxury of abled people trumps the necessity of the disabled

  • What the function of capitalism is on disabled bodies

  • How disabled people are used as pawns in the pro-choice/pro-life debate

  • Why there is inherent racism in the pro-life movement

  • What laziness is and is not

Resources:

Connect with Imani: Website and Instagram

Resources mentioned: https://www.sinsinvalid.org, https://disasterstrategies.org, https://www.americanprogress.org 

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to struggle care. I'm your host, KC Davis. And I'm taking a well needed break this month. But I want to play for you some of my best episodes my most downloaded. This episode here is called you can't save the rainforest when you're depressed. And it's an incredible conversation with Imani Barbara, and she's a disability rights and inclusion activist and speaker who uses her voice and social media platforms to create conversations engaging the disability community Born with cerebral palsy, Imani often writes and uses her platforms to speak from the perspective of a disabled black woman. So if you are someone who has ever experienced guilt or shame over not being eco perfect, and you need some more accessibility in your life, this conversation is for you. So Imani. First of all, thank you so much for making the time to be here.

    Imani Barbarin 0:48

    Of course, thank you for having me.

    KC Davis 0:50

    I have been following you. I almost said stalking you. But then I thought maybe that was on creepy on Tik Tok. And I really liked your content. And I learned a lot from you. And I really appreciate the way that you express your opinions on things from like several different identities that I learned from. I'm like Saltine, cracker white person. And I feel like I've learned a lot about you from about race. I feel like I've learned a lot about you in the disability realm. And so I'm really grateful to sort of bring your expertise to the next little time we have together.

    Imani Barbarin 1:30

    Oh, thank you. I'm really excited to be on this podcast with you.

    KC Davis 1:33

    So how did you come to a spot where you found yourself advocating for disability

    Imani Barbarin 1:39

    after college? Well, during college, I was kind of exploring my disability identity more, I was just kind of like hit over the head with all of these concepts about disability that had literally changed my entire life. But up until that point, but I had no words to put to it. And so like kind of discovering that language, like I was hungry for it. And I wanted to understand more about myself and my community is also my identity at the crux of being both black and disabled at the time. Well, always but and so like my professors were really excited to like, be like, go go wild with it. Like we don't care like, as long as you just turn in your assignments on time, you can explore whatever part of your disability you're writing. And so I was so grateful for that. Or that after college, I kind of worked as an assistant for a little while, but it wasn't really my thing. And I just started my blog because I really just wanted to write about disability, and just talk about it with somebody, anybody, and just talk about my experiences being black and disabled, and kind of feeling like very isolated growing up. And then from there, I just started promoting it on social media. And here we are.

    KC Davis 2:47

    So one of the things that happened to me when I got on Tik Tok, and I sort of accidentally found this platform where I talk about mental health was that I started talking specifically about the idea of adaptive routines for people with mental health disorders. So you know, the benefit of running your dishwasher every day. So that there's a routine for someone that maybe has ADHD, we talked about the idea of getting paper plates for someone who's too depressed and doesn't have any dishes to eat off of. And really quickly, I started to get a lot of hate comments from people who were saying, you cannot recommend this. It's so bad for the environment. And I understand the initial pushback, right. And so I would sort of say, well, here's the thing, though, we're talking about harm reduction. We're talking about adaptive routines for people with mental health disorders. And but what surprised me, and it's sad to me that it surprised me because what it tells me is that this is the attitude in general, and I just woke up to it in the last year was people would come back and say things like, you being sad is not an excuse to kill the earth with paper plates.

    Imani Barbarin 4:01

    Oh, yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's really wrapped up in like white supremacy. And I feel like it's one of the very few things where people are actually passionate about. And so they see, climate change is a threat to the life which touch all of our lives. And so their virulence in their hatred of disabled people, when we say things like, that's just not feasible for us, like we were creating these routines. So it's accessible to us, but it's alarming to say the least.

    KC Davis 4:28

    And what I was doing some reading around that time, and one of the things that sort of jumped out to me and it wasn't specifically about mental health disability, but it was just about disability in general, when it came to climate change. The demographic that is one of the most impacted by the harms of climate change is the disability community. And they were talking specifically about some things that happened like in Hurricane Katrina, where the amount of people that died, who were disabled because they could not get out people could not service them. They did not have any access to the things that they needed was way overblown. In terms of like disability rate in the population like it should it was an unconscionable amount of people with disabilities.

    Imani Barbarin 5:11

    Yeah, I mean, it's always the risk. And so it's always really upsetting when people say the disabled people just don't care about the environment, because we're telling you what we need, but it flies in the face of your performative activism or their performative activism. And then when you look at the actual numbers about it, disabled people are the most affected by climate change. We cannot. I mean, if you ever see videos on Tiktok, there's several videos of like, kids in wheelchairs or kids on crutches and the fire alarm at school goes off, and nobody thinks to grab this kid. Right? If you nobody thinks to grab them. That is literally how we deal with climate change. We leave disabled people behind. And so like this pervasive ableism, behind this environmentalist movement, is really flying in the face of this goal of preserving the earth for all of us. Yeah, I think it's no mistake, either that the two highest groups for disability in the country are indigenous people, for the land back, and black people like to demographics of people who this country has been trying to eradicate, for centuries, have the highest rates of disability, if people who consider themselves environmentalist, have no problem doing away with these demographics and people?

    KC Davis 6:22

    And I mean, if I had to guess it would seem obvious that the role of white supremacy is a huge role in why these populations are seeing higher rates of disability. Oh, yeah,

    Imani Barbarin 6:35

    I mean, environmental ableism is real, if you don't have access to clean drinking water, that means disability, if you don't have access to doctors that believe you, that's disability, if you've structural racism, from institutions, that's disability, so it ableism and racism are interwoven so deeply, that it's alarming to me that people will be so overtly ableist and then claim themselves to be anti racist. You can't be one without the other.

    KC Davis 7:04

    Do you ever feel like sometimes as white people, like, we want so badly to be oppressed? And maybe we found that in environmentalism?

    Imani Barbarin 7:14

    Yeah, I think it's two things. I think that like, white people want to be oppressed. And so they found They latched on to environmentalism. But simultaneously, it's one of the few things that when you advocate for it, it doesn't have a voice of its own to disagree with you to say that you're not advocating for me correctly. It's more of a pet. Yes, the pro life movement of the left, like the perfect victim.

    KC Davis 7:39

    So because as a white person, I get to be simultaneously the victim and to the Savior. Yes, exactly. And who wouldn't want that. And I know that people sometimes bristle at the idea that white people want to be oppressed, but I'm someone who came from the evangelical church, I still very much a person of faith, but I'm sort of deconstructing my evangelicalism. And I've never been offended by that only because like, when you go to church, and the pastor tells you, like, you're on the right side, you're for God, but they don't know. And they want to stop you. And you know, we're gonna persevere. And we're this and it's like, that feels good.

    Imani Barbarin 8:17

    Yeah, it does. I mean, I grew up in the church. So I'm very familiar with all of the same rhetoric that you are. And one of the things about white supremacy is that it lacks nuance. And so whenever you think of yourself as the Savior, or is the one helping on the righteous side, everybody else is on the wrong side, right? It's not through, there's nuance to literally everything. And so when white people position themselves as environmentalists, and people were fighting back and be like, Listen, this is not as inclusive as you think it is, then everybody else is wrong, is is the exact same positioning, regardless of the argument.

    KC Davis 8:52

    It's the trump card, it's the ace of spades, as long as I'm on the right side. And you know, it's interesting, I see sort of queues of that show up a lot and some other content where somebody comes in at the most recent one was we were talking about like the breast is best campaign. And people come in, and they really think as long as I'm on what I believe to be the quote, unquote, right side of this information. It doesn't matter who I'm harming. Like, I'm absolved of who I harm who I step over, as long as at the end of the day in this sort of black and white non nuanced thinking. I'm on the right side of the issue.

    Imani Barbarin 9:29

    Yeah, exactly. And I think that I've seen some of this most like, disgusting ableism and racism towards the indigenous community here is demanding land back and rightfully so. Like every single indigenous practice, regardless of other malted meat or not, is more sustainable than what white people are proposing. You get people ignore them? Because it's more comfortable to believe that you're in the right simply because you're you're saying something when you're not like, you know, these practices have been in place for 1000s of years and simply just have the arrogance to say, to look at a community who's been living with so few resources for so long, based off of ancient practices and just be like, No, I don't like that at discount it. It doesn't apply to me. Like, that's arrogance. That's white supremacy. And it will kill us, who will literally kill us if we do not listen to communities who've been doing this for centuries.

    KC Davis 10:23

    So one of the things that I heard you say one time and a tick tock, you said that COVID is not just a mass mortality event. COVID is a mass disabling event. And I thought about that for days. And, you know, it's obviously a physically mass disabling event, we have people who are now long haulers with their physical health. But the other thing that I thought about was that it's also mass disabling psychologically, oh, 100%, like the amount of people that never dealt with mental health symptoms, or maybe were able to manage these mental health symptoms, are finding themselves struggling in a way that they weren't before, because of all the circumstances around COVID. And I thought that was such a thing we don't talk about. Yeah,

    Imani Barbarin 11:07

    I mean, I would even argue that people who never were diagnosed with COVID have exacerbated mental health symptoms, because of this sheer isolation if you're taking it seriously. And so there's going to be ton of people that are, you know, coming out of this, you know, with agoraphobia, and anxiety and depression. And I think that people are at a breaking point, you know, in terms of the mental health, which is very scary, because we simultaneously do not have any infrastructure for mental health care in this country. Like, I think I read somewhere that, you know, our prison system is the largest mental health system in the country. Does that why why? Why is that a thing? And so yeah, there's gonna be tons of people who are dealing with mental health care for the very first time, who don't know how to reach out to a healthcare provider. And because hospitals or get again, at capacity, are not gonna be able to get to see a mental health care provider, or, you know, be admitted if they choose to, for mental health care. So, yeah, we really don't know the long lasting repercussions of COVID. societally, interpersonally, we won't know those things until decades from now.

    KC Davis 12:12

    And one of the things that I found sort of fascinating was when people push back so hard on this idea of adaptive routines, you know, when I thought about this term, eco ableism, you know, what came to mind for me was sort of the plastic straw debate, which was sort of my most recent memory of the big environmental push that sort of left people with disabilities behind. And that was a big conversation. And so I'm curious if you know, for someone who's listening, that maybe this is their first time thinking about these types of issues. Can you give us other examples of ways in which the environmental movement has left people with disabilities behind?

    Imani Barbarin 12:54

    Yeah, I mean, so first of all, the straw bans were my personal health, but I never, I never want to talk about them again. or dislike them. I don't ever want to talk about them again. But no, I mean, I do all the time, because people just never let it die. So even you know, environmental preparation routines that people tweet out, or ableist, because they simply do not take into account like one of the recommendations for people to prepare for an emergency environmental disaster, is to collect one month's worth of medications, In what world, people are struggling to pay for insulin from month to month, and you're asking somebody to just save some insulin for literally a rainy day. That's not possible, you know, there needs to be infrastructure with that. And people always like, well, you could just siphon off a little bit here and there like this, no medication works. There's also the idea that single use plastics, like you said, are unnecessary to disabled people, disabled people we pay 28% More of our income, then non disabled people just to have the same quality of life. Because of inaccessibility, it little things like having to do the dishes, having to take the trash out and having a cleaner to help us. I'm having an assistant to help us. And people are like, well, you're contributing to plastics, why can't you just wash the dishes like everybody else? Because we can't do everything like everybody else you can try to tell I go and people get really belligerent when you bring up that fact. And I always kind of throw back in people's face, you know, although kn 95. All of these, you know, medical masks that we're not wearing for COVID-19 that doctors are wearing, keep you safe or maybe have a plastic. There's far less pushback when it comes to keeping non disabled people live than it is to keep disabled people live because we they do not believe we deserve to live in their heart of hearts. And that was one of the things that's so dangerous about ableism is that we are taught from a very young age to praise eugenics in our society. And the minute the minute, you ask somebody how their beliefs impact the disability community If they're progressive, they almost always flip on a dime, and start acting like, we don't deserve to live like literally on a dime. I've talked to people who are pro choice. And then as soon as I bring up the fact that Disabled Parents want to keep in half, they're having keep their children to be like, Oh, well, they should be sterilized, like literally on a dime. And that instinct is going to harm our entire society. Because when we think about, like I said before the racial breakdowns of disability, you cannot be anti racist without being anti ablest. And so the same thing applies to environmentalism, if you're telling a certain group of people that the way that they survive, everyday life doesn't matter, and that they should do what you tell them to do. Without any sort of alternatives that are actually feasible to that community, you're literally saying to them, I don't care if you live or die, because a lot of the things that people think is frivolous for the disability community is quite literally life and death for us. And so that instinct is going to do more harm than it could ever do any good.

    KC Davis 16:04

    You know, what it reminds me of is, every time somebody dies of COVID, the first thing that gets asked is well, did they have any underlying health conditions?

    Imani Barbarin 16:13

    Oh, yeah. Yeah. 100%. And people will say that automatically, I'm like, does my life matter any less? Because they did, or, and people really do tell on themselves? When they ask that question.

    KC Davis 16:24

    And I get why they're asking, I think there's this fear of, I want to believe this can't happen to me, I want to other myself, like, if I'm not somebody that has some type of disability, then maybe I don't have to deal with the existential anxiety around the fact that I too, can die.

    Imani Barbarin 16:43

    Yeah, and that's that cockiness. Again, because we're in America, like, the sudden matter of fact, is that not a lot of us have access to regular health care. So the idea that somebody can walk around thinking they're healthy is just false. If you haven't been to the doctor in a year, you have no idea what's going on what underlying conditions you have, even if you are seeing your doctor regularly, you may or may not know what's actually going on with your body. So the idea that is only immunocompromised people dying is only immunocompromised people that we know of.

    KC Davis 17:13

    Well, and when you talk about COVID being a mass disabling event, even for people that don't get COVID Think about the amount of women that didn't get their mammograms and 2020. Because, you know, the risk benefit at the time was, you know, let's not go out, let's not go to the doctor, let's push anything that's not urgent. And like some of those women have cancer that was not caught.

    Imani Barbarin 17:34

    Exactly. You know, even people who because there's certain medications, you have to be blood tested for me never gotten those medications, you know, the people who have lupus, and who want hydrochloric, when was trending or whatever, could not get their medication, their illnesses, were exacerbated as well. People who cannot get chemo treatments because hospitals aren't capacity. People who cannot even like minor things can turn into disabilities, if they're not treated. And with hospitals, that capacity, that's more likely to happen. So you can never say from one day to the next that you're not disabled, that's just not possible.

    KC Davis 18:10

    I'm still really like stuck on your comment about how, you know, when we talk about what the general public are, what a healthy person needs to stay healthy. no one bats an eye, even if that's a bunch of plastic. Everyone needs a mask. Now, everyone needs gloves now. Okay, let's do it. Because, you know, we have to obviously, if you tell them that same person, that somebody with a disability needs something with a disposable plastic to live, you're totally right, we do have this attitude of, well, you're just making it up, or you're just being indulgent. Or you can find another way. And I think I'm truly simultaneously blown away at that connection. And like, sad at the knowledge that obviously, that's true. And I feel like I wake up to pieces of this more and more.

    Imani Barbarin 18:58

    Yeah, it's one of the most upsetting things to learn about society. Is that like, you know, I remember somebody said to my video and said, like, I did not believe you when you said that most people hate disabled people. And I was like, yeah, that's not something I lightly say, I may be jokingly making a joke or be sarcastic about it. But it's very cool. This disdain that society has that, you know, the thing that society hates most about disabled people is that we've survived it despite his best efforts to kill us. And that's the truth. And so whenever people question what we do to stay alive, they're really questioning, why are you alive? Like, why? If your life is going to mean mine, then why would somebody less than me want to stay alive?

    KC Davis 19:43

    I mean, and not to mention, you know, we haven't even touched on how much capitalism has to do with this. Because if I'm taught from a young age that I'm only worth what I'm able to produce when I'm able to work. I mean, obviously, then that belief I'm going to color the way that I see someone who in my view, can't produce or can't contribute in the way that I can or even at all,

    Imani Barbarin 20:07

    you have not only can't but there's this perception that, you know, disabled people really aren't as disabled as we say we are and that we won't contribute as much as we should, which is a very important distinction, because then we, you know, we restrict social safety nets, based on this perception that people won't contribute if they get the necessary resources, or they won't participate in work, or life if they have access to health care, which is why our health care is actually tied to our employment because of racism. Because a lot of jobs, a lot of these jobs that came with health insurance, were mostly filled by white people. And that's why our healthcare is tied to our employment epoch. Yeah, capitalism is really like a mind bender. When you think about the ways in which disability plays a role in a lot of people disabled themselves with this idea to do they need to hustle and prove that they're better than everybody else, or prove that they're not as lazy as those other people who were just leeches on the system or whatever. So all around is very damaging. One of

    KC Davis 21:09

    the things that I heard you say in a tick tock was you were talking about cuz sometimes people will say, well, obviously, if someone needs that plastic, they can have it, but the rest everybody else should be. And I thought you had a really interesting point where you said, like, we can't play that game.

    Imani Barbarin 21:24

    Yeah, one of the things that, like, it should be abundantly clear to everybody is that things do not become available to disabled people, unless non disabled people want them, you know, work from home, telemedicine, all these things only became available, because it became necessary for non disabled people. Now transfer that over to the plastic and you know, recycling debate. If we don't have plastic straws, if you don't have plastic cutlery or paper plates, there's no way disabled people are getting them, because not only will they not be available, but also many places, they'll just be scarce, which means the price will go up, which means a lot of disabled people won't be able to afford them. And contrary to popular belief, not a lot of us have, you know, access to assistance or aides are people that will help us like this not a thing that happens. So they're literally like, piece by piece, a piece of plastic with a piece of glass, like killing off disabled people with a lot of their ideas. When you

    KC Davis 22:18

    talk about sort of exploring your identity as a disabled person, I'm curious if you have any thoughts on what I'm about to say next. Because whenever I talk on my channel about adaptive routines, and I talk about things like if what's gonna get you to eat today is a prepackaged salad. Like you need to buy the pre packaged salad. And when I get pushback from people about, you know, disposable toothbrushes, and they'll say, Well, you know, you can't promote this to people, because, you know, we're all going to kill the world, our disposable toothbrushes, but one of the things that I find is that a lot of people and this might be true of other disabilities, too, but in particular, a lot of people that I see with mental health disabilities, they don't quite know, whether they are disabled enough to deserve what they see as well. You can have it if you quote unquote, really need it.

    Imani Barbarin 23:11

    Yeah, that's something I see a lot in my advocacy is that at least people, you know, who are coming into their disability identity will tell me Oh, I didn't know that. Like, I could do that. And we're also it's not funny, but it's also kind of very just sad in a way, because whenever we hear functioning labels as disabled people, particularly in like the Disability Justice Movement, we cringe, because this is the purpose of those functioning labels, like high functioning, low functioning, is this way of setting up a hierarchy of who needs help and who does not. And we reinforce it every single day with our language, and with our perceptions of what high functioning versus low functioning people need. And people think that just because they're on one end of a spectrum versus the other, they don't need as many supports, or they'll pass judgment on somebody else for navigating the world in a different way, by saying, Oh, they're less than they just, they're worse off than me. When in reality, you just need what you need. Right? Like, you don't need to add qualifiers to you don't need to beg for acceptance from non disabled people, because honest to god, I do not care what those people think, like, I have to survive them every single day, you think I'm gonna give them the peace of purchase in my brain as well. Like, they don't have a lot of land up there. They just know like, I don't care. So you got like these functioning levels play like a very serious role in the way that we talk about disability. And people don't even understand like once they come into their disability identity, just how ingrained they are in us and how damaging they are. But I really hope that people kind of deconstruct that, because you're going to need what you're going to need you're not better or less than anybody else. Some people have more accessibility needs. Some people have less. Some people need to need plastic straws. Some people need like sippy cups like It doesn't stop passing judgment on what you need to survive. You're just do what you have to do to survive this, the only thing people can ask of you.

    KC Davis 25:07

    One of the things that was really hard for me postpartum both times with my kids was brushing my teeth. And I actually got postpartum depression and anxiety with my second who was born three weeks before the pandemic. And it was, the word that comes to mind now is suffering, like, it was so difficult, it was so hard. And I'm someone who for the most part, like I had addiction, really, really early on, I had some sort of diagnoses floating around. But then like, for the most part of my adult life was pretty stable, mentally, physically and otherwise. So to go through this pandemic, and all of a sudden feel like I'm not that stable anymore, despite being a therapist being mature, having all of this, you know, education and experience was interesting. And it was it got harder and harder. And I've tried lots of sort of, Oh, I'll put my toothbrush in the sink at the kitchen, I'll put it on my list of closing duties. And what I finally did a couple weeks ago, because I started having tooth pain, and I was like, I'm gonna have to go back to the dentist, I also have a complete phobia of dental work, I broke down and bought myself a box of 144 prepasted toothbrushes, and for the first time in 18 months, I've been brushing my teeth every day. And so I also have ADHD. So I think there's some executive functioning issues around it and you know, not having a nine to five job where you have the get up, go to the vanity, do your things. And I found myself even though I talk all the time about, you know, you need what you need, you know, using resources, it's not wasting resources, you need what you need, I have had so much guilt over it. I haven't even made a tech talk about it, because I thought I just I can't justify it, I'll never be able to convince people that I'm not just this wasteful. And what I did in my mind to try and sort of resolve this, like cognitive dissidence was I started thinking about, Okay, what in my life, could I take out, I'll stop using paper towels, I'll that's what I'll do. I'll stop using paper towels, and I'll stop getting Starbucks. And that way, it'll sort of even out so I'm not doing more. And that'll be my justification that I can tell people's Well, I cut these things out. So I'm not really my footprint isn't bigger. And what hit me all at once was, Oh, my God, paper towels. And Starbucks cups are not morally superior to prepasted toothbrushes. And yet, somebody somewhere who is able bodied able mind set the acceptable usage of plastic and said, You know, nobody is going to judge you for using paper towels. And there might be some people that will roll their eyes at your disposable Starbucks cup, but like you getting takeout once a week, nobody is going to come and give you a death threat for that.

    Imani Barbarin 27:44

    Yeah. And that's a wildest thing about ableism to me is that ableism is so pervasive that people I have never met in my life, people I will never meet people I don't even know don't even have a concept of cannot even imagine their faces have an effect on how I live my life. Because we have been recycling these exact same perceptions, about disability about wastefulness over and over and over again, people who do not like who people who I would not blink twice, that are shaping the way in which I live my life, so I feel less guilty for them.

    KC Davis 28:22

    I don't know. It's just wild to me that somebody who is you know, I want this is the best ever. I one time had a woman shame me for saying that I ran my dishwasher even when it wasn't full, because that's what allows me to overcome the executive dysfunction of like being able to keep up with my dishes. And I went to her page, I'm not kidding you and money. She was a travel blogger. You gotta be kidding me. This woman had been on at least eight airplanes in two years.

    Imani Barbarin 28:52

    No, no, no. See, that's the thing, like, because that's the thing, like, their luxury. Trump's your necessity.

    KC Davis 29:01

    Like, I'm just trying to brush my teeth over here. I know that if people have these ideas that maybe if I tried harder, I could do it in a more sustainable way. And I get it because I have those own internal voices. But I finally did almost take my own medicine and go Well, Casey, you know what, it's been 18 months. And it's been at least eight months of you trying with self compassion, but very much trying to find a routine in your life that will make this part of your health successful. And at the end of the day, they're probably going to use just as much disposable plastic to fix your fucking teeth at the dentist. If you don't stop, I'm gonna find a way to brush your teeth.

    Imani Barbarin 29:38

    Completely because I have trouble brushing my teeth too. When I get into depressive episodes, I have generalized anxiety disorder. And then I also have what they like to affectionately call double depression. So like I struggle with the same things. And I also grind my teeth when I'm stressed out. So like I remember like, just my teeth were so bad. I bitten to a chip in it. cracked my tooth, like in half. So my teeth are like, very sensitive, because of the sheer amount of anxiety that I've had my entire life. So I understand completely like the in the amount of like plastic bags that go into, you know, you're getting your free, you know, take home toothbrush after you for hours. Team and you're just like, well, I guess it is what it is now? Yeah, like, Why does her luxury, she's doing worse for the planet than you are doing just to survive your day. Like the audacity it takes to look at somebody else's life and be like, well, you're ruining the planet. I don't do any of those things. But I'm gonna go to Bali for like two weeks, and I'm going to not pay as much for food to underpaid, you know, the workers that are indigenous to that area. And, you know, right on a moped,

    KC Davis 30:51

    yeah, the issue really isn't that there's an objective amount of waste you're allowed to produce, it's that you can't produce it as a disabled person.

    Imani Barbarin 31:01

    Right? That's wild. Listen, any space you take up when people do not expect you to live is too much space for other people, they do not care. They think that you know, you living is a luxury, it is a privilege, and they can take it away from you at any second and pass judgments of your entire time here. And then with a real messed up part is when they use your life, to inspire themselves, but leave you in the US.

    KC Davis 31:30

    So you get to be inspiration porn, that's like the role that capitalism has made acceptable. Like, that's the only acceptable role.

    Imani Barbarin 31:37

    Yeah, I always say inspiration. exploitation is enable a society placing value on a disabled life where in which they do not find any otherwise. That's the function of capitalism on disabled bodies, if we take advantage of these stories, and we present them to disabled people and non disabled people and say, they're both for the grace of God go on, you know, that type of thinking, when in reality, we've left disabled people to die at every turn in this country. And your inspiration, is you just surviving that.

    KC Davis 32:10

    And I mean, we haven't even touched on the reality that the individual carbon footprint is like laughably, since like, 20%, right? Not really going to turn things around, for better or for worse, is really just not going to have an impact if we can't move things at a political level. And it must be scary that the people who are willing to move things at a political level still manage to leave people with disabilities behind.

    Imani Barbarin 32:40

    Oh, yeah, like, the reason why I don't revisit the straw man argument very often, is because we got death threats, like, people were telling us, oh, you should kill yourself. Disabled people don't deserve to live anyways, we'll just let them die off over straws. Like is the most absurd thing like when you just say like, it's just over straws, but it was true people were telling us that, you know, will compassionately euthanize disabled people. And if it comes to it, like,

    KC Davis 33:08

    it's like the liberal version of when conservatives blow up abortion clinics, because they don't believe in murder, right? Like, they kill doctors or like, rally, he was a murderer.

    Imani Barbarin 33:17

    Right? Like, and that's the scary thing. Like I said, people will shift their beliefs, the instant disability is introduced, and that instinct is gets a lot of people killed all the time,

    KC Davis 33:28

    you can walk so far to the left, that you just look back around and hang out with eugenics.

    Imani Barbarin 33:33

    Right? Like, we're kidding. When we say like people believe in eugenics, like hardcore, they really do. They do not think that they're just as bad as some other people. Because like we said before, white supremacy lacks nuance. So if I'm in the right, everybody else is in the wrong.

    KC Davis 33:50

    That's super fascinating. And you know, with the conversation right now, with the Texas abortion ban, one of the things you know, when you and you were recently talking about the rate of sexual assault on the disabled community, and how you know, when we get sort of blindly without nuance into something without being able to consider a disability, and you were talking about how sometimes sterilization was about preventing sexual assault. And one of the things that came to my mind was that it was so horrible, this politician, basically using the excuse that, you know, I think it was like up to 40% of people or babies with Down syndrome are aborted once that found out that they have Down syndrome. And he was trying to sort of conflate like, this is why this is a really righteous like, we can't let anybody get abortions, which was really kind of disgusting, but there is this side of abortion where you can get so blindly pro choice that you don't stop to have the nuanced conversation about the amount of ableism that goes into that choice when it comes to, you know, being able to fight I doubt that your fetus in utero has a disability.

    Imani Barbarin 35:01

    Yeah, and the abortion debate is very tricky for a lot of disabled people. Because, you know, I had relatives telling my mom to abort me when my mom thought I would likely be disabled and but my mom and I are both pro choice regardless, like my mom still carried me to term, but she's very pro choice. But my mom always reiterated to me like growing up like I wanted you like, I still want you, I want you as my daughter. But I still reserve the right to have a choice and for you to have a choice. And people really lack those conversations. And it's really irritating. Just how often disabled people are used as pawns in this argument over pro choice or pro life, and nobody really asks us what we need. You know, not a lot of disabled people even get sexual education. Not a lot of disabled people even get sexual health care. When I was talking about the story about people who sterilized disabled people, it's not to prevent rape is to prevent children, they're not meant to prevent the rake, they're just trying to prevent the children. And like, that's the more devastating part is like, they're not even trying to address the root issue to a lot of these problems. They know that the abuse is gonna continue, they just don't want any children birth and disabled people.

    KC Davis 36:11

    And the politician that was talking about, you know, uh, well, you know, it's just so ableist to abort a Down syndrome, a fetus that has Down syndrome. And it always comes across to me like, it's this like, gotcha moment, like, we know that the lefties are into not being able to. So what do you say now? Gotcha. And it is not it is being upon

    Imani Barbarin 36:34

    it is also a miscalculation of the left to cause like they will 100%. What are you talking about? Like, yeah, what of it? Exactly. But I think one of the things that is so irritating about that argument about people with Down syndrome being aborted is that like, if they had the social services in place, where disabled people to survive, once we take our first breath, rather than us just being in utero, less people would probably make that decision. Like, the nature of us being pawns in a lot of these arguments, is to just ignore us once we're alive regardless. So I don't like I hate that argument. Because I know how difficult of a decision it is for a lot of, you know, pregnant people to make that choice, whether to have an abortion, and to have an abortion, whether because it's a disabled child, or might just be a disabled child, it was a hard decision to make. And I think that people just erase the fact that if we did better by disabled people who were alive already, people would not feel as pressured to make that decision.

    KC Davis 37:42

    Yeah, that's kind of the breakdown of the whole pro life argument in general, which is, if you really wanted to reduce the amount of abortions, you would make it not suck so bad to be a parent. Yeah, who was unsupported or and a child who can't, doesn't get the social safety net?

    Imani Barbarin 38:00

    Well, I mean, it also points to the racism of the pro life movement, which is that they don't expect these children who these unwanted children, these pregnancies that are carried to term out of the soul and, and strife to actually be members of slidy, a lot of these children are shuffled into the prison system, like that's the entire point. You know, a lot of white people want a white ethno state, and then to arrest and incarcerate children of color, then, like, that's the end point. And so like, even the argument that we're trying to make is, you know, irrespective of this idea that race plays a role, it very much so plays a role. And I think the right has projected outwards decades, what they hope this moment in history will do for white supremacy. And so yeah,

    KC Davis 38:50

    you know, you started our conversation by talking about how, for lack of a better term, anti ableist. And what I think has been interesting is, as we've been talking, we're sort of naturally not even jumping, but like we're naturally having to talk a little bit about white supremacy and talk a little bit about the abortion debate, talk a little bit about indigenous rights talk a little bit about and it's, it really is so entwined, and I feel like well, I want to thank you, because I feel as though even having this conversation with you has been illustrative of that, that it's just been even impossible. It's like we can't sit down and go, Okay, we're just gonna talk about eco ableism for 45 minutes. No, like, by necessity, we had to sort of foray into all these other identity intersections and issues and so that I feel like that sort of makes your point so beautifully.

    Imani Barbarin 39:46

    It's one of those things where like, weather always makes fun of me because if anybody triggers a disability conversation to me, I will always bring up my statistics about how it affects racially. I mean, that's also the reason why we're seeing a lot of these Republican bills that look like how to menus on how to exclude disabled people, because a lot of the areas that they're excluding, and cutting and restricting voting access, fall along the lines of things that have aided disabled people in particular disabled people of color in voting in past elections. So yeah, it all connects. And I think that disability is kind of like the crux of a lot of different movements that I don't think people really realize can be used against them. Because like I said, that instinct is very frightening. And it will turn on a dime, to say, Oh, those people don't matter. But then we actually look at the numbers, you actually be like, Oh, crap, that would actually eradicate an entire group of people.

    KC Davis 40:41

    And I feel like ability, in particular, physical or mental ability is always like the unrecognized privilege. Like anytime I've brought up issues of privilege on any of my content channels, there's always like, the disaffected, lower income white person that's like, I really didn't have privilege, because they kind of do their list. Or I, sometimes I get it from women where they'll say, you know, if I can keep my house clean, you should be able to keep your house clean. And at the end of the day, they're like, Well, I didn't have any privileges, I can't afford a maid, you know, I didn't have these things. And you're like, the fact that you can stand for 10 minutes is a privilege.

    Imani Barbarin 41:23

    Yeah, I call them. I like to make fun of non disabled people a lot, just to keep them on their toes. And I call them like, celebrating their default setting, like, really good defaults, like, I get it, you could do all these things. But like, I don't care, I'm still gonna have to do what I have to do. Because the truth of the matter is, is because of a lot of the Savior behavior, they believe that there's always going to be somebody to help. That's just not true, that there's always gonna be somebody that will rise above and, you know, really make a difference. And social media has really impacted and kind of warped our perception of how we as a society help one another because we're doing a lot of this stuff on camera, we're filming people at their worst moments needing help, for likes. And people seem to think that that's the norm. It's not like that's not normal, but it's not normal, that people are gonna just rush up to me and help me, most of the time, people are just grabbing at me for fun. So it's not like people are going to actually be grabbing at me to help me nine times out of 10. And if they do, sometimes they actually wind up hurting me. So this idea that, like people have resources that we need, and we're just taking advantage of the system is kind of this pervasive idea that kind of started with Reagan. And you know, the welfare queen stereotype which is extended to black women, particularly who were disabled, that were leeches on the system, and that anybody who's taking advantage of a social safety net, doesn't actually need it, Reagan, it can be traced to a lot of ableism of the country, in the United States, particularly the way he weaponized racial stereotypes along the axis of disability.

    KC Davis 43:00

    I feel like so if you're someone who's listening to this podcast, and you're resonating with maybe some of the things we've talked about, about, you know, you need what you need. And you're still kind of hearing that inner voice that says, Oh, not me, no, I think maybe I'm just lazy. I just want to take a minute to say that as a therapist, I've seen so many clients, I've seen so many clients with mental health issues with addiction, seeing clients with physical disabilities, and I have to say, I've never met someone who's truly lazy.

    Imani Barbarin 43:30

    There's no such thing. Like, there's really no such thing as lazy. There are people that can, and there are people that just are not able to. And we have this perception that they won't, again, there's going back to this idea that people just won't do the right thing. Whereas there's not enough services is of course, for people to be able to survive. And so they're just struggling all the time.

    KC Davis 43:51

    Yeah. And I always say like, don't get me wrong. I mean, entitlement exists. Exploitation exists. There are definitely people out there that feel like they have more right to labor to leisure and rest than somebody else does. And so it really should be these people were breaking their backs and working so that I can rest. But that's not laziness. That's entitlement. Yeah. Right. Like the person listening to this podcast, who's like, Oh, God, I think I would probably finally get my teeth brushed. If I had prepasted toothbrush. It's like, you're not lazy. That's not it. Like the things that you're thinking, you would help you survive the day with meet your basic needs. That's not laziness.

    Imani Barbarin 44:31

    It's just you creating accessibility where you can. Like, that's the goal. That's what you need to have happen. So like, stop passing judgment on yourself. I mean, honestly, like my mom, my dad, always I have ADHD too. So my brain like, I'm gonna diagnose you, but I'm 100% certain the way my brain works like it's just but my dad used to tell me like I used to hate going to the gym. I still hate going to the gym to terrible degree. I really hate it for my dad. I always used to say, Who cares what they think they're not going to be there when you're struggling, none of these people who were staring at you none of these people were passing judgment on, you would never lift a finger to help you at all. So why are you keep taking into account what they think about what you need to do to survive? When they're not gonna be there,

    KC Davis 45:19

    you need what you need, right? So there's probably some other people listening that maybe aren't necessarily resonating with that message. But they're realizing that they have never really given a ton of conscious thought to ableism, or to eco ableism, or maybe just ableism in general. And I'm curious if someone's listening, and they're thinking, Oh, my gosh, these are concepts that I have totally never thought before, but totally seems like something I should be aware of. Do you have any recommendations on where you think someone should start if they wanted to educate themselves further, or if they wanted to sort of do the work to not be a part of movements in a way in such a way that they leave behind the disabled population?

    Imani Barbarin 45:59

    Yeah, absolutely. So I always recommend since aamva, leads Disability Justice work, they are excellent. There's also an organization called the strategic partnership for occlusive disaster strategies. They're working out of Louisiana right now. And they work internationally to prepare disabled people in particularly for natural disasters and climate change. They're run for and by disabled people, which is remarkable to see people in wheelchairs, like climbing rubble to get other disabled people out. Props to them always. There's also several articles that I wrote about climate change and disability. There's a couple of articles on my website on the straw ban, which again, I refuse to revisit, it's traumatizing. There's a climate change article about disabled people. There's the Center for American Progress also does a lot of pieces on the intersection of disability and climate change, as well as disability justice in general. They have a disability justice initiative that you can look at. So there's just some of the research just off the top of my head.

    KC Davis 46:57

    And where can they find you if they want to follow you? Oh,

    Imani Barbarin 47:00

    my website is crutches and spice.com at Imani underscore Barbara and on Twitter, and then at Coaches underscore and underscore spice on Tiktok and Instagram.

    KC Davis 47:10

    Awesome. Well, Imani, thank you so much. I've really enjoyed our conversation. And I always love when other people with ADHD are on the podcast with me because I feel like oh, we can just be ourselves. We can just non sequitur through the next hour together.

    Imani Barbarin 47:26

    I love that.

    KC Davis 47:29

    That's awesome. Well, thank you so much. And I am going to say goodbye to everyone now

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

Christy Haussler
44: Best of Executive Functioning with Lesley PsyD

Today, we are diving into executive functioning, which is a popular term being bounced around in mental health communities. I want to take a closer look at what it means and how it shows up in people’s lives. Join me to learn more from today’s guest!

Dr. Lesley Cook is a psychologist who does a lot of work with ADHD and other neurodivergencies. Born and raised in Hawaii, she now lives in Virginia and works with children, adolescents, adults, couples, and families. Dr. Lesley and I met on TikTok, and I’m happy to have her here today!

Show Highlights:

  • A common-language definition and explanation of executive functioning

  • How executive function deficits show up in someone’s life

  • How shame, guilt, and inconsistent performance are clues to executive function problems

  • The difference between motivation and task initiation

  • Why the underlying issue with lack of motivation is more about what a person values

  • How a person’s sense of self is affected when they believe their authentic self is “bad”

  • Why external supports are necessary when an internal system is down

  • Why rhythm is better than routine for those with executive function disorder

  • How neurotypical people experience interruptions with executive functioning on a regular basis because of overload and anxiety

  • How blips in executive function occur in neurotypical people with predictability and response to intervention—as opposed to someone with a diagnosis

  • How someone with ADHD can have incredible deficits in executive function on days when everything is going their way–and won’t respond reliably to normal interventions

  • How to build into each day differing levels of acceptable outcomes–and give yourself permission to choose what fits your needs at that moment

  • Lesley’s advice to those who think they have executive functioning issues

Resources: 

Connect with Dr. Lesley: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

Find great resources about executive functioning: 

 www.understood.org, www.psychologytoday.com, and https://chadd.org/

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. I'm your host, KC Davis. I'm taking a break this month for making new content. And in the meantime, I want to play for you some of my most downloaded episodes. This episode is my most downloaded by far. It's my first episode. It's about executive functioning. Maybe you've heard of it, maybe you're kind of wondering exactly what it means. Well, I brought Dr. Lesley cook on to the podcast to talk about this. Dr. Cook has experience working with children, adolescents, adults, couples families, she's worked in a variety of settings, including schools, testing centers, private practice, and administrative and supervisory roles. She has a particular passion for working with individuals of all ages with neuro divergence. So Autism Spectrum Disorder, ADHD, learning disorders, and she has extensive experience providing professional trainings in this area. So buckle up, get a drink of water, take care of yourself and enjoy this conversation about executive functioning.

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust, welcome. I'm so excited for this episode, because I have Dr. Lesley Cook, who is a psychologist, and she does a lot of work with ADHD and other neuro divergences and actually met her on Tik Tok. So Lesley, thank you for being here.

    Lesley PsyD 1:18

    Thank you for having me, this is really exciting for me, because I feel the same way about you and your content. So this is going to be a great talk.

    KC Davis 1:26

    Oh, I'm so excited. So I wanted specifically for us to talk about executive functioning, because I feel like it's a real buzzword right now. Or buzz words, sort of floating around the mental health community. And I really wanted to learn more about it, I have such sort of like a cursory knowledge of it as a therapist, but I have heard you in your content, talk about executive functioning. And I just thought, you know, this is someone who I really want to sort of pick their brain, about the way that executive functioning shows up in people's lives and the way that it relates to trying to do everyday care tasks.

    Lesley PsyD 2:05

    Yeah, I think that this is an area that is both extremely exciting for me that people care about, because I don't think it would have been a buzzword a year or two ago. So that makes me happy. But I also love that we're going to talk about how it applies both to people with diagnoses, but also just to folks in general, because if you have a central nervous system, you have to use these functions on a daily basis.

    KC Davis 2:27

    So what's interesting is that I used to run a family program for a drug rehab. And one of the things that we would talk about was about how we had this little Did y'all ever do this, it was like the hand, like made the fist to talk about like the different parts of the brain.

    Lesley PsyD 2:44

    Yep.

    KC Davis 2:44

    And we'd be like, Okay, this is the brainstem by your wrist and your little thumb coming over is sort of the seat of like the instincts and the fight or flight. And then your prefrontal cortex is the front, except when I was talking about that to clients and families, what I was focusing on what's actually the fight or flight aspect of it, and talking about how when your fight or flight gets triggered, you kind of go, your frontal cortex goes offline. And since that's the part of our brain responsible for impulse control, and sort of cause and effect, it would help families and clients think about how when they're feeling really activated, whether in therapy or just in the world, how all of these amazing coping skills that they're learning in rehab might temporarily go offline. So I really focused on talking to them about that part of the brain kind of getting hijacked, focusing on the fight or flight. But now that I've been diagnosed with ADHD, and I've been doing this work around helping people who have functional barriers, deal with care tasks around their home, for the first time, I'm starting to want to learn more about that frontal lobe, that part that's going offline, like, what all is that responsible for? So I wanted to start I send you like, kind of six questions. And I would love to hear you describe executive functioning for a layperson, like someone who doesn't know any type of psychological terminology or therapeutic language.

    Lesley PsyD 4:10

    Yeah, this is actually something that I am continuing to hone because it's really hard to translate. It's really complex. So hopefully, this will be easy to understand. And thank you Disney feel like I should be paying them for the movie Inside Out. The best image I can think so as I talk through this, a good visual image is that control panel inside of the main characters brain. So there is the what are the behavior that she's engaging in, which is more choice based in that movie, then there's the emotions, and they have an effect on the control panel, but they're not the control panel themselves. So executive functions are these eight core functions of that control panel that tell our body, how to do things when why, to what extent when to stop and here's the list of them. There are abilities to inhibit, like, stop ourselves to shift from one thing to another. Controller emotions, start a behavior, remember things as we're learning them, how to plan and organize, how to monitor what we're doing in the middle of it, and how to monitor how we're feeling about what we're doing. So you can imagine how complex this control panel is.

    KC Davis 5:22

    Wow. Yeah. It's a lot. That's like, I feel like when you describe those eight functions, as a therapist, that's like, everything that I'm trying to teach someone is like, how do we be more aware of our emotions? How do we regulate our emotions? How do we think through things? That is such a great, great summary, it almost kind of gives me like the visual of like a dam. And you know how you can like, open the dam a little or you can open the dam a lot. But like that dam is really in control of what is coming and going, and in what amount whether it's a tension or feelings or emotions. And so I could definitely see how like if somebody's control panel is shorting out, or someone's dam isn't like letting in or out the right amounts of things. Why that would make life so complicated.

    Lesley PsyD 6:13

    Yeah, incredibly, so in for diagnoses, like ADHD, it's like those emotions showing up to work every day in Riley's brain, and somebody's like, oh, shift is down today. Oh, man. All right, Colin, task monitoring hills have to work an extra shift. And you really can't predict like what's going to be offline or online on a given day. So you can imagine how that would not only make your day difficult, but also would affect emotions in the opposite direction, then you get frustrated that you can't shift when you need to.

    KC Davis 6:42

    So what does it look like when somebody has issues with executive function like when there are disruptions? So that control panel like, how does that show up in someone's life? Like, What would someone have to tell you like in a session to make you go, Hmm, I wonder if there's some executive functioning issues here.

    Lesley PsyD 6:59

    So a lot of the time, the first way that shows up is people expressing how bad they are at something. So I always get curious when someone says, you know, I know that my difficulty, like losing things is really impacting my life. But I'm just so terrible at that. That's usually some kind of note to me to ask more questions. Because if you were just terrible at that, you probably would never do it. Usually when that shame kicks in of like, look at this part of me that so bad, I'm not doing well, it's because you feel like you should be able to, or you feel like, you know, I can on this day. So maybe it's just my effort. So whenever I hear shame and guilt in there, I'll ask more. And there's a difference between not being great at a skill, and then having an actual executive function disturbance. So I am not great in developing physical systems to organize my stuff. But I am fantastic at developing tracking systems for my work. If I'm great at developing tracking systems for my work, then my tracking system should work every day, but they don't system. So that's the second factor is inconsistent performance, even with effort and energy,

    KC Davis 8:11

    which is interesting, because I think that somebody who is experiencing inconsistent performance like that, that's the reason why they assume that they must just be lazy, because they go to work. And they never miss, you know, a work call, they're on top of what they need to do at work. And then they can't come home, and can't seem to motivate or activate themselves to do the dishes and the laundry. And they're confused, because they're like, it's the same skills, I'm going to work and I'm seeing what needs to be done. And I'm doing it. But then I come home, I see what needs to be done. And I can't seem to do it.

    Lesley PsyD 8:46

    I would add to that, that when I see clients in my office that present with that kind of concept. They're even harder on themselves. I hear, I can go to work and manage a multimillion dollar contract, but I can't do my laundry. So they also kind of push these care tasks down in important importance in their life somehow, like I should be able to do this. It's so much easier. But it's not really laundry is about 15 different tasks. And so that's another thing that I'll look for is when they say I'm good in this environment, but I'm terrible over here. That's usually a sign that there's something else going on.

    KC Davis 9:22

    Yeah, and I totally see that too. We especially the comments that I sometimes get on tic TOCs was just clean as you go just put it in the dishwasher. Just do your laundry. Because for people whose executive functioning is firing on all cylinders, like they don't recognize that they're actually doing 12 different steps and utilizing eight different skills to do something like their brain has automated that to the degree where it feels like a simple, non complex task.

    Lesley PsyD 9:50

    If there was something that came up the most. That is the bit of information that's really helpful I found for family members who don't experience executive function problems. Is that because you don't perceive that you're doing 15 tasks, does not mean that you're not doing them, it means that your neurology showed up to support your motivation. Those are two different things. You can't motivate yourself into better executive function you can't

    KC Davis 10:16

    Fascinating. And you know, one of the questions that I had and will sort of skip around just because coming up is, I want to kind of talk about the difference between motivation versus task initiation. Because those things I think, get confused. And I think there's a lot of people showing up to their therapists office saying, I'm just not motivated. I'm just not motivated. And I think a lot of therapists are getting curious about what does that mean? What does that look like? So they're jumping right to sort of interventions that can help with motivation, when the actual issue is task initiation? So can you talk about the difference between those two things?

    Lesley PsyD 10:51

    Sure, motivation is either the desire to do something or the acknowledgement that it's really something that would be good if it gets done now. So it's more of a sensation than anything else. Motivation is a feeling, look at that pile of laundry. So even though that's full of dread, that's motivation, I'm not looking at the pile of laundry going. And I really love that that is an art sculpture, I hope that never goes anywhere. Which is might be true, that's where I've reached that level in my life. But motivation can be positive, or, you know, I hate to use negative, but it can have a distressing component. But then there's the behavior of task initiation. And actually, that is even multiple tasks in itself. So the signal to the body to move for individuals who do not have ADHD, or other forms of executive function disturbance, the motivation is followed by activity to that motor cortex almost immediately, they think it they do it, they just do it, and they don't have to tell themselves to do it. Anyone who has depression or significant anxiety, or ADHD knows the feeling of staring at the task and saying, move, get, move your leg, just move a foot, just do something. So there's a disruption there, the motivation is not leading to the body moving, and then we have to fight to get up. And so task initiation goes from what should be a seamless reflex almost, to a mountain to climb. And that can be incredibly distressing in itself and make us feel real bad about ourselves.

    KC Davis 12:18

    It's interesting, because what you're describing sounds exactly like what I described when I first got on Vyvanse, where I said, all of the sudden, the transition from sitting in a chair, to getting up to do the laundry was seamless, like the rails had been greased. It was not a hard transition to make. Whereas before, I would sit in the chair and think about how I needed to do the laundry. But I just so badly, either didn't want to or couldn't get up. And it took a long time to almost talk myself into and create. And I had to come up with all of these methods of creating momentum, so that I could get myself to go do the laundry. The other thing it reminds me of so most of my career was an addiction. And I have totally had those conversations with clients where it was a lack of motivation. And the way that they describe it is I don't care, I don't care that the laundry is not done. And sometimes it's really frustrating because you're sometimes talking about addiction, or you're talking about something unsanitary. And the poor families are like how could you not care? How could you not care that you're dying? How could you not care that you're not taking care of yourself? How could you not care that you have dirty clothes, and you smell and they would literally say I just I don't care, I can't make myself care. I feel complete apathy. When I think about those tasks, or they say, I don't think that I deserve those things. And so I have no motivation to do them. And that, for me really helped realize, oh, so motivation, a lack of motivation. And you can correct me on this shows up more like apathy.

    Lesley PsyD 13:54

    Yeah, lack of motivation is the best way that I can think about it is motivation is a sensation, it's not an action. It's just something that you feel. And so there's probably 1000 different versions of motivation, you can be slightly motivated, you can be not motivated at all. But what I see a lot when I have clients with actual motivational issues, is that they can convince me all day long, why they should do something. But then when we get down to it, and I say, Do you want to do this? Is this something you want in your life? They'll kind of exhale and be like, No, and I don't understand that. Like, what does that mean about me? And it's okay, we can deal with motivational issues. There's interventions for that, but confusing, the two really leads to a shame and guilt cycle.

    KC Davis 14:38

    Yeah. And a lot of times, especially around care tasks, when people talk about, you know, I just struggle with the motivation to do XYZ. And maybe it's something like clean my room, and sometimes it's a task initiation sheet, right? I want it clean. I function better when it has some order. But when I look at all the things there are I get overwhelmed, I don't know where to start, I get distracted. I have overwhelming emotions. But sometimes when people say, Oh, I can't find the motivation to do it, when you get really curious, you find that it is an actual value issue. Actually, I don't value a clean room, I only think I should value it because of the way that I was raised. But I function fine and a messy room. And so sometimes you find that the motivation is about what you value, and you just, you don't actually value that thing you just feel like you're supposed to, or that's what good people are supposed to value.

    Lesley PsyD 15:36

    That is exactly why in all of my interventions related to this, the first question I asked someone is, if no one was watching, and no one could say anything to you about this, how would you do this? Just you and people, not only have most of them have never even allowed themselves to think about it that way. But usually, there's a big realization at that point, oh, I think if it was up to me, I would probably just leave all the laundry in the laundry room, I wouldn't be moving stuff all over the house. And so then we say, alright, so if that's what your brain wants, can't we just build a system around that? So you don't have to fight yourself?

    KC Davis 16:12

    Yes. And I think, you know, one of the pillars of struggle care that I talked about is that shame is the enemy of functioning, and how shame can create short term compliance or short term change, but it doesn't really create long term change, nor does it create or sustain any type of intrinsic motivation. And I think it's what you said exactly about, at some point, you're alone. And shame is always about what someone else thinks of you, or the fear that you won't be accepted. Or, you know, I'm full of shame, because I'm a piece of shit, I'm a bad person, I'm not lovable, I'm not good enough. And that all has to do with the need for belonging and acceptance in your tribe. But if your tribes not around all the time, like you're going to default to whatever motivational or initiation issues are there. And so the shame doesn't work. And as someone who went to long term residential behavior modification for 18 months, you know, I was on point I followed every rule, I did really well, like I won, I won the game. And I functioned really well, when there was constant. outside pressure outside, it was like having an external control panel, right. And there was always an external pressure and external accountability. You know, these rules, regulations, structure, peer pressure monitoring. And once I left, although I did learn lots of great things there, there were so many things that was like, Oh, I'm two days in, and I'm not getting up at the crack of dawn and doing chores and doing all these things that were so easy for me when I was in structure.

    Lesley PsyD 17:53

    And I think that what that in both of those examples in your example of leaving that highly structured environment and the other example of people having what they often describe to me as relapses when no one's around, what's really happening in those moments is that people are returning to what is authentic, and guilt and shame causes us to interpret authenticity as bad. So imagine what that does to our sense of self, when being who we truly are is the bad way to be. How do you escape that?

    KC Davis 18:23

    Yeah, well, and then you carry it into every relationship, because no matter how much someone says, they love you, no matter how much praise or validation, you get, there's always this voice inside your head that says, if you only knew, and what's interesting, you know, kind of going back to talking about the way we show up at work, the hardest job I ever had, was working at a restaurant, I worked at a really high end restaurant for Hillstone Restaurant Group, and they ran their waitstaff, like a boot camp. I mean, I can't even describe to you like everything was very regimented. Everything from like, you had to memorize certain abbreviations. You could only walk into the kitchen and one door, you had to have things in your hand, as you left the door, you had to put drinks on the table within 30 seconds food on the table, within 10 minutes. Everything was highly, highly regimented. And so as you're going through your shift, you're having to multitask, prioritize, work with your working memory. And I was excellent at that job. But there was this structure there, there was this external structure, and there were all these other people. They're doing it with me. And I think it's so fascinating how there are environments in which my executive functioning can fire on all cylinders. And then I can go home and look around my home and not be able to sort of turn everything back on and I will assume it must be because I'm not trying hard enough. It must be because I'm not good enough as opposed to there is an obvious environmental difference between work and home.

    Lesley PsyD 19:59

    Absolutely. And that's what we talked about as, as clinicians who work with people with executive function disturbance. And in this case, especially ADHD is that if our internal structure is inconsistent, and we know that then we need to build external supports. So if we do that, right, that's not good. And then we shift that if we do that, effectively, that in a way that works for us, we do it so that it enhances our view of ourselves. Because if we notice that our control panel shift button is down that day, we can complement it with other external support. So we can utilize that concept really well. I think what happens is, we don't teach people about this, when they're, well, we're not teaching children and teens about executive function. So we have all of these assumptions, I can do it at work, but not at home. That must mean I don't care as much about my home, well, no work is set up perfectly for you, you've got all these external supports that help you so that no matter what function is down, you've got a compensatory strategy. And I find that that's a lot of your work that I witnessed and have on a daily basis, is you're really helping people figure out where you know, what system is down for them, and how not just individual solutions, but how to think about yourself and your environment, to provide your own external support that goes with you from place to place

    KC Davis 21:19

    Well, and I find that so many of the resources that talk about like running your home, and setting up systems and routines are very intimidating, because there's like, you know, 9000 checklists for the day, and it's really all consuming. And I think that we can write those things off as if no, no, no, those things are for people who have their shit together. Those are for healthy people that are on top of it, that are using those kinds of strategies, as opposed to I mean, and you see this too, with like, when you watch the TIC TOCs, about people like restocking their pantry, like when you look at the all the clear containers, and that like that gets written off as Oh, that's something Pinterest moms do. But in reality, there's some real functionality to having clear canisters where you can see things and having a time of the week where you restock everything. It's just that we sometimes I think need help making those systems accessible. And so it reminds me of when I started having a cleaning schedule, I always said no, I'm not going to do that. And then I started one and I really call it a care tasks at schedule. And it's literally one thing a day just one like I do laundry every Monday. On Tuesdays, I restock bathrooms. On Wednesdays I clean one thing in my kitchen. On Thursdays I do the sheets and on Fridays, I do the floors. And then on Saturdays, I do the groceries. And so it's really simple. It's nothing that anybody would like all over Pinterest in but setting up that system mirrored some of the more structured environments I've succeeded in in the past and circumvents ways in which my control panel short circuit so because my working memory is unhelpful to me at times, I found that when I do laundry on Mondays, it took about a month but now the idea that laundry is supposed to be done on Mondays is not something being handled by my working memory. It has been filed away in short term memory and contextualize. So that Monday and laundry are inextricably linked in my mind and my associations. So from the moment I wake up on a Monday, it's like it gets flagged it goes it's a laundry day. And before when I was just waiting to do laundry for when we ran out of clothes, it had no associations. So I'm either procrastinating it not doing it getting into the wash and forgetting about it, getting into the washer, the dryer, but then putting it on the floor. And it totally changed my ability. I mean, I literally can't tell you, Leslie, I have never been able to do laundry in a timely manner and have clean clothes put away until eight months ago. And what else is funny, I was looking at it tick tock that I did recently where I talked about how I used to try to be on the houses schedule. Like oh, I noticed that the clean sheets are dirty time to clean the sheets. And when we run out of food or grocery shopping, we run out of clothes or laundry. And I never could keep on top of anything. And so when I started washing sheets every Thursday, all of a sudden, the sheets were getting washed. And it was for some reason it kind of went to like an enjoyable activity because I felt like I was participating in the routine and I was doing it and that felt really good. So it even changed my like reward system relationship with the task. And I think it's really funny how for Casey Davis the only two options for the frequency of how often I wash sheets is every week, which I recognize is too often or literally once a year.Like that's it.

    Lesley PsyD 24:56

    But I love the idea that that's based on trying things, and then honoring yourself. And when you find that thing that starts to work really leaning in and not worrying about is this what I'm supposed to do isn't weekly too much. I don't think I have to do that. It doesn't matter if you are finding a rhythm. And I think rhythm is a really important word. For people with executive function issues. Rhythm is better than routine for a lot of people routine is like you set it and then I have to do it that way. That's how I do it. Rhythm is paying attention to how it feels, and leaning in when it feels right.

    KC Davis 25:30

    How that gave me goosebumps. Rhythm is more important than routine. And I think that that must be what I'm feeling because rhythm is so satisfying to me. Rhythm is even if it's it could be the most monotonous task. But if it's on a rhythm, if it's in the flow, all of a sudden, I feel a sense of reward when it's accomplished. Only if it's in the rhythm and in the flow.

    Lesley PsyD 25:53

    Exactly. It's funny because I think we're both gonna say things like in the last year in the last eight months, because the pentatonic really created this opportunity to really look inward. In all the time we had with ourselves. I really found in the last year that I enjoyed the fact that my family all slept in later, because they weren't going to school, both of my kids stayed home and fully homeschooled. And so I don't sleep in past seven, I never have, it works for me, I like it. And all of a sudden, I had an hour, from seven to eight of this pristine quiet. And what I found is that I was starting to get a cup of coffee and sit in the same chair and do my notes. My notes for work for if anyone who's not a psychotherapist, it's kind of the bane of our existence. Usually, we need to do it. And it's important, but it's not fun. We like the people, right? We like working with our people. And so I hate notes, and I would often get behind. But what I found is I started getting up at seven, no one's awake, sitting in my chair with my cup of coffee, doing my notes. And then all of a sudden, that became a really joyful time for me a peaceful time. And if I heard footsteps, I very kindly reminded a child not until eight, we have to, like stay in your zone. And so I agree with you, I think when we find our rhythms and we lean in, we really are honoring ourselves. I think it's just hard in our modern society to feel like we're allowed to do that.

    KC Davis 27:16

    And I love that you came to that rhythm gently. Because that's been my experience with all the rhythms that work in my house. Now I came to them gently, I wasn't forcing them. And so what I mean by that is like you didn't say one time, like, you know what, I'm going to start waking up an hour earlier, so that I have some time to myself, and then you know, you wake up and you snooze, you don't it was like it kind of accidentally happened. And then you realize you've liked it. And so all of the things, the rhythms for me that stick are the ones that I sort of happen upon gently, they're not the ones where I'm trying to force myself into a routine or force myself into a schedule. And that's kind of what I'm hearing about your rhythm too.

    Lesley PsyD 27:55

    Yeah, I'll give you an example of how two people can utilize the same compensatory strategies and opposite ways. In my house, we don't have a set day for any task, because that didn't feel rhythmic. To me, it didn't feel authentic to me, what I do is in my brain is surfing. So I have a rhythm of the things that need to be done not on a daily basis, but more than might like monitoring the house. And I do what feels right that day. And I just don't repeat the same thing two days in a row. And so that's another way to utilize the same skills to get the same result, but in a completely different manner. And that really, I think speaks to why it's so important not to just look at someone else's strategy and say, I'm gonna copy that exactly. And if it doesn't work, that's my fault.

    KC Davis 28:41

    Yeah. And that's why I try really hard not to make it sound like when I'm talking about what works in my home, that I'm not handing it out as a prescriptive routine, like, oh, everyone should do this. This is the answer. Because people are so different. This is just what works in my house. And maybe it'll work for three weeks, and I'll try a new system. Maybe it'll work for three months, and then I'll try a new system. One thing I know about me now is that the challenge and the novelty is really important. And so if I use a system for a rhythm for three months, and then I stopped using it, I don't have to I can either just kind of go with the flow and naturally get back on it. Or I can go maybe it's time for a new rhythm, a new system, it doesn't mean that I failed, or that I've done something wrong, or I've relapsed. I can't keep on a system for the life of me. Maybe it's just my natural need for novelty and challenge. And so instead of sort of beating myself up and trying to force myself back onto something, I can go, so what's a way that I can do it now? What feels right now that will still get those same functioning goals done and I think it's okay to change your rhythms as they change.

    Lesley PsyD 29:52

    Absolutely. And I think that's what I really enjoy about your content is the strategies that you provide are kind of like a bouquet of flowers. You might pick these flowers to hold and smell today. And maybe later, you'll be like, I want to go back to closing duties. And we've implemented your concept of closing duties in our house. And what I noticed is that we do them for a while, and then they become pretty easy to do. And we don't look at the list anymore. And then all of a sudden, we'll kind of notice and noticing is a, by the way, just as a pause is a really helpful concept with executive function disturbance, because noticing is different than criticism. So Oh, no, I'm not using my planner can become, Oh, that's interesting. I haven't used my planner in a week. So when we noticed that in the evenings, we're feeling more stressed, or there's more mess, we'll just recenter ourselves and be like, Oh, time to go back to closing duties. And if you do it that way, it's really a way to think about having this variety of tools in the same toolbox. And it's totally fine.

    KC Davis 30:48

    It's funny, because last night, I had my three year old do her closing duties, and then I did my full closing duties. But I honestly hadn't done either one of them fully in a week. And I had that same noticing of just non judgment. It's not Oh, I haven't done this, I need to do it. It was you know what it would feel good to do them tonight, it would feel good to have these done for the morning. And that's totally fine. Because I get that question all the time. I feel like I start out strong, and then I fall off. What do you do to get back on the horse? And I think the answer is there is no horse. Yeah, there is no horse, there is no falling, there is no horse, it's just meandering through the woods. And sometimes, you know, you start to walk off path because it's interesting, and it meets your needs. And then, you know, when you get a little disoriented and it serves your needs to get back on the sort of beaten path, then you do that there's no moral judgment on either side. So let me ask you this. One thing that all of this sort of came to head for me was, although I now know, looking back that I've had ADHD my whole life, when I had my second daughter, and I was postpartum in a pandemic, that's when the majority of the executive functioning came to a head where I couldn't function anymore, right? I look back on my life, and I see where ADHD has been. And and then at the same page, I see all these compensatory behaviors. But when I was postpartum, in a pandemic, it was as though the control panel broke down even more, and the compensatory sort of tools I had didn't work anymore. And one question I wanted to talk about, because we've been talking about ADHD, and depression and sort of these diagnoses that cause executive dysfunction. But certainly there are instances or circumstances or seasons when even someone who's neurotypical can experience interruptions with their executive functioning. And I wonder if you could talk about that.

    Lesley PsyD 32:39

    Yeah, not only can that happen, it happens for everyone, at some extent, probably every few days. So one of the things that's challenging to really cover in full on a short format, social media, like tick tock is all the nuance that's involved in this. So I like to kind of make the quip that, you know, if you have a central nervous system, you have executive functions. And if you have executive functions, then you're gonna have days with executive dysfunction, it's just how we were we're homeostatic. So you know, we deplete ourselves of calories, we get hungry, we eat. And that's the same for all of these self monitoring strategies. The biggest thing that impacts executive function, the two biggest things are overload, and anxiety, any kind of anxiety, not even clinical anxiety, just that pressure and nervousness, predominantly impacts things like working memory, and focus for every human being. So if all of a sudden, you are home with your kids all day, and you still have to work or take care of your home, and that is your primary work, and they are having a tantrum, there is a lot going on. So you could be overloaded on two counts, which is going to decrease some of these executive functions. So you might be in the middle of I was just gonna say, Well, everyone who listens to this, maybe will find this to be familiar. But let's say you are cleaning up a mess that a child has created. And then you have another child who's on the bathroom, you know, on the potty and needs to be wiped, and then someone else who's crying because they're hungry, that's too much for a human being to process in the moment you're going to have to sacrifice something, it's very likely that if you had another task, you're going to either let it to the side on purpose, or you're going to forget completely. We also know that because just because you mentioned being postpartum, we do know and there's emerging data that shows that estrogen fluctuation and to some extent other hormones as well impact executive function for all people, especially so for ADHD, but even for neurotypicals it's not unheard of that folks would have all of a sudden more difficulty with their attention and focus, you know, Miss An appointment misplace their keys when their estrogen is particularly high or low. Problem is we don't have concrete evidence, whether it's the high or the low, and we don't know why it affects some people and not others.

    KC Davis 34:58

    Interesting. And when you say and that like worry and anxiety can affect executive function, even for neurotypicals. What came to mind for me was, I think everyone's had the experience of being at work. And you know, you're in the groove, you're being productive. And then you get the email from your boss says, hey, I want to talk to you at 430, right? And then all of a sudden, it's like, it's impossible to go back to work and be productive again, like you can't focus, you can't think you just have this worry in this anxiety. And so that totally makes sense to me. You know why that can happen if someone is experiencing stress, or anxiety or just overload?

    Lesley PsyD 35:32

    Yeah, and those things can compound each other. So I think one of the things the pandemic did is not only did it remove a lot of people's external coping, it compounded our anxiety in a way that we've never experienced. So going to be anxiety provoking to teach your children at home. But when you have the extra worry of making sure that they're safe and early in the pandemic, we were, you know, washing the grocery bags and leaving are outside. I imagine for a whole lot of people, they found themselves experiencing a whole lot more disruption in these areas than typical, and that may last for quite a long time.

    KC Davis 36:07

    Yeah, I wonder if you would say, you know, when you were talking about how there are people who have these kinds of long term diagnoses, who will experience executive functioning barriers, but then a neurotypical person experiences them every once in a while, or even once every couple of days. And to me, you know, because there is a real difference between the way that someone who has a diagnoses whether it's the degree is different, or the frequency is different. And it almost reminded me of, you know, when somebody is chronically ill, their experience of medical problems and medical issues and barriers in their life is completely different from someone who's not chronically ill, who's not chronically ill. And but even someone who's not chronically ill get sick sometimes. Right? And so there's some way in which they think they can relate, you know, someone who has had the flu might look at someone who is chronically ill talking about being fatigued and having a fever and think, Oh, I know what that's like. But contextually, you know, the degree to which someone experiences executive dysfunction can really make a quality of life difference between someone who is just sort of on the normal course of life experiencing little blips here and there.

    Lesley PsyD 37:20

    Yeah, absolutely. And the way that I explained this to folks is that for someone who does not have ADHD, but is having a particularly stressful moment, and finding that they have some executive function challenges, maybe they just feel overloaded, or they forgot a bunch of things. Their challenges with executive function are two things, they're more predictable. So it makes sense when they happen, oh, I can see why, gosh, it's been a crazy week at work. And my kids are yelling, so they're more predictable, and they respond to intervention. So in the middle of it, if an individual who does not have an actual diagnosis does not qualify for that says, whoa, slow down. All right, you know what, I'm going to take some things off my plate, I'm going to take a minute for myself, their executive function skills will probably return right back to typical because they're more bound by the environmental stress. The core feature of something like ADHD is that the symptoms are fundamentally unpredictable. And don't make sense with the environment. People with ADHD can have incredible deficits and executive function on a day where everything is going their way, there is nothing wrong, they feel great. And conversely, they could be having the worst day of their life and remember everything and they don't respond to typical interventions. So things like just slow down and focus, just use a planner, right? Just use a planner, don't you think you should get more rest, stop drinking so much coffee Wanderlei have done all of these things today. They don't respond reliably, they may respond sometimes, but they don't respond reliably. And that's why ADHD can be hard to diagnose, especially in very young children, because we need that pattern and the severity to understand it. So for folks who don't have ADHD, try to imagine yourself on your worst day where you were the most disorganized. And imagine that that worst day could happen at any moment, with no warning and didn't respond to anything you did. That's what it feels like.

    KC Davis 39:12

    And I think that's probably also you know, what we're talking about the shame and beating ourselves up. Because, you know, if you get a phone call in the middle of the day, and you get some sort of scary health news about a family member, and then shortly after that, you suddenly kind of lose all motivation to do anything else with your day, you're gonna go well, that makes sense, right? I've had this big stressful conversation, I'm, well, I'm worried. And there, it's easier to be kind to yourself in that mess. Maybe I do need to just take it easy today. But if you have ADHD, or really any of these diagnoses that can create executive functioning issues and you wake up one day and you're going about your day and then randomly at 12 You don't have a phone call, but just randomly everything goes through and just powers down. and you don't want to do anything else with the rest of your day. We don't tend to give ourselves the same kind of kindness of oh, well, let me just, you know, that makes sense that seems valid. Let me just take it easy today. And I think the biggest difference that I have been able to experience since getting my diagnosis was it being easier to be kind to myself, and I'm incredibly privileged, that the stuff that I work on in terms of my struggle care platform, is very flexible. And I control my own dates and goals to some extent, because I will wake up going, I'm gonna get this and this and this, and this done. And then all of a sudden, everything just powers down at 1030. And I get to go, Well, I guess it's not getting done today. Or I guess it's only kind of gonna get done, or I guess, let me see if there's some other sort of flow that I can jump into, and maybe just switch projects completely. Now, we don't always have that option in life, there are things that have to get done at certain times. But even when we have to sort of trudge through the ability to sort of be kind to ourselves. And I think that's been my experience is trusting myself and honoring myself that if I feel that power down, that is something that really just happened. I don't know why maybe there was no triggering point. But it did happen. It was not a moral failing. It's not laziness, and it's okay to just kind of go with it.

    Lesley PsyD 41:26

    Yeah, absolutely. There's a model that I use with clients that's so similar to this. And it's been expanded upon by my friend, Abby on Tiktok. She's at Proactiv busy body of the stoplight model. So those of us with these challenges, we typically have red, yellow, and green days. And a Green Day is where for some reason, we're just firing on all cylinders, we're doing really well. And on those days, we don't need as many supports as we usually would need. And we can kind of raise our expectations for ourselves. So if we wake up, and we're feeling great, that's the day to say, Alright, I'm gonna get some extra stuff done, we have our yellow days where you're feeling a little uneasy, you're doing okay, but you could really use maybe some extra supports. And then we have read days where we wake up, and anyone with ADHD typically will will resonate with this. And by half an hour after waking up, we know what they were about to have, we've already lost our keys three times and then found them in the freezer. And on those days, we need to lower expectations and increase supports. And moving through those lights is a way to both hold ourselves accountable, right? We're not that's why it's not laziness, we're not saying it's a red day, I'm doing nothing. No, we need to increase our supports, and really decrease our expectations to focus only on the most important things, which always, by the way, includes self care.

    KC Davis 42:44

    It also reminds me of why you know, when I did sort of build myself this care task schedule over the week, and when I did my closing duties, I tried to build into each one of my routines, differing levels of acceptable outcomes. So like, I have a list of things that I do for my closing duties when I closed on my house, and it's like six things. And then I have a another list that I call survival day closing duties. That is just two things that absolutely need to be and I have full permission to choose whichever list fits my needs and my abilities in that moment. And the same thing with when i This is always my suggestion when someone says I want to try a cleaning schedule, what do you suggest. So I suggest, you know, if picking a room or a task a day, but that when you say Tuesdays is bathrooms, it doesn't mean on Tuesdays, I clean every single bathroom, it just means on Tuesdays, I clean something in a bathroom. And that allows you to stay within the rhythm that feels good while still honoring sort of your needs of that day. Because it might be a day where you go in and you wipe the countertop off, and then you walk out. Or it might be a day where you go in and clean the whole bathroom top to bottom or every thing in between. And so that we don't feel like when we have a day where we can't accomplish the whole thing that we failed, because any of those options within one thing, or all the things is acceptable. And frankly, no things is acceptable, too. I have things on my little cleaning schedule that auto like almost week to week, barely ever get done. And sometimes they do. So as we sort of land the plane here. I want to kind of talk about, you know, if someone's listening to this podcast, and they're really relating, and they're thinking, oh my god, I think maybe some of my struggles might be related to executive functioning issues. Where would you suggest someone start? I want to ask this in two parts. Where do you suggest they start in terms of who is the right maybe person or provider to look for? Because I don't think all providers are really knowledgeable about executive functioning issues. And then for people who maybe don't have access to more one on One providers, any resources that you would suggest to them?

    Lesley PsyD 45:04

    Sure. You we have in psychology right now in particular the area of support for Neuro divergence, we have an issue, clients and community members not being able to reliably tell if we are going to be helpful to them. And we are working on this. So the biggest suggestion that I make is if you have access if you have a mental health benefits through insurance, going to a licensed clinician making sure that they have a credential of some kind. And make sure when you make contact with them, if you're looking for supports that you interview them, ask them questions, ask them Do you know what executive function is, this is what I'm specifically looking for. This is one of the things that I find that people don't realize they're allowed to do. And any good clinician would welcome. So if you have access to those kinds of benefits, a psychologist or a therapist, really just starting with even psychology today.com, which is a little bit limited, or just Googling your zip code, and executive function, and therapists, it will give you a nice fat list of a lot of people more than you could contact. But working with a licensed clinician, if you have access to that is really helpful. If you don't have access, or if you want to do something to start dipping your toe in this pond and figuring out if this sounds like you, I absolutely love understood.org It is a wonderful website, I do not make any money from understood.org. Just so everyone knows, I'm not sponsored by them. I'm just a patron, they have a wealth of articles, they have a simulator so that if you have this disturbance, and you'd like someone in your family to know what it feels like, you can have them do a simulator for executive function challenges. And there are also articles about what concretely to do to start helping yourself and also how to reach out for support. Those are my favorite two suggestions.

    KC Davis 46:46

    Awesome. Yeah, and I will say, as a licensed professional counselor, I have a Master's in Counseling. And I can honestly say that my education did not provide that much information. In fact, I don't remember hardly any information about executive functioning. Certainly, my education and counseling gave me the tools to understand what I was learning when I went out to learn about executive functioning. But I just wanted to sort of echo it's definitely something to ask of a therapist because not all therapists are going to have experience in that area.

    Lesley PsyD 47:19

    Yeah, absolutely. And they're even if you don't have ADHD, Chad c h a d 's dot org is another resource. Sometimes individuals forget that. If you don't have a diagnosis, that doesn't mean you might not benefit from the information. So it's really okay. You don't have to feel like I have to have the diagnosis to even look at this. There's probably a wealth of information that can be helpful to you.

    KC Davis 47:41

    Awesome. Well, thank you so so much for all of this do you want to go ahead and plug your socials and where you are and how people can watch you and contact you if they want to?

    Lesley PsyD 47:53

    Sure I am predominantly on tick tock it is my favorite social media platform that's ever been invented because it's everything is one minute, which works for me. I'm also on Instagram, my Tiktok is Lesley PsyD lesley PsyD. My Instagram is actually Lesley underscore PsyD. And that'll be more of the professional information. I'm not on Instagram as much so Tiktok is the best way to peruse my content.

    KC Davis 48:18

    Awesome. Well, thank you so much.

    Lesley PsyD 48:20

    Thank you for having me. This is wonderful.

    KC Davis 48:22

    This has been an incredible talk. And so if you are listening, I hope you guys check Lesley out and thank you for tuning in.

Christy Haussler
43: Codependency Doesn’t Exist with Shahem McLaurin

Dear Listeners,

“We want to inform you that this episode marks the end of our current season. We would like to take a break during the month of August to recharge and prepare exciting new content for you. We will be back with fresh episodes in September, filled with engaging discussions and insightful interviews. We appreciate your support and look forward to reconnecting with you soon”

-KC Davis

Codependency is one of those buzzwords often used in therapy and mental health around relationships. Today’s guest has provoked a lot of feedback by challenging people’s views on this subject. Join us for this intriguing conversation.

I’m joined by one of my favorite people on TikTok, Shahem Mclaurin, a social worker in Brooklyn, NY, with over 500,000 followers on social media. Shahem is self-described as a person who is “queer as hell, Black as hell, and loud as hell.” They use their platform to address a wide range of social and mental health issues impacting people of color, patriarchy-impacted people, and members of the LGBTQ+ community.

Show Highlights:

● How Shahem’s view of codependency has challenged the worldview of many people

● Why Shahem got a lot of blowback from his thoughts on codependency when he began to challenge popular worldviews

● Why we need to differentiate between attention-seeking and connection-seeking behaviors

● Why people get defensive when their “codependency identification” is challenged

● How the term codependency originated as part of popular therapeutic language

● How our culture sees having empathy for someone and expecting accountability from them as opposites that can’t both be true at the same time

● Thoughts on codependency, outside validation, connectivity, and feeling emotionally safe

● How to take a look at your unique journey “in the pool”

Resources and Links:

Connect with Shahem: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to struggle care. This is a podcast about self care, mental health and just shit that I want to talk about in general. I'm here with genuinely one of my favorite tech talkers, Shaheen, and you are a licensed professional social worker and say a few words about yourself so that the audience can know who you are.

    Shahem 0:25

    So I'm Shaheen, I am a licensed social worker practicing therapist. I'm an LMS w. So this close to my See, I had to take a year. That's overall uncomplicated twisty windy stories, but I am originally from Baltimore. I'm stationed in Brooklyn, and I am queers. How on black as hell and loud as hell, nine times out of 10. So that is what you get from me. Yeah,

    KC Davis 0:52

    Well, thank you so much. I've really been looking forward to this, because we're gonna talk about codependency. And I saw you do a tech talk recently on it. And I was like, I have thoughts. And I know you have thoughts. And that is really all this podcast is, is finding people that have like capital T thoughts on things that are sort of like mine, and then bringing them on and then talking about it. So what just give me your like, one minute download as to like, why the word codependency makes your assets.

    Shahem 1:21

    So I got a lot of blowback from that, like people were so upset, but it was fine. Because

    KC Davis 1:27

    Did you really?

    Shahem 1:28

    I did, and, you know, I anticipate it when you challenge people's worldviews, I find that that word is so overused, and often like it villainized as people's desire to connect to other people, because a lot of the times what is at the root of codependency is like completely swept under the rug, right. And there's people who are seeking secure and safe connections. And especially in a world where like hyper individualism is pushed, like to the forefront, like encourages people to further disconnect from the reality of like seeking connections and safe connections with other people, building community with others in having grace, conflict resolution, and all of the things with people. And I think, like one of the reasons why people feel so strongly about it is because a lot of us like one of pathologizing away our desire to connect to other people and to be human beings in the social. So yeah, I find that the word is overused, I find that people like often use that, like the term codependency to, like dismiss people's desire for connectivity. And I think like in our society, in our specific context, it like encourages people to disconnect from people around them, which is like, connected to so many larger issues that we face as a society. And it just, it really does make my assets. That part, right.

    KC Davis 2:58

    I feel like it's similar to like the phrase, like attention seeking, where it's not that there isn't certain behavior that's maybe like not working for you that you would like to work on. But it's like you said, like it demonizes the underlying desire, and then that person ends up like hating themselves for this desire.

    Shahem 3:21

    Let me say this, you are also one of my favorite creators, like literally, I'm honored to be here. I saw your video when you talked about attention seeking versus connection seeking. And I was just like, Thank you like that is the perfect way to describe that because a lot of the times, kids specifically, you know, worked in foster care, the juvenile justice system, and I am like no stranger to the phrase, attention seeking a lot of children often dismiss their needs are often dismissed as seeking attention, as opposed to like the acknowledgement that these children are like they are lacking connectivity. And instead of like us focusing on how we can solve that issue, which is connected to again, these larger social problems, like loneliness is systemic. And instead of addressing these issues, we are reactionary, and we attack the effect and not the cause, like, but that is like, again, connected to so many larger issues in this context, because we never really addressed the root of the issue. We just disappear, we pathologize and dismiss, that is something that makes my assets.

    KC Davis 4:39

    And I think one of the reasons why it gets so much blowback is because and this is true of a lot of like pop psychology terms or like psychological terms in general, is that you have people who have a genuine struggle or like a genuine behavior that's neither not working for them or it's destructive for them or or whatever. Are and they find a term that they feel like the meaning of that term. It helps them like move through whatever they're going through, it helps them identify what's going on. It helps them like work through something. And then they feel very defensive when someone like comes for that term. And I'm thinking specifically of like, so a lot of my background is in addiction, like I had a really severe addiction. And I went through a long rehab, and then I worked on addiction my whole career. So, you know, it's interesting, like, we've been talking about, like teachers and disabled students a lot on my tech talk right now. And everyone's like, well, you've never taught but you would be amazed the similarities between working in addiction and like observing what's happening, like on teacher talk right now. And there's also I think, a lot of similarities with working with foster kids, because it's this because mine were always young adults, it was always like, kids in their early 20s, that had addiction issues, and all the same stuff about like, are they like, they're manipulative, they are dishonest, they are attention seeking. They are like all of these things that really get slapped on them. And codependent was one really big one specifically for the like the women that would come through. And in my addiction, my mother, like really struggled with what she now believes to be like enabling behaviors. And she went through this process of like, learning boundaries and learning that like, hey, regardless of what my daughter chooses to do, like, I am my own person, and like, I can have joy in life, even if she's not like, I can't save her, but I can be there for her and all these things. But like, the books like my, these core memories of my mom, and these, like melody Beatty books, on codependency, like in her like little bedside, write her little, and every day, just like her little codependency books, and they really helped her. And I think that that's why like, people can get really defensive because it's like, okay, we're not coming for your journey. Like, if that word has done something for you, that's great. But like for every person that was like, helped by that word, like, it wasn't the word that helped you. And then there's like other people who are not helped by it. And so like, we're not taking that journey away from you, if like, that's an identification that has helped you. But I totally agree with you that sometimes a term and maybe at one point, it was a helpful term like, well, first of all, I think the term originated in addiction. And it was like, akin to the word co addict. And literally codependent was specifically like you had the person who was dependent on alcohol. And then what they found was that they were seeing that like the Dine, obviously, like, there's a lot of dynamics that you can recognize in addiction, like over and over and over, like, Oh, these all seem to be similar, like, regardless of where these people are in the demographic, you know, bap, but what they found was, and it was obviously, mostly men that they were treating, like when this first started, their wives also seemed to exhibit similar patterns of dysfunction. And so the word codependent came about not because you're dependent on another person, but it was like this person's up dependent on alcohol. And this is the CO dependent like, it was describing a dynamic between two people, right? Where like, one is in this like chaos of addiction where they're literally like circling the drain going down, and the other person is in that dynamic with them. And they're like creating this like kind of sick feedback loop where they're both going down together. And so she was the CO dependent and that's the term how it started and then it kind of got hijacked and got like a lot of terms got so pop psychology EAD that now, you know, if my boyfriend isn't calling me back, and I'm upset about it? Well, I'm just being codependent.

    Shahem 8:51

    That is a perfect example of what I mean when I say people overuse it. But I think you are pointing out something that is so important is the way that language is CO opted. It happens so often. And I'm going to say the next this next part, I know every time I say this around the therapist is like a narcissistic personality disorder. The way people talk about narcissism, online narcissistic abuse, and I'm not here to say like narcissistic abuse is not a real experience. And some people really do get a lot from talking about like narcissism, but a lot of people do also overuse the terminology and lean heavily on like one, I just always careful about talking about it because people get really up in arms about this, but just basically like villainizing entire personality clusters of personality disorders, and like basically dehumanizing other people and slapping the label on pretty much anybody that they come across, who is an asshole in one instance to them and it is I think like that is like a really like the biggest that I see once I talk by pretty frequently, but like, the way that people take language, and yes, it does help them in their journey, which is a beautiful thing, like, but they take it and they like apply it broadly across the board. And I think a lot of language gets like eaten up into this like larger machine that is like, frankly violent, and it's chews people up and spits them out, we live in a very carceral society where we are quick to other people and to like disappear people whenever they do things that are deemed societally unacceptable. And I think the way that we use a lot of this mental health language is a part of that, like it is often co opted into the machine. Like when I worked in the juvenile justice system, attention seeking behavior was like the most commonly used phrases to describe children who were frankly, like, behaving like kids were hurt, because he's a lot of these kids have been in the system for years. And like, instead of like connection seeking, like, you know, attention seeking, like, I think like the language is all a part of like this larger machine that seeks to like exploit other and you know, basically, like, disappear people. And I think that's why when we do bring up things like you know, maybe not attention seeking, or maybe codependency is a little bit of a strong choice of words for you to be seeking connection from your partner, that we get pushed back. But I do think it's important to keep pushing back on these narratives, because this is how the language becomes co opted. And not that, you know, I think language is that because I'm actually going to be talking about this probably a little bit later. But like language is so important. language as a tool is essential. Having the words to put your experience in can make it easier for you to navigate your experience. It makes it easier to make decisions. Like when you have therapeutic language like a you can understand if someone is like for example, gaslighting you, and you are able to call that out. It's really important. It's like these tools are necessary. But like any other tool, it can be used for good or bad. Or it can be because tools are just tools.

    KC Davis 12:22

    And there's like a bell curve of it. Right? Like, okay, nobody knows what gaslight is. And then it's like we learn what it is. And then it's like the really empowering word. And the more it's used, and the more it's normalized, the more helpful it is to identify things. And then it hits like a Zenith where it gives us so much that now it becomes really watered down and like it's like helpfulness takes a nosedive. And then we have to kind of look back and go, okay, like, it doesn't just mean everything. And I think that's the point at which a lot of these like terms go from psychology to pop psychology, where there's like this short window of use, yes, trauma, bonding, trauma dumping, like all those things. And I have an interesting question about the pathologizing thing. But let me take a short break here. Okay, so one of the things you mentioned, especially narcissistic personality disorder, I had this thought where there's two interesting things happening at the same time. So like, let's take that term, or even like borderline personality disorder. What's interesting about that is that I see people using that term to pathologize like to demonize someone like to take what's a, frankly, a pretty normal human response to deep, deep trauma, and calling it you know, something that is a mental illness. And it's like pathologizing, but then I see people taking the term and doing the opposite, where it's like, they're trying to use it to say, Hey, I'm not evil, I have this disorder. And so you can't be angry about it, you have to have empathy for it, you have to have, and it's so interesting to me how the use of the disorder language, like does both at the same time, and I and it's like, oh, I don't know what to do with that. Because on the one hand, we can't pathologize it too much. But on the other hand, it's like, but they're both making the same mistake, which is, this is this is a, I don't know, I can't stand personality disorders because people don't understand the difference between the personality disorders and other disorders because like, there are some disorders in psychology and this is same in medical, whatever, but like, where we see a cluster of symptoms, and that tells us the cause, right? Like if we say someone has diabetes, like we see the symptoms, the blood sugar or that the other and because we realize that that's diabetes, we know the cause we quite literally know what's causing those symptoms and it is, you know, the stuff happening In their liver, pancreas kind of stuff. And then there's other ones, right? Like, okay, you have the flu? Well, we saw the symptoms. And now we know you have the flu. And literally the flu is the cause. It's a virus that came in and it did XYZ. But there are other types of disorders or even like medical ones, where we say like, Okay, you have chronic fatigue syndrome, we have no idea what causes that. We don't know whether there are multiple causes, or one cause we just know that there are people showing up with these clusters of symptoms. And they're showing up often enough that were clear that it is something and so people I don't think understand that, like when you talk about DSM disorders, like there are some of those that, like when we say you have Bipolar, we know that something is going on, that's causing the bipolar in your brain. Like it's not trauma, it's not like there might have been an environmental flip, right. But it is something in the chemistry of our brain, or OCD. Like there's something happening in the brain that's causing all those symptoms. And I don't think people realize that personality disorders are not like that, like there is not like a gene that causes borderline personality disorder, or narcissistic personality disorder. Like, that's not what we're saying. We're just saying that, like, there have been so many assholes that have showed up with this very specific constellation of symptoms, that it is helpful for us to call it something, because then we can better treat it because we can know that like, if this works with that person, it might work with other similar, like personality profiles. And I think that becomes really sticky for people because it's like, it's not quite as simple as like, I don't know, man, I've just got narcissistic personality disorder. So like, we don't want to demonize anyone, even if it is something but it's like, well,

    Shahem 16:55

    Not quite the same. And I think like you bring up a like a really important point. I think it's an overarching thing that like, this is real, it really grinds my gears, it pisses me off when it comes to conversations around mental health. And I think like it speaks to the context that we live within the current state of society. But a lot of people try to operate in extremes. And like, they don't like to find balance within all of these conversations. And I like to tell people all the time, like you have the one thing about like mental health, no matter which side you are talking about, like you need to have balance, like there is a point where it's like, you have to hold yourself accountable for your actions, having any disorder or any like, it's not, like if you are someone who can account for their, like, if you're oriented to this reality, you can account for your actions, and you have to like, you know, there are consequences for actions, you know, and but there is a balance, because there are people who have like, disordered thinking people do deserve, like to be able to experience, you know, life and to react to trauma without being thrown away. You know, there is space for empathy. And there is like, it's just a balancing act. I think.

    KC Davis 18:08

    I'm glad you said the oriented to reality part. Yeah. Because like we at some point, we have to admit that someone experiencing psychosis is different than someone who has a personality disorder. Yeah, like there's a different level of accountability there.

    Shahem 18:24

    Yeah, like, if you're not even like, you know, if you're not oriented, like time place, like all that, like, if you aren't oriented, you're not playing with the same like deck of cards as everyone else. So like, I think it is just like, again, it's that balance, like being able to balance which being able to balance like how to, like, have people within community in society, without necessarily feeling the need to throw everybody away who has any defaults, or defects. But I think a large part of that goes back to systemic issues where a lot of frankly, if you ask me, I think personality disorders, a lot of them can be resolved if we, like adjusted the way that we operate as a society. Like trauma is systemic, like, think of how a lot of housewives in the 1950s were like, traumatized, deeply traumatized, by the way that their lives were set up because of the way systemically they didn't have the same options, as a lot of women do now, but even still, like you know, we have a lot of systemic issues that women go up against which create a lot of dysfunction and the same goes across the board for a lot of people like no matter the identity. I also am a huge like proponent of like disability theory, I think society disabled people. And I think like if we function better as a society, a lot of the issues that we face can be shifted, but there are there is also again, balance like the genetic components like some people actually have like mental health, mental health have things that they have to go up against and face that are genetic, like, like, you know, if you are you have Bipolar, like there's a genetic predisposition to it. And like there's just a balancing act. And I think one of the issues comes when people try to place everything on the same like plane, when it's a matrix, it's not like just the plane is a matrix, like there are different factors that contribute to everything. And I think when we strip ourselves of the nuance, and we don't approach it with nuanced thinking, which often happens when things are watered down through pop psychology, like it really does more of a disservice than it does a service.

    KC Davis 20:46

    And I think people are probably wondering, like, What the hell does all this have to do with codependency, but I think it is really connected. Because I think that whole conversation, like it revolves around this, this thing we have in our culture, where you can either have empathy for someone, or you can expect accountability from them. Like we see those as opposite, right. And so I think people who are struggling, they feel alone and they desire connection, and they desire allowed to be human. And so what that comes out as like, Hey, this is a disorder have empathy for me, don't demonize me. And that's just that same like kind of cry of the heart of like, Don't put me out. And but then the opposite of it, which is like when people get really harmed by people, and they're going, No, I'm not going to just excuse that by going, Oh, I feel so sorry for you, you've abused people. And people truly can't imagine a world where empathy and accountability happen in the same place. And I think that that is one of the things that leads to what we call codependency, right, I end up in a relationship with someone, I don't feel like I have worthiness outside of somebody else's value of me. And so I there's this person, and so if that person is harming me in some way, I don't know how to hold that in a space, right. And so I ended up thinking, Well, I have to have empathy for them, I have to have empathy for them, I have to have empathy for them. And I don't expect accountability and my own self worth is so degraded, that I find myself in a dynamic where I continue to run back to either the same person or the same types of people that I need connection so badly, but then when I get that connection, it further harms me. And that makes me need it more. And we kind of end up like there. There is something happening there. And it kind of comes back to boundaries, which is another thing that I think we get wrong with boundaries.

    Shahem 22:48

    Oh, my goodness, the hyper focus on boundaries, often when I love talking about boundaries, because I do boundaries are very important, like for community. But a lot of the ways that we talk about boundaries in this mental health space that we all exist within is it hyper focuses on like, individual, like hyper individualism, like I said before, like the same problem with codependency like it tries to like push people further to isolate and to sever connections with people around them, as opposed to like, like, you know, and you know, of course, there are the people who are trained resolve clinicians who actually talk about it in a way that I think is like really healthy and helpful. And then there are the people who like try and push people further towards isolation and disconnecting from people around them. And I think there's a lot that we get wrong as a society. And I think that's why conversations like this do matter, though, because they're like, I can't tell you how many times I've heard people say, Wow, you really did shift my, my perspective with thinking on this because I didn't think of it like that. And I think it's important for us to just keep pushing the space don't get me started on carcere ality in a way that, you know, therapists are allowed to exist on the online space. But I'm like, a really big advocate for us, like, are people who are professionals like sharing their expertise online, because it is like pretty much part of our duties at this point to combat a lot of like, the misinformation and disinformation that is easily spread online, just around language overall, but like, even things like you know, something as simple as trauma dumping, like, you know, I can't tell you how many times I've heard people use the term trauma dumping. I can't tell you how many times I've had clients, like patients of mine come to me and say like, I'm sorry, I don't want to trauma. And I have to let them know your therapist. Like you're actually supposed to talk about your drama like that's what I'm here for, like you're not trauma dumping, because you're sharing your experience because a lot of the language that is used and the space is like, literally used to push people towards isolation. And yeah, that was a long winded way to say I agree. And yeah, it's a mess, the way we cover a lot of these things, but we got to keep talking.

    KC Davis 25:13

    Okay, so let's do this, we're gonna take a quick break and come back. Okay, so I want to move on to talking about like, what would be a better way? Because I have thoughts, I know you have thoughts of talking about what people are trying to talk about when they say codependency because there's like, separate different ways. So I want to give you kind of an example of something that I experienced that I used to identify as codependency when I was young. And then you put your therapist hat on and tell me like, how do you think this would be better conceptualized for someone. So back when I was using, I felt just as addicted to people as I did the substances. And there's one specific memory that has always sort of been seared in my head, which it was like a Saturday night. And I was like, Okay, I got it. And I had like a group of friends. And it was a large group. So like, sometimes some of them were here, some of them were there, some of them were all together, or whatever. And I was calling around trying to figure out like, where's the get together? Like, what are people doing? Like, where's the event or the thing that I can go and be a part of, and part of what I loved about using drugs is I went from like walking into a room insecure to walking into a room where everybody stopped and looked up and went, Hey, like, there she is, and I knew what to do. And I knew what was expected. And I, I knew how to inhabit the identity of this like subculture I was living in and and so I'm Saturday night, and I'm calling around, and no one's picking up the phone. And I can't figure out like, is anyone doing anything? And if so, where are they? And and, and how can I go be apart? And no one's ignoring me? It wasn't like, Oh, my friends are hanging out. Without me. It was just that, you know, I would get someone on the phone. They'd say, Oh, I'm not doing anything tonight. And then somebody wouldn't answer and then somebody wouldn't answer. And then somebody wasn't doing anything. And the more I called the more frantic I felt, because like I couldn't find people to go be with. And it felt as desperate as like calling around for a fix. And nobody has anything. And I'm calling and I'm calling and I'm calling and I get to like the last person I know to call, and nobody's out doing anything. And I literally collapse on the ground and just start hyperventilating and crying and screaming, because I feel like my chest is going to cave in, if I can't go be with these people and experience that feeling of okayness. And so that was the experience that early on was like, Oh, I'm codependent. But so if you had a client that came to you with that experience, like what better language or like view could you give them to understand that experience?

    Shahem 27:58

    Well, first, I'm so sorry, that is a part of your experience. That sounds like that was really tough. And I can only imagine, I'm sorry that you had to experience I know, going through stuff like that is not easy. But as far as I'm concerned, it sounds just like how we were just talking about like, it sounds like you want to connectivity like you want it to feel connected to a community of people around you. And you didn't feel that in that moment. And I think even beyond that, I would start personally to explore like exactly why it is that you feel so disconnected despite you having these relationships, and people you should you can call up because that doesn't come from just like nowhere. I think that is part of the experience of wanting to be connected. But if you are in a setting where you are surrounded by people, and you don't feel connected to the people, unless you are physically around them, or you're out and you're busy, why do you feel like you need to be connected to people or being being out in order to be connected? Why are you driven by this, like, outside validation because I don't even know like it would require so much compensation which is another sidebar when people ask me for advice, which is why I do not give out advice on tick tock like I travel this avoid it because it's like, I wouldn't eat so much context. But this is a point of exploration, which is why I'm like jumping, leaping directly to codependency as like a term to just like stamp it. Sometimes it does a disservice because there's so much you can explore as to why it is like that feeling was there to begin with. We are human beings, right how we are taught to connect to other people. When we are young, have huge, you know, attachment theory versus how we are taught like, when we're young to like connect to other people. It follows us for a while it can change over time. But part of that change if the way we are connected to people is is unhealthy, where we feel like we can't function if we're not connected to other people at all times. Like, we have to explore what where that comes from. Right. And that could be a number of things like, you know, some people do have, like, genetic predispositions to mental health concerns and things that prevent them from being able to like exist without feeling that connectivity, some people like that's trauma, like, it is just a point of exploration, if you ask me, and that is the part, the point where I would start to explore a little bit further, and not just like, slap a label on it.

    KC Davis 30:34

    Yeah, cuz that label has become the end of the journey. You know, I mean, it's like, you hear that you're like, oh, codependency is like, Okay, we have a diagnosis. Let's move on. But here's the thing in all my years, nobody has ever said what you just said to me, specifically, like literally 20 However, many years later, I'm having this aha moment when you said, you were connected to people like deeply that loved you, that you loved, that welcomed you that appreciated you. Why is it that there's no emotional permanence? Because my head went right to, like, Yes, I know, I need connection. But like, I should be able to be okay on a Friday night, once in a while being alone. But when you said, first of all, like that such a human need, like there's nothing wrong with you for needing that connection. But what's interesting is that you had it, but you couldn't experience it unless you were physically with those people. And I think that that's really what the heart of this conversation is about is that like, when you go with, well, you shouldn't be healthy, you should be a person who's Okay, not always having outside validation. Like we go right to like, what's wrong with it? Instead of what's right. Like, there are things in you functioning normally, which is like you need connection. But there's something that has like gotten in the way of your ability to experience like, in my case, like the connection you actually have. And you said, like, that becomes the beginning of a journey and the opening of a journey that has a lot less shame than you know, when I went to rehab, and they gave me my first treatment assignment about codependency. And it was like list the seven ways you're codependent. And why do you need the validation of others, and it pushes it, it also says, like, you say this really well, where it's like, no one's saying that, like, that's not a painful place to be. And that if we were to have to use the term slightly dysfunctional, and that it's just not working for me. But when I went through rehab, when we worked on my codependency in quotation marks, it presented the answer to that as just being my own island, never needing the validation of other people never needing to have to be around. And so that just puts me right into like, this black and white shame place, where I feel ashamed of myself if I can't have my own self esteem. And I feel okay with myself if I can, but I'm never gonna get there. If the whole journey is this. Well, I just want to be okay with myself. So I want to do the healthy thing instead of like, actually having a healing journey. And I think that's like the key to the issue is when we talk about pathologizing something versus understanding that like, and I used to call this I had a podcast recently with someone where we talked about this idea of like, first person experience versus third person experience, where when I got into the mental health world really young, what quickly happened was this dichotomy of if you're healthy, that's good, and you're worthy. And if you're unhealthy and dysfunctional and codependent like that's not. And so when you do things in this category, you feel shame, because you're not good enough. But when you're making therapeutic progress, you are good enough. And everything you experience is from this like third person point of view, where there's like this invisible audience saying, Good, now you're doing good. Now you're doing good, as opposed to first person experiences where like, Wouldn't it be nice to for a Saturday night where I could make a cup of coffee, or watch a movie by myself and still enjoy feeling connected and knowing that I'm loved, like that experience is rewarding in and of itself. It doesn't have to have this extra layer of and now I'm healthy and I feel like I'm worthy.

    Shahem 34:14

    Exactly. It is just about like being able to feel emotionally like safe, if you ask me. And also, I just cannot in this conversation without saying like, you cannot heal in isolation. That is just like a number one thing. We are a social species. We need other people. We need relationships, frankly, like I like one thing I love talking to when I work with foster kids. I would ask them like, you know, who who is responsible for these lights being on maybe like, oh, we have a bill. Yeah, but like there's also somebody who runs the electricity plant. Like there are people who like build the wiring like we are a social species like we are all connected in ways where we don't even know if we are connected in those ways. Like we have to connect to other people for other things too, right. And that includes like, mental health and mental wellness, like you need other people. And that's okay. And a lot of the times I will say this, because I also have to save us before we close. But, you know, as someone who was recently trained in EMDR, like, I can say, like one of the things that I worked through, because in the training they make you go through and process your own trauma. One of the things that I worked through was like my connectivity to my family, because in a lot of ways people will say I was codependent because I was like seeking connection from family. But when I was able to process and metabolize certain traumas I recognized like, you know, like, I just like literally had trauma that was not metabolized. And sometimes it is that simple. Sometimes it's not. In fact, I would say none of that is simple. It's all very complex. But that's the thing, right? Like not settling for, like these very broad, very, sometimes shaming is shameful, like terms, and language, because it can literally stop you or getting away from exploring yourself, your journey, your story, like what is at the root, and like helping yourself come to a space where you feel safe, because that's at the end of the day, you feeling safe, and connected and tethered and present and all the things because that's ultimately what I think a lot of us want.

    KC Davis 36:33

    Well, and if your codependency becomes like the period before the exploration, because I can totally see if I were to come to you and tell that same story. But the difference would be like, I keep like I find a group and then they go away, where like you would be able to therapist to go, hey, the issue is you don't have a community. And like not having a community and feeling that desperation is a completely different journey and solution than someone that comes and goes, I have a community, they really liked me, but I feel desperate, if I'm not physically with them. Like that's a totally different way of exploring. And it's also very different than someone coming to you and saying, there's this one particular person who is abusive to me, or toxic to me or mistreats. Me, and I can't quit them. Like that's also an codependency I think dangerously lumps, all of these different issues together with this one stamp of something's wrong with you go figure it out instead of, you know, realizing like there are a lot of different ways that could show up and different ways to explore that. And one of the things for me, I can't remember which therapist I was like working under, when we were talking about addiction, specifically around this idea of like, enabling someone or not having boundaries with someone. And they were the first person I heard talk about how like codependency is not helpful term. And the terms that she used when working with couples and families where there's like a dyad, or a triad of like somebody with, you know, either mental health or addiction or even toxic behavior. As she said, like, throw away the word codependency, I want to talk about looking at this relationship, like where are the areas where you might be over functioning, and where are the areas where you might be under functioning. And that, to me was such a more helpful way of thinking about it, because she would address it the person that was like, quote, The identified patient. And we would talk about how like, in terms of community, like you have obligations to community, and you have privileges from community, and you will occasionally get someone who wants to enjoy all the privileges of community, but consistently under functions when it comes to meeting the obligations of community or the responsibility of community. So whether it's family or community or friends or whatever. And oftentimes, another person in response to that person's under functioning will then begin to over function. So I'll just do things for them. I'll rescue them from their emotions, I'll pay those bills for them, I'll do that. And it was such an easier way of looking at so it wasn't this person's a piece of shit and you're codependent.

    Shahem 39:16

    Yeah, I think like the more we talk about this stuff, the more it spreads and gets out there and the more people can like probe, hopefully somebody will hear this and they will think to themselves, like maybe I should explore a little bit further. Just slap a label on myself. Because I think one thing that you highlighted that is really important is like that shame that comes with like feeling like the problem is you. It really impacts like your ability to function overall. And I think it's important to be able to question and like give yourself grace through it when when you know like that these things can come from so many different like aspects and avenues and you can hold yourself accountable while also holding empathy for yourself. Like that makes it a lot easier.

    KC Davis 40:04

    I feel like it's like thinking of the difference between seeing your mental health journey for lack of a better term or your healing, you can see it as a lap pool, like an Olympic sized lap pool, where it's how far am I going? How fast am I going? Am I going in the right direction? And how am I going in comparison to the people in the other lanes, right? Like, you can visualize it that way. And that's what where a lot of that shame comes in. Because I'm not moving as fast as everyone else. I'm not moving as fast as I should be. I'm not winning. I'm not doing the correct strokes. I'm not going in the right direction. I'm not moving, you know, all of these things, versus seeing it as like a resort pool with a beach entry. Right? It's like, you can wait in you can sit in the shallows for a while you can get deeper, but you can be deeper off to the left, you could be deeper off to the right you can you know, there's a waterslide that maybe unbeknownst to us circumstances just plunged your ass right into the deep end, right? Like, it's just a so much like, let's just wait into this pool. And everyone's doing something different. But it's not this like lap pool where like, you're good if and you're bad. If it's like we're just getting in the pool, like you might have a toe and you might have your whole body and you might be and what's funny is like you might be up to your neck, because you're standing in the deep end of the waters up to your neck or you might be in the shallow end, but you're willing to lay down up to your neck.

    Shahem 41:27

    What a beautiful analogy, like,

    KC Davis 41:29

    thank you. It just came to me.

    Shahem 41:32

    That was actually really, really good. I might have to use that. Really good. Yeah. I do have a session at 10. I don't know.

    KC Davis 41:41

    Well, we'll let you go. But can you tell everybody where they can find you if they want to follow you?

    Shahem 41:46

    Yes, I can be found at five h a h e m, on Tiktok and Instagram. And yeah, that's pretty much it. It's such a beautiful conversation. And I hope that somebody out here is questioning the term and the usage of the term codependency and understanding that your journey is important and exploring yourself is important. And no matter what, you deserve to feel safe. Yeah,

    KC Davis 42:15

    thank you. And we'll put that in the show notes for anybody who wants to link and thank you so much again, and I hope you come back and we can have more conversations about other things.

Christy Haussler
42: Self-Esteem Sucks. You Need Self-Compassion with Dr Kristin Neff

I’m excited about today’s guest because she has had a huge influence on me. I can confidently say that finding her research on self-compassion was a turning point in my healing journey. Do you need more self-compassion? Join us to learn more!

Dr. Kristin Neff is a renowned psychologist, self-care researcher, and author. Her work has had a profound impact on the field of psychology and has helped countless people cultivate self-acceptance and resilience.

Show Highlights:

  • How self-compassion became Dr. Kristin’s main area of research

  • Understanding self-esteem vs. self-compassion

  • The three components of self-compassion: mindfulness, common humanity, and self-kindness

  • How self-esteem creates comparison and social disconnection by being conditional and unstable

  • How self-compassion gives the gift of authenticity

  • The difference between fierce self-compassion and tender self-compassion

  • How self-compassion helps us get past our shame

  • Why self-compassion doesn’t mean indulgence

  • Pathways and blocks to self-compassion

  • The connection between self-compassion and psychological functioning

  • How self-compassion helps when we fail and make mistakes

  • Why the goal of practicing self-compassion is to be simply a compassionate mess who is completely human

  • Why the practice of self-compassion has to start small with baby steps of warmth and support (What would you say to a friend?)

  • A look at Dr. Kristin’s latest book, Fierce Self-Compassion

  • How anger fits into self-compassion

Resources and Links:

Connect with Dr. Kristin and find many helpful resources: Website

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust, this is Struggle Care, the self care podcast by a host that hates the term self care. And today I have a guest that I'm really excited about Dr. Kristin Neff, thank you so much for being here today.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 0:17

    Oh, thank you, KC, happy to be here.

    KC Davis 0:18

    I have to admit that I have been a little under the weather for like three days. And I was like, no matter what, I will not miss this recording. Okay, so the reason why I wanted to ask you to come on the podcast is because you have been such a huge influence on me, when you talk about self compassion, and the research behind it, that was a real turning point for me in really starting to heal and grow and get better in a way that sort of leaned me out of the self improvement kind of genre of getting better and more into the actual healing of feeling better. And so I wanted to ask you, how did self compassion become your main area of focus in your research?

    Dr. Kristin Neff 1:06

    Well, for me, it also started as a personal practice, I needed self compassion, I was a mess. I you know, I didn't invent the idea. I learned about self compassion when I first learned about mindfulness meditation. And it just made such a powerful difference to me, I was going through a very stressful time, and I started being more kind of supportive to myself. And I saw that the immediate difference it made, and this was when I was actually my last year of graduate school. And then I did two years of postdoctoral study with one of the country's leading self esteem researchers and I studied self concept development. And I started to see how we can come back to this how self compassion didn't have some of the problems associated with the need for high self esteem, that kind of endless treadmill of self improvement. So when I got to UT Austin, where I still am, I kind of thought, well, no one's really researched this before. But heck, they can study self esteem, they can study self compassion. So I started researching it, you know, really shortly after I got there about around 2000. And I'm just so blown away by not only how beneficial it is, but the applications just so many areas of life life, I mean, basically any area of life in which there's suffering or struggle with, there's a lot, it's irrelevant. So very quickly, it just became my life's work, I became devoted not only to research unit for the last 10 years, figuring out how to teach other people to practice being more self compassionate, because it's not just an idea. It's not just like a trait that some people have. And some people don't, it really is a practice, anyone can learn.

    KC Davis 2:37

    So how would you define self compassion, and then I also am curious how you would define self esteem because I feel like most of us, I mean, I grew up, I was one of the 80s, kind of a 90s kid. And I feel like a lot of the self help world when I was sort of growing up, and even today was this heavy focus on self esteem. I remember going through rehab at 16. And doing all these treatment assignments about self esteem, I remember having to look in the mirror and say, I am okay today. And people like me, and I write like giving myself these positive affirmations. And I remember thinking, this is not working. I do not believe these things. So can you tell us what the difference is?

    Yeah. So let me start by defining what self compassion is, and then I'll come back to self esteem. So self compassion is really just like compassion for others. You know, the Lenten compassion being with suffering, how are we with the tough stuff, whether that suffering comes from, you know, your hurricane, or COVID, or something difficult happens externally, or you're suffering because you feel you aren't good enough, or you've made a mistake, or you feel like a failure of those types of sources. And really, just like we work with a friend, we naturally be warm and supportive. When our friends hopefully for good friend, they say they're having a hard time we're present for them, we listen, we pay attention to them. And also the difference between compassion and pity is, hey, I've been there. It's inherently connected stance. It's not like I feel sorry for myself, or I feel sorry for you. It's just recognizing that everyone struggles, everyone's imperfect. That's what human life means, really. And so those are the three components mindfulness, being aware of difficulty, common humanity, recognizing this, this is shared and kindness, warmth, support. So the thing about self compassion is it's really unconditional in the sense that it's there for us. You know, we can be kind of supportive towards yourself when things are going well. But we're also especially kind of supportive towards yourself when things aren't going well. The difference between self esteem and self compassion, as you might say, self compassion is a stable unconditional friend. Self esteem is pretty much a fairweather friend. Right. So what do I mean by self esteem? It's important to define our terms. I'm referring to a positive judgment or evaluation of self like, I'm good are people like me? I'm great. These are positive judgments and values, you know, good as opposed to bad. So the thing about self esteem is that, and nothing wrong with having self esteem, it's actually psychologically better to delight yourself than to hate yourself. The problem is that it's contingent, it depends. Again, it's unstable. So typically, it depends on first of all feeling special and above average, it's not okay to be average, if I said, KC, yeah, your podcast is pretty average. Admit it, you feel hurt, right, I would feel hurt. You said Kristin, your work is pretty average. It's not okay to be average in our society, which means that technically, if we asked to be above average, it's technically, impossible for us to all have high self esteem at the same time. So we're setting ourselves up also in the sort of comparison, like is that person better than me, you're smarter than me or more attractive to be whatever it is. And that can create social disconnection, for instance, and we know one of the reasons kids start to bully others is to raise their self esteem. I'm the cool kid, you're the nerdy kid, I'm picking on you, I've got more power compared to you, that raises my self esteem. So that's a problem. Really big problem is that it's contingent on success, whatever we value, and so usually, what we value for our self esteem is social approval. Like you said, other people like me, well, that's great when they like you, but what happens when they don't like you? And how are you going to be authentic? If your self esteem is totally dependent on whether or not they like you, right? Or how we look? Actually for men and woman perceived attractiveness is huge. What happens when you start getting older or you know, you don't look the way the supermodels? Look, you don't have the filter on your camera when you post it on Instagram, right? Your self esteem takes a hit. And then also performance, right? So we have high self esteem when we succeed for what happens when we fail or make a mistake. We feel badly about ourselves. So the difference with self compassion is when we make a mistake, or other people don't like us, or you know, we're feeling inadequate in some way. That's precisely when we give ourselves compassion. Oh, well, it's only human to make mistakes. What can I learn from this? Right? Okay, so I'm imperfect. That's part of being human. That's okay. Whoever said I was supposed to be perfect. Other people don't like me sometimes. Ouch that hurt. Well, can I like myself, at least, you know, do I really want to twist myself to contort to meet other people's expectations if it's not true to me. So those are the types of difference. So just to show you one study I did on comparing self esteem and self compassion, we found that the stability of self worth the both forms of self worth, but self compassion is unconditional, because I'm a flawed human being, self esteem is usually conditional, because I'm the way I want to be or because other people like me, or because I'm better than others. So the self worth linked to self compassion was my first stable over time that the self is worth that comes from self esteem.

    That makes me think, also, when you talk about self esteem, being sort of contingent on how you are in comparison to others, or how others think of you, that's not always lined up with your actual values, like people can like you for the wrong reasons and hate you for the right reasons. And and so it that makes it even more turbulent?

    Dr. Kristin Neff 7:54

    And that absolutely, yeah, so one of the biggest findings of the research is self compassion is linked to authenticity, right? You know what some of the feedback powers your self compassion practice helped me personally? Well, I'm still very flawed, I still got a lot of problems, but I'm authentically flag, who I am. Because my self worth is contingent on other people liking me. And that's one of the gifts that gives you you can be your true self. And also, by the way, it doesn't mean some people think it means you're complacent, you aren't going to try to change or improve. That's not the case at all. It's why do you want to improve, I want to improve not to be acceptable as am I'm already acceptable. I want to improve because I care about myself, and I don't want to keep suffering and causing problems with myself and others. And what that does is when it's safe to fail and make mistakes, that means I can actually learn from them. If I'm just full of shame, Oh, I'm such a failure. Everyone hates me. It's not exactly conducive mindset to like, figure out what happened or try to learn from the situation or try again. So it's actually a better motivator is more effective motivator than the motivator of shame or self criticism.

    KC Davis 8:59

    I'm so glad you said that. Because when I talk online, and so you know, my focus is mainly on how people care for their homes and their self in periods of struggle. And one of the major push backs I get is, well, if I'm being compassionate towards myself, when my house is a mess, and everything is dirty, and I'm not really caring for myself, like, won't that just enable me just give me permission to stay stuck? And it's interesting, because in my own experience, it's the opposite. There's nothing more motivating than real self compassion.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 9:31

    Yeah, we know that empirically. So here's the difference. So I like to turn these fierce and tender self compassion, tender self compassion is about unconditional self acceptance. It's also about accepting the fact that life's imperfect, we have difficult emotions. It's kind of the acceptance of the imperfection of life. Fear self compassion is about taking action, right? What can we do in terms of our behaviors and our situations not to suffer? So even while unconditionally accepting yourself and the fact that your house is a mess doesn't mean that you're less worthy person because it that your house was mess, you don't have to identify with it. But if your house being a mess is causing you suffering, if it's making you harder for you to, you know, relax or to get things done, or it's actually causing stress in your life, then it's actually not helping you. So compassion is about the alleviation of suffering, right. So if you're doing things that are causing suffering, like the way you live, or something's causing you suffering, it's not compassionate to let it slide. But it's aimed at our behaviors and our situations, we need to try to change our behaviors and our situations, to maximize well being at the same time that we as people are worth is like, given the fact that we are at imperfect human being is all we need. That's the only bar we need to check to be worthy of compassion, which remember is kindness and support. It doesn't mean you know, maybe you aren't doing things, right. It's not fake, because you don't say, oh, Kristin, you're great. Actually, Kristin, and this has happened. That was a really unkind thing. You said, that really hurt that person's feelings, that self compassion now saying, and you're terrible, horrible person, I hate you. That's not self compassion. But saying, Kristin, you said, what you just said was really unkind. Pay, I understand your stress is only human, it happens sometimes. But this person is hurting, what can we do to try to repair the situation. So for instance, we find that self compassionate people are more able to take responsibility for their mistakes or things they do, because it's safe to do so. And they're more willing to try to repair them again, because you have the emotional resource to do so.

    KC Davis 11:34

    So I want to take a short break here. And then when we come back, I want to talk about that word tender.

    Okay, we're back with Dr. Kristin Neff. I love that word tender. Because what I was trained to be a therapist, we talked a lot about this term, unconditional positive regard that we're supposed to have for our clients. And when I heard you use that word tender, something kind of switched for me when I realized that when I am compassionate towards myself, it's not necessarily an unconditional positive regard, because sometimes I haven't done something positive, but it's an unconditionally tender regard. Because if that connected

    Dr. Kristin Neff 12:14

    conditionally positive evaluation, but to the extent that warmth and kindness is a positive emotion, which it is, it is positive, right, really good analogy, I think an intuitive one is an ideally compassionate parent, you know, most of us are not ideally, compassion raised by them. But if you imagine an ideally compassionate parent, that parent loves their child unconditionally, when their child fails, does something wrong, just mean hurtful. The bottom line is I love you, I'm here for you, right? But a compassionate parent doesn't stop there. A compassionate parent wouldn't say, oh, that's fine, get all this, skip school, use drugs, whenever you know, don't worry about it. That's not because that's causing their child's suffering. A compassionate parent is I care about you? How can I help sometimes it may be kind of tough drawing boundaries, listen is really important that you follow these rules. Because if you don't follow these rules, you aren't gonna learn the skills you need to get by in life. You know, that is true love. And the same thing with ourselves. Complacency is not caring for ourselves, it's actually undermining ourselves. But shame and self hatred is also undermining ourselves. So we can combine unconditional warm support, being there for ourselves with some real hard honestly, this really needs to change. It's not working for me, you know, if I want to be happy, if I don't want to suffer, I gotta either me, I have to change or my situation. So fear, self compassion is also I think, for instance, the Black Lives Matter movement, or the me to movement. These are pure Self Compassion movements, when people rise up and say, Hey, this, you can't treat me this way. I'm valuable, you know, this, this situation is wrong, or maybe your work situation, you're being treated unfairly. Or maybe you're in a relationship where you're not being treated well, part of self compassion is taking action against either behaviors, yours or others, or situations to try to engender wellbeing and alleviate suffering,

    KC Davis 14:03

    When I find that when self esteem is sort of the measure, and there's a lot of shame involved, people can't be accountable, because when that truth is being brought to them about something that's either not going right or something they've done, that's harmful, they can't get unless you can get to a place I don't even know how to it's like, We're such social creatures, that when I'm feeling the social rejection, that is the only thing I can feel. It's the only thing I'm preoccupied with. And it's the only literally my fight or flight kicks in and goes I have to find out how to be acceptable again. And when that's happening, I'm inherently centering me. And I'm not even able to look or be accountable to the thing that I might have done.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 14:46

    Exactly. Shame is incredibly self focused. I mean, it's human. It's natural. It's we evolved to feel shame, but it's so self focused and it shuts down our ability to learn. When we're flooded with shame. We actually can't learn from our mistakes all we can

    Do is like hide in a corner and say I'm so terrible, please don't hate me. And again, shame still rises for me because it is actually evolutionary emotion. So shame arises and like, okay, human beings feel shame, that's okay, this hurts. How can I help myself in the moment, you know, and often helping yourself in the moment means, well, maybe I need to apologize, maybe I need to do something different. But here's the thing, some sources of shame are from social injustice, prejudice. So for instance, we've done a lot of research with teens who are, you know, LGBT plus community, who are shamed all the time. So in that case, it's like, screw you shame, I'm not going to buy into this message perfectly wonderful, just as I am. So but you know, if the shame, like my case, did say something mean to someone, then the shame was playing a function and saying, Hey, Kristen, who, you know, that was not good. And then I can move on from there. If we get stuck in it, that's when it really holds us back.

    KC Davis 15:55

    Yeah, I remember having these feelings when I first entered rehab, and people would try to help myself low self worth, by saying things like, oh, but you're so pretty, and you're so smart. And you're so these things. And there's this real sense of, you know, no matter how many good attributes you try to ascribe to me, I have this sense of if you only knew, and I think that's where that authenticity comes into place, because it really felt like it will not penetrate my heart and make any difference, unless I'm being fully known by that person. And it wasn't until I was able to get authentic and honest, and let everybody see kind of all of the ugly insides, then receive that sort of compassion from others that I was in a place to actually hear. And here are some issues that we may want to look at KC?

    Dr. Kristin Neff 16:45

    Absolutely. You know, and the slight problem with that, although it's natural is that we don't want our compassion to be contingent, either. Everyone, you know, people in prison are people who've made horrible mistakes of their life, they're worthy of compassion as well. All human beings are worthy of compassion, right? Something that's an intrinsic human right, compassion. Again, that doesn't mean indulgence. That doesn't mean letting you get you know, what you do for people to try to help society or help them is a different issue. But our worth isn't dependent on our attributes, you know, and also, these are attributes are constantly changing, right? We all get older, I'm getting older. Now I'm seeing that one, you know, we go up and down, none of this is really stable. The only thing stable is that, at least in the course of our lifetime, is that we are aware human beings who are experiencing life, and that's actually the source of compassion. And you know, you could get spiritual on this, if you want it, I have no problem going there. And it's not like generated by our small cells, it's part of being a part of this larger interconnected universe. You know, we're one in many ways, we're all part of this larger, interdependent whole. So our worth comes from being part of this larger, independent whole, it's supposed to be ego based, like, because I went to grad school. And because I did this right look a certain way. That's where my worth comes from egocentric way of looking at it, do you think that in order to have self compassion, you have to be able to humanize others first, like if you're sort of seeing others, as if you're being really harshly judgmental to others, if you're having to kind of push others down to push yourself up, if you've got whether it's internal bias, or all these things, like I imagined it would be hard to extend yourself the grace and compassion that you're not extending to others or that you believe others don't? Because if they don't deserve it, then how could I deserve it? Yeah, so there's a lot of pathways to compassion and a lot of different blocks to compassion, I, from what my understanding, also with my research, it's not like some people say, you have to have compassion for yourself before you can have compassion for others. That doesn't seem to be true. A lot of people are very compassionate to others. And that oneself, I wouldn't necessarily say that you have to be compassionate for others before yourself, either, because there are probably some people who, whatever reason connect with their own experience and not those of others. So I wouldn't say there's a halfway but some of the principles are the same, the principles of understanding the nature of humanity, and the fact that, you know, we aren't totally in control of our actions, we do our best, but there's so many causes and conditions, you know, culture, history, genetics, environment, so many things that are out of our control, even our thoughts. I mean, how good are you at controlling your thoughts, you know? Exactly. Right. So so many things that are out of our control, understanding principles like that definitely help foster compassion. For some people that's the doorway in is because they can see it with others, they might be able to then make a U turn and do it for themselves. Yeah, I wouldn't be comfortable saying it has to be the case. But what we do knows when you learn to be more self compassionate, it does increase compassion for others, because again, we're understanding the bigger picture of our shared humanity, but it also does big time is actually gives us the

    resources to care for others. Not everyone, but most people are pretty compassionate and caring to others and not to themselves. But what happens is they burn out, they give and they give, and they give. And you know, they always say yes to other people, and they're always trying to help others. And they're, they deny themselves, they don't meet their own needs. And eventually, their cup runs dry. So um, self compassion is very good for decreasing caregiver burnout.

    KC Davis 20:22

    So somebody asked you that you published a lot of research on the connection between self compassion and psychological functioning. I think a lot of people see things like self compassion, I think that's nice. And people should feel nice about themselves. But they don't necessarily understand that it's not just a nice thing to teach people that it actually helps them raise their psychological level of functioning, that it actually can be a way of them getting better and feeling better, and sort of that, you know, the high tide that raises all ships. Can you talk some about that connection?

    Dr. Kristin Neff 20:57

    Yeah. So again, if you think of the word compassion with suffering, how are we with suffering, right, and it's usually the suffering the painful emotions of painful thoughts that derails us psychologically might lead to things like addiction, or suicidal ideation, or eating disorders, or depression or anxiety, because when difficult feelings or thoughts or situations arise, we get overwhelmed by them, we aren't able to cope effectively with and we get overwhelmed. And we're still just trying to cope by whatever means necessary. We're just trying to survive. And so by having a resource, which is warmth, care, support, kindness, what can I do to help kind of unconditional self acceptance, but also that realizing that maybe, how can I change that in a way that's helpful and supportive? That resource is, first of all, you might call it a type of emotion regulation, because it helps us being so overwhelmed by the difficulty. It also is a form of resilience, we might call it a form of resilience and coping. It's huge, right? It's not just good feelings, it's a way of approaching difficulty. In fact, sometimes it doesn't feel good at all, you know, it's really allowed opening to the incredible pain and grief and distress and all the difficult stuff, we open to it, we don't sugarcoat it. But we do open to it's love. And it's the love the warmth, that's actually the strength that helps us get through it. In fact, I think if you don't do it, if you just kind of grin and bear it or just shut down, you can function but it's going to come back to get your body's going to start holding all the trauma you experienced in your processing it. One of the things the ability to open to pain with warmth allows us to process difficult emotions, so they aren't stuck in our body so that we can work through them. So we can kind of integrate them in our understanding of ourselves in the world. If we don't, that all that stuff just gets stuck gets shoved in Eskalene. Things like heart attacks or you know, physical problems are coming back and like dramatic we're experiencing from my point of view, self compassion is really essential to leading a healthy life. And we're also showing that it's like basically, marker of good therapy, doesn't matter what type of therapy you use. If it's good therapy, it's gonna raise yourself compassion. It's kind of like what it is, is how do I can I relate to difficulty suffering stress difficult does in a way that that helps whether the harms is kind of like self evident, from my point of view at both course, we want to do that. Why don't we? Okay, so when we come back from the short break, I'm going to ask you a series of sort of negative messages and talk about the difference about what would that look like from a self esteem standpoint versus a self compassion standpoint?

    KC Davis 23:37

    Okay, so the idea being that, let's say that I'm going about my day, and I make a mistake at work. And the first thing that comes to my mind is me going, Oh, I'm so stupid. I think when we come from like a self esteem perspective, we're often told that the way to combat that is to go no, you're smart. When it's like, well, but in that moment, like I wasn't, that was actually me not being able to think through something or that was actually a mistake that I made. And so I think that's why for so many people that often feels really hollow as a response, like, What do you mean, replace the negative messages with positive ones? I don't believe that I'm smart. I made a stupid mistake. But what would self compassion sound like in that moment?

    Dr. Kristin Neff 24:21

    Yeah, so certainly is not positive thinking anyway, that falls flat. You don't say I am smart. There's a couple things you can do. First of all, one of the things about self compassion is remember, it's kind of separating ourselves from our behaviors or the situations. So yeah, it was a stupid mistake. It doesn't mean that you're stupid. It also doesn't mean you're not stupid. In a way the kind of what you are is irrelevant. Right? Because you are a human being who did the best you could in the moment, but there might be a way you could do better next time, right? So it'd be like okay, that behavior was not good. It didn't work out right. Maybe it was a stupid mistake, but me

    First thing you do is give yourself tender compassion for the pain of that, oh, oh, man, that hurts. I feel ashamed. I regret it. Ouch. So you kind of where you're with your pain of that you kind of hold it, give yourself some space, some comfort, you know, everyone makes mistakes. It's okay. But that's like step one. And then okay, well, that didn't work out. So could I do differently next time that might be more effective. This is how we learn mistakes. And again, even if we do it more effectively next time, it's not because that'll make us a good person. We're already flawed human being is okay, who we are. But we want not to make mistakes, because it helps us to be happy and healthy. And whatever our goals are, it helps them to achieve them right or do well at work, whatever our goal is. So it's really, really separating our worth is people from our behaviors and the situations we find ourselves in another thing, self compassion, because compassion, I'm just complexity, you know, understanding of the causes or conditions. It's also we have lots of parts of ourselves, the part of myself that made that decision maybe wasn't working that well. But maybe there was another voice or another part of myself that wasn't engaged. So instead of saying, I am bad, or I am good, it's like, well, first of all, I have a lot of different parts, and they're neither bad nor good. There's just some of them are effective or skillful or aren't effective, or skillfulness. Focus on what our behaviors are, what gets manifested. Our intrinsic worth is unquestioned. That's the bottom line of self compassion. All human beings, no matter what they do any awareness, you know, and if you think of the thoughts in your head are different than the thoughts in my head, but as your awareness different than my awareness, that's an open question.

    KC Davis 26:36

    Well, I think it's important to say that we don't have to believe that we're worthy to treat ourselves with compassion, like it's actually not a prerequisite, like, there's a lot of people that don't believe they're worthy, but you actually like, you can still treat yourself as if you are like, there's no like worthiness police, can I bust down the door be like, no, no, no.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 26:54

    Well, and the thing is, you have to ask yourself, when a baby is born, do they have to, like, get their high school degree? Or what's a GED enough to be worthy? I mean, right. So it's like, there's something intrinsic to being a human being who's aware is where the worthiness comes from. Now, for people who were treated by their parents is that they weren't worthy of kindness or compassion. It can be scary to have self compassion and can be difficult. But there's even a term we have for it called Backdraft. It's like when I give myself unconditional love, I immediately remember all the conditions under which I was unloved. And that could come up. And so that's something else we have to have compassion for, you know, it's natural doesn't mean you're doing it wrong, and actually means you're opening to the pain so that it can be healed, right? It has to be dealt with. It's totally natural. But yeah, it's really the thing about compassion is it's not self focused. It's really not about me as an individual. It's about life, the human experience, which is again, which is intrinsically worthy of compassion. As long as you're a flawed human being. That's the only checkbox you have to check to be worthy of compassion can take a while, because we aren't taught that. But again, as you act that way, eventually, there's a part of you who will start to be able to see that oh, yeah, that's right. I'm a flawed human being doing the best I can.

    KC Davis 28:14

    I talked to my book about my sort of journey with self affirmations and how they always felt like someone was just asking me to believe in Santa Claus, and you can't really make yourself believe something,

    Dr. Kristin Neff 28:23

    by the way, you aren't getting stronger every day. I'm not I'm fifth year, that's the truth. The only one that ever really worked was when I finally started saying to myself, I'm allowed to be human. Yes, exactly. That's the truth. One of the sayings we have in the self compassion world is the goal of practice is simply to be a compassionate mess, right? So you will still be a mess. I've been practicing for 30 years now I'm still making mistakes, but I have a compassionate mess. So your goal is chess, just from getting it right to be getting it opening your heart that starts to become your goal. And then when your hearts open, even when things are painful, your heart open, feels good, you feel connected to all of life feels good, that actually becomes your primary goal. This mean you don't even give up on all the other stuff as well. But it's not as important. The point is not to perfect ourselves, but to perfect our love, you know, and that when once you you shift your aim in that way, then things are much more workable, much more doable. You are human. Yeah. Whenever people ask me, you know, I've been trying self compassion, and I'm just not very good at it. What do I always say? Well, I mean, then you can just have self compassion about how hard self compassion is. Absolutely. You start where you are. That's actually often when I say to people, what's your current source of struggle? I feel so frustrated because I can't seem to practice self compassion. Well, what if a good friend came to you and said that would you say us cuz you're stupid idiot. Just give up? No, you probably say, Well, of course, it's hard. You know, you're given your history and it's challenging and you know, you just take it day by day and

    KC Davis 30:00

    So that type of warmth and support you can give toward anything, including how hard it is sometimes to practice self compassion, but you can also start small, you're just a baby step, you're just like, ah, you know, just kind of like a little bit, just a little more arms and get your foot in the door. And then you build on that little bit of warmth, that little bit of understanding, having a tiny bit of patience for some people path is, you know, you walk a little slowly, but you might go farther, right? So it's just about taking it moment by moment, trying to approach each moment with warmth, that sense of support, how can I help myself in this moment?

    One of the things that that I'm thinking about is, because we talk a lot about, you know, what would a friend say? What would a friend say? And it's made me when I say to a friend, yeah, what would I say to a friend, it's really made me realize how much even that is something we sometimes have to learn. Because for so much of my life, I would say to a friend, no, you're smart, and beautiful. And there's nothing wrong with you. And you. And I had to learn how to just hold space for a friend and say, yeah, yeah, maybe it was a fail, I fail two people fail, it doesn't change that I love you. It doesn't change. Failure, you fail doesn't mean you are a failure. Like you have to sum up the whole your entire worth is a failure. But I think it's powerful that it whether we're applying it to ourselves, or trying to have compassion to others, sometimes we really haven't raised with the belief that it's about fixing it. It's about convincing, it's something entirely different.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 31:27

    Yeah, you know, it's both right. So that's why you have to talk about the fierce of the tender. My new book is called fierce self compassion, because people get a little confused. We don't need to fix ourselves, we are fully worthy as we are. But some of our behaviors and our situations can use a little work, and that we need to honor that. Because if we don't, that's not helping either. So it's really disentangling our worth is people from some of our behaviors or situations which, and you know, again, we just do the best we can, they aren't going to be perfect. And that's okay. But we still try. And of course, as Carl Rogers said, the curious paradox is the more I accept myself, the more I can change, right, because it gives us the emotional resources to try to make effective I love the idea of fierce self compassion, and what that means about anger and women. Because I feel like as women, we've been told that anger is not okay to have. And that anger is a result of sort of maybe being unhealthy or not being at peace. When self fear self compassion really reframes what that anger is about, like, you shouldn't be angry, if you're being abused, you should be angry if other people are being abused. Yeah. So it's simple to say is that so simple to do, but simple to understand is, when anger is aimed at alleviating suffering, it's helpful. And when anger causes suffering, it's not helpful, right. And so if someone attacks my child, you better believe I'm gonna get angry. And that anger is involved emotion, that's going to give me a lot of things, it's going to focus me, it's going to energize me, it's gonna allow me to be brave, it's going to reduce the fear response, so that I can protect my child, you know that anger is really useful in the moment, but it's aimed at alleviating suffering. Now, if the person who you know, maybe, so maybe I stand up to that person, but once it starts getting personal, and I start, like getting angry at people, and kind of dehumanizing them, or harming them in some way that it's no longer helpful, but it has a role, it can be harnessed, we need to harness it for the alleviation of suffering. But if we just cut it out, if we suppress it, if we say we don't have it, well, that disempowers us because anger is, is an important source of power, when it's harnessed and channeled correctly. And actually easier said than done, I still struggle. But it is something we don't want to reject. We want to embrace,

    KC Davis 33:45

    I can imagine that if you're caught up in a self esteem sort of rat race where you have to be above others, anger becomes your weapon to push others down to push others away, to tear them down, because that's the only way that you can feel good. But if you've been practicing self compassion, I imagine it's a lot easier to let anger be your advocate, instead of you know, harming people.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 34:06

    Yeah, well, also, when you accept this part of yourself, you know, there's nothing wrong with this part of yourself. In fact, it's very useful. Again, this is the button it is a big butt because what happens we're angry is we just forget I mean, carried away. So it is challenging, right to work with, I'm not going to pretend it's not I struggle, but it definitely has a role, especially when it comes to standing up to injustice. Because what happens as we can see the tender and the fierce need to be imbalanced for two fears of a really angry, we have no tender acceptance of ourselves or others, then that's not good. But if we're too accepting, and we, you know, is no fierceness, then that's not good for ourselves for others, right. So it's really the balance. It's much, you know, will fall off balance. We try to reintegrate and it's a process. It's not like an end point we get to finally, that's really great.

    KC Davis 34:55

    Well, I really appreciate the time that you've taken. It's this is a topic that is something that we could talk about for hours. But if people wanted to know more about self compassion, where could they go to read your books and learn more from you?

    Dr. Kristin Neff 35:08

    Well, easiest place to start is if you Google self compassion, you'll find my website self compassion.org. You can take a self compassion test, you can read research hundreds of articles on there by a lots of different researchers. There's a guided practice, I've got videos, things you can read. And then you can also links to order by books. I've got four at this point. So and some of them are practice based, some of them are more just kind of talking about my own journey with self compassion.

    KC Davis 35:34

    Awesome. Well, thank you so much, and I appreciate every bit of it.

    Dr. Kristin Neff 35:39

    Thank You will KC It was fun talking to you

Christy Haussler
41: Breaking Free from Self-Improvement with Frankie Simmons

I’m so excited to have my first in-person guest on the podcast! Frankie Simmons is here, and she’s literally sitting right next to me. I love Frankie’s TikTok content, and I resonate with so  much of what she says. I feel like she is a younger version of me, as we have similar backgrounds and healing journeys. I hope you will join us for this conversation!

Show Highlights:

  • Get to know Frankie and our thoughts on being fellow Texans

  • How Frankie exited her background in Christianity and fear and began to explore the world

  • Why Frankie does TikToks about her functional responses to trauma and finding self-trust

  • The journey from fear and insecurity into feeling worthy and accepted

  • How Frankie experienced a mind-blowing shift in her approach to life

  • Why Frankie has chosen to be sober–and how that has changed her life and relationships

  • Frankie’s journey to understand herself as a confident introvert

  • How we can experience a different version of life when we accept ALL of ourselves

  • What things are like in Frankie’s relationship with love and acceptance

  • How it harms us to be taught that we should feel guilty if life is “easy” and not a constant struggle

  • How Frankie and KC describe their current relationship with Christianity, faith, and spirituality

Resources and Links:

Connect with Frankie Simmons: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to Struggle Care. This is your host, Casey Davis. And I am so excited to bring you my first ever in Person guest Frankie Simmons,

    Frankie Simmons 0:18

    That's me

    KC Davis 0:19

    Sitting literally right next to me. Okay, so Frankie, the reason that I asked you to come and do an in person podcast with me is because first of all, I love your material. And I feel like I really resonate with a lot of the things that you say. And and I mean this in like, the least patronizing way, I almost feel like you're like a younger me.

    Frankie Simmons 0:39

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 0:40

    And not in the sense that like, oh, I learned those sorts of things years ago, but like, I feel like you are at the same place as I am in terms of our like, general healing journeys. You're just younger than me.

    Frankie Simmons 0:52

    Wow. Honored to hear that. Cool. Thank you.

    KC Davis 0:54

    And so I truly did not even have like a pre conversation with you before we literally you walked in the door, and I was like, here are headphones. And I don't even really have like a full agenda. I just wanted to kind of ask you about yourself. Because I knew that if I did that on the phone, that we ended up having a really great conversation, and I would kick myself and I'm recording it. So do I understand correctly that you're an expand Jellicle? Okay, so I think that that is one of the first things that I really related to you about because I am so I got sober when I was like 16. So I ended up in rehab. And it was like a 12 step rehab, that very much pushed like spirituality, not any necessarily any religion specifically. But they definitely said like, if you cannot figure out a way to have a relationship with a God of your own understanding, like you are not going to stay sober. And that was scary, because I didn't believe in anything. And I started to like, wake up every morning before everybody else. And I would go outside, and this was in like a cow pasture in Oklahoma. This is where this place was. And I would sit on a bench and I would like watch the sun rise. And I would literally pray to a god I did not think existed, and sort of eventually sort of felt as though okay, like, there's something happening here. And then I got out of that rehab after like 18 and a half months, but it was so heavy on behavioral modification that I was terrified to trust myself. I really believed like if I thought something, I had to run it by like a panel of people. And I had to do exactly, I had to have all of these like accountability. And I had to look at every single thing I was doing and make sure I wasn't being selfish.

    Frankie Simmons 2:41

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 2:41

    Right, like, really be insightful. And I feel like the majority of people that talk about like a mental health journey or a healing journey, almost experience like the opposite, where it's like, they go from a place of not being aware to a place of self awareness, and understanding like their own motives and understanding why they do the things they do and learning how to be introspective. And to not just blame others, but to kind of see where they're participating and maybe things in their life that aren't going the way they want. So I feel like that's the majority of the people that I know when they talk about the journey. And I think that's what attracted me to your content was because I feel like and maybe I'm wrong, but I feel like you would agree with me that I it was like the opposite though. Like I started out hyper introspective. Yeah, very much like, what are my motives? Do I have pure motives? Am I being altruistic enough? Am I being humble enough? Like just constantly navel gazing? Because first it was sobriety, like I truly believed that if I wasn't, quote, unquote, spiritually fit, that I would start using drugs again, and then I would die. And then I ended up converting to Christianity when I was like, 19. And there were some things about that church that I really appreciated that I think really helped me in terms of this idea of God as like, not this like judgmental policeman in the sky. But I still ended up with this sense of like, I have to hyper analyze every move. Yeah, every decision, every emotion. And I had this as a sponsor that kind of went into this. So like, let me just give one example. I remember calling my sponsor one time, because I felt so guilty. And I truly believe that like, if I didn't like say it out loud, and kind of like a tone for it, that it would cause me to go use drugs or it would cause me to like be cut off from God or whatever. And I called her and I was like, I just need to confess like, I have a theater degree. I went to u and T. And I had this class called movement class, where you would learn like, you know, like, how to play, let not play like stage fight or these sort of things. And we had this one class about like leaps and jumps. So think like, you know, Nobody puts baby in a corner. Right?

    Frankie Simmons 5:01

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 5:02

    And so that's what we did. And there was like this really cute guy in my class. And I was like, oh, I want to be partner with him. And then I was. And later that day, I was talking to my boyfriend at the time. And he was like, what would you do today, and I told him about this class. I was like, and we were leaping and jumping, it was cool. And I got to like, run, and this guy would like, put me in the air. And I had this like, sudden flash of a thought, which was like, I wonder if he that makes him jealous, because that would be nice. Because it feels good when someone's jealous about you. But after the conversation, I was like, wrecked with this guilt of like, I was trying to incite jealousy. And I call and this woman who was like, my spiritual mentor at the time, reamed me on like, if you can't not think about yourself, like, you are not going to be in this relationship anymore. Like, if you continue to harm other people, like then you are not ready for a relationship. And just this idea that like I needed to be spiritually fit enough to deserve to be in a relationship. So I know, that's like a really long story, but all that to say, that's where I began.

    Frankie Simmons 6:09

    Yeah, no, I feel that so much of just like, actually, the issue is not that I don't understand what's happening. It's that I'm like, making too much meaning out of the things that's happening. And I think that's so interesting that like, because for me, it was I grew up in Christianity, it was like, just everything I am was like, shaped through that. And it's interesting to think about, like coming into it later in life, but at like such a vulnerable place where you're like, my whole world just fell apart. And now I need to rebuild it. Like it almost has that similarity of like,

    KC Davis 6:36

    Yeah, totally.

    Frankie Simmons 6:36

    I'm curious how that feels like

    KC Davis 6:38

    Well, yeah, cuz I think as a child, it's like, you have nothing. And so your entire life is built on the foundation of like, this is how you understand the world. And I do think it was very similar, because it was like a world ending event to go to rehab.

    Frankie Simmons 6:53

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 6:54

    And then there's this fear of like, I don't ever want to be that person again. I'll ever want to be in that kind of pain.

    Frankie Simmons 7:00

    Yeah, no, that makes sense. And it is like that fear, like, I'll do anything like, I'll believe whatever I need to believe to, like, not go back to that place where it's like, the way that I grew up. It's just like, the fear of hell is like, so baked into your bones that it's like, it literally doesn't matter what you asked me to do, if like, I don't have to go to that place, then like, cool, I'm on board. But yeah, and that fear, just like constantly keeping you from actually getting to have like, even like an authentic thought process where you just like, go on a decision making journey and approach anything with curiosity, because there's like this end goal that you always have. So you just don't get to like, even just explore or expand or ever, like, grow beyond that point. Because it's like, constantly, it just will follow you forever if you let it.

    KC Davis 7:43

    I remember this like guy that came to the church one time I was talking about, like, his spiritual gifts and how he could hear a God and he would talk about like, walking into his closet in the morning and being like, God, what should I wear today? And then like, choosing what to wear to I mean, like, that's how intense it felt like it was

    Frankie Simmons 7:59

    yeah, no, I remember people being like, if you lose your watch, and you try to find your watch without asking God, where your watches that is you acting out of your own wisdom and like not giving your life over to God. It's just like, there's not a single thought that is free from like, this could be a sin. And this could be like you your nature, like coming in to destroy everything.

    KC Davis 8:20

    Yeah. So how did you exit that?

    Frankie Simmons 8:23

    It really started with I think, like shifting my politics, I went off to college. And immediately I remember very specifically, I was on Tumblr, and in like 2013, and post popped up on Tumblr that said, I don't exactly remember exactly what was going on. So this might not be exactly but it was like every House Republican just voted against, like equal pay for women. If you're a woman, why are you a Republican? And I was like, I'm not anymore. Cool. Like, it was just because I just been so like, brainwashed that the moment I got exposed to something else, I was like, Oh, this makes so much more sense, like, so I was shifting, like, politically, like over that time, which to me was like, not at all there was like, no conflict between that and my faith. Because I was like, Yeah, this is what Jesus wanted, obviously. But I kind of like then got to the point where I was like, and I think maybe gay people should be allowed to do whatever they want and be whoever they want. And that was the point where it was like, Oh, I can't actually continue to pursue that and stay in community with the people that I'm in community with right now. And I remember like, just sitting in my bed and being like, if God is who I've always been told he is, and he's not actually afraid of my question, I was realizing that like, I've never actually allowed myself to ask the open ended questions because growing up in the church, there's this like, yeah, you're gonna have doubts, ask the questions, like five steps in of like, I know that this is true. And I know that this is true. And I know God loves this. And I know God hates this. I'm having an issue with this one part of that, can you help me not have an issue with it anymore? Like, it's you're always assuming that like, the end of the doubt is not having it anymore. There's never like a question that could lead you in a different direction. And so I was like, I have to just let myself actually Approach a question with a willingness to have my mind changed, or else I'm never going to actually know. And so I just like started exploring, just like, what does the Bible actually say about all of these questions that I had. And so it was really that first that like, started to crack things. And then I think just from there, like realizing how much of a lack of love there was in the way that I had been taught to relate to myself and to relate to the world and being in a place where I'm told that like, God is love. Meanwhile, you're standing on this foundation that is like just fear, like, more than anything else. And it's like a version of love that is all filtered through fear. And, yeah, it was just like, oh, I don't think this actually makes sense to me anymore. And so it was really just that that, like, stepped me out of it. And then, but from there, I was like, in the midst of it also going on a lot of like, opening the doors to my own, like mental health journey. I was like, in this place where I was like, really navigating everything. And I started to watch myself go to these other spaces of like, trying to practice like my therapy homework, or trying to engage with other forms of spirituality and watching myself have a very like, fundamentalist framework and how I practice those things like continuing to come to everything, like I am broken. And if I journaled for three hours every day, maybe I will be less broken. And having just like, so much black and white thinking and everything, and I just started realizing, like, okay, it's not actually enough, I actually need to take steps for the church to leave me because this whole way of like relating to myself and relating to the world is like, the only pathway my brain knows how to follow. And I just need better pathways. Because this one like is not, I just keep running into more walls. And I think that was like a big thing to like, take this conscious step of like, I don't want the foundation of my whole world to be that I'm a terrible person anymore. And that I need to take all these steps to try to be less terrible. Like, I would like to move from a space of like, what if I'm good, actually, maybe I'm just kind of started to run this experiment of like, what if I started treating myself like I actually was trustworthy, just to see what happens and to see if everything falls apart the way that I was always told that it could be. And it kind of changed everything. So

    KC Davis 12:11

    that was so profound. When you said, it wasn't enough for me to leave the church, I had to take steps for the church to leave me. And I do really resonate with a lot of what you say, especially when you talk about like, the fear of hell, like I didn't necessarily have the fear of hell, but I had like, it was like hell on earth. You know what I mean? Yeah, you have this tech talk recently, that really spoke to me where you talked about how you don't believe that there are parts of you that are, like, inherently bad, that need to let go sit in a corner and hate themselves? And will you talk about that for a second? Because that very much spoke to some of my experience? And like where I am today?

    Frankie Simmons 12:51

    Yeah, I think that was something that I feel like found me as I was just like, basically learning about the nervous system, and how like, your body responds to trauma, because I suddenly started to see all of these parts of myself that I just like, hated and thought were so annoying, as like, Oh, these are actually very functional responses to like, the way that I was taught to view the world and through the situations that I was put into. And I think it really helped me think about like, what if I just got to sit down and have like conversations with those parts of myself and be like, What are you like looking for right now? And what do you need, and starting to move from, like, a default assumption of self trust. And I think sometimes when we hear about self trust, like, I remember one time, a mentor of mine looked at me and said, however you are feeling in this moment is the correct way for you to feel. And I was like, no, like, I feel selfish. Sometimes I get like, jealous of other people. I get like mad. And there's like, all these parts of myself like that are obviously not correct. And being able to see like, okay, yeah, not like however I feel it's however, I get to act and like, that's the correct way for me to act. But like, however I am feeling is an understandable way for me to feel. And it's a feeling that I need to have to be able to like stay in relationship with myself. And that was so helpful to be able to, like hold with tension, because I think a lot of times we hear people talking about like self trust, and we hear, Oh, I just get to go do whatever I want now. And obviously we know that that doesn't work out. And that isn't kind to other people. But being able to be like No, any part of me deserves a conversation with me. So yeah, I don't believe that there's any part of me that was created to just be told to go sit down and shut up and never be heard from again. But I also don't believe that there was any one part of me that was designed to be like, put in the driver's seat of my life and call all the shots with no authority. And I really try to relate to myself as I just have a really wide board of advisors and I get to like go sit down at the table with all these different things and be like, What are you asking me for? And how can I create something that is a loving ecosystem for like all the different parts of me, which is just so much slower and requires so much more intention than doing what I was doing before which is just like reading Acting out of like whatever trauma or like also reacting in like distrust of myself, which was also this like gut assumption that would just like always take me in one direction. So just being allowed to stay in conversation with myself and move from the assumption that there's like something here that I get to here was very just a big game changer for me

    KC Davis 15:24

    it reminds me of, you know, I talk a lot about like self care and caring for yourself in the moment, and people started to ask like, well, but if I care for myself, right now, I'm gonna fuck myself over later, right? Like caring for myself now is not doing my dishes, but then I don't have dishes. And it reminds me of this concept of, I had to learn to see like the three versions of myself like past me, present me and future me, and to learn how to dance with all three of them, and try to take care of all three of them. Right? Yes, sometimes I want something pleasurable in this moment. But I also want to take care of future me. Yeah. And so like, I try to shepherd my present self, like in a loving direction towards the kinds of pleasure that don't harm future me. Right. And also, though, recognizing that sometimes I want to react from my past self and all those traumas and all those hurts and, and like what would feel good in that moment to that little girl? And recognizing that, like, sometimes she gets to do that? Yeah, like, it's not inherently bad to react out of that space, as long as I'm not hurting other people. And I'm still taking care of present me and future me. And that's reminds me of that same concept, right? Where it's like, but you're doing it lovingly. And I think that what happened to me and I think what happens to a lot of people on a self improvement journey, whether it's religion, or sobriety, or mental health, or wellness or therapy journey, like I got to this place where my worthiness and my ability to feel as though I was worthy of love was contingent on doing good. And I don't mean doing good acts. I mean, like making therapeutic progress. Yeah, I had this binary, where it's like, I'm either doing good, or I'm doing bad. Yeah. And if I was in a really bad place, it was like, Well, I'm doing bad right now. Like, I'm not making good choices. I'm feeling really distressing feelings, like I'm not feeling at peace. And then if I was doing the things I was supposed to write, if I was meditating every morning, and I was going to help people once a week, and I was always being honest, and I was never being selfish. And I was always being humble, like, then I was doing good. And the whole journey of self improvement was just hijacked by this belief that I was going to self improve into a state of being worthy of being loved. And for that reason, I for seven years, I meditated every single morning. And when I stopped doing that, I experienced so much more real growth. Yeah. And so like, I feel like in some ways, I'm like living in the upside down when it comes to my own healing.

    Frankie Simmons 18:22

    Yeah, no, I feel exactly the same way. Like, I looked back at the version of myself that made her bed every single morning and worked out all the time. And like had, you know, did like all the routines and everything. And I was like, That person was so scared. And like, so unhealthy, like the version of myself that seemed to have it the most together was actually running so far away from herself. And I think, yeah, for me, like just allowing myself to watch like, the bachelor religiously, and just being like, Yes, this is like a toxic cesspool of a show. And that's okay. Like, I'm allowed to not and always take the high road and every single choice that I ever make constantly,

    KC Davis 18:59

    Yes, I can just fucking rest. Not every single move every single thought every single like, yeah, that just really hit me because that is so true. And it's hard, I think, to talk in like public arena about that journey. Because like, there are people and and that was me, at one point, it is important to look at like, what kind of entertainment and what like, does it have effect on my mind? And is that helping me? Is that functional for me? Or, you know, am I dressing from a place of freedom and pleasure? Or am I dressing from a place of fear and insecurity? Like, I'm not saying that there's not value to those things? Because I think sometimes when I talk about these things in my journey, it almost sounds like I'm telling people like, do whatever, yeah, fine. Like don't try to figure out your motives on anything. And I'm not saying that, obviously. But I am saying that like, when you come from that place where you just like, feel like you aren't even worthy. You just can't be Be okay with not being okay.

    Frankie Simmons 20:02

    Not treating yourself like a project that has to move forward every single day or else why are you even here like having inherent worth to your existence that is just worth, like experiencing and enjoy, even if it's not going anywhere is like for me, it was just like such a mind blowing shift in how I approached my life at all. Because, yeah, there was just this constant journeying to an end point that needed to always be happening, or else, there was no point for me to be here and being able to settle into like, actually, I deserve to be here like point blank, like, I could not do anything for the rest of my life. And I still would like have inherent value that just like flipped my world on its head,

    KC Davis 20:38

    Not feeling like everything you did was either like moving up the mountain, or like slipping back.

    Frankie Simmons 20:43

    Yeah,

    KC Davis 20:43

    You know, like, there was this linear space that you always existed in and you're either moving forward and doing good, or you were like slipping back into your old ways.

    Frankie Simmons 20:53

    On the good place where like they every single action or thought you ever taken has like a either a red or a green number next to it. That was like my whole life.

    KC Davis 21:02

    Totally. And, you know, you mentioned like, doing the things that you're supposed to make you feel good versus do make you feel good. And I feel like there was this place of it feels good to do all of those things. Because it feels good to be a person that I know would be accepted by the community and the culture that I've chosen. Yeah. Like, there is pleasure in that. Yeah. But that's really different than guy call that like third person pleasure, which is like I'm outside of my so I'm enjoying watching myself, right? Yeah. Like I'm outside of myself and looking at myself and going like, Yes, I approve. Yeah, but here's the thing that is no different than how I was operating when I was using drugs. I just had a different place. Like when I was using idolized, like every tragic drug addict character, right, like Kurt Cobain, and, and really Bradley Knoll, and all these people and and they were miserable. And they did not meet good ends. But I wanted to be them. Because when I looked at them, I felt like people thought they were cool. And they were worthy. And they were deep, but they were artistic. And there was just something so inherently beautiful about them. And so interesting about them. And so like I did everything that I could, because I didn't feel worthy enough to be good. I thought I'll just work really hard to be worthy enough at being bad and tragic. And I think that there was this part of me that believed that I wasn't worthy of love, and I wasn't going to get love. But being saved could feel close enough. That if I could be tragic enough, if I could be broken enough that somebody would want to save me, and that would feel close enough to love that I would feel like I could breathe. And so everything was this third person pleasure where it's like, okay, I'm on the outside looking and going, okay, that thing I did, that's cool enough, that thing I did, that's beautiful enough, that thing I did that, you know, and I was very much sort of like a hippie when I was using like, I was definitely like selfish and arrogant and immature. But I still was very much like, let's all love each other, like, you know, let's go to a field and spin around barefoot. Like, I was still very much like yearning for this connection to something bigger and greater and beautiful. And so I just but it was that same thing. And I think recognizing that here. I was like, seven years sober. And I was still just as preoccupied with myself as I was when I was using drugs. Yeah, I was still just as preoccupied with this, like third person, reflection of myself and being good enough for the culture that I chose. It was the exact same thing. It was just a different culture, a different set of rules, a different set of people, a different community, trying to be good enough for that community so that I could feel okay. But when I started kind of the journey that you and I are talking about was the first time like when I let go of that perfectionism of like, it's okay to not always try and self improve. For the first time in my life. I didn't think about myself so much. And then I knew what real freedom was. For the first time in my life, I was experiencing my life in the first person. You know what I mean? Where you could like, look at birds and be like, that makes me really happy. Yeah. And you could do small simple things and be like, that makes me happy and listen to any music that actually makes you happy no matter how like stupid that music is.

    Frankie Simmons 24:36

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 24:37

    And it doesn't have to be rated on a scale of righteousness or a scale of healthiness or a scale of whatever. But yeah, I just think that it's hard to put that into words.

    Frankie Simmons 24:50

    Totally. What did that shift like? Feel like to the first person pleasure if you can think of like the first time that you experienced that like was there any like tan double shift or

    KC Davis 25:01

    I think it was slow. Like, when I was dating my husband, he very much had a huge influence on that shift for me because like, he is someone who, you know, when we met, like, I was very, like devout, and he was just as devout. But without all of the perfectionism, because what had happened was that I had gone through that really intense rehab. And then I went to church. And like, I got the whole package of like, all of the rules and regulations that went along with this like book of the Bible. Whereas my husband, he read everything in the house until there was nothing left to read. And then he read the Bible. And he describes his experience as literally reading the Bible and going Fuck, I believe this, like no control over the act of faith in that moment. Yeah. But because that was his first like, he did not grow up that way. So then if he reads that he connects with it, then he walks into church and goes, What the hell is this? Like nothing about what he was seeing matched what he was reading? You know what I mean? So he never had that, like, oh, I need to analyze every thought, Yeah, he definitely grew up and became mature and takes accountability and cares about people and, and like, is a wonderful WW, I think, really healthy person. But I think primarily, like, exists in that like, first person, space. And so I think it was slow. Because what so anyways, the point is, when I met him, I was still in that space. And so I was constantly going through this, like, do I like him too much? Yeah, because I'm not supposed to like him too much, because then I'll get attached. And I won't be able to see clearly whether it's right, whether it's the one that God has for me, or whether it's healthy enough, because like, I had just really been taught to believe that my base desires were dangerous. Yeah, because they were going to cloud, either my own judgment or what was healthy or the will of God, like you could put any of those things in that fill in the blank, right? And so like, I was wracked with conflict the whole time, because I really loved him. And I really wanted to be with him. And I was afraid that I loved him too much. And I wasn't allowed to love someone too much. And that if I loved him too much, he would be taken away, or that like, I would do something wrong. Yeah. So that it was sucked. And then we got married, and I kind of calmed down slightly. Okay. Nobody can take him away now. And I think it was just like this slow movement for me. And people ask me all the time, how did I come to a place where I talk about like care tasks being morally neutral? And the truth is, is like it was this? Like, it had nothing to do with actual care tasks. It was just this journey to a place of like, all of these things that I had moralized Yeah. And then being like, well, maybe it doesn't actually matter. Like, what if things just like didn't matter that much? Yeah. So yeah, I think it was just like, such a slow movement. And, and like, I also haven't been to church in a really long time. And I think that's been really helpful. Yeah, for not like getting into that space. And I'll occasionally go and experience it as, like a beautiful moment. But it's been really helpful to like, step away and just exist. And to to approach it from that perspective. Yeah. So you are in a relationship right now? And is that relationship like how is that fitting into sort of like your journey of like, non pressure healing and growth?

    Frankie Simmons 28:34

    Yeah, I think I thought of it when you were describing how like your husband like just watching the way that he related to, like, his spirituality and stuff was like shifted things for you. Similarly, in my fiance is like, very grew up secular doesn't have any of like that programming. And I distinctly remember one time where like, we were on a camping trip with their family. And we were like, reaching the evening, and Ian just like, pulled out this little like Bluetooth speaker and turn it on to a song that they liked, and put it next to them and just like sat down in a chair and just was like, This is what I'm doing right now. I'm sitting in this chair, and I'm listening to music and me being like, that's just nothing I would ever allow myself to do. I remember when the pandemic started and their job, like furloughed them, and they were like, Okay, I'm gonna go home, and I'm going to watch Star Wars for the next month, like, I'm going to watch every Star Wars thing that has ever existed. And I would sit in the living room and watch Star Wars all day, and I would be in the bedroom being like, maybe I need to break up with this person, because why are they not focused on caring for themselves and learning new things? And like, you know, maybe we have fundamental differences. And then two weeks later, being like, actually, they're having fun, and I'm not so like, who's actually winning in this situation? And so it's been very interesting to watch them just like approach their life with so much more like moral neutrality. And so they are somebody who just gives themselves permission to really be where they're at and very rarely do they question like, even stuff about our relationship that like we have I have a very unique style of like, how we run our home and how we handle our finances and all of that stuff. And I'm constantly like, there's a part of my brain that's constantly in the like, what if we're doing this wrong? And like, what if the fact that this looks different than other people's relationships means we're actually in a terrible relationship, and we just don't realize it yet. And Ian's, like, No, this is just working for us. Like there's nothing in them that questions things that they enjoy. And that's been very wild to live around for, like the past four years. And I think so much of my healing has come down to just them, I would get up at 10am. And they'd be like, I'm so proud of you for getting up at 10am. And that was just like, wildly healing for me to just have somebody that was like, you're enjoying yourself. And that's fine and could like, get in the middle of those thoughts, spirals, and just make space for me to like, exist. So.

    KC Davis 30:53

    I think also, for me, the like you mentioned being tender hearted. And I think that this like season for me, and however long I've been in it is very much marked by the idea of being tender to myself, and not from like a pity. Place of like, you know what, you screwed up, you failed, but that's okay. But from a place of like, I get to give myself tenderness for the sole reason that tenderness is lovely to experience. Yeah, not because I deserve it, not because it's good for me not because it's healthy, not because it's going to encourage me to be better or anything. Just that, like you can truly just decide,

    Frankie Simmons 31:40

    Yeah, like just I'm going to be on my own side. Because I deserve to have somebody on my side all the time, which I think it's interesting how like, for myself, I've noticed that when I get to that space of like, I don't actually have to be moving towards anything, I don't actually have to be like, I just get to be accepting of myself. Because that is an experience that is good for me to have, how much healing that actually creates, like how it actually moves me a lot of times towards the things that I was trying so hard to get towards. It's always interesting whenever I make tic TOCs, I have this series where I'm just just like, list off a bunch of things and be like, Oh, that makes sense. Like, it makes sense that you're feeling this way or whatever. And like that's the whole thing is just like saying, this makes sense that you're in this space. And every single time there are people in the comments being like, Okay, so now what, like, okay, I get it makes sense. But now what do I do? And every time I'm like, if that's the question that you're asking, then you have not yet given yourself space, you don't actually get that it makes sense if you're because when we are in full acceptance of something, we're usually not like, offended by its presence. Like when we actually are in complete understanding that something makes sense. We're usually not like in complete urgency to get it to stop existing. And so being able to be in a space of like, just allowing myself to stay with that. I think we really underestimate the healing power of just like validation, and just being an acceptance of ourselves. And like what just that can do all by itself.

    KC Davis 32:55

    It reminds me a little bit of like, those horribly awful like church things, the way people would say, like, God won't give you a relationship until you're okay, on your own and you want a relationship. And so you would find, I don't know about you, but like, I would find myself being like, how do I make myself not want a relationship so that I'll get the relationship I want? Yeah, right. Or, like, how do I get myself to not feel this one way in order to control this other thing that I want? Yeah. And just like the freedom of realizing that like, either there is a God, and he just gives things to people because, or there's not a god, and you can just have things because, like, there really isn't like a bait and switch. Yeah, of like, you have to make yourself happy on your own. Yeah, before you can be in a relationship. Let me tell you like, I was created for companionship, like, I never felt 100% Okay. Yeah. When I was alone, and that wasn't like a fault. Yeah, that wasn't like, oh, you you know have to have others validation or like, you're not healthy enough on your own or complete enough on your own? Like, could I live a happy and fulfilling life? If I didn't have a partner or family? Like, yeah, I could. But that would never not be something that my soul crave. Yeah. And even that, in and of itself was like, such a huge place of being like, oh, there's nothing like immature about me. Or like, I'm not unhealthy. I don't know. Like, there's nothing like unenlightened about. Yeah, like there's some plane of existence. I could be at where I stopped being like a social creature. And I mean, not everybody necessarily wants a monogamous relationship or children or to live with someone but like, we all need the kind of connection that like we need. Yeah. And it's just so It's such a stupid myth that you don't deserve those connections unless you can get to a place where you don't want those connections. Yeah. Or need those connections.

    Frankie Simmons 35:09

    Yeah. And that I think there's a lot of ways where, like, you know, I think it's interesting that the word like needy is used as an insult when it's like I'm a living being, which means that I just like have needs and like, I'm a human, which means I also have emotional needs as well as physical needs. Like that's just a fact of my existence. But the fact that we are so often punished and being like, told that you're supposed to heal out of like, having needs is just creates a lot of chaos.

    KC Davis 35:35

    Do you have anything that you want to talk about?

    Frankie Simmons 35:37

    One thing that I really appreciate about your content is, I don't think you talk about it as much anymore. But to my understanding, you're still a Christian. Yes. And I really appreciate that. Because I think I would no longer identify as a Christian, but I also love faith and love spirituality. And I feel like every time I talk about, it's kind of similar, when I talk about being a Texan online, I have to like, prepare myself to defend Texas, against all these other people. And there's a similar thing, like whenever I talk about, like, my religious deconstruction, I have to prepare for like all these people that are going to come into the comments and be like, yeah, all religion is terrible and evil and needs to go away. I'm just curious, like how that felt to you to like, go through this journey, and come into like, an authentic definition of your own faith.

    KC Davis 36:22

    Yeah, I think that it helps that I didn't grow up in church. So like, I very much I was anti religion for a long time. And so I understand, like, where that comes from. And I think it's valid. And you know, at the end of the day, my experience with my faith was an experience that can't be challenged. Like theology can be challenged, and like, what you believe about the way the world works can be challenged, and what's right and wrong can be challenged, and dogma can be challenged, and tradition can be challenged. And like I very much am someone who like went through a deconstruction process, but retained my faith almost exclusively, like everything else kind of fell out. But because what remained was like being 16, and broken and sitting on a bench staring at a cow pasture, begging for there to be something in the world, more than me, that could be personal, like not just like spirit of the universe, because like I needed something a little more than that. Yeah. And there's this feeling as if there was like this presence that would come and sit next to me and be quiet. Like that was what really took me back was like, I'd always sort of seen this idea of God as like someone who would have a lot to say to you, yeah, about what you do, right, and what you do wrong, and all the things you need to know. And to have this experience, like in my worst moments, where it just felt like there was this presence that sat next to me and looked at the same place as me was so real. And it happened really slowly over time. And I don't think that there's just anything that could ever be done or said that would change the fact that that happened to me. Yeah, you know what I mean? And there are some aspects of Christian doctrine that I think just resonate with me deeply from my own experience. Like, I don't think that I'm inherently bad. But I certainly identify with being like, inherently imperfect, and for a long time, even, like, inherently broken and inherently find certain things about life difficult. And I find a lot of comfort in a theology that basically says, like, there's a God, that's not surprised by that. Yeah, who wasn't expecting anything different? Yeah. That the only person surprised by your own sort of mistakes, or fumbles or downfalls or whatever is you like, you know, and so, yeah, I think that because so much of that was just like, deeply personal, that theology around that can change and dogma around that can change and all that kind of stuff. And it just doesn't bother me, because that'll always have been my experience. I also think that the trauma that people have experienced at the hands of religion is really real. Yeah. And I think the other part of it, though, is like because my experience was this like, very personal, real visceral, like experiential thing. And because I do like, believe there is a God, I don't have this fear that I feel like a lot of religious people seem to have where it's like, the world is spinning out and we need to correct it. I don't know. I just don't really think God needs our help. Yeah, you know what I mean? Like, what are we worried about? If like, we think that There's like a loving creator of the world that loves us and is going to take care of us in ways that we don't understand, either now or later, or whatever. So I don't know, I think it's all valid. I think that there was a time when I felt all those same things. And I feel like my encounter with God was him being like, it's okay to feel those things. So like, who am I to have any thought differently about somebody else's feelings about those than how I thought God felt about it with me? You know what I mean? Like, I don't know,

    Frankie Simmons 40:30

    No, love all of that. And I think it is, like, definitely so valid for people to have like, their experiences and their hurt and to like, have really complicated feelings about religion as a whole. Because of that, I think there's a space where like, I know, I felt in myself, there's a different, it's again, going back to the way that that fundamentalism, like rewires your brain to view things that way, even when you step out of that specific religious practice. And I think there's a way where sometimes I hear people talk about like, when humanity ascends. And if everybody was like, as smart and intelligent as we could be, like, everybody would believe the way that I believe, which is that there is nothing and we would have no organized religion. To me, it feels very similar in some ways to the like, evangelical way of like, viewing the world where like, I need to convince everybody else to get on board with my version of things. And I think giving people space to like, have their own experiences, whatever those are, until, like, be with what is like really true for them. And know that it doesn't have to be like in contradiction or in conflict with like, what your experience and your truth is, is just a really beautiful place to land.

    KC Davis 41:35

    Yeah, I think that when you have like, when everything is kind of like a house of cards, almost, you know what I mean? Where it's like, it wasn't really based on like an experience, it wasn't based on a searching, you know what I mean? Like, there was no process of like, I searched for something, and I found something. And that thing was valuable to me. And then from there, I sort of began to learn some theology and walk through that. And then, you know, deconstructed from a lot of that theology. And ironically enough, like going to seminary was probably the biggest part of that deconstruction was learning like, oh, the majority of people talking about what the Bible says or don't know what they're talking about. So I think that I could definitely see how, you know, if I had that experience, that if the uniquely in that way, feeling a lot of fear about somebody challenging some part of my belief, because it would feel as though like that one little piece of like, thread that you pulled on it too hard, might like, unravel the whole tapestry. And I think that I just kind of came to a place where I was, like, I'm gonna pull on the thread. Because if it's real, like, whatever I come out on the other end with will be sufficient, I guess, like, I don't even know if like real is the right word, because I think that somebody who pulled the tapestry and came out in a different place than me, like, maybe not being a person of faith anymore. Like, I don't want to say that that was not real for them. But I think that, like, whatever you have, and whatever you need, like, you're gonna still have it at the end. Like, I just think that not having fear, when you pull that tapestry, because like, either there is something that is real there for you. And there's no amount of pulling on the doubts and the questions that's gonna make that real thing disappear. Or there is something real out there that you have yet to encounter, whether that is some sort of faith, or that is just sort of like your experience with your own truth and life and something that makes your life worth living like, and better to pull all those strings so that whatever this sort of facade that was there can kind of go away, and you can move forward and find what resonates deeply with your soul. Because I think it's at the end of like all of it. I have seen people from different faiths than me and from no faith in a place where something deeply good and deeply sacred and deeply real, was speaking to their soul in a way that they could tell that that same thing has spoken to the souls of other people, for 1000s and 1000s of years, like says something very viscerally real. And I've never seen that and then thought, like, well, but that's not real. Like, I've always just thought, like, I recognize that that's what I feel, too. And that's enough for me, you know what I mean? Like, I don't really know what beyond that matters. Like I could certainly be wrong about a whole lot after that. Yeah, I just I've never seen someone of another faith, have a deeply religious experience and not felt like they were like tapping into the same source that I was, yeah. And so whether one of us is right, or one of us is wrong, or we're both right, or we're both wrong, or both, whatever. It just sort of seemed like who am I to say? Yeah, this has been so lovely. Yeah. And we you tell everybody like where they can find you and follow you and hear more deep thoughts.

    Frankie Simmons 44:58

    Yeah, so I am on tick tock at Hey Frankie Simmons and Instagram at Frankie Doodle Dandy. And I have a digital newsletter called letters from home that you can sign up for there. And it's a fun time.

    KC Davis 45:12

    Thank you so much for coming down here and taking a little road trip to sit and stare into my backyard and talk about life.

    Frankie Simmons 45:20

    Yeah, thank you for having me. It's been a joy.

    KC Davis 45:22

    Awesome as a reminder because I never ever do this. I do have a website called struggle. care.com I do have a book called How to keep house while drowning and if you don't follow me on Tik Tok or Instagram, you should do that. Domestic blisters on Tik Tok and struggle care on Instagram. And I guess if your grandma wants to follow me on Facebook, I'm struggling here on Facebook. So thank you guys. Take care of yourselves.

Christy Haussler
40: Anti-capitalist Financial Planning with River Nice

Our topic today is intriguing, so I can’t wait to learn more from my guest. I’m joined by River Nice (they/them), who was originally in a tech job they hated. After using their skill set to help their partner with debt from her gender transition, River found their calling: to help queer people with their money. Now, they run their own financial planning firm, Be Intentional Financial LLC (BIF), to serve their clients and community and help to dismantle oppression in all its forms. Join us to learn more!

Show Highlights:

  • Misconceptions people have about the term “anti-capitalist financial planner”

  • A look at the harmful and inaccurate mainstream financial advice in our world

  • Why we live in fear and worry about our financial survival in a capitalist society

  • A look at white privilege and how we can make the world a better place under oppressive systems

  • What “redistribution of wealth” looks like, practically speaking

  • How River helps clients with investing for long-term financial security

  • A charity giving model vs. creating an interdependent community

  • How River teaches financial emergency preparedness to clients

  • How anti-capitalist financial planning is a holistic view of life, money, values, and relationships

  • River’s advice about specific financial scenarios around debt management, living paycheck to paycheck, planning for the future, and accumulating wealth

Resources and Links:

Connect with River Nice: Website, Instagram, and TikTok

Check out River’s Website for FREE resources and a FREE 30-minute consultation!

Also mentioned: the Mint app and the Honeydue app for couples

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient balls of stardust, this is Struggle Care with your host, KC Davis, that's me, therapist, author of the book How to Keep House While Drowning. And this is the podcast where we talk about all sorts of things, mental health, self care, even though the word self care makes me want to vomit. And I have a really great guest today. So I want to introduce river to y'all, they are an anti capitalist financial planner. And when I heard that I was so fascinated. So River, will you just sort of introduce yourself and tell us a little bit about how you got to be an anti capitalist financial planner?

    River Nice 0:38

    Sure, and thanks for having me. So my name is ruber. Nice. My pronouns are they them, the I guess, if I tried to make it a short version of the story. I was working in tech and hated my job. But I know I'm a numbers guy, and I was actually a project manager, and Trump got elected. And I was like, I do not care about the work that I'm doing, there has to be a way that I can do work that uses my skill set and is more useful to especially the queer community. And my partner at that time had a lot of credit card debt from her gender transition. And anytime she tried to find help for it, you know, no financial adviser was going to help a broke trans woman with credit card debt. And the whole internet was like, well stop buying coffee. And she was like, that doesn't help. So I sat with her, and kind of intuitively and kind of with my project management skills just built out like a budget and a timeline and was like, here's what you need to do, here's what it's going to be over. And it was her idea. She was like, this is your calling, you have to help queer people with money.

    KC Davis 1:33

    I love that you mentioned the like, just never buy coffee again, because I had some questions for you. But then we may go out of order, because I have to tell you, like I came from the church world, which is like ruled by Dave Ramsey. And if you're listening in your home, Dave Ramsey is he's like this evangelical budget guy. And he is taken for like wide swaths of really like white America, I would say, as like, oh, the best way to like money manage, and I never like utilized him for anything. But it wasn't until I started kind of deconstructing that I started hearing, like financial planners and CPAs and people that were talking about, like how problematic Dave Ramsey was. And I feel like that is just so the hoarder, like, just if you could just stop eating avocado toast, you could afford a house. So let me ask you this. When I first heard the term, anti capitalist financial planner, my first thought was like, That seems like an oxymoron. And I'm sure I'm not the only one like, what would you say are some of the misconceptions people have when they hear the term anti capitalist financial planner?

    River Nice 2:43

    Yeah, and it's a tricky term, right? It is kind of an oxymoron, it is a very tricky spot to inhabit myself. But it is my shorthand to try to help the people who need me find me. So as far as misconceptions, you know, the capitalists all think that I'm either naive or like a liar. And then, you know, the leftist find me. And some misconceptions are that like, you know, I am trying to operate entirely outside of capitalism, which is not how I actually operate, or that I'm going to tell people that what they're doing is evil or immoral, which is not how I operate. So what I am actually trying to do is say, hey, capitalism is oppression, we agree on that. And I want to help you kind of intentionally live the best life that you can, according to your values, under late stage, patriarchal white supremacist capitalism, and we can get more into that with your questions. But does that help give a sense?

    KC Davis 3:41

    No, it really helps a lot. Because I think that, especially if you've been really exposed to like the shame based financial planning stuff, the don't drink coffee, if you just saved if you were just more responsible, I think a lot of times, I expect that I'm going to encounter that again, right? So I'm going to encounter, you want to get on a plane and go on a vacation when there are people starving, you are so selfish, right? And so there's, I feel like there's this fear of like, Oh, am I going to be told, I can't save up for a house? Or am I going to do what I can't save up for a bigger house? Or am I going to be told that I need to give everything away? Or am I gonna be told? And I think that's a really, first of all, I think that's just interesting information for me that like, that's the fear that comes up. But I also think it's interesting that like, the financial world, unless you're already wealthy is so sewn with, like fear mongering and shame. That's almost like, I didn't even realize that that's what I would expect with like, what's going to be the same shame just with a different, like political ideology. And so I think that's a really helpful clarification, actually. So we kind of touched on this when I wanted to talk about like some of the harmful and inaccurate mainstream financial messages out there, because I think a lot of us have internalized those. And I think a lot of people listening may not even recognize that like, Oh, that's not the only way to survive, or that's not the only way to get out of debt or that's not the only way to like have a life worth living. So I'm curious what other ones you can share with us besides the like stop drinking coffees.

    River Nice 5:10

    I mean, something that I like to say to everyone is that, like, we live in a world where money is necessary for every aspect of survival. Like if you need money for shelter, food, water, health care, and also connection to other humans, and the ability to connect with other humans, like, of course, we're all going to be in fight or flight or freeze or fawn mode about money, like all the time. Because, you know, like, when we break down, like, what are our physiological most basic needs, and then money is necessary for most of them most of the time, like, of course, that's going to mess us up. Of course, we're all going to have a lot of baggage around money. So I like to say that I also find it important to point out like, you were kind of saying, like, there's so much we cannot control about global patriarchal white supremacist capitalism. So I want to help people focus on what they actually can control within themselves, instead of trying to think, well, if I can't fix the world, then it's not worth trying, or I'm not allowed to enjoy a vacation, if there are people who are still suffering, do that black and white thinking, exactly the black and white thinking. So it's not like, I'm not saying totally let go of the things that you can't personally control. But like, notice how much power you actually have in the world and how you're using it intentionally. Instead of feeling like that kind of just American individualism exceptionalism popping up again, of thinking, well, if I just did this, then the world wouldn't be so bad. Or maybe I suffered more other people would suffer less.

    KC Davis 6:38

    Ooh, if I suffered more than maybe other people would suffer less, that is a really powerful sentence. Because I think that there's obviously some truth to this idea of, you know, I want to make my table bigger, or like, I want to share what I have, or I want to bring others up with me, or I want to, I want to lean into creating and being a part of an interdependent community. Like, I don't want to hoard, you know, stuff while people. But I feel like those things are all really admirable. And yet, when I talk to people about it, it seems like what most of us have interpreted from that is, maybe if I suffer, other people won't have to suffer, even if the suffering doesn't actually create any material. I see that with environmentalism a lot, where it's like, if I throw this one thing away, and it's like, I mean, yeah, it'd be great if we could all you know, live out of a mason jar of trash every year, but like life is life. And it's that sort of black and white thinking, which I find really interesting, especially with my platform of talking about moral neutrality. And some of these issues, obviously have some moral implications. But I just am so blown away, every time I realize how much of our headspace as like humans in this society is filled with, if I don't make these right decisions, I'm a bad person. And if I'm a bad person, I don't deserve to be loved. And I think that's what sort of gets us to that I have to suffer if other people are suffering. So that's really, really fascinating. Do you have any others on the list? I think about, I don't know, the amount of times that a thought flies out of my brain on this podcast is impressive. So it's fine. And if you want us to cut anything out, you don't have to take a minute, we'll do that, too. Oh, and I had a question too. And I'm trying to like, crawl it back into my brain. Oh, I think I was just gonna relate like when you said, every need, we have, like these deeply human needs, like we live in a society where we have to pay for all of it. That like almost brought me to tears. This is already I'm going like we're nine minutes in. And this has been like an oddly emotional topic for me, because I genuinely like even though we are financially stable, in many ways, financially privileged, that fear has not gone away. That fear of what if tomorrow, my husband dies, and we don't have his income? What if tomorrow, one of my kids gets cancer, and we have to be able to afford all of this? What if tomorrow, you know, a war starts in the US, and all of a sudden, we don't have access to these things? Right? Like, I think a lot of the times, when we look at that frantic, like, I don't want to I want to hoard wealth, or I want to just hustle and grind. I think we can talk about the aspect of that that is fueled by greed. And that's real, right. And we can talk about the aspect of that that's fueled by white supremacy, and all those things. But I wonder if there isn't also just a real human element of like, it's terrifying. To love people and to think about your ability to keep them safe and healthy, is dependent on having the money to do that, and how hard it must be to have that fear. And also hear people will be like, just relax it. It's like it feels so I don't know if you have any thoughts on that, but that just really touched me.

    River Nice 9:57

    Yeah, absolutely. And like who said benefits by us being so scared. And so on the edge of survival all the time, you know, like, capitalism in the big picture is like the 1% of actual, like owners exploiting the rest of us. And we are better laborers if our survival is threatened by us not having the money that we are laboring for, to pay for the survival things. So like the system is working as designed. And of course, it's making us all have really intense feelings about it all the time. Like, I'm not surprised that you're on the verge of tears, nine minutes in talking about this, I have people crying in meetings with me all the time. Like, it's our literal survival we're talking about and then the financial services industry wants to paint it as this like cold spreadsheets, there's no emotions, here. It's just money. It's just hard data. But like, when the hard data reflects whether or not we're going to be okay, in old age, our kids are going to be okay, our parents are going to be okay. Like, our trans community is going to survive, like, of course, we're all a mess about it. And there has to be space for that, if you're going to be able to do anything intentionally with it. Yeah,

    KC Davis 11:07

    I want to pause there just for a second, we'll take a short break, and we'll come right back. So sometimes, when I and this could be like your personal opinion, your professional opinion, just thoughts in general, I watch a lot of content where people talk about like, sort of like the evils of hustle and grind. I won't even say culture, but it's like, as a prescriptive. Like, that's it equals your moral fortitude, like get up hustle and grind. And I watch a lot of content about like talking about like slow living, and it's okay to not like, live for the weekend, like it's okay to rest and enjoy your life. And to not have to feel as though you have to be producing, producing, producing, producing. And one of the things that so I find that content really fascinating when it comes to financial planning in the financial world, because I hear a lot of people say, I don't know how I'm supposed to interpret this message when I'm living like paycheck to paycheck. Like I'm not like hustling grinding, because that's my worth. I'm doing it because like, I have to pay my water bill. So how am I supposed to incorporate these, you know, what are anti capitalist ideas about my humanity, when I'm paycheck to paycheck, and then I have almost like the opposite end of the spectrum response, where I watch that content, and I go, Yeah, I want that. I want that I want to wake up and, you know, talk for hours with my spouse on in the garden, I want to be there for every one of my kids like soccer games and not have to like necessarily go into work, I want to work a job where I can work a couple or a few hours a day, and then be able to do these other meaningful pursuits. But one of the things that confronts me when I have those thoughts when engaging that content as a cisgendered, white, upper middle class female is, but to do that is just my privilege. That's just me living a privileged life. And I don't know if this goes back to the life but if I suffer, other people suffer also. And I sometimes don't know how to someone who is financially privileged and is just privileged, in other respects, engage or incorporate those type of anti capitalist ideas about maybe slow living, or, you know, having a more holistic focus on life because you don't have to hustle and grind. Because there's this like, achy part of me that's like, oh, I mean, I could just retire and be like, a kept housewife. But like, that doesn't feel very anticapitalist of me. So I'm curious if you have any thoughts about that. And I'm sorry, this is basically turning into a therapy session where I'm just asking you to talk about my financial emotional issues.

    River Nice 13:44

    No, that's really interesting. And I'm glad you brought it up. I don't think you're the only person asking that question and thinking about it. And I guess what I am thinking through as you're talking is, like, I guess what I would be thinking through if I was to try to advise you on this, I would be thinking through like, the privileges that you have, or that I have, and like what I am doing to make the world better, while also making my life as good as it can be under all the oppressive systems. So like, I also am like white and upper middle class, I am Trans and Queer that I'm neurotypical, able bodied, thin, you know, like the axes of oppression that affect me are pretty few and it's mostly just being trans and queer. So I see my place is like building the life that I want, because I am part of the queer and trans communities and it is important to me that we get the chance to build the lives that we want, and seeing how I can redistribute the resources that I have available to me, relative to my levels of privilege and access to resources. So for me, it is fairly easy to make money because I am white and neurotypical. So I feel a sense of obligation to make that money and redistribute some of it to black and indigenous group. People specifically, I also have the ability to, you know, be self employed and set up my work day work week year in the way that best works for me. But I don't want to end up working unrealistic amounts or an unrealistic schedule that I burn out. And I'm not useful. I'm trying to play the long game. I'm trying to play my whole life, how do I live my whole life in accordance with my values. So if I'm trying to set myself up to work as much as possible, and make as much money as possible to redistribute as much as possible, that might not be able to work for the next 60 years. And I want it to work for the next 60 years. So for me, it's setting up the business and the life where I am helping people that I feel like my skill set is most useful in helping you know, I'm not necessarily able to help every single person with their financial planning, I can help a type of person and a type of situation most effectively. And then how do I make my time and energy efficient to that end, while still making enough money to redistribute while still being able to have kids and spend time with my kids? Does that help? And like how I would be thinking through this? Yeah.

    KC Davis 16:06

    And I also think that, you know, when we talk about redistribution of wealth, can you talk a little bit more about like, what does that practically look like when you're talking with clients? Because I think there are probably a lot of people listening that already have maybe some preconceived notions about what that means. Maybe some people even feel this fear, because they relate, you know, just redistribution of wealth with some type of political movement or governmental movement, or, you know, maybe they're thinking, Oh, this woke stuff. And then I think there's a lot of people that say that, hear it and like it and think, yes, I want to be a part of that. But I gotta be honest, I don't know that I really understand the intricacies of what that looks like, outside of like giving money to a charity giving money to a person. And is that what it means? Or are there other more strategic ways that people can go about? Or they start thinking about that?

    River Nice 17:00

    Yeah, totally big questions, but I love them. I want to first point out that, like capitalism is not a pressing is all equally, right. So that means that where you are starting from and where you currently are, is going to inform what redistribution means to you. So for folks who are listening, who come from, like, generational wealth, I would point you to resource generation as a national movement with possibly a chapter local to you that can help you figure out your specific values, your personal practice, on how you approach this work, and then how much to give and where to give and how to give. Most of the clients that I work with come from working class or lower middle class backgrounds, but now have access to money for the first time. So they have the money, and they have no information about what to do with it. Right. So for those folks, we talk through what to do with the paycheck as it comes in. Right? We're not talking about inherited generational wealth, we're talking about a high paycheck when you are not used to experiencing high paycheck. In that high paycheck, we can list out the budget, you know, shelter cost, this much food cost this much healthcare costs this much. And then as we get to the more discretionary parts of the budget travel going out to eat entertainment, hobbies, we figure out a level of giving that reflects how important redistribution and reparations is relative to those other items. So sometimes I'll see like a 22 year old white queer person who has so much white guilt, they're giving away more per month than they are actually able to, like pay their own bills. And that's not a sustainable thing to continue to do that suffering is disproportional with the amount that you're helping. But if you are able to take a trip once or twice a year, maybe you can also redistribute the same amount as what you put towards that trip. If you are again, like you know, a white upper middle class person, you know, like these other factors of privilege have to come into the equation and thinking about what you're doing. But if you can give at a level that reflects how important economic justice and racial justice is to you compared to your takeout, your entertainment, your travel, etc, that can give you a guiding principle to start with.

    KC Davis 19:11

    Do you talk to people also about like, how they can invest that money or grow that money because like one thing that I I'm that person that's like out the gate, like, let's just give all of it, you know, away. And it really was my husband that was like, here's the thing like, yes, we want to give now. But if we also take a portion of this and invest, like there will be more money and more security down the road to give bigger amounts to offer ourselves a kind of stability that allows us to be more involved in things. And that was kind of a big eye opener for me because like I didn't know anything about like investing or I didn't know anything besides get a paycheck, pay your bills, maybe have a savings account. So I don't know if that was a question but thoughts

    River Nice 19:58

    Yeah, yeah. And this is something that I'm actively exploring and questioning for myself as well, right? Like, I don't think I'm like an expert, and I'm done. And now I never have to question these things. Again, my approach thus far has been that those of us who have the ability to have money in older age like to be investing for the long term and have access to money, when we can no longer work, in some ways have kind of a responsibility to have those resources available for the community at that time, like you said, and in another way of thinking, if we are continuing to follow along that idea of individual wealth growth in order to contribute to community as more of a like, giving to charity model instead of I am part of a community and we all share resources all the time model. It's a tricky spot. So currently, for me and my clients, and again, knowing that the majority of my clients are not coming from generational wealth. And now as money for the first time, we do talk about investing, and trying to choose investments that avoid fossil fuels that avoid private prisons. But invest to be able to have that security of safety as old people, especially as like, older trans people, you know, like, we can try to work on that while still giving part of the paycheck every month. Again, for folks who are coming from more generational wealth, I would point those hooks to resource generation because they're doing some really cool work about envisioning what retirement could look like as a community care practice instead of as an individual piles of money practice. And especially if you're coming from financial security that can be really cool to explore what it looks like to invest that money in, trying to create universal health care, so that we'll all be okay as old people instead of just a couple of us being okay, as old people.

    KC Davis 21:47

    Yeah, it's interesting when you talk about like the difference between a charity giving model and creating an interdependent community, because that's one thing that we've recognized for ourselves, which is like, it's weird. I mean, it's not weird, right? Like, there are some great organizations out there. But there is something about having exclusively a charitable giving model that distances you, I think that's both to the detriment of the people you're trying to help, and also to our own detriment, because it doesn't create interdependent community. And it keeps us in this position of I'm someone that has at all, and I give to the have nots, as opposed to, I also have needs, that I could be getting met through my community, these human needs, that I could be getting that through my community. And that was kind of a big aha moment that I had this last year, which is like, okay, and then once you start having that conversation, then it's not just like, What do I do with my paycheck? It's like, where do I live? And who do I live by? And where do my kids go to school? And it's not like, I think that there's one right answer for all those questions. But it's interesting how what you think is, like you said, just like this dry conversation about the numbers, all of a sudden is like, Wait, like, I don't want to be alone. I don't want to have to, you know, it's really isolating to be in a position, like you said, where every single support needs you have has to be paid for. And there's no interdependency where, yes, this person might pick up my kids for me, but I go over there and help them with, you know, XYZ. And that, to me, is more anti capitalist than this idea about, like how much money I do or don't have, right, like,

    River Nice 23:34

    Right, totally. And to come back to what you were talking about earlier about how scary it is, you know, what if my kid gets sick, what if my husband dies? What if? What if, what if, when I teach financial emergency preparedness, we talk about multiple ways to protect yourself, right. So there's having the emergency savings fund just like liquid cash available to pay an unexpected bill or whatever. We talk about insurance policies that you can get like life insurance, that if something happens to you, your family gets money to help them get through what they need next. But then there's also that social safety net, and you can invest in that in other ways, and in financial ways. So if you did have your third emergency in one year, if you did have a housing crisis, if you did have you did have like, who would you turn to? And are you nurturing those relationships? And like, I think sometimes, especially working with a lot of trans people, it's like, well, family of origin is not a place to turn back to and I get that. And what are the other nonprofits doing work to help us or doing work about some of these financial crises that people experience? What are the mutual aid groups what your neighbor is doing? And like, how can you make sure that you are a valued member of the community even if you don't have much money or time or energy to give How can you like show up and create social connection with other people and provide them the social connection that all of us need? So that eventually if you do have your like, tough emergency or third or fourth emergency, like there are people You can turn to

    KC Davis 25:01

    well, and one of the things that I think is interesting when we talk about being interdependent with people, and this is sometimes money, or sometimes other types of help or connection is that it feels so vulnerable to ask someone for help. But one of the things that I've learned is that, and there's been studies on this too, like, when somebody asks me for help, it makes me feel more comfortable asking them in turn, like human beings are actually very comfortable with this idea of like, it's not being in someone's debt, but it's like, there's something about, you know, man, I don't know, I don't have words today, but you get it, right. Like, there's a lot of, I think, sometimes we're so afraid to be the first person to ask for help. And in my experience, like I had a friend that she had a little girl that was the same age as one of my daughters. And we both lived in a city. We didn't know anybody we had done, like some playdates. And one of the things I find really difficult is like, how do I take people from this sort of like nice acquaintance to like, an intimate person that I'm doing life with as a support system. And there was a day where I had something really important that I had to get to, and my kids got sick. And she out of nowhere texted me. Oh, it was before this, actually. So that we had a natural disaster here in Houston. And there was no water, there was no electricity. My house was one of the only ones that had electricity. And so I invited her and her family to come stay with us for a few days. And it was like kind of a leap. Like, we didn't know each other super well. But I was like, yeah, come on, and do this. And then like, not a few weeks later, like my kids had gotten sick. And she texted me and was like, Do you want me to come over and watch them. And there was really it was that like, reciprocal nature of like, someone has to kind of make the first move to either ask for help or offer help, is awkward as it feels. And like, that was the thing that took us to the next level. And I kept waiting for the comfort and the familiarity and the intimacy to be there before I felt comfortable asking or offering help. And then I realized, Wait, asking and offering help, is what gets you to that point of like that new sort of depth of a relationship. And so I think that's really interesting.

    River Nice 27:07

    Yeah, I live in an apartment building that is five apartments. And a couple weeks ago, I just invited all my neighbors over, I just like, put out some chips and salsa, I baked some cookies. And I was just like, everybody come by between five and eight. I like made it very, like, need to understand this is what's happening. Here's a picture of the food, like, these are the times come knock on my door. And most of the other folks did come by and I was like, look like, let's just get to know each other a little bit. What is everybody do? What is everybody's schedule? Like? Can we all start a Text group chat, so that when a package gets delivered on the front stoop, and you're not home, someone else can bring it in before it gets stolen. And it's just, it's just a starting point. But I had realized, like, I moved into this apartment right before COVID, shut everything down. So I never actually met the other people in my building. And I was like, Hey, I would love to just like put faces and names together and like, start a group chat for logistical things in the building. But now if somebody's like, Oh, can you feed my cat, oh, my car broke down, or whatever. It's like, now you have a little group chat of people just in the building. And then if there is some kind of bigger crisis, we all have each other's contact info and a little bit of an understanding of what each other's lives are like, so we can try to help each other out like that. So I love that you like then moved from the acquaintance to the like actual mutual care, taking care of each other's families, as as possible. But like, yeah, it's getting started. That's tough.

    KC Davis 28:29

    And I think, you know, as we talk more, the idea of like, what does it mean to be an anti capitalist financial planner, it seems like, so much of it is about looking holistically at a person's life. And that money is just one part of it, and one expression of what their values are. And I think that, to me, seems like the biggest difference because most financial advisors that I've ever, like watched content about or seen personally, like, it is this very, like, myopic view of like, let's look at your money, and how can we make more of it? As opposed to how is money fitting into your life?

    River Nice 29:05

    Exactly. I think of money as a tool that we can use in different ways and debt to money and debt are tools that we can try to use within you know, the bounds of everything we're experiencing. So instead of how do I have the highest number possible at any cost? It's how do I use this tool to have the best life I can? And how do I use this tool in accordance with my values?

    KC Davis 29:27

    Well, I feel like that's like one of the biggest misconceptions too is like debt is bad. Debt is always bad. I had that

    River Nice 29:33

    message. You said Dave Ramsey, and I was like, Yep, he says that we are sinners, and we are terrible people if we have any debt at all, and that we're not allowed to have a single ounce of joy in our life until all of the debt is gone. And who benefits from that? Because it's not you and me.

    KC Davis 29:49

    Well, it's a lot easier to stay in your, you know, like, not even making survival wages. If you feel like you just deserve to have no joy in your life and because of your orell failing of being in debt, and that you can't go out and have any fun, which is alright, yeah, you won't have any more. You won't need money to have fun because you'll just be. Yeah. All right, another quick break. And then I want to get into some questions about like, where people might start depending on where they are. Okay, we're back. And so remember, I had like, sort of this 1234, like different scenarios. And I would love to hear if you have any, like practical takeaways, or maybe just some overarching advice, but like, where could someone else position start? So the first one would be like, if someone's in a lot of debt, and they just don't even really know where to start? Like, where do you start with them? Where could just like a listener start?

    River Nice 30:40

    But I always start with organizing, actually, what is the debt? Where is it? How much do you owe? What are the interest rates? What are the minimum payments, a lot of times folks are so scared that they refuse to even look at it, which I totally get, right. Again, this feels like a direct threat to survival. But you're not gonna be able to do much about it, if you don't know actually the extent of the situation. So you can go to the Federal Student Aid website to get the actual specific numbers about your student loans. And you can get your credit reports from annual credit report.com, for free to find out, what are the other debts associated with your social security number? Where do they live? Who do you owe the money to? How much money do you actually have anything in collections or not? I make your list, you know, right out, how much do I owe to whom, what's the minimum payment, what's the interest rate, if you're in a situation where you can make all of the minimum payments, great, you work on building a budget, or just having money flow in and flow out in such a way that you make at least the minimum payments. And I would always always rather see somebody making minimum payments sustainably than throwing too much money on the debt and then having to go further into debt before the next paycheck comes. So that would be a starting point. If you are able to make more than the minimum payments, and you don't know how much is sustainable. There's a free online calculator called the debt blaster calculator, you can Google debt blaster calculator, and that'll help you understand how throwing an extra 10 bucks a month is going to impact your debt timeline or an extra 20 bucks a month, and kind of go from there. But again, make sure that you are keeping enough money, like liquid in your checking account, if you have, you know, if possible, if you're actually making enough to live to be able to afford all your bills so that you're not going further into debt before your next paycheck just because you threw too much at the debt upfront.

    KC Davis 32:25

    Also, I was like an absurdly old age before I realized that you could like call companies and negotiate and try and work out like, you know, I can pay you a smaller amount now or like, I didn't know I did that. That was even something that you could do.

    River Nice 32:40

    Yeah, it's always worth a try. I'm glad you brought it up. I feel like in our current economic environment, it's going to be hard to get any credit issuers to decrease interest rates, because interest rates are on the rise everywhere. But you can try you know, and if you're doing the dishes anyway, or doing something else anyway, and you don't mind sitting on hold for half an hour. It's worth a try. And when it comes to making decisions like that, like is it worth this time and effort to try to save money? I think about like, is half an hour of my time worth potentially $100? For me, yes. You know, and so that's a way to think about whether the effort might be worth the return. And then certainly, if anything, does go to a collections agency, absolutely negotiate that do not pay them in full. That's not how they work. But I don't want to spend too much time on this.

    KC Davis 33:26

    I find that with medical bills, too. Like, yeah, I mean, yeah, like my credit card company is not going to like cut me a deal for us or whatever, right? I'm like, student loans aren't but often if you call a hospital and just say like, I don't have this money, they'll often be like, Alright, can you give me a fourth of it? Or whatever? Yep. Okay. So next one, how do you work with someone who is living paycheck to paycheck or like they're just surviving?

    River Nice 33:52

    Yeah. So similar advice in terms of getting organized, I think a lot of times, we are avoiding the reality of the numbers of the situation, because it's so painful and stressful to look at and can be, like, demoralizing to look at. But I want you to try to gain agency where you can first because I think what's so terrible from one of the many things that's so terrible about being stuck in barely surviving mode is that feeling of just a total lack of autonomy and agency. So if you can go look at like an actual, like, where all of your money went last month, where all of your money came in last month? And here, are there any changes that you want to make? I'm not saying you have to cut out the copy to be a good person, right? I'm not saying you need to do X, Y, or Z to be a good person. I'm saying, Are there opportunities for you to claim agency and autonomy in your day to day financial reality? And then, you know, maybe looking at how much money you make can give you an indication of whether this gig pays better than that gig or putting more of your time and energy towards this thing versus that thing. Or if you took a class online, you'd be able to improve your skills To get a better paying job in your industry, like looking at opportunities to increase income, looking at opportunities to decrease expenses, maybe if you can find a cheaper place to live, you know, like, all of this is up to your autonomy, your decision for your life, none of it makes you a good or bad person. But like if you have opportunities to adjust your situation incrementally that could help you end up in a better situation in the long run.

    KC Davis 35:26

    That's great advice. Do you have any like favorite online, like websites that will like kind of automatically do like a pie chart of where your spending is going?

    River Nice 35:35

    Great question. So not a pie chart and not automatic. But I do have a free spreadsheet template on my website, be intentional financial.com. And that is designed to take you through looking at your money for the very first time. So you can follow this steps there. It comes with a series of videos telling me what to do if manual data entry into a spreadsheet via a computer is not accessible to you. The min app is the free app that you can use on your phone that links with your bank accounts, you just have to go in and categorize each of the transactions that happened because the artificial intelligence is probably going to categorize things incorrectly the first time. So that can be a free tool to try. And then if you are you and a partner wants to do it together, one of my clients recently told me that they really liked the honey do app to be able to manage it as a couple. So those are a couple of free things to get started.

    KC Davis 36:23

    Cool. Okay, so how about somebody who is financially stable, maybe for the first time ever? And they're now thinking towards the future? And kind of going, where do I start? Because there's all sorts of things out there like that can feel really intimidating, about like a 401k, a Roth IRA, and just investing? Do I just build a savings? Like what what does that look like for someone who wants to start planning for the future?

    River Nice 36:47

    Totally. So that is the type of person who might benefit from working with me, honestly, that's the type of situation that I am most qualified and useful for. So I offer free consultations, if anybody wants to talk to me for 30 minutes and get a sense of what they need to focus on first, and whether it is the right time and price point to work with a professional or not. So be intentional financial.com, you can schedule that pre consultation. Besides that, I suggest that people start short term and then start thinking longer term from there. So first, build up the emergency savings, to make sure that you can handle an unexpected bill, make sure that you've got a monthly budget that includes how much you're redistributing, if that's relevant to your experience, and then start thinking about how much am I saving up per month for the thing that I want to do six months from now, a year from now, two years from now? And then am I investing for things that are further away than two years from now? And am I thinking about investing for retirement? So that could be a framework to start with?

    KC Davis 37:45

    All right. And then the last question, where would you start with someone who came to you and they had really already begun to accumulate wealth?

    River Nice 37:52

    Yeah. Similarly, I would start with the short term and build out to the longer term, because we want to be doing all of this for long term sustainability, the lives that we want. But if you do already have wealth, we're talking a little bit more on the redistribution end of things and what is sustainable while still letting you have a good life. So we'd be looking at short term is what I have prepared for emergencies actually appropriate, or am I keeping too much cash around too much cash in the bank? How much having invested so far for my medium and long term goals? And is that appropriate? Do I have a chance at inheriting more in the future? And what am I going to do with that inheritance? With that unearned money as it comes in? And yeah, kinda like how do all the pieces fit together according to my values, and like, levels of privilege? Does that help?

    KC Davis 38:45

    Yeah, that's awesome. Those are all really my question. This has been honestly a really cool conversation. I think you kind of hit the nail on the head when it's like most people think about money is going to be a dry subject, but it's really not when you talk about holistically and so I really appreciate the conversation. Yeah, are there any other things about you you would like to plug before we go

    River Nice 39:04

    oh, people can find me on Instagram river nice stuff, financial planner. Tiktok River, not river nice dot finance. And then like I said, my website is the intentional financial.com. And thank you so much, Casey for talking about money on the podcast. And money is like still one of the biggest taboos and I think it really helps to be able to talk about it and hear about it and start conversations. So thanks for having me.

    KC Davis 39:25

    Awesome. Thank you.

KC Davis
39: Life Coaching: the Good, the Bad, & the Ugly

Coaching is an interesting field with many nuances, and we hear a LOT of buzz about coaching right now. There are coaches for literally EVERY aspect of life. While there are things to appreciate about the field of coaching, there are definitely things to look out for, as well. I’m joined by my good friend, Heidi Smith, who is a Licensed Professional Counselor.

In Part 2 of this conversation, I’m joined by Rachel Ambrose for a coach’s perspective. Rachel is a coach for neurodivergents who has been diagnosed with ADHD and autism. As someone who holds multiple coaching certifications, she is here to give us a better look at the coaching field. She talks about the bounds of coaching and her personal experience around green and red flags in the industry. Rachel shares tips to help people know how to find a helpful coach and be more knowledgeable about the coaching field.

Show Highlights:

  • How Heidi partners with clients and coaches in her counseling work

  • Why there are legitimate questions about the training and oversight in the coaching field

  • Why coaching is, by definition, a less intimidating relationship than with a therapist but is like “paying for a friend”

  • How coaching and therapy embody very different relationships, lanes, and ethics

  • What to consider in questions about licensure and certifications

  • The ethical rabbit hole around the client’s relationship with therapists and coaches

  • Why the coaching field is like the Wild West right now

  • Pitfalls in the coaching industry around sexual integrity, case management, interventions, and narcissism

  • KC’s experience in researching ADHD coaching

  • The vagueness around a “spirituality coach”

  • The bottom line about coaching: “Do your research and be aware of potential drawbacks.”

  • Part 2 from Rachel Amrose:

    • Green and red flags around coaching around the following:

      • Power dynamics in the relationship

      • “I have the cure/the magical answer for your problem!”

      • Concrete, actionable items

    • How to know if a coach’s training is worthwhile or not

    • How to gauge a coach’s willingness to refer out–and stay in their lane

Resources and Links:

Connect with Rachel Ambrose: Website

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. I'm KC Davis, your host. And this is the podcast where we talk about mental health, self care, all things that have to do with just kind of surviving in the world that we live in. And I have my good friend, Heidi Smith, who is a licensed professional counselor supervisor with me. How do you? What are the chances I'm going to get angry emails from the coaching industry about this podcast episode?

    Heidi Smith 0:30

    Oh, as long as it's just you getting them, I'll be happy.

    KC Davis 0:33

    So I wanted to talk about coaching. Because it's an interesting field. And I feel like it requires a little more nuance than like a 60 second. Tik Tok can provide me?

    Heidi Smith 0:46

    Yes, it's an interesting field. And I've used coaches, but and I also have thoughts on them. There's I think there's certain things that I really appreciate about them. But I think there's certain things to look out for as well. Yeah. And there's like lots of different there's like recovery coaches in the addiction field. And there's ADHD coaches, life coaches, spiritual coaches I've seen and I financial coaches, financial coaches.

    KC Davis 1:11

    Yeah. And I'm kind of like you, like I have worked with really great coaching, I have seen coaching be really, really helpful. And I think that I have too much of a like, behind the scenes, like look at coaching, right? So it makes me extremely cautious about the field in general.

    Heidi Smith 1:30

    Yeah, for sure. At the same time, like, just, for example, you know, when I see an adolescent for therapy, which I because I specialize in substance abuse, I get a lot of substance abuse cases. And so if you want me to see your 15 year old son, you know, for individual therapy, I'm almost going to require you to have a coach on board. So because there are so many moving parts with an adolescent, you know, with school, with discipline, with contracts at home, things like that, that just to be honest, I don't, that's not what I love to do. It's not what I really want to do. I'm a therapist, I want to sit in the office with you and do therapy. I don't want to have to do all that other stuff. And I'm not great at it. And so, so I definitely partner with coaches. But But like you said, you know, it's the regulations around it. And, you know, the personalities behind it. You know, there's a lot of wildcards.

    KC Davis 2:29

    Yeah, the places that I've seen coaching work really well is like, I know, there's a there's a company in Dallas, like prides themselves on providing like wraparound services, where you'll see a therapist once a week, but then they have these coaches, and depending on your level of like mental illness, they'll come spend hours a day with you.

    Heidi Smith 2:47

    Yeah, they call them life development coaches.

    KC Davis 2:50

    Yeah. And they'll take you to do your laundry, and they'll talk about doing dishes, and they might even go to a social event together and talk about social skills.

    Heidi Smith 2:58

    Yeah, and I mean depending on, you know, the individual's level of functioning, I mean, it may be as detailed as taking you out to eat and teaching you how to order off a menu and teaching you how to put gas in your car and, and things like that. It's basic self care items, you know, all the way up to Yeah, just taking you to an AA meeting, taking you to play basketball, spending time with you developing social skills, things like that. So, and that's something that I can't do as a therapist.

    KC Davis 3:25

    Hmm. You know, I mean, there are some therapists that I guess, do some kind of out of the box things, you know, but for the most part, most of us have an office and you come in and you meet with us for an hour, and you leave. And so there are definitely limitations to what we can do. And so there, you know, I think these coaches fill a gap that is really necessary. I think what you start getting into is what kind of training do you have? What kind of oversight Do you have, you know, and ultimately, kind of who's, where's the oversight of those individuals? And there's some I feel like there's some coaching, that's way more cut and dry. So like, when the like development coaches, like they're specifically doing like life skills, you know, like we mentioned, or in someone who is, I mean, in a lot of ways, like, if you get like a Personal Organizer like that is they actually are a coach.

    Heidi Smith 4:16

    Absolutely.

    KC Davis 4:17

    Especially a good one that's not only going to engage like, I guess there are some people that are just personal organizers, like they're going to tell you where to put things, but the ones that I know that are really good are more like coaches, because they're going to examine, like, how do you operate in your space? And is it working for you? And like, what's keeping you from the skill of finding what you need? And what if you did it this way, and I actually interviewed a coach recently that I liked and asked her like, what she thought was the difference between like coaching and when you start to like, get into therapy world because it's when you get to like life coaching, that I feel like or like relationship coaching like the dating coaches and stuff. All of a sudden there's this like huge gray area.where it's like, how much can you talk about someone's feelings? And someone's like Outlook and beliefs before you start to get into like therapy world?

    Heidi Smith 5:09

    Yeah, yeah.

    Speaker 1 5:11

    I like the way she put it, she's like, you know, I can be there to offer a different perspective. But I'm not there to like mine the depths of like how to change yours.

    Heidi Smith 5:20

    Yeah, and getting into real deep clinical work, you know, I mean, I and it is that such a fine line that it's almost, you know, impossible to know exactly when it's been crossed. And same with career coaching. So I worked for an organization that went through kind of, you know, your typical cliche, almost like office space, the movie, you know, where they brought in, like custom consultants and, and, you know, we're kind of reevaluating the whole way, they did everything. And as part of that they brought in a coach and required us to all me do like six sessions with the coach, which, again, that's kind of getting into a whole different topic of, it seemed like, a little bit of a boundary violation, just even require that, you know, because it is kind of this deep personal work, we didn't get to pick the coach, it was there, it was a coach that they brought in. Either way I did it, obviously, I played ball and did the coaching, it was very interesting, like it was I got to, you know, work on setting career goals, and working on using my voice in different ways. And making kind of these micro adjustments at work and how I interact with other people. And it wasn't therapy, it was something different. And this woman was a trained coach, you know, with all kinds of certifications, it was much more of kind of like a professional, almost chart that she took me through, you know, of questions and actions and behaviors that I could change to meet my goals was very goal oriented, and not clinical. And she was clearly very well trained. But it was interesting, because it definitely, I mean, there was lots of sessions where I cried, you know, we're like, because I was like, facing fears of maybe, you know, using my voice in a staff meeting in a different way. And, you know, maybe asking for a raise, yeah, things like, very out of the box for me, but it was it honed in in a specific area of my life that I probably would have never done with a therapist.

    KC Davis 7:19

    So when I ran the rehab back in the day, one of the things that that was actually really helpful about the coaches that we employed was that like, a client would have a session with a therapist. And, you know, in a perfect world, like you're being totally transparent with your therapist, even when you kind of you're like saying things like, oh, I don't think that's going to work or I don't like the way you just said that or I'm feeling kind of uncomfortable in our therapeutic relationship. And like not everybody's there. And it was it was interesting to see, you know, this person would go in, they'd sit with this therapist that they saw as like this expert, usually older, more credentialed more training, and they'd come out of it. And they'd kind of be like, I don't know, like, what I everything that I think about that, right. And they turn around and have a session with their recovery coach and kind of like, share those doubts and fears. And that recovery coach was truly like the backdoor, like the guard of the backdoor of like, keeping them enrolled in recovery of like, yeah, man, I get it like I've been there. One time I like they do a lot of more like self disclosure, like, let me share my experience with how like, I wasn't sure therapy was working. But here's how it was really helpful. And kind of answer any questions. And then like, Have you have you talked to your therapist about that kind of like what you were talking about with like adolescents and homework and stuff? Like, it's like somebody else out the door?

    Heidi Smith 8:40

    Yeah, absolutely. And it's, I think, by definition, it's supposed to be a less intimidating, professional relationship. And so it's an enemy. There's actually a whole industry of peer recovery coaching certifications, where it really is like peer to peer mentorship, as opposed to a professional hierarchy. And so I think that's 100% I mean, it's, you're gonna get a whole different person. You know, like you said, for half for at least 50% of the population goes into therapy, even I do after years of being a therapist, like the last time I did you kind of a ballot of therapy myself, I mean, like, I was kinda I wanted to impress her and I wanted to make her think I was Yeah, I don't know. It's like I had to confront even myself in that context of realizing that I don't always go in like 100% Raw, vulnerable, authentic into my therapists office.

    KC 9:35

    It is also like paying for a friend. And I don't mean that in a bad way, but it's like, you know, a friend when I go to a friend like when I call you for advice, like I I'm calling you for like your like, casual as a person friendship like advice on a situation like I'm not expecting you to be perfectly objective or to hold some like unconditional positive regard. Hard for me like, you're gonna tell me I'm being an asshole if you think I'm being an asshole. And like, there might be a day that I call you and you're short with me and but like, that's a friend that I'm expecting to hear from, but I also like, I also can hold space for recognizing, like, am I treating this as a reciprocal friendship? Like, do you call me with your problems? When I call you with my problems? Am I also interested in your life and I think coaching can be helpful for people that maybe find themselves in this place where it's like, okay, I need some help. Not necessarily like therapy, deeps emotional work, but like, I have the situation at work, where it's kind of toxic, and I need to learn how to be I'm struggling with my ADHD and I can't seem to get anything clean. I can't get anything organized. I'm missing appointments. And like, I honestly need someone who can kind of serve as that one way street. But yeah, but more of a peer not like, it's a sure.

    Heidi Smith 10:56

    And it's more, I think, also, it's more accessible. And real time in theory, you know, like, depending on Yeah, situation, it's like, and I'll see my therapist for two weeks, and I only have a 50 minute session with her, you know, and I'm unpacking all this other childhood stuff, you know, but my coach over here, like, I can call him because I just got written up at work. And you know, I'm in my car crying over at lunch, and I may not be able to get a hold of my therapist, but that may be something that my life coach can walk me through. And so I think it's more accessible. And like you said, casual in, like, all the right ways.

    KC Davis 11:33

    Yeah. And I think that, like, if I were to work with a person, one on one about their home, like, based on like, the book that I wrote, and the content like that truly would be coaching. And absolute, because I would be asking, like, What messages do you tell yourself about care tasks? Like, that's an appropriate question for a coach, and then they'd share. And if they shared like, well, you know, my mother used to beat me, when my room wasn't clean. Like, if I was in a therapy session, where we would go with that is like, let's talk about that. And let's talk about those feelings. And let's maybe think of some modalities or interventions to talk about that trauma. Whereas if I'm going to address them as a coach, I'm going to go Okay, so like, it seems like, that's probably affecting the way that you look at cleaning now. So, you know, maybe we can come up with a, like a mantra that you can use to remind yourself that, you know, you're in your home and your home is safe now.

    Heidi Smith 12:34

    And right, like, that's yes, like moving kind of see moving around that in a different way than necessarily trying to sit there and unpack it. And that's, and that's like, exactly, I mean, that's where you get in the danger zone, you know, is is like coaching is very dependent on the specific into Huami I guess this is true for everything, like therapists to your it's very dependent on that specific person's training, level of integrity, and like level of humility, and ego of like, what they're capable of, and staying in their lane. And so being able to, to know that person and know that, like they're not trying to play therapist, and that they understand what their lane is, and that they have a some kind of guiding ethics around, like, here's what I do. And here's my lane. And here's what I don't do. And I guess that's true in most industries.

    KC Davis 13:30

    Right. And so, you know, but finding though there's really lacking that that licensing process, though, yeah, like, because, yes, you can get a therapist, that's not good. But I think the danger zone is like, if you get a therapist that is downright unethical and dangerous, like there is recourse out for reporting that person, right. So and I think that's like the good and I, I couldn't help but notice that like, one of the green flags, I guess, for coaching is like the great coaches that I've known, has been on a team. And I'm not saying there aren't great coaches that just kind of run their own business. I'm sure that there are, but I think that it definitely is helpful when you know, okay, there's the company that I knew that they would give you a therapist and a coach, or, you know, if you were to encourage, you know, an adolescent to get a coach, like, ideally, you'd be able to communicate with that person. Well, yeah, and that parent was in charge of that,

    Heidi Smith 14:25

    What like the, you know, some of those organizations you're talking about, even the the plan, the coaching plan is developed by a team that includes therapists. And so, you know, there's oversight, there's planning, and there's guiding ethics, even just by nature of being an employee of this organization. You know, like, we have obvious ethics as therapists, you know, I mean, we can't have dual relationships, we can't cross boundaries in the area of, obviously romantic sexual contact I mean basics right? And So having guiding principles and ethics around that, you know, is of the utmost importance.

    KC Davis 15:06

    Yeah, for for that reason, I think that I, most of the time would be more comfortable with someone that was an employee somewhere, right, like a coaching business with employees. Yeah, I'm not saying that there aren't individual contractors out there that are great. I'm just saying that like with an independent contractor, you have to do a lot more research, and have a lot more discernment when you look at them. And so I think that's like the good, right. So let's pause for a second here from our sponsors. And then I want to come back and talk about the bad and why I feel so apprehensive about coaching, even though I know it can be so helpful, you would think that like, one of the downsides to coaching are that coaches might dabble in mental health things that really they shouldn't, because they don't have that training, they don't have that education. And that's certainly one of the errors, especially when someone is a quote unquote, life coach, like it's kind of nebulous, like, What do you mean little life coach, like, there's not a specific skill set that they're focusing on? To help them develop? It's just general life coach, right? So you might think, you come across someone, and it's like, wait, but this person is a coach, and they have a Master's in Counseling. So like, that's the best of both worlds. And unfortunately, unless that person is also like, I know someone who is a therapist and a coach, but she maintains her therapy licensure, like, she still has a private practice. And she does therapy work. And then she also has a coaching business where she does, like cleaning, organizing, making appointments, and she does not take the same clients for both, okay, you can only be one or the other. And with that one, she is very clearly delineates, like, I'm helping you develop life skills. Yeah. And I'm talking about how you've organized your pantry and why it's hard to clean and how you're feeding yourself. And someone like that I would be comfortable with because if they were to do something unethical in a coaching space, like their board would still hold them responsible for that. Sure, right. Because it's like, oh, you know, you're a licensed therapist, and but you've got this like side gig where you're taking advantage of people. The part that makes me so nervous, is when a person has a Master's in Counseling, but they don't have licensure. And they're working as a coach.

    Heidi Smith 17:35

    Well, and then I mean, not and this isn't I'm not I don't mean this to be a wholesale judgment. But my first thought is like, Well, why don't you have a license? Yeah, and you know, because it's definitely something somebody who maybe has had their license removed, for, you know, who knows why, then it's like, they hang up the shingles coach. And so either way, I mean, whether they choose not to have a license or not, I would definitely want to look into the history there.

    KC Davis 18:01

    And, you know, I have to admit, like, this is 100% a prejudice on my part. But it's a prejudice based on experience. So I'm in no way saying that, like, every person out there, like, and I, you know, what I've actually heard a lot of is I came across someone the other day, and she was a black woman. And she said, You know, I have given up my licensure, because I'm uncomfortable with the position that puts me in when I'm working with people where I might get, you know, required to turn over medical records. Interesting. And here's the thing I don't I'm not like a marginalized population. And I certainly know that a lot of governmental systems are not set up to protect marginalized people. And so like, I think that's an interesting perspective. And so I'm not saying that anybody that, you know, decides not to get licensure. I also know like having ADHD, I can for sure, see someone who is trained and capable, that like, just couldn't get it together to get licensure. Sure. Sure. They couldn't do the admin part, maybe or get it renewed. Yeah, yeah. Or maybe they got a supervisor and their supervisor was really traumatic. And they just were like, Oh, God, I can't do this. Maybe they decided I want to be able to go to people's homes and help them with doing laundry. That's really my jam, like so. So please, if you're listening, it's not a wholesale condemnation. But I do want to share my experience. The only three people that I've ever known to hold the education of either being a therapist or a psychologist that did not hold licensure, all had sexual misconduct, yes, either before or after, right, some lost their license because of sexual misconduct and became coaches. Others never got their licensure. And then I come to find out that there's some sexual misconduct going on. Like truly that is and so that's why I personally am just like, now I have to say, all three of those people were men, heterosexual sis men. So that, frankly, may be more of a discussion for like, the red flags of like men that are not holding licensure that want to work with women. Yes. But then again, like, there's women out there like Teal Swan. Yeah, who certainly has some education? I think she has like a bachelor's in psychology or something ridiculous. Right? And, you know, she's pretty dangerous also.

    Heidi Smith 20:24

    Yeah. I mean, it's gosh, I mean, there's so there's, it's such a rabbit hole, when you go down, you know, the unethical things that we've seen in this industry, both coaching and licensed professional counseling or social work, and realizing, you know, when I was in school, you know, they talked so much about it during my ethics class. And I remember thinking, like, Who are these people that are like having sex with their clients? It just seems so like fantastical, you know, almost just like, that's got to just be like, you're one off, that never happened. I mean, you know, and then when I started working in the field, I mean, it's just it happens left and right. And, you know, realizing that this is that nobody's actually above it. And it's one of the things as a supervisor, and as a teacher that I've really, really been passionate about is helping people realize that you may think you're an amazing person with a great kind of ethical grid, but you find yourself in some blind spot. And it can happen quicker than you realize. And especially, you know, yeah, I mean, it happens to male therapists a lot. It happens to women therapists a lot.

    Speaker 1 21:35

    Yeah, if you've been practicing for any amount of time, and you can, like, I almost like don't believe someone who's been in practice, like, decades and decades, says that they've never been attracted to a client.

    Heidi Smith 21:46

    Oh, yeah. I mean, if you're not like, if you're open about, you know, that transference and countertransference, which is kind of a clinical term for, for that energy exchange, that happens and those feelings that happen in the context of the relation that therapeutic relationship. Yeah, I mean, that's, it's insane to think that your human beingness, you know, wouldn't show up in that context?

    KC Davis 22:10

    Well, it's interesting, because I think that would prevent like a counseling student or an intern or an associate from bringing up that they were feeling that is this fear that like, they're going to think I'm someone who is going to be unethical, but like the difference between therapists that are ethical, and there are like the difference between therapists that engage in sexual misconduct and therapists that don't, is not whether or not they've ever felt attracted to a client. It is whether or not they've ever been open with a peer about that and asked for, like, accountability around working out that transference.

    Heidi Smith 22:47

    Absolutely, and have a healthy amount of fear of themselves like, right, I'm not above this. I mean, I'm human, and I'm feeling a certain energy in this room that's scaring me. And I need to be open with it and seek counsel and seek supervision, and figure out how I can therapeutically navigate that or how I can end this relationship. And so I 100% agree. I mean, it's about the humility to be honest, and ask for supervision.

    Speaker 1 23:15

    And I think that's kind of what I hesitate or what scares me about the coaching field right now, as it stands being kind of like the Wild West, because you can find companies that offer certifications, you can find companies that offer training. But I think what the general public doesn't understand is like the difference between licensure and certification, like licensure is run by your state government. And they have big groups of people that come together to decide like what kind of education a person has to have, and what kind of training they have to have. And then there's this centralized place, where they oversee all the people that have licenses, and they're all under the same ethics. And if you report someone the same, you know, everyone gets the same kind of investigation. Whereas certifications, like certifications can be great. Like, I want to go to someone that has a certification for XYZ, I want to go like, if I did want to coach, I would want someone that had a certification. But the general public needs to understand that like, I, as Casey Davis could wake up tomorrow, make a PowerPoint presentation and offer a certification at the end. And people could listen to my

    Heidi Smith 24:23

    right and just print out a certificate. Yeah, like it's that easy.

    Speaker 1 24:27

    So you have to look when someone says I'm certified as a life coach, you have to go figure out like, let me Google that company like was that a coach that I interviewed? She did a nine month training. Yeah. supervise our boundaries? Yeah. Whereas other people can take a weekend course. Yeah. And so I think, you know, I really don't believe that, like fair, I think it's easy to get into that elitist space where it's like, therapists are better than coaches. And that's not true and they're different and the The kinds of people that are therapists are not different or inherently more ethical than the kinds of people that become coaches, it's just that there are systems set up within a licensure world to provide a place for that supervision so that people can talk about that, that provide a place where we know that everyone's getting that same education on those sorts of dangers. And there's that oversight so that if someone does mess up, we can.

    Heidi Smith 25:27

    Absolutely, and then there's, I mean, continuing education requirements. And you know, it's an ongoing, the license is an ongoing process. It's not a one time training over a weekend.

    KC Davis 25:39

    And what I would see sometimes with coaches, and it was typically again, it was older men who would do coaching. And often what I would see is they would work for organizations, but they would only be independent contractors, sure, so that when they kind of overstepped a boundary, there was no firing, there's no employment, like it can just move on record. Yeah, they just the person who usually approaches them, they don't want to make a big to do or a big hug, and they just go, you know what you need to go, we're not going to renew your contract, and they go, and they go to the next place. And there's not like this record of who's been investigating or who's been keeping up. And it's really unfortunate, they can go to a different state, and they can do this. And so that's why I feel sometimes really, I think it's really careful. I certainly, and again, I know this is prejudice, but it's one of those things where it's like, I'm sure there are really great, loving stray dogs, but like, it's still safer to say never pet a stray dog, because like, it's just not worth accidentally petting the wrong one. Sure, like, I just would never send a woman to get a coach that was a heterosexual sis man. And I'm sorry, to all of the men out there that maybe are the best coaches in the world that love to work with women, but like, I just never would. Yeah, it's too risky.

    Heidi Smith 26:55

    I don't know any, none of the coaches that I currently work with are referred to. It's all gender specific. And so I definitely, I think to err on the side of caution, you know, men coaches should work with male clients and female coaches should work with female clients. And that's not to say that's not failed.

    Speaker 1 27:15

    I mean, I have some room for like, well, and I have some room for identity too, like, sure. I've never seen like a gay man. Pray on a straight woman. Right. Yeah. And if you are, you know, and if you actually, yeah, yeah, that's true. Everyone can prey on anyone. Yeah. Or, you know, if you're a gay woman, like that's, that's a similar dynamic, working with someone who falls in line with who you would be attracted to. She would see in that air, you know what I mean? Like, I guess that's

    Heidi Smith 27:43

    who the potential lies for you to sexualize? Yeah,

    Speaker 1 27:46

    exactly. You know, I mean, the real question is, like, is this the type of person you would fuck? Right, let's be real, right? And not not even as a client. I'm not saying the client should ask that. I'm saying that like, yeah, the type of person that coach would fuck probably don't go with that coach. Yes, exactly. And again, not because y'all, there aren't some out there that are amazing and wonderful. I just would be hesitant, I think, because of I think the coaching industry will get there. Like, I think we'll get to a place where at least when it comes to like life skills, coaching, maybe we have a better set of guiding printed regulatory.

    Heidi Smith 28:22

    Yeah, well, and the interesting thing is, I mean, the only pitfall isn't even like, the idea of sexual integrity. But I mean, so many families I work with which I work in the addiction field, have been at least they claim now, I haven't done my own investigation. But you know, I talked to I work with young adults. And so I talked to moms and dads that have been burned financially by coaches, interventionists, you know, because interventionist is another, you know, and then worse, right, and case management. Yeah, that's another kind of interchangeable word. As you know, the in the addiction industry is the idea of these case management, people who kind of come in and get really involved with the family and help guide them as to how to deal with their son and where to send them and things like that. Now, I want to say, I mean, I most of the case managers, interventionists that I work with, obviously, if I'm working with them, I respect them and trust them, and so value, the space that they're in, in the work that they do, and they're needed. So I want to make that clear. But you know, there's bad X, and a lot of the abuse that I've seen actually has really been financial, hey, you need to pay me you know, $20,000 for a six month contract of case management, and then they don't do shit. It's like two phone calls a month, you know, I mean, and it's, and they can't ever get their money back. And so,

    Speaker 1 29:50

    yeah, and I'm kind of with you where it's like I so that like it's such a needed role, and I do value it. I just feel really, really bad for clients and families. Because you almost have to be like, someone like me someone like you someone inside the industry who's all connected to know what you're looking at. And that's unfortunate is like, there's no way to know what you're looking at.

    Heidi Smith 30:14

    Yeah, I mean, a family will call and tell us that they're working with a certain interventionist or certain case manager. And it's like, we all roll our eyes, you know, like to ourselves and just think like, oh, shit, it's not he's not the worst, but he's not the best. And you're probably not going to get your money's worth, and you know, and whatnot. And so yeah, it is, it's like, you have to kind of have your own experience your own insider information. And families get taken all the time.

    KC Davis 30:40

    And I always felt like, there's ton of like two kinds of people that become therapists, there are like people that have dealt with their own shit, then go, wow, I found that process so valuable. I would love to be the person that helps other people engage in that process. And then there's people that are like, they have not dealt with their own shit. And they have like a weird savior complex, and a very, like, it's the kind of people like you and I used to joke that, like, we would look around in counseling school and be like, some of you should just be rescuing puppies. Yeah, please like that. Like, like, just just don't like if you're, if that's what you like, just don't like if you really need to, like bleed heart all over someone, like go rescue puppies, like, don't do this, or that arrogance of like, I can help people, I can fix people, I can save people. And I feel like you run into that same thing when it comes to the coaching industry, where it's like, there's two kinds of people that become coaches, there's people who have, like, figured some stuff out and gone through some difficult times and came out the other end with a lot of wisdom, and a lot of practical skills, and realized, I love I've been telling my friend, I love this. Like, I feel like I could help people. And then the other person is like a person that goes through like their experience, and then believes that their experience is gospel and then decides, I just want people to pay me to tell them my experience.

    Heidi Smith 32:01

    Yeah, there's a lot of narcissists in this industry. And again, there's a lot of nurses licensed and not in every industry to I mean, you know, so it's like, it's hard to know, because they present well, and they sound good, you know, but sometimes they're definitely a one trick pony. You know, I mean, they what they have to offer is what worked for them. And that's kind of all they've, they've got.

    Speaker 1 32:24

    Yeah. So I wanted to share with you, at the end of this episode, I'm going to play the interview that I had with this coach. And I thought it'd be interesting for me to share with you like as I was looking at her website, like what I as a person who's really familiar with the industry, like saw that gave me like green flag vibes. Okay, right. Okay, I'm gonna pull it up. Hang on. So it's ADHD coaching. So off the bat, I love that there is a specific focus. Yes. Right. And on the front page, you can see prices and their per session. I like that. I'm not saying it's the only right way to do it. But I would say if someone's asking me to prepay for six months of something, yeah. Before I've had any experience with them, it raises, I'm more cautious. Yeah, absolutely. Like, I'm going to need them to really justify to me what that's about. And but right on the homepage, can you diagnose me? No, coaches do not diagnose? And there's a whole paragraph about that. Right? Do you work with kids? No, I do not work with kids. How do you know what you're talking about? And then there's a list of where she got some certifications, where she got trained a little bit about herself.

    Heidi Smith 33:33

    And so she's already saying on the website, what she doesn't do, which I think is yes, yeah. Here's what I do. Do and here's what I don't do. Yeah.

    Speaker 1 33:42

    And so when you go to her like sessions and services, you know, obviously, you have like the individual coaching sessions, and but then she has group coaching sessions and listen to that sandbox, a weekly group motivation session for neurodivergent creatives on Thursdays. It's four sessions per month, about what you pay, and then she has a price. Hype yourself up about your creative practice and hype others up. And it's just like a, you know, when you're feeling stuck, yeah. And I'm like that to me way green light, because it's like very much I'm a peer. And I'm gonna bring together other peers, and it's about like, pushing each other and encouraging each other and helping get unstuck from like, a creative process, or maybe a work process.

    Heidi Smith 34:27

    Well, yeah, and there's not a lot of clinical jargon, too. Yeah, that's another red flag for me is when I hear a coach talking, saying a lot of clinical jargon, like, you know, trauma, just even that it's like, well, you know, work on their trauma. It's like, are you gonna do you need to be working on their trauma, you know, so even just the words that and

    Speaker 1 34:45

    then the next thing is, yeah, there's no clinical jargon. Okay, so then we have group body doubling sessions, get more things done with other neurodivergent people. It's great for those who thrive on seeing other people's energy and progress. And I'm like, see, that's great. Yeah. If we're gonna get on a video call and get, you know, get something done around our house that we need to get done that's hard to motivate ourselves for. And then she also has a queer Joy support peer support group, where we get together and we pull from each other's collective wisdom, share weekly wins, and even make friends. So off the bat, I love that she has outlined some very specific skill takeaways that you'll get from her. It's not just I'm going to help you with your life. It's like, oh, she's really honed in on like, I'm here to facilitate I'm here to look at specific skills and help you get unstuck, so you can access those skills. I don't know, what are your thoughts on that?

    Heidi Smith 35:39

    Yeah, no, I mean, I love it. I think even just the words about you know, she used the word, we're gonna hype you up, and really motivating, and supporting is what the whole purpose is. And so I mean, I couldn't agree more that there's a lot of green flags there, in the way that she's presenting what she does in a really authentic way.

    Speaker 1 35:59

    I love it. One thing that is a red flag for me, and I don't even know that it means that it's always bad. But man, I've never met a spirituality coach that I trusted.

    Heidi Smith 36:12

    Man, that's such a gray area, right?

    Speaker 1 36:15

    And the reason is, is because by nature of the very like subject of spirituality, it's just too easy to create a power dynamic.

    Heidi Smith 36:26

    Yeah, I don't even what is I mean, I don't even know what is a spirituality coach. I don't like are they? Did they go to seminary? Are they trained and a specific?

    Speaker 1 36:36

    Yeah, I don't, might be might not be, but I'm thinking like all Teal Swan type characters. But others like that I've come across that maybe you're talking about teaching meditation, or that could turn into illness cult leader real quick. That's where I go, it just makes me nervous. Like, I would rather find a community to help somebody plug into Yeah, or a group something or another versus like a one on one, I'm going to teach you about spirituality just because again, like, it's so easy to get into this area where all of a sudden, it's like, I'm the person that holds the sacred knowledge. Right? And I know you better than you know, yourself. Yeah, yeah,

    Heidi Smith 37:16

    There's a lot of power and influence. When you start, you know, throwing around spirituality, I think there's an opportunity, it just depends. If a life coach is getting involved in helping somebody seek, taking, hey, let's go visit, you know, a Buddhist temple, and let's go visit a synagogue and let's go try out a mosque. And let's explore some different options here and see if anything fits. I think that's great, you know, versus somebody who's trying to guide and lead in a way that creates a power dynamic. And so, man, it's, it's so much of it is dependent on the person. And I think that's the good and the bad, right? It's like, I could see somebody being an amazing coach who helps somebody explore spirituality, if they had like, incredible integrity and ethics and kind of guiding principles of here's what I do. And here's what I don't do. If somebody is on a narcissistic power trip with very little insight into themselves, and they're a quack, you know, who's just out to make money. And there's no way to know that until there's like, kind of bodies laying in the background. Yeah, I mean, metaphorically, you know, until you've seen the work that they've done, and there's already been damage. And so it's, that's a hard learning curve, you know?

    Speaker 1 38:38

    Yeah. And I mean, that's true of any I mean, that's not even a coaching specific thing, like I, you know, because we all know, priests and pastors and all sorts of people in really it because it comes with that spiritual authority. Yeah. I think yeah, for a lot of people that goes hand in hand.

    Heidi Smith 38:55

    Yeah. And that idea of giving somebody spiritual consent and your life. I mean, you even get into that with 12 Step sponsors, sponsorship, you know, is like, I'm going to put myself in a vulnerable position and give this other person in my life, like a level of spiritual consent for them to give a feedback and explore this kind of, in depth area of my life. And so, there's, there's a lot of opportunity for abuse there.

    KC Davis 39:22

    I love that term, like spiritual consent, or even like emotional consent, because I'm kind of someone that believes that, like, it's okay to give a person feedback if they're doing something really harmful, like anyone, right? Like if if I know of a therapist, and I don't know them, but they're doing something harmful for me to be like, hey, I need to, like give you some feedback here. And if there is something I can do via their licensure, fine, but if I know someone else and like, it's not that like, I have to have someone's permission to like point something out to them. But I do think that when it comes to like, just areas of like, Hey, this is where I think you're wrong about something or this is where I think you need to grow about something or this is where I think You have like a mistaken belief about something. It's not that I can't point it out. But to me, the spiritual comes into it. Like, if that person then says like, Okay, thanks. Or they say like, no, that's not it. That's to me where it's like, I don't then get to like, push and argue with them. And be like, No, it is, and here's why. And here's, like, engage with them. Unless that someone who has given me that like spiritual consent, as a friend that has said, I welcome you to push back on me.

    Heidi Smith 40:29

    Yeah, that's fine. I mean, I think it's a great term, actually, I'm sure it's like a common term, but I learned it from my husband, my husband uses it a lot in that in the context of 12 Step sponsorship, and, and with your spouse, and with your friends, and that, like you're talking about that there's this small circle for me that, that I've allowed somebody in my life and given them that spiritual consent. We're like, you know what, I'm open, like, you have hold a place in my life where, like, you get to tell me the truth at any time. Like, I've given you that spiritual consent. I haven't always, it's not always like a formal conversation, you know, but it's sort of an unspoken thing where that happens in really intimate friendships and intimate relationships.

    KC Davis 41:12

    And now this is like a little off topic. But it reminds me of a conversation I had with a psychologist from Divine where we were talking about, like, the difference between taking accountability for something in your community and be like, having to, like, let people walk all over you and just like, treat you like dirt because you messed up. And like, who has the right to, like, tell you that your accountability is or isn't good enough, or any of that. And she had this great metaphor, and she was like, you know, it's important. Like if you're in your in your, like, home, and your spiritual home or whatever. And people are saying, like, hey, we need you to come out and talk about this. And like, taking accountability is like stepping out and like opening your door and letting people look in and be like, Yeah, okay, this is what's going on inside. Yeah. But that doesn't mean that you have to let anybody just anybody come in your house and start like rifling through shit. Right? Like that you need specific consent for?

    Heidi Smith 42:09

    Yeah, absolutely. That I think having those personal boundaries, which is a whole different podcast, you know, but to understand, like, who, who deserves spiritual consent, and my life, and, you know, again, a different podcast, but that idea that employers, you know, especially in the helping industry, I think, oftentimes think that this is a space where just because like we're working in the helping industry, like we're all we're gonna run our staff, like, you know, like a big spiritual feedback session all the time. And I think that can get very abusive very quickly. ,

    Speaker 1 42:46

    And that we're going to definitely do an episode on that, because I could talk for days on that.

    Heidi Smith 42:51

    Oh, I could do and I've been a victim of it as well, myself. Yeah. So that's not maybe a victim, but I've experienced it for sure. Yeah.

    Speaker 1 42:59

    Okay. Well, thank you, Heidi. I mean, I feel like that's a good overview of like, The Good, the Bad, the Ugly. I think the bottom line is, do your research. Yeah, honestly, whether it's a therapist or not, I just be aware of some of the potential drawbacks. I think that also what I've seen is I've seen someone get under the thumb of a really unethical coach. And then they're you, like you said, like, you look around, there's like bodies on the ground. And then they want recourse. Right. And it's like, and you have to, and I think that's where this comes from, like, so I hope people can kind of understand why I feel so cautious about this. But it's like, if you've ever had to break it to someone who had been truly, like, violated emotionally, physically, spiritually by signing it, if they financially by someone that they believed to be an expert coming to help them if you've ever had to break it to that person. Oh, actually, there's nothing you can do. There is no one that you could tell there is no way to stop them. There is no way to put a mark on their record. There is no way to alert the public. I mean, like there's no governing authority. Yeah, there is no yeah, like, it's just so difficult. It is yeah. So I just that's the thing that I want people to be aware of. And look at that. And so So next I'm going to sit down and talk to actually that ADHD coach and hear from them what they think about the bounds of coaching, their personal experience about sort of green flags that they see in the coaching industry versus some red flags that they see to help the people that are listening that might find coaching helpful to them, to make them feel a little bit more equipped to be able to pick out a coach. I can't wait. Thank you, Heidi. Thanks. Rachel, thank you so much for being here. Will you introduce yourself to the audience?

    Rachel Ambrose 44:44

    Hi, I'm Rachel Ambrose. I run for to like coaching. I used to hear they pronouns but I'm really happy to be here.

    Speaker 1 44:50

    I am really glad that you're here too, because I was just speaking with my friend Heidi. She's a therapist and both of us have worked with coaches before so we're going to start talking about like the good, the bad, the ugly and And I wanted to bring in a coach and talk specifically about some of the green flags and red flags that people can look for if they feel like a coach would be helpful to them. Yeah, absolutely. Let's

    Rachel Ambrose 45:09

    Yeah, get into it.

    Speaker 1 45:10

    Okay, so one of the things that I loved that you said, was the difference between whether or how someone is presenting themselves as an expert, can you talk a little bit about like green flags and red flags there?

    Rachel Ambrose 45:23

    Yeah. So obviously, when you go to a therapist, they are an expert in mental health in whatever their modalities are. And I think it's really important when people go to coaches that it's very clear that they and the coach are on the same level, for two reasons. A, I think that it's very important that the client is centered in the entire coaching relationship. And in order to center the client, the coach needs to make sure that there's no weird power dynamics at play. And so in order to do that, the coach really needs to meet the client where they're at, and be able to work with the client, following the client's lead. And if you style yourself as an expert, there's already sort of that initial assumption of oh, this coach knows more than me like this coach, like, somehow got like the magical tips and tricks that I've never heard of, and cannot ever come up with in my own brain. And that's not a place where I personally coach from, and that I think, is a particularly useful dynamic to engage in. And I think that centering the client and making sure that the client knows that they are fully empowered to take the lead, puts the client in a really interesting position, because I don't know about you. But so many times where we express struggled with being neurodivergent folks in neurotypical society, we're just sort of handed these boilerplate advice bits that don't actually help us out in the long term. And a coach should really empower the client to be able to explore and come up with their own best solutions.

    Speaker 1 47:21

    So one of the things that you mentioned to me when we talked was and I guess we would call it maybe like a yellow flag when we're talking about like, someone who presents themselves on this pedestal as an expert is kind of a red flag, you want someone who's appear, but also like, in the marketing, when you see language about like, try my proven method, right? Or like, it's like, it's okay, if somebody has a workshop or whatever. But sometimes in the marketing, you can tell that there's like intention to exploit somebody's vulnerability. And like, they talk about cures and fixes. And there's this really awful woman on Tik Tok right now, who is making tech talks about how like her son used to have autism. And he, you know, she has cured him. And if you want to book with me one on one consultations, and like, I will coach you through what to do, right? And so like, immediately, you know, we should have red flags about like curing like, probably not, right, no, absolutely not get in. And it's like, all of this, like, let me sell you MLM supplements. But that would be I mean, my first red flag is anyone who says it can cure autism, but that if somebody may be a new parent wasn't, you know, didn't know anything about autism. But that should be the first thing is like curing fixing. You know, you're inherently broken, but I have the magical answer that I've put behind this paywall.

    Rachel Ambrose 48:43

    Yes, yes, yes. subscribe to my newsletter, where I will break down five easy steps for you to work with your autistic child and cure them of their No, absolutely not. We don't do that.

    Speaker 1 48:57

    Yeah. Okay. You mentioned the issue of training, like, obviously, there's no licensure, there's no like, training across the board. But how can we look at if somebody says, like, Oh, I've trained, what can we look at to know whether that person maybe has worthwhile training or not?

    Rachel Ambrose 49:14

    Yeah, that's a great question. And I think that it requires clients to be so much more canny than they would be if they were having the same conversation with a therapist. Because, yeah, coaches should go to coach school, they should go to ADHD specific code school, if that's the particular niche that you're trying to get help in. And some really great programs out there include AGCA, which is the education program that I went through. It's a nine month process. If somebody tells you that they took like a weekend course and how to become a life coach. Don't book them. It's a really intricate process because it's a completely different way of engaging With a person, then the typical conversation with anyone else might go. And you should be learning from mentors and certified master level coaches. Some good things to look for include ad code, badging, or I act badging or PAC badging on a coach's website. And those are all training programs and credentialing programs that cater specifically to ADHD coaches.

    Speaker 1 50:30

    Thank you. So the last little category that you mentioned, when we were talking was the idea of like a coach's willingness to refer out.

    Rachel Ambrose 50:41

    Yeah, I think that my golden rule for coaching is no your lane, love your lane stay in your lane. And so I will refer out for two reasons. Well, many reasons, but two big ones. One is I say coaching and therapy can work side by side. But they but coaching cannot cross into therapy. And what I mean by that, specifically is in regards to trauma and mental illness in terms of biochemistry. So if a client were to come to me and say I have ADHD and depression, but my depression is really well managed. And I'm working with a therapist alongside your coaching, that's great, we can play ball. If a client comes to me and says, I have ADHD and depression, I've been in a in and out of therapy for some time currently out of therapy. Yeah, we can give it a shot. And if it turns out that the depression is in need of adjustment, or if there's trauma that comes up within the course of the coaching relationship, I will immediately refer out because I can work with we can we can talk about trauma during the context of a session, I do not process trauma at all, I don't touch it. That is for people who are way more qualified than I am. And it they they should be able to be accessed. I've even sat on client calls where they have opened up like psychology today with me, and I bought it out with them while they have made those initial reach outs to their local therapists.

    Speaker 1 52:32

    So there's one thing that you said that I highlighted when you and I were emailing back and forth, and I just want to kind of read it and then have you maybe expand on it for our last little spot here. But you said, another really important element of coaching is its concreteness, a client might want to work on their blog, for example, a coach would say what specific things would you like to get done on the blog between this session and next, what feels sustainable, what feels like something that could fit easily into your schedule this week, once the client has narrowed down what they might be a realistic goal for the timeframe, the coach might offer to check in with them a few days and see how it's going. I love how you put that because I think what can be hard is like a therapist can do therapy. And they also sometimes provide what can what is kind of like coaching, like they can give you practical, practical advice, actionable advice, but they can also do the like, Hey, we're not going to necessarily take action items, we're going to like delve in and talk about feelings and talk about psychology. And so I appreciated that you brought that up, because I think if somebody is working with a coach, and they're not walking away with concrete, actionable things, then that will kind of raise a flag about like, what am I doing with this person? Like, what are they trying? Like, there's no ambiguous healing this person can give me right, like there should actually be walking away with concrete things. And so can you talk to that for just a second?

    Rachel Ambrose 53:54

    Yeah. So I think that having a specific outcome within the course of a session is a really important distinction from therapy. I personally have never walked into a therapists office and had the therapist sit me down and say, Okay, what are we talking about today, and whether it's, you know, mindfulness or whatever the topic may be, okay, what would be a successful metric for you to walk out of this session with, and then partnering with the client to make sure that they get there. And I think that, like people who are not familiar with coaching or have never been coached before, that can be a really important distinction to make between a coaching session and a therapy session, because it's, the client is totally in the driver's seat. And the coach is just there to make sure that they get to where they want to go. And then it's like, okay, like we've gotten to this action plan and now you have some concrete steps to go and work on your blog. And do you need any support from me? In order to fully accomplish this task over the next few days.

    Speaker 1 55:04

    Yeah, that's really helpful. It reminds me almost of like when you go bowling and they have like the bumpers that they can braid as it's like, this is you and your journey, you're going down the lane, but like, I can help act as those bumpers of like, you know, setting concrete goals, checking in with how you're feeling, checking in with, you know, what you're thinking and being maybe some accountability, maybe some different perspectives. Like I like that idea of, you know, I'm moving, I'm in charge of my journey. But from a practical sense, like, I need someone to kind of help me with these practical things as they go through. And again, like practical things are going to include like, Hey, I'm anxious about this, or I'm telling myself that I'm not good enough to do this. So like, yeah, as a coach, you're going to come up with those sorts of things. And so knowing how to talk to someone about those things is okay. But you know, I think that you're right, it just takes a good coach to know, you know, when are we talking about, hey, let me offer you a different perspective. Or let me share my experience with feeling like I wasn't good enough. Let me encourage you, you know, Hey, have you ever heard, you know, here's a saying that I heard that really helped me like at that versus getting into like, well, when? When was the first time you thought you didn't feel good? Right. So that's really helpful. Yeah, that's really helpful. So I'm

    Rachel Ambrose 56:18

    I like to say that coaching is for the present and future you whereas therapy sometimes can focus more on the past? Like I would never ask, like, when was the first time that you felt like you weren't good enough? Like, you know, that deep historical self narrative isn't really for coaches to touch a lot of the time. But if you are having issues with adjusting your expectations when it comes to like cleaning your kitchen, we can dig into maybe where those internalized expectations are coming from and whether they're appropriate for you to continue having and what you might want to replace them with.

    Speaker 1 56:59

    Yeah, that's helpful. Rachel, thank you so much. Where can people find you if they want to learn more about your services?

    Rachel Ambrose 57:05

    They can find me at my website is welcome to the porchlight.com and they can find me on Instagram at porch dot light dot coaching.

    KC Davis 57:15

    And you do ADHD coaching?

    Rachel Ambrose 57:17

    I do and audio HD coaching. I work with people who have the combo meal of ADHD and autism as well. Awesome.

    KC Davis 57:25

    Well, thank you so much, Rachel.

KC Davis
38: Interview with the White Woman Whisperer

Racism. You may think you know what it is and in what ways it exists in our society, but it is a deep and multi-faceted topic. We could spend hours trolling the depths of language, attitudes, behaviors, and nuances that are influenced by race. We are attempting to explore and learn more in today’s show. I’m joined by Rebecca Slue, also known as the White Woman Whisperer. You may know her from TikTok, which is where I found her. We connected when I took an anti-racism course and reached out to her for help, and I’ve already learned a lot from her. Join us for more from Rebecca’s perspective.

Show Highlights:

  • An example of how KC got into a quandary over comments on social media and the fear of being labeled as a racist

  • How amazing conversations are happening when we aren’t concerned about perfectionism in our words

  • What we need to understand about white supremacy

  • How Rebecca uses a caste system model of values to understand the behaviors that perpetuate white supremacy

  • Why our understanding of anti-racism is a journey and not a destination

  • Rebecca’s experience of racial identity as she grew up the child of Jewish and Jamaican parents

  • How Rebecca’s experience played out when she entered corporate America

  • How she became the White Woman Whisperer

  • How racism created a holistic layer of chronic stress for Rebecca

  • How Rebecca uses a  metaphor to explain white fragility, white privilege, and the pinata of white supremacy

Resources and Links:

Connect with Rebecca: Website and Podcast, Instagram, TikTok

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient balls of Stardust, welcome to Struggle Care. It's the podcast about self care and mental health by a host that hates the term self care, and doesn't always have great mental health. I am here today with a friend of mine named Rebecca and you may know her as the White Woman Whisperer on Tik Tok. So hello, Rebecca.

    Rebecca 0:25

    Hello, KC. I'm glad you're here today. I'm glad I'm here, too. But we recorded an episode together that ended up being so long. Because you and I can't stop talking. Isn't that great?

    KC Davis 0:39

    problem to have? I'll take it. Yeah, I think so we'll do our best to be professional podcasters. Okay, so for the listeners, Rebecca and I met, I was actually taking a course an anti racism cohort. And there was like this section about black history. And at the end, it was like, reach out to a black person in your network and ask them, like, how were they taught black history? And so I sat there and I was like, okay, and I don't know why you came to mind first, but I was like, and I didn't really even know you that well. Also, that's a real humbling moment in your anti racism cohort where they're like a black person in your network, and you're like, oh, shit, I

    Rebecca 1:22

    gotta find, find. And I'm like, what black person in my network is not going to be offended by me being like, Hey, you're black. I was told to find the black mine.

    KC Davis 1:37

    And I remember being like, Okay, you and I had exchanged some messages. And you were making like, anti racism content. So I felt like, okay for white women to I mean, yeah, I felt like, okay, safe bet. Yeah. And I was in that phase, which I still am sometimes where I'm like, terrified of making a mistake. Yeah. I get that. It's fun when you bring your like perfectionism and to anti racism work. Oh, yeah, that's the killer. That will do it for you. But I was so happy to see the message from you. And I know that was so weird. But I mean, I was open, especially it was the beginning. I was so naive and innocent and excited. And you know, you were one of my first Mutual's where I was like, I think I may actually be doing something here. Like, it's got the right vibe. I like what she's doing. Like your content inspired a bit of my content in terms of moral neutrality, and not that perfectionism in terms of even being a black person. So it just made a lot of sense. I was like, Alright, let's see what this is going to be like. The questions were interesting, though. Well, and you quite literally had a huge role and a turning point for me like it was, gosh, it must have been like a year ago now. Like it was a while ago, it was a while. And I had a woman call me out because I had made a video where I had referenced having locks when I was like, 19. And I was kind of making a joke out of it. But the joke was just like, look at this thing. I did. Oh, my God, I was 19. And she left a message about like, hey, this doesn't sit right with me. You're like making light of it. But it's like kind of a big deal to some of us. But the problem was, is that I just like glanced at her profile. Well, so first, I was like, Okay, I hear you. And I took the video down. And then she started commenting, being like, Hey, you're not being accountable. You're not doing this, you're not doing that. And she was really passionate about it. And I mistakenly, because I just kind of glanced at her profile picture thought that she was a white woman. And so I came out like guns blazing, like, you know, how I would talk to some because sometimes that happens, like other white women want to like outwork me. Oh my gosh, yes. They try to outwork me so and I just don't have a lot of tolerance for it. I bet.

    Rebecca 3:54

    I bet I come out quick to especially when you see a lot of comments all the time. It happens it happens. Turns out, she identified as MCs. She was like, No, I'm talking about my culture, my own experience, like you have actually offended me. And anyways, details of this are not important. But basically, you know, I talked to her we sort of worked it out and I'm in an apology and but what started happening was that like, you know, on tick tock, the peanut gallery like everybody, oh, actually, I just learned that the peanut gallery is like a racist term as well. So that's not the best term to use. So did I. Okay, so lots of commenters. All the sudden I was getting flooded with comments that were like half of them were like, This is no big deal. You should not be making like, just let it go. And then half of the comments were like, yeah, no, you need to like do something about this. This was really horrible. And I was in that period of my anti racism journey where I was really into like, listen to black people, listen to black people, but the split was all black people. It was like half of the white people saying that my comment saying like, nor that girl is just making too big of a deal of it and then half of them

    mean, like knows is very, very serious. And so I was like, paralyzed. And I was like, What do I do? I don't know what to do. And I happened upon your content at that time. And I started like binge scrolling your content. And you had this one video where somebody was saying to you like, I'm so afraid of making a mistake. I'm so afraid of saying the wrong thing. And you had said to her, like, I mean, what's the worst that could happen? If you make a mistake, if you say the wrong thing. And she was like, well, like, I don't like when I'm trying to do the right thing. And people mistakenly think I've done something racist. And so like, now they think I've done the wrong thing, even though I've done the right thing, and she literally looks at the camera and you were like, you'll be fine.

    Right? Even if all of that is true, you will be fine. You will literally be okay. In the real use of literally, you are on this is the safest I can be as a black woman is on the internet. And for white women to say they're scared, especially afraid. This type of language of being disliked by a black person may be at worst case, you know, they don't like you. Okay, they yell things on the internet at you and, and the mistake your intentions, they will get over it and probably not even yell at you to be honest, when we make jokes, and you'll feel a little silly. And that's your moment. What do you do with that I've had some amazing comebacks, not comebacks isn't clap backs, or call outs, but people just go, oh, I messed up. And then they get so much respect from restraint. And just to you know, I remember when there was a big tick tock drama, and you reached out and told me that you had utilized some of my work to just not, and that you were so grateful that you had made the choice to not do something is amazing. And it's like, oh, all I want to see come out of this is like it can be easier than this, like what you guys are doing is daunting, because what perfect dialogue are you expecting to have, where you know exactly what's going to happen, what the other person is going to say, that's also a problem with that sentiment to me, you know, we're gonna be mad, or you know, what we're gonna do? You know, we deal with physical violence and generational fear. I'm not so concerned about being insulted or offended. These aren't words that we're focused on.

    Yeah, that was the part that really sort of, like shook me out of that moment was that and I get it, like social rejection, even perceived, like our nervous system that hits hard, it can feel sometimes like the same thing as physical danger, because that's how desperate we are, you know, that's how much worth at stake for us. But the reality is, is that if a white person mistakes, your intentions in real life, that can can and does lead to violence, right? You could be jogging through a neighborhood, and if a white man mistakes, your intentions, decides they don't like you, that leads to violence. And for me, if I do something, and a black person mistakes, my intentions, I'm gonna be fine. Maybe they don't like me, but like, Okay, I don't think that's

    a stretch, you know, we don't know you're on the internet, is it? We don't know, you. And I think some of that is, you know, check the self importance there. You know, black people are trying to live and survive and get through generational trauma. And we're finally able to speak our minds. Without that fear of physical harm happening the moment we speak. And that's why you see so many amazing conversations happening. If you're listening to Black Tech Talk, not because they haven't been had before, it's just that the voices have been silenced. So, you know, we throw things out there. We're not concerned about perfectionism in our conversation. And I am not concerned with perfectionism because I'm like, Who knows when they're going to shut this down and stop listening. I need to get this information out there. And if you think about the intentions of black people, when they speak, which never happens, you will find that it's actually not that hard to listen and move forward from there. But I feel like the intention conversation happens after an offence or wrongdoing has already been pointed out. Now we want to talk about intention, but what about my intention on making the video that you got upset about, you know, why did I do that? And no one I don't see that in those who get upset. You know, I see that obviously from those who are doing the work, but

    Well, in that moment, like I felt as though like I had spoken to her privately we had had a conversation about like, I bungled this how can I make this right? And so she and I had already had that conversation, and the leftover Panic was just my image, my PR like all of these people in the comment section, where I was wanting to prove myself I I was wanting to defend myself I was wanting to say like, no, here's how you're wrong, you think I am an A. And that's where like that tick tock, you may and I think even messaged you about that. So I was like, this just saved my life. Because I was able to take a beat, and just learn to tolerate that it felt bad that these people and I want to say theoretical, they're not here, but there are literal people, but they're also like, not people I know that like, affect my life in any way. So it's just like the idea that theoretically, a black person could think that I was racist. It was like causing me genuine panic. And I think the most eye opening thing in my journey of going through that cohort and of listening to creators, like you was realizing in any moment, like my clarifying question was like, okay, am I concerned about how to actually impact like black liberation for good? Or am I concerned about being liked and approved of by black people?

    Right, by every black person? Because you have you have it like you admittedly had black people on your side. And I want you to consider that a lot of those black people that were not happy with you, or an actual black people. So I know we talked about they are people, but I find a lot of they know how afraid white people are of messing up and having a black person not like them. So often, I will have people come into my comments and start a phrase with as a black woman, I don't agree with you. And got to tell you, that gives you a way right there. We don't walk into the room and announce our race and gender because it's there in front of you every single day. How we speak, is what tells you that but I often have digital blackface happening in my comments, to shut maybe other white people down who are coming to my aid or trying to explain though, throw in a I'm black at the end. Yeah, then you know, cannot capitalize the B and then make, you know, never the math doesn't math. But I know that it does silence people. So there's that too.

    Well, it's so true, because the woman who had made the original comment was a light skinned mixed woman. But like even she didn't feel the need to say I'm black. Right? And this bothered me, right? Which was where you know, right? Like, you do not qualify at all people, you'd think that she would feel like she had to qualify yourself. And she's like, No, I'm black. I'm mixed. And she identified as mixed. But she also talked about being black, which is why I'm using them interchangeably. But so that's just interesting to reflect back on that show. Like, I'm talking about myself.

    It's one of those funny things. I remember in the beginning, I said, You know what's funny, I realized that white women walk into the comment section announcing themselves all the time, it was just like a funny thing to me just like, hey, I'm pale and or I'll come in with, like, a funny description for why I'm a white woman. And this I'm neurodivergent. And this, you know, some qualifier. And that is a sort of like characteristic, I believe of white supremacy now that I can see it in bulk and realize that we never do that. I've never felt the need to start with why you should listen to me. But in whiteness, your category comes first. And it's always

    with our like, white as faces in the profile picture to like, I didn't need the descriptor, Sally.

    I know, for so many other reasons in the beginning of your sentence, you know, I know what you sound like, I know the talking points, I see the picture. I mean, what you're going to speak to is probably going to let me know you're not going to use a v you know African American Vernacular English. Oh, and the way we're gonna get into that the literal understanding of black languages is another thing we could work on in comment sections. But that's for later times.

    I have this like line and I've never actually said it to anybody, because I'm not sure how appropriate it is. But it's, I think it in my head, especially when like because I've seen someone say something that is racist, and maybe to them they wouldn't recognize it as racist. Like, they would recognize it as like, oh, maybe it's a microburst, like no, it's just all racism. And when they're called out, and someone uses a she her pronoun, they'll get really angry about like, I'm actually not she her, like, either they'll say I am a man or I don't use those pronouns, or my favorite is like, why would you assume I'm a woman? And you know what I say in my head, and you can tell me, like she just say someone I always want to be like, I mean, white woman is as white woman does exactly. Like, I don't care if you're actually a woman or a man or white or whatever. Like I'm just saying,

    because no one identifies as white once they're pointed out as white. And the other thing is, I'll just be talking to someone and say, Hey, you're wrong, and they'll say, Why do you assume I'm white? Okay, I didn't mind. You know, it's not even a thing, right? Like, no one's technically white. So the moment you get called out and you say, I'm not this, it's like, okay, well, you're white enough for me. Okay. You could be black and be white enough for me because the conversation is is about white supremacy and white supremacist behavior to me, not about people, individuals, or you know what you're about, I can't take the time and focus that much on individuals, I'll never get anywhere, I have to focus on behaviors, especially if I see them over and over and over again, I don't need to know much about you to address this talking point, that there's always this special,

    I want to talk a little bit about white supremacy. But I want let's take a pause real quick. And we'll be right back. Perfect. Okay, we're back. And when we talk about that term, white supremacy, I feel like I can like hear my white listeners like their little toes curl. Because a lot of us were really taught growing up to believe that white supremacy is believing consciously that black people are inferior to white people, that white people should sort of rule that it should be this like very Hitler asked, like white Aryan society, with our little pointy cloak hats and burning crosses. And it has been very eye opening to me to talk about white supremacy as something more than that. So do you have like a working definition that you use with white people about what it means when we talk about white supremacy?

    Hmm, I do not have a working definition. And I also don't have a cute analogy for it yet? Well, I guess I do, I will, in a basic sense, I like to formulate it around the behavior I'm trying to address. So white supremacy is foundational to the conversation we're trying to have. If you're interested in reading the book cast by Isabel Wilkerson, I suggest reading from black people that are alive today. One, and she is and it's to understand it as a system, a caste system so really don't even have to discuss race or racism, if you discuss it as a caste. It we saw a caste systems see them in India, and we see them in Nazi Germany, and here in America. And she reviews the three as systems that you can see, as a set of behaviors, laws that were put in place based on this specific caste system for us was white male property ownership. Based on those three things, we will now formulate the rules in order to dictate behaviors that will continue this value system. If that makes sense. I like to envision it as a pyramid. And the bottom is just like white supremacy. And then our laws and our institutions are created based off of that, so that we make sure our education system is based off of that our financial institution, our healthcare system, everything comes with the assumption that the white men that created it, that their characteristics, and what they saw as important is across the board.

    That's like the most powerful definition I've ever heard, honestly, which is impressive for starting out with I have no definition.

    This is usually how I just kind of we get there.

    I know. But no, you're right, because it's this idea that it's a value system. And that. And I think about that sometimes when people talk about the Constitution, when they'll like some argument about whether or not we should do something in our country, we'll be like, well, but that's not what like the Constitution says this. And that's not what they meant, not what they want. And sometimes I just want to be like, what if it's just like,

    it was a bunch of dudes in a room just because they wore different clothes and had white curled up hair that didn't make them special. And I think we have, you know, made them this mystical dudes. And if they were in button downs and khaki pants, would you see that constitution as some magical piece of paper that they had more information than we have?

    Like if Elon Musk and Bill Gates, and like George Bush and Jeff Bezos, like walked out of room be like, we have a document? Yes. And this is how we're gonna run everything. And I mean, listen, I think that there are parts of the Constitution that are inspirational and beautiful, but it's not like they intended that to apply to anyone but them,

    right, it's, and then set up all the law is based off of that, and the small number and the size of that triangle. Yeah, it can grow, but it can't really change. It's just gonna get like, taller and fewer. And because it's based on this static, nonsensical, imagination based value system. It's not based on what

    is perfectionism. Like, when I first started sort of learning about racism, and being willing to believe that I had unconscious racist beliefs, one of the things that I realized was causing that like now I'm too afraid to make mistakes. Now, I don't want to say anything to anybody. Because what if I make mistakes and I don't want people to not like me. And it was pointed out to me like that level of perfectionism that you think if you can't be right, you're going to be cast aside and rejected and that Will Make You worthless. And so you're clinging to it like that is a value of white supremacy.

    Yes, you will never achieve that. That is a trend. Not

    every culture has that value, right? Sometimes just

    making it, just figuring it out. And what does that look like for you? Who are you the system? You know, I thought about the phrase, there's no I in team. Why do we like that? I am important, okay. In a team, if there's no if we're just doing whatever we're told to do, you have no opinion that is valuable. And it's just not true if you hadn't decided to make a tic toc. And I hadn't decided to make a tic toc. Because you know what? Might as well, and to expect perfectionism, we will never move. I would never put out anything, you wouldn't ever put out anything. And we just stay quiet. sounds gross. sounds gross. I don't want that

    my first tech talks were me being like, this is how you cook chicken. And then the conversation would be like, That's not how you cook chicken. And I'd be like, just kidding. Here's another way to cook chicken. Like I just, I genuinely started doing how to one being like, I'm just making this up. Like, this is what I think I know. And it's funny.

    Once you realize, if you can't do it, like there's no Oh, I like to say there's no destination. So people look at it as like, I'll get to this place. Like how do you get comfortable talking about this? When do you finish where now you're like, I'm good. And that's just not how life should be because there is no destination, anywhere. It should be about the journey. And it should be about making those mistakes and then highlighting those mistakes. This would not be an impactful demonstration of anti racism if you didn't say I did this, and then I did this instead. And now I feel better. If you just went in with how do i i wouldn't be able to really work with that. Because you are a part of it. Everybody is can I tell

    you a totally tangential joke, please do. So when the Little Mermaid like preview came out and I hadn't seen it yet. And they were talking about the like Little Mermaid being black. And for like a hot couple of weeks. I thought we were talking about Halle Berry.

    Well, okay, that's reasonable because itself but here's

    what sounds exactly like, but what's funny to me is like when I realized it wasn't the same person my first thought was like, Casey, like, you need to get real serious about your anti racism work like not every black person is the same just because it seems like God, like see black people as people. And then like, but so I was like kind of being very somber with myself about like, let's look at ourselves. And then I realized that like, I also thought that like Josh Groban and Josh Brolin were the same person. Yeah,

    I mean, give her that everything that's serious.

    And I just recently found out that the lead singer of Florence in the machine did not star in a movie with Harry Styles. Oh, that is in fact, not the same person. Even though her name is Florida. So anyways, I was just laughing at myself, because my initial thought was like, Wow, we got to do some work. Like

    no, just stupid. No, just stupid. Not this one. But I liked it. You're out here. I like you're on the lookout.

    I showed up to the game. There may not have been a game that day. But I was in my uniform. I was ready. Close. It was close when it was close. Okay, okay, we're gonna do the same thing. We did the last podcast, which is Chuck, I have actual questions here. Okay, let's go. One of the things that I loved learning about you was your experience of your own racial identity growing up, so can you tell us about your mom and your dad?

    I can. So my mom is Jewish from Brooklyn. And my father is Jamaican, who also moved to Brooklyn, but was born in Jamaica came here when he was 15. And they somehow found each other. He also was a Jehovah's Witness growing up, which adds a cute little element of fun. The whole X cult life, and my grandmother died still a part of Jehovah's Witnesses, they live together. That was interesting as well as you know, nice little Jewish kids. We worked it out. So just based off that alone, I kind of was prepared for this non traditional life that I did not realize was so foreign, because I grew up mostly in Teaneck, New Jersey, which was the first town to voluntarily integrate their schools. Very proud of that. I grew up with so many biracial friends just because we were friends not because we were biracial. We just happen to be a black Japanese girl a bunch of I was the only Jewish person that was brown in my Hebrew school, but I was okay with it. I was fine. You know, I did ballet and maybe I was the only Brown Girl No, probably not but one a few and I knew that. I knew I was brown. And I would say Brown. You know, when brown Cinderella came out was brown Cinderella, not black to me when Brandi was Cinderella, but when my brother was born, he was very white looking And I was aware, you know, maybe not when he was first born, but even my father would say, I'd asked him, you know, what if, when we learned about Martin Luther King, what if it goes back and you and I Dad are not allowed in the same places mom and Brandon are. And he told me, I didn't know what to say to you, because he hadn't realized that I had realized. But by that point, I mean, my hair was different. I'm a child, I'm not an alien. And so when we have these conversations about if kids should be learning, it's like, well, they are, you know, they can see, I can see things with my eyeballs. And he just said, you know, that'll never happen. And I was like, okay, good. We're in this new world. We're all good with this multiracial family, it's never gonna go back. And I don't have to worry about

    it. And how did that change? When you entered corporate America in the Midwest?

    Oh, my goodness. Well, you know, and it's, I think, corporate America period is a big shift. And I didn't realize at first, you know, it's like one of those things where in hindsight, it's very clear, I wore my hair straight. If you don't know my hair is very curly. Right now. i It's in its natural state has been since I was 26, though, because the world tells you, as a black woman, what your hair needs to look like, it needs to be fixed and professional. Another one

    of those white supremacy, values, professionalism, not being professional, but what professionalism means what kinds of things are professional,

    it's not what you wear every day. It's not how you look every day. It's how that guy looks every day. And what they naturally do you have to look like it to me, it's if you are living in your black self, and you are you have this rich experience a deep colors, like how I like to think about it, and like blacks in this depth of something. And then you go out into the world and into corporate or into the professional world. And it's pastel white supremacy to me is pastel. Yeah, there may be variations and colors, but you know, it's all pastel, it's got this light tint to it. And that keeps it all even in the same family. So when we show up to work, we have to powder ourselves up to be as pastel as possible. And make sure we do not disrupt that powder, we don't move too fast, we don't take any off because the second you, you know if you can see through that, we get called out on it, and are made to feel as though we don't belong in that place. And we can see through that powder you're wearing and you're not really one of us. And that is exhausting to turn that power down and have to not knowing why. Because your value is based on how pastel you show up is hard for the brain, at least for my brain, because I understood. You know, if you do something, well, it will be reflected as such. And someone will say, Hey, you did a good job on this. You know, you can't get past that. But with professionalism, you can get past that. I can do everything right.

    Yeah, I remember you telling me that you were like kicking butt taking names, you were putting out more measurable like KPI output than everyone else on the team, including the people that were supposed to be your managers.

    Yep. And that was a mistake. That was a mistake. Somehow, I didn't learn the rules of professionalism. I was the first person in my family to go to college and to graduate. And then I went to business school, and I thought I was doing something by you know, wearing my currently natural hair at business school. And I was very proud and forthright about my blackness, and that I am here to change things, but also to do a good job. And to have these conversations. And it does not matter. Because of this little thing that I call pet to threat someone else is going to because it's great to have you on be all black women and look at your hair, and then a little bit of the actual petting and the touching that happened here in Chicago did not happen in New Jersey, that you want to start kind of speaking back on it and making your presence known and being very good at the job. Now you are a threat to those who need to see themselves as higher than you. And I did not know that was going to happen. I thought it would make us all look good. But if you're focused on hierarchy, and you're focused on the fact that you are my manager, and now you can't instruct there to desire to help from white people is what I see in this hierarchical structure. If you're a higher than someone, your role is to help them and I would rather have had support, but because you know, I'm good at what I do. I always have been that's how I got there. And then to show up and have a white man asked me if I'm scared of PowerPoint, or if I know that this email is my canvas. And this is where I can show my skills and write out things. Meanwhile, I just you know, one plus one wasn't equaling two and my brain was not what was truth. I didn't know what truth was anymore. That to the point where it's like I I am doing so much and being treated so little, like such a little thing I was told them this I was very forthright and professional, I brought it to HR with HR language. But none of that matter, just like when we talk about on tick tock, you can put everything right. And at the end of the day, he will say, well, I need to help you understand what I'm trying to tell you. You need to have empathy for me in this situation, because I have kids, and I am working through stuff as well. You know, meanwhile, there's protests, and I'm speaking on behalf of black people at work. So I know this is kind of all over. But you know, there was a pandemic, and I'm doing my job. And I'm also educating white women at this job, which made me realize I could do this work as white woman whisperer. So you know,

    who hid and they asked you to do that. Right? They asked me to do

    it. Yes. They want awards based on what I did. Was I the recipient of that award award? No, they won multiple awards off of my work, but somehow still, but then you weren't a team player, right? I wasn't, you know, maybe a cultural fit. I wasn't spending my time, the way I was supposed to listening and obeying, I guess, rules that did not exist, you know, there was silent treatment, but then also micromanaging at the same time. And he just, there was no right way. And I needed that lesson. But I would rather other black women in the workplace not get the lesson I got in the way that I received it, especially these younger generations, it was terrible.

    So I want to take a pause there. And when we come back, I want to talk about the impact that had on your mental health. Okay, we're back with Rebecca, the white woman whisperer. And I mean, okay, so this is the struggle care podcast, right? Like, my book is how to keep household drowning my tic toc channel, it's really all about how to do life and care for yourself when you have barriers in your life. And so I have a lot of people that follow me that have mental illness, mental health issues, that are neurodivergent that are stressed, that are, you know, maybe they have kids, or they just lost somebody or they're chronically ill.

    So there's like, all these different reasons why, you know, you could be experiencing, like limited capacity or barriers in your life. And one of the things that I've learned from you and other black creators on Tik Tok and like authors, and is that the racism isn't just like some uncomfortable thing you experience that it creates this holistic layer of chronic stress. And so can you talk a bit because you had taken a leave from how much stress that caused? So what did that do to your mental health?

    Well, it wasn't great. I'll tell you that much. It definitely wasn't great. It wasn't a good time. But, you know, I'm just so grateful that during that time, I had my boyfriend, who is black and very educated in the black experience. From a generational information standpoint, he came from the south, and went to an HBCU, a historically black college university. And when I was on the brink, I had someone to say, No, this isn't about you. Because I was so sure that I was doing something wrong. Even though I would stay up, I would hyperventilate before work, because as you know, knowing I had to talk to them, I said, in my head, there was something I there was a correct phrase that I had to say, to get them to understand, you know, because it was not just my manager, it was his manager, and the communications between them and the gaslighting of, you know, I get your side, I get his side. And so then I, you know, trying to figure out how to make two people think something is not possible. One, I found out through a lot of therapy, and I'm still in therapy over it, because there's, we are taught that good work, should receive good things, at least I was, and maybe in terms of my neurodivergent. See, I've relied on that. I relied on the fact that regardless of race, regardless of gender, you do the right thing. People can't ignore that. Because it's right.

    KC 34:15

    You work hard, you

    Rebecca 34:16

    raise up the ladder, right? You pull yourself up, all you got to do and I saw another aspect of this was, you know, I would go to many people who said they supported me at this job that won awards based off of me, I would talk to them, what am I doing? What can I do? A lot of white women mostly because that's what I connected with that work. And there weren't many other well, there weren't many of the black people. But if there were, it's kind of like, you know, just stick it out. What did you expect type of thing and I didn't work well with that. But it was always framed as what I could do. You know, if I would go to the VP of HR and say, Hey, this is happening. The response was okay, how can we get you out from under him? As in What job do you need to do? Like, what job can you apply for within the company that gets you out? And it can't make him look back? And you can't burn that bridge. But you also how are you going to framework for the conversations with him moving forward, because you do need his recommendation to get this job. But you are amazing, you cannot leave. We are so happy to have you, you are changed so much. No one said, I'm gonna go talk to that man. No one gave me a way out. There was a lot of victim blaming, if you do that, but so I started not trusting myself, I'm not seeing it. from a higher perspective. I'm just seeing, I'm crying in front of so many people as a black woman. And I'm thinking one of these conversations it's gonna hit. And that's tough.

    KC Davis 35:40

    I mean, it really says it. As a therapist, it sounds so similar to when I have counseled families that have like abusive dynamics, where like, the man is really abusive. And the child is constantly being given this burden of Well, here's how you can navigate his anger so that you stay safe. And the wife is often like the nice white lady who's like, I get it. I know it's wrong. I'm so sorry. Right, but they won't leave him and take you with them. Right? They won't stand up to them. And they're similar products, like different but similar reasons where it's like, oh, I can put my own oppression on the line.

    Rebecca 36:22

    I mean, I'm thinking you don't you want to know if this person is being disrespectful to me and demeaning me just to make a point. And I'm telling him, and he's pretending to write things down. And then he lies and says, I called this meeting to HR when I did, and the HR person is on there, not correcting him, listening to him, gaslight me the whole time, and then claim that I'm not understanding him correctly. And I didn't know gaslighting. I just got out here to Chicago, I moved for this job. I have no family out here. They do the love bombing. So they give you all the stuff in the beginning, I interned first under black leadership with black HR, black everything and was bait and switched a week after moving to Chicago, in my opinion, reorg, whatever. And it's this is my financial livability. And as a black person who was the first one to come out of college, it's like this was success. This was supposed to be the spot I got into, I moved, I got this corporate job making almost six figures or you know, and finally, the immigrant's daughter makes it and but somehow I'm feeling like teeny, tiny, but also blown up and so powerful and impactful. And I'm being praised all the time, but also being diminished and made to question my own sense of self during George Floyd protests, where my company talked about looting and rioting. And I just watched this man at all times a day be nailed on. And I'm connecting dots and things that happened to me and to my brother who doesn't even look very black. But he has a gun pointed in his face across the street from my own house in Teaneck, this beautiful little community. So to put all of that, and then realize what was happening within my own job and how I was questioning myself. And then at the same time, get this data that said, you were blowing the numbers away, like you were serving your customers. They had been looking for you specifically to teach though. And these men not seeing me. Something just snapped.

    KC Davis 38:32

    Is that what get out was about Ooh, like you were describing that and all of a sudden I was realizing like that feeling of like we're in it together and then like this, like I heard like scary museum movie music when it was like dawning on you like, oh, shit, like the call is coming from inside the house. Like these things that have been happening to me and these people that say they love me, but all of a sudden they're talking about looting and rioting like what you're like, Oh, God, yeah,

    Rebecca 38:58

    this is against Wait, I'm working for oh, and they were telling, you know, it was coming to the office. This is you know, we got scientists and the DEI strategy, you know, there was a lot more things in terms of hair touching and stuff that you know, was just coming back to me, and how do you still have trouble processing it interesting. And I'm still in therapy and I have not gone back to that job. And you know, realizing what is for me, I've never thought about it. I've just been trying to survive this whole time. And that's what black people have been taught and trained to do is just up until this point is to survive especially like I think our generation and my dad's was kind of like don't like get there get there and then worry about but I got there was terrible. And I

    KC Davis 39:46

    can imagine like not only first of all I love that your boyfriend like was the one to gaslight you and like bring you back to that that's so huge. And but not only are you experiencing this like extreme like racial gaslighting, racism, racial discrimination and then everyone gaslighting you about it at work. But then like I see you talk about racism online, and I see the comment section just line up with white people going. That's not real. That doesn't happen. We aren't like that the world's not really like that. And it's just like gaslight upon gaslight.

    Rebecca 40:21

    Yeah. So imagine you are sorry, already thinking that like when I was thinking, thinking, How do I explain this to someone and explain to them that it's racist, but really it's just him questioning me at every turn and then deciding it's not right and giving himself credit for things he adds to my work, and then giving the credit to me as if he's doing me a favor. Oh, nice. Nice job adding that sticker on the bottom that he added interest? Did you see how I gave you that? I threw that at you? And I little? How do I convey that to this third party woman? Who is already looking for it not to be true? And do I just list every event? Do I show these? I mean, I have so many emails. This is please show your creativity. But if when you do at this at this at this, and my coworker is texting me on the side? We don't know why he's doing this. I'm so sorry. You have to Can I help you? You could talk to him. But I didn't even think that, you know, I'm just thinking, Oh, well, that's validation.

    KC Davis 41:20

    Well, all the while you knowing and frankly, like, you know, the word intersectional gets thrown around a lot to mean a lot of different things. But like, originally, it was specifically about the legal context of a black woman being discriminated against at a job. And but the problem is, is that like legally, like black woman is not a category unto itself, right. And so she either had to prove she was being discriminated against as a woman, or she was being discriminated against as a black person. And there was no way to nail that down, because the job would go, Well, we have other black people, because they had they had black men there that weren't being treated that way. And they could go, Well, we have women here that aren't being treated that way. And she was like, No, I know, it's the specific intersection of being black and being a woman that my job is discriminating against. And it's like when people are telling you like, I don't know why he's doing that to you. Was there a party? It was like

    Rebecca 42:14

    I do. It's a power thing. And I think I couldn't even admit to myself, like, it's just as plainly as I do is because I'm black. Because God forbid, you know, even saying that out loud. At the time, the fear of having someone negate that someone I was giving me a little bit of validation. Having them go well, I mean, because I had people on my team when I would tell them about because, of course, you know, after George Floyd happened, my director calls and asks me how to talk to the team about what is going on. And I tell them about, you know, touching my hair and how it's rooted in, you know, people being in zoos, and people, you know, being entitled to the black body. And even when they don't realize I will tell them a story about how this happened, and how it made me feel, and afterwards touch my hair, to acknowledge how pretty it is. As if they are not doing the thing I just talked about, I am not even kidding. I had two people, my black director, we were talking about how his dog walker touched my hair before she even knew my name, and how it was crazy. And then the two women hearing it said, Oh, wow, that is nuts. But you do have gorgeous hair, and touched each side of my head. And my director looked at me, we made big eye contact. And that was it. And we talked about it all the time. But that's how insidious it is. And how to then have someone questioned something that I'm struggling to come to terms with already. And it's someone I like, and I'm like losing white women, left and right.

    KC Davis 43:39

    And I've seen the white women in your comments talk about like, but it wasn't because of race, they didn't touch your hair because of race. It's because it's so different. It's because it's beautiful. It's because of that. But the part of that story that really sticks out to me is you and your manager locking eyes because you know, because this has been happening to you your whole life, because you have been experiencing this your whole like, you know why it's happening.

    Rebecca 44:05

    It's deep, like we know immediately and without words, and then we will leave and then be like, Oh my gosh, you know, there is these conversations are happening. And what I like to say on my page every once in a while is like I'm giving you information. We these are not nude conversations for us. We have just always have to have these conversations in silence and you didn't secret away from you because of the reactivity. I don't know if that's helpful. I don't think it's done. It's very good. And you know, the concept when we started, you know, white supremacy, the words saying the words it's like, but for who, who's uncomfortable at hearing the words, white supremacy. It's not us. You know, who's going to be uncomfortable at hearing the N word, which I don't love that we turned it into just another word so that people can say without saying it, say it if you want to say you're just not there consequences, you know, this whole not allowed business is very white supremacy, because we'll be perceived negatively You're allowed to do whatever you want, you know what, who was not allowed? The BlackBerry will we were literally not allowed to read or write. So yeah, no perspective, zoom out every once in a while and think why, who's uncomfortable and why.

    KC Davis 45:13

    So you're on your channel, your experience, I feel like has led to first of all, I love your brain, because you come up with like the best metaphors. So you talked about, like, the volatility. So like, oh, you bring up to someone like, hey, it's because of racism. They're like, what? No, I'm not racist. That's not right. And it's like this white volatility, and which is, I think what most people are referring to we talk about white fragility. And so tell us your metaphor for white fragility, or white privilege.

    Rebecca 45:43

    So I like to start with white privilege being a booger, just pretend someone points out to our white privilege that it's a booger, how are you going to feel if they yell at you? Right? If I go, Hey, stupid, you've got a booger in your nose. And everyone here can see it. Now, that might hurt a little. But now you get to take care of that. And we get to stop staring at you. And you're aware of information that everybody else has. Now you just say thank you, and you wipe it away. Often, no one's gonna scream that at you. But except information, appreciate it. And then just keep going because you will be okay. Now, the other aspect of privilege that I think is a little bit more insidious and violent, it comes around what I was considered the pinata of white supremacy. So like the goals of white supremacy, being rich and white, and thin and Young is this pinata up there. And we're trying to take it down. You know what white women are now like, we got a smash it give us bats, but you're not adept. You just got here. And there's a lot of, you know, Poles and levees in there that's going to go on, and we're just trying to tell you like, hey, excuse me, that's not how you do it. And oftentimes, you turn around because you're covered by that privilege that like that blindness, you have the blindfold, and you have white privilege, and you smack the black woman next to you thinking you're doing something and you're not good. We're trying to help. We don't talk to you because we want to be mean and have sentience. We've got other things to do, like take care of our lives and make sure we can eat when we're talking to white women about white privilege or anything. It's for our own survival and for yours. So if we're telling you, hey, you're not doing it, right, listen, maybe just and not ask for instructions, know that you have a blindfold on. So you need to stop swinging, put the bat down and give it to the people who have been here longer. Let black women tell you one, we don't even want that vignette. If we could just stop swinging at the piano and just go play our own game over there and let them just pull out that thing. They'll get bored. Eventually, they'll just be pulling at the piano. No one will be swinging. And we'll go play good, nice game without that's one where we don't have to smash things or something maybe based on humanity and like sharing resources. I don't know.

    KC Davis 48:03

    I feel like that's like it needs to be like an SNL skit skit. It's so good and visual,

    Rebecca 48:09

    and people added such good things to it, too.

    KC Davis 48:11

    I wish we had so much more time because I feel like we could keep talking. But I don't want to go too far over our time without giving you the chance to plug your podcast and your social channels. Where can people find you if they want to come and learn

    Rebecca 48:23

    so you can find me at White woman whisperer.com There are links to like everything else. So it's a nice one stop shop. I've mostly post right now on Tik Tok and I am out I have a couple episodes of my podcast out which I'm very excited about, which is on everywhere. Podcasts are included in my website. So you know, we're figuring it out trying to grow up our community, definitely consider joining my Patreon. I'm aiming for social capital, or over financial capital trying to start a new model where you know, the people speak and not one guy with a lot of gross paper that has touched

    KC Davis 48:57

    a lot of ham. And is your podcast white woman whisperer? Is that the title that

    Rebecca 49:00

    is white women whisperer, the podcast. I tried to keep very consistent.

    KC Davis 49:05

    I like that. It's everywhere. Awesome. Well, Rebecca, thank you so much for your time and thank you for having me. I just am I grateful that you're in my life. This is awesome. I can't wait to do it again. Bye bye.

KC Davis
37: Technology Aids for ADHD with Kat Hunt

Technology can be challenging for those with ADHD, and I’ll admit that I’ve struggled at times in this area. If you are someone who responds better to tactile and visual learning, you can probably relate. There are many tools and hacks available to help with executive functioning issues, and I’m excited to learn more in today’s show. I’m joined by technology expert Kat Hunt, who is raising a neurodivergent daughter. Let’s learn more about technological aids that can be helpful for ADHD. Join us!

Show Highlights:

  • Three specific areas in which neurodivergent struggle and technologies that can help:

  • Why mobile access to these tools is preferable over a physical tool, especially for those who travel or move from home to office frequently

  • How Kat uses Alexa technology to her advantage in time management with her family and at her office

  • How the Due app forces you to pay attention to notifications for events and tasks

  • How parents can use Alexa features with neurodivergent kids to increase independence and self-efficacy while still having parental structure in place

Resources and Links:

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. I am KC Davis. Welcome to Struggle Care. We're going to talk today with cat hunt about technological, not, I guess, AI solutions, but technology aids when it comes to having ADHD, when I'm particularly interested in this subject, because I feel like I've tried out a few. And I have a difficult time with technology anyways, because I always feel like everything needs to be like tactile and visual around me. So I'm interested to hear a little bit more about what could be useful to the ADHD person when it comes to technology. Yeah,

    Kat Hunt 0:43

    So I am a little bit opposite, I work in a tech industry. So it's been kind of in my wheelhouse for a long time. But a lot of the solutions that I've been discovering recently, are very user friendly. And I kind of honed in on three particular kind of symptoms that people with ADHD or other executive functioning disorders or challenges, kind of grapple with. And I've identified what these technologies do that helps those three specific areas in my life that I think for other people as well, it could be a solution.

    KC Davis 1:19

    That's wonderful. Okay, hit me with the first one. So

    Kat Hunt 1:23

    one of the first big ones is time blindness, where you either underestimate how much time you need for something, or you exert a disproportionate amount of time to something that you're hyper fixating on. So for example, one solution that I use Calendly, I can actually build in buffers, for my appointments and things. So I don't have to worry about going over into another appointment or other obligation. And it also gives me a little bit of breathing room because it sometimes can be hard to pivot from one activity to the other. So having like 30 minutes or 45 minutes, to decompress after an appointment and start into the next activity can be very helpful. And with a software solution like that, I don't have to think about it, it is built into my schedule automatically, without me having to spend a lot of cognitive energy trying to calculate that with every individual appointment, it just happens automatically. So this

    KC Davis 2:26

    is something I totally think that I should do. Because I use acuity which is like a similar one, where I block off times and do this at the other end, I actually saw at one point where it asked me like how much time to put in between appointments. And I just didn't click anything because at the time, I was like, oh, pack it in, right. But here's the thing, you're so right, not only on the back end, but like the amount of times where I've gotten sidetracked and started something late. So it pushes it beyond. And I take ADHD meds in the morning. And so when I get several hours of this, like really intense motivation. And I find that during that time, I'm less likely to be tuned in to what my body needs. So whether it's going to the bathroom, getting a drink of water, eating something. And I have definitely found that like times when I have like back to back to back to back meetings or appointments, I'm not leaving myself any time in between. To do that, well, then we say that there is enough time to do something in between, there's not enough time for my brain to decompress from that meeting, to the point where it can start to actually hear the messages my body is sending.

    Kat Hunt 3:43

    Exactly, definitely some other kinds of solutions to that as well. I know I'm not sure if other people do well, I'm sure some people do. But I will have lots of tasks on my to do list. And I never have enough time to necessarily get to all of them. So some software solutions, I particularly use something called artful agenda. There's probably others that do this, I think task li does this too. It will migrate tasks that are undone. At the end of the day, to the next day. Again, it's automatic, I don't have to exert cognitive energy to think about it. It's just Oh, she did not finish that she didn't check it off. Let's move it to the next day. Sometimes I might reschedule it for a day later in the future. But I don't often identify that the day of it's the next day that I look at the tasks again and say oh, I need to push this out a little bit further. So that keeping track of that data, which was kind of my next problem, data loss and data overwhelm, kind of keeps all of that together without me having to exert extra mental energy for it.

    KC Davis 4:50

    And is it putting it on your calendar or is it putting it on just like another day's to do list?

    Kat Hunt 4:56

    So this particular software solution is interesting. I I put in my Google calendar, which my Google calendar if you saw, it would be absolutely insane, because there's my calendar. But there's also calendars that I have to have an awareness of, and not necessarily directly related to me. But if I'm a manager, I'm in a kind of a managerial role. So like I'm having to coordinate, well, I migrate my personal things into this other software. So that pops up on a monthly, weekly and daily spread, I don't have to copy it, it does it again automatically. And then it has in that software task areas, it kind of looks like a paper planner, this particular solution, but it's not. So rather than trying to write things from one page to the next to migrate it, it just automatically does it.

    KC Davis 5:49

    That's great. Okay, hit me with the next one.

    Kat Hunt 5:52

    So the third problem is the problem of dopamine. So ADHD, individuals in particular, but a lot of different people who have other neuro divergence have dopamine seeking behavior, or dopamine resistant behavior, in my case is dopamine seeking. And if things are under stimulating to me, I won't keep up with them. And it's not only that, I won't keep up with them. In some cases, it can be actually painful to engage in something that is not stimulating. So the act of going to a calendar and writing down your agenda in a planner, for example, this is a very tedious kind of task. So by eliminating that, and automating it, it gets done in an efficient way, that's not painful to me, or doesn't get shoved under the rug. Other solutions, kind of with time management, there's one program I use called forests, where it will actually grow a tree for every 25 minutes, you're working on something, it's a virtual tree, you can create a little forest.

    KC Davis 7:06

    So I'm not kidding when I say that, like of everything you've said, that one has blown my mind the most. Because, you know, I found myself playing. So I play love and pies, which is a mobile game that I'm kind of obsessed with. But I play it all the time. And one of the things that I find myself thinking about, like, as I'm playing it, because it's one of those games where you know, you have like a certain amount of energy. And as the energy goes down, then you gotta like, wait a few minutes and get more energy. But one of the things that I find myself thinking is like this, you know, I'm like merging strawberries to make a pie. And it's like, this pie doesn't exist. I don't know why my brain feels so satisfied by this completion. I remember thinking, like, I wish there was like a game, where in order to get more energy, I had to go to like, do some sort of care task, like and then it could magically know that I went and like, did my dishes. And I'd come back to all of this energy tokens, and I could keep going. Because you're right, there is something really satisfying about just that, like it's moving towards something, it's doing something it's not, I'm not just like doing things in the abyss. And I can 100% see myself, like working extra on something because I'm like, Well, I'm seven minutes away from the next tree, or whatever it is.

    Kat Hunt 8:26

    Yeah, actually, you know, if I don't do it as regularly yet to create, like a whole forest, but I have had days where I have some super tedious work, where I'll have multiple trees, and it's really quite satisfying to look at a whole forest of what you've done. So you could apply that to any number of things. But it also keeps things again, kind of talking about trying to manage your energy levels, you don't often recognize when you're approaching the end of your energy level, by breaking it into 25 minute increments. If it's something I'm really engaged in, it has the opposite effect, oh, I've worked on this one thing for, you know, an hour and a half, maybe I should step back from it and take a break or switch to something else.

    KC Davis 9:12

    It's great, because like the passage of time related, that timeline is like it really is difficult. And whenever I talk about solutions with like timers and things, I find that there's always two kinds of people that are really drawn to that. And the first are people that they don't want to start. But if they can visually see like, oh, it's only going to be this amount of time. It's like okay, I can keep going there's only a little bit left. But then the other people are people who are like once I start I just forget the world and all of a sudden hours later I'm still doing this and I've missed all these things. And so that visual passage of time is really important. But I found that like so my go to is always the like the visual timer right where you turn the dial and it colors the time in like a color so like red, blue, purple, but that's what really only helpful for me when I need to visualize how much time has passed coming to a specific stop point. So I only want to do 15 minutes. But like you're saying, if the issue is the opposite, where it's like, I can work on this as long as I want to it's open ended. But I do need to be aware how much time I'm spending on it, I need to see the passage of time to be better tuned in to how much time you know, I'm taking away from what other things I might need to do that day.

    Kat Hunt 10:32

    Absolutely. It For Me, I've seen those physical timers, I think those are really neat. One of the big things about all of the solutions I use is its mobile access. And that's something that I very rarely forget a planner, I always forget it at the house, I forget at the office, it's never where I need it to be. tools that are physical like that will get left in a bag. And when I switch bags, it's not with me anymore. For my particular profession, I travel a lot, I'm on the go a lot. So having everything in a handheld device is really helpful for me too, because I can use it anywhere. So that

    KC Davis 11:08

    I totally get that because my number one like and I guess you could call it technology. Okay, so we're talking about the passage of time, right? Okay, so this is a timer cube. And it's basically like this little cube, it's like the size of my palm. And you can get them with different increments of time, right. So mine is the one that has five minutes, 10 minutes, 20 minutes, 30 minutes, just around the site. So when I put the time that I want facing up, it starts a timer for that amount of time. So cool. So this is really helpful, very satisfied.

    Yeah, sorry, just scratch my chair. It's really helpful when I'm at home, because I was like setting a timer on my phone. But then I'm picking up my phone and I'm getting distracted by the things on my phone. This is really helpful. And the way that I finally like cracked the code of the best way for me to use it is like, let's say that I have a meeting and 30 minutes. So what I used to do was say, okay, great, put the 30 minutes up. But then it would go off. And I'd be like, oh gosh, oh gosh, I might be right in the middle of something. And I'd be like, well, let me just wrap this one thing up. And then it'd be 10 minutes later, and I'd be late to the meeting. So what I found was, the best way to actually do it is if I have 30 minutes until I have to be at a meeting, I do the 20 minutes instead. So that when it goes off it orient me to the time, and I go, okay, so I need to spend about five more minutes wrapping this up. So then I'll click the five minute one over, and then I'll focus on wrapping something up so that when that timer goes off, I'm done. And I still have five minutes to like prepare or pull up the screen or get on the phone or whatever for the next thing. And when I finally figured out that that's what I needed, like I needed the to not just be told when to stop, right? Like we don't just need a timer. We truly need tools that orient us to the passage of time as we are doing something, which is what I love about like the forest one, what's it called, again,

    Kat Hunt 13:13

    it's called forest. And I think it's actually a lot of these are free or very cheap. I think forest is free for most functions. And you'll like this as well. I don't take advantage of this because I can't be disconnected completely in most cases. But it will actually block out all of your apps and notifications if you ask it to. Oh, so the phone becoming its own distraction can sometimes be mediated that way. For some folks, again, I can only do that to a certain degree,

    KC Davis 13:50

    people who work I do. Okay, I'm gonna check out the forest app. Let's pause for just a second to hear a word from our sponsor. And when we come back, I want to ask you about Alexa, because I heard your Alexa going off and I have some questions. Okay. Okay, I want to talk about Alexa because I have one and I don't know like how much you use your Alexa but I feel like I'm not using it to its potential. Because other ADHD people talk about these, like really creative things they're doing with their Alexa and I don't do anything with mine except like the timer when I'm cooking.

    Kat Hunt 14:21

    So I actually discovered Alexa first for my daughter years ago and she actually is on the autism spectrum. So shifting tasks for her is very challenging for different reasons and in different ways. So for us we started using it was just kind of a speaker to play music. You know, we got on some freebie or bonus or something. I would tell Alexa to give my daughter cues that in 30 minutes she was going to have to start shifting gears into something else or in 10 minutes and sometimes depending on how how difficult it was for her for certain tasks, we might do a couple of those, you know, 30 minutes, 10 minutes, five minutes. So it really started as a tool for her. I don't use it in the house very much personally. But what I use it for is the office more. So in a lot of what you were just saying about how you'll use your cube to give you some buffer to orient your time. Alexa does that for me in my office, when I'm here, she'll I call her Ziggy, because I'm a big David Bowie fan. And that's one of the options but I've got my calendar plugged into her. And she will say in 30 minutes, you have an interview with Casey Davis.

    KC Davis 15:42

    So that only you have her plugged into your calendar. Yeah, so

    Kat Hunt 15:46

    my virtual calendar feeds into her. And she will remind me in an increment that I set of appointments that are coming up,

    KC Davis 15:56

    that is helpful, because I get the push notifications on my phone. But I can't tell you the amount of times that like you're doing something and it comes down, you're like you like swipe it away, or you don't see it, I had no idea that you could actually connect so that the notifications are coming through Alexa,

    Kat Hunt 16:14

    exactly. You can do Apple calendar or Google Calendar, which Google calendar can feed into Apple calendar, which I have an Apple Watch. So I do that Google Calendar is where I have my foundation, because it goes everywhere on any device pretty much. And then it can feed digitally into a variety of different devices, depending on what I use them for another app that is good for that it's not on Alexa specifically, but do will harass you about reminders until you acknowledge them. That was actually on an ADH forum on Facebook. I can't remember which one but someone suggested it. And I tried it. So things that are really critical. I will do that. So I don't do the swipe up and forget that data loss that I mentioned earlier. That's a big one for me. So it'll remind me again, do due

    KC Davis 17:08

    Do you e Okay, so how does that work? So like let's say I need to feed my cats.

    Kat Hunt 17:12

    So I do have a couple of reoccurring ones. For my mids, I'll you know I take my meds a little bit later in the morning because I have to stay up later for work and family obligations. So I have a reminder on a cycle and it will harass me every five or 10 minutes until I acknowledge it. And even with non like repeating tasks. By just having awareness of it, I can say, Oh, I can't do that right now because of this important thing that got in the way. But let me reschedule it to a time I think I can. So it doesn't get lost, I'm not losing the data. It's bringing attention to it and I just reschedule it. Or I say okay, I need to go ahead and do it like it's harass me three times at this point, I need to I need to get that done. So that's very helpful, too. I wish I could connect Alexa and do but they haven't figured out that link yet.

    KC Davis 18:08

    So how is do different than Alexa just like setting a timer and alerting you to something

    Kat Hunt 18:14

    that harassing feature the inability to get rid of the notification without either rescheduling it or deleting it, it will just keep there's no easy way to snooze it, it will just keep going in increments that you set. So you could say, you know, remind me every five minutes, they have a new feature now to where it's urgent, where it won't even let you get rid of it at all. It's like this is really, really important. I haven't used that feature yet. Because I haven't had anything that's like that critical. But it just continues to remind you until you either reschedule it, or delete it or do it. Because it's the ideal thing. Do you

    KC Davis 18:51

    ever just delete it? And then forget to do the thing?

    Kat Hunt 18:54

    No, it's a process to delete it. So that's another thing about it is the way it's it's what we call a user interface. So that's what you're interacting with. Its user interface is set up that it's not easy to delete it you have to like really cognitively say I'm going to delete it because it's no longer relevant. You cannot so I'm busy.

    KC Davis 19:16

    It's interrupting. It's like no matter what it is sufficiently interrupting your train of thought and direction. So that like if you're going to take the time to delete it, you might as well just go do the thing. Yep, that's actually kind of smart. Because it is so easy to just say like Alexa turn off. Yeah, or to swipe away notification on your phone. And part of that is because you're thinking, Oh, I've just got five more minutes on this thing. And I'll do that and you're like you're like, you're just like batting it away with your hand and then I it doesn't take me very much time to forget something. Say that. It's interesting.

    Kat Hunt 19:51

    When you hit when you reschedule, you pick increments so I can say I want to be reminded again in three hours or I want to be reminded again in 10 minutes, so maybe you're Like knee deep and some thing that really can't end a kid's got a problem your bandage it up the knee, whatever it might be, you can just very quickly say, remind me in two hours or you know what have you. Okay, but you can't delete it as easily as you can reschedule.

    KC Davis 20:17

    So if you do want to just batted away quickly, you can only do that by rescheduling it. And the rescheduling is easy.

    Kat Hunt 20:24

    Yes, fairly easy, but it makes you think about it. So you're not Yeah, you know, losing it in the ether of your brain.

    KC Davis 20:30

    I will say the thing that I use Alexa for, besides just the timer stuff is the grocery list feature. Because the amount of times that I have gone grocery shopping and forgotten, like something major. And I always think like when I run out of something major, I always think like this is so major, there's no way I'll forget to get this when I go or when I order or when I whatever. But I found that like, I'm noticing that I need something in my kitchen, usually when I'm in the middle of doing something in my kitchen. And so putting the Alexa in my kitchen, so that as I'm literally like, you know, I'm stirring a pot, right and I use the last of the red wine vinegar, I can literally just be like Alexa, I have red wine vinegar to the right, and I don't have to even stop what I'm doing. Because what I found was I wasn't stopping what I was doing to go like right down the list. So the ability to have her do something for me while I'm doing something else. And then you have like your whole list there.

    Kat Hunt 21:32

    Yep, absolutely. I do that with my my Apple watch, because I can feed it into the do app as well. I can set reminders or make lists. So Alexa and in and my Apple Watch kind of work. Similarly, one is just fixed in my office and one goes with me wherever I am.

    KC Davis 21:50

    Well, the thing that I also like about I don't know about the Apple Watch, but I had a smartwatch one time that I could make it the notifications just vibrate with no sound, which was really helpful in environments where there was other people around, or I didn't want to alert people to like what it was I was reminding myself, like you don't want to be take your medication right in the middle of a board meeting, right. But you still want to be alerted. And it's like, okay, I can do that. Like that a lot of there was something else I was gonna say. I think it was about the Alexa Oh, you were mentioning like giving your daughter like transition times and like layups to transitions. So I've started doing that with my kids too, mostly because I forget, I'll be like 10 more minutes a TV, and then I'll go do something and it'll be 45 minutes later. But you know what I found? And if you found the same thing, my kids respond much better to Alexa telling them that it's time to stop doing something than me.

    Kat Hunt 22:45

    I don't mind when you're better for everybody else's parents, but me.

    KC Davis 22:49

    It's almost like they see her as some objective robotic. Yeah, it just is time the house just went off right. Like as opposed to, Oh, mom just doesn't want us to watch more TV. So I just that's like an interesting observation I wanted to share with listeners because

    Kat Hunt 23:05

    I can't remember how young your kids are minors worry and five minds about the beat 13 and a few months. And one thing to think about as they get older, that's been good for her too is she started taking accountability for her own time buffers. So first, second, third grade, I would set the transition time, but now she sets her own. So she'll say, Alexa, remind me in 30 minutes that it's time to get ready for better or what have you. So she'll set her own buffers and and that's given her that skill that she'll take with her as she gets older. And it gives her some self efficacy with it too. So it's not Oh, you know, mom is imposing this thing on me it's me doing this to help myself feel better and do the things I need to do.

    KC Davis 23:55

    I have seen people utilize also like smart bulbs with their Alexa where you know, it'll, it'll change the color. Like if there was somebody that I was listening to where their kids get like 15 minutes to read before they go to bed. And instead of the parent having to go in and be like okay, lights off, they have a smart bulb, and after the 15 minutes, it turns purple to let them know they have a couple of minutes left. And then it turns off. And I mean obviously you can turn it back on but it's like it reminds them and I think that's so key for neurodivergent kids like teaching them how to use the technology that's going to be helpful to them. Because I've really I haven't done it yet but I really would love to even for my kids at their age like get some smart bulbs and put like one of the I have like an echo that someone gave me like the Alexa little dot, which is only like 50 bucks. I would love to set that up in their room to wake them up in the morning. Right where it was like telling them it's time to get up and it was like turning on the lights and maybe playing some music which is crazy that like even at the age of three and five, there's a way for me to start to give them some independence and some ownership. And I mean, I'm probably still gonna have to go up there and help them and things like that. I'm not like leaving them on their own. But I feel like there's so much potential in technology with our kids, to still give them the structure that they need, while allowing them like better teaching them to have some ownership over that, you know, their processes and taking care of themselves and creating their own structure.

    Kat Hunt 25:32

    Definitely. And for me, and my daughter, you know, being on the autism spectrum, she thrives on structure, and I am one of the most unstructured people in the universe. It's helped bridge a gap for us as a mother, daughter, dyad, where she's getting the structure, she needs a little bit more, but it's not either, it's not totally impossible, because a lot of things would be without these assistive technologies, I think for me, but it's also not abrasive to me. So it really creates a very harmonious kind of ecosystem. Not that things don't ever go wrong ever. We've been working on it for years, but you know, I definitely am things. There's little things like they're so simple, but they make a big difference.

    KC Davis 26:17

    That's awesome. Well, cat, thank you so much for coming on. And for sharing those solutions with us. I think that's gonna be really helpful to people. And I quite literally am going to go download the tree app right now.

    Kat Hunt 26:30

    I'll make a list of everything I kind of mentioned today to you so you can have it and share it and you know, all of these are just a hodgepodge of things I've tested so there's nothing they will put it in. Yeah, awesome. Thank you so much for having me today.

    KC Davis 26:45

    Absolutely. Thank you.


Christy Haussler
36: ADHD & Sex with Catie Osborn

As you can probably figure out from the title, this is NOT the show to listen to around children! I’m joined by Catie Osborn, better known as @catieosaurus on TikTok–with an average of 30-50 million monthly views. She is an actor, podcaster, sex educator, adult performer, and mental health and disability advocate based in Atlanta. We are diving into the interesting intersection of ADHD and sexuality. If you are curious to hear more, join us!

Show Highlights:

  • How growing up in a very conservative and religious household gave Catie an interesting perspective on sex that was based on shame

  • How Catie became interested in kink, received an ADHD diagnosis, and became a sex educator

  • Why sex is a “fragile moment”

  • Why sexual dysfunction and sexual disappointment are NOT the same things

  • How ADHD makes it difficult to stay focused during sex because of overthinking

  • How neurodivergent people struggle to articulate their needs–especially with intimacy

  • Why sex shouldn’t be in terms of obligation, duty, and service but in terms of being authentically ourselves in surrender to the experience

  • How our sex lives are influenced by layers of white supremacy, capitalism, trauma, and heteronormative values that need to be unpacked and investigated

  • What kink is at its core–and why it has saved Catie

  • Why conversations about sex and intimacy connect you to your partner, breed trust and vulnerability, and lead to better sex!

  • Why Catieosaurus’ TikTok series, “Burnt Out Gifted and Talented Submissive Brat with a Praise Kink,” has been hugely popular

  • How kink allowed Catie to be the one who calls the shots and feels safe and supported–for the first time


Resources and Links:

Connect with Catie: Website, Podcast, Instagram, and TikTok

Book mentioned: Come As You Are by Emily Nagoski

 Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • Unknown Speaker 0:00

    Hey

    KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient sexy balls of stardust. This is struggle care, the podcast about self care by a host that hates the term self care. And today's episode is probably not the one you want to play in front of your kids. And if you are my mother or my father or my in laws, probably also not the episode that you want to listen to, unless you want way too many details about my sex life. So if you are neither a child nor related to me, carry on.

    Welcome back to the struggle care podcast. I have an exciting guest today. You may know her as CatieSaurus from tick tock. It's Catie Osborne.

    Catie Osborn 0:44

    Hello. It's me. Catie Saurus. I don't know what I was going for there. It's right. Oh,

    KC Davis 0:50

    it's fine. Listen, guys, I prepared for this podcast by saying meet me at the maypole at 10am We're gonna do a podcast.

    Catie Osborn 0:59

    Live here from the maple.

    KC Davis 1:01

    We're live here from the maypole. That's about the amount of preparation that I put into this podcast, which is not a reflection on how excited I am or how important of a guest you are.

    Catie Osborn 1:12

    I feel like that just means that you have a lot of trust in me. So I'll take it as a compliment.

    KC Davis 1:16

    Well, I did have this thought of like people a lot of times when I'm on their podcast will like prepare questions ahead of time and send me questions. And I've definitely done that for people. But I'm also someone who is like, perfectly happy to like, just like rip off the hip. And I did have this slot where I was like, I'm super grateful that Katie is the one on the podcast. Because something tells me she could probably just go off the dome.

    Catie Osborn 1:40

    That's what my entire podcast is. That's what we do on our podcasts. We pick a topic and then we just go oh, what do you think about this topic? And then sometimes we wind up staying on topic and sometimes we end up like reviewing movies like it just it's you never know. So I get it.

    KC Davis 1:55

    Well, I'm super excited about our topic today. Speaking of topics, because as many of you maybe know, Katie and I both are over on Tik Tok. And we've had quite similar trajectories. I feel like we've been at the same follower count for months now. not static, but like when you grow I grow.

    Catie Osborn 2:15

    Boy, I sure hope you grow next week then because oh my god. I think I got 10 whole followers yesterday. It was really exciting. Oh, no, it's fine. We're all five.

    KC Davis 2:26

    Well, listen, if you're listening to this, you gotta go follow Katie. Okay,

    Catie Osborn 2:30

    go follow me. Well, I mean, listen to the podcast first, make your own informed decision. Make an assessment. So hey, Casey, what are we talking about today? Well, okay, we're

    KC Davis 2:39

    going to talk about sex today. So sex and ADHD, this is an interesting cross section most of your content about ADHD. Yes. And then you started this series about sex and ADHD, which is fascinating to me. So tell me how this came about to be a topic of combo. Okay.

    Catie Osborn 2:55

    So well, how do you want the long story, the medium story? I want whatever story you want to tell. Okay. So my relationship with sex has always been really interesting, because I grew up in a very conservative, very religious household. And so sex and our bodies were, I was raised thinking that they were very shameful, and you know, something to be like, embarrassed about, and we didn't talk about. But what that also meant was that I didn't have a really good understanding about my sexuality, and about my body and that kind of thing. And so then, as I got older, that was kind of something that I wanted to take back, I wanted to empower myself to like, sort of understand myself in that way. And so I got really into like kink and that kind of thing. And I started educating on kink and that type of stuff. And then after I got diagnosed with ADHD, I started doing some research, but at the time, it wasn't specifically about just, you know, ADHD, neurodivergent, the effects. But I started looking into, you know, just ADHD has effect on our lives. And what I was, I don't know why I was surprised. But I was surprised to find out that ADHD isn't just a school thing. It's not just a work thing. It affects every facet of our lives, including stuff like orgasms. And when I learned that my mind was quite literally blown. And so I started sort of like studying and secret to become a certified sex educator, because I'm one of those people where if I tell people, I'm going to do it, then I won't do it. And then, you know, and then they asked you six months later, and it's embarrassing. So I totally held in secret for a year and I took a lot of classes and did a lot of work to become a certified sex educator. But the thing that solidified it for me and I tell the story a lot, but I like it because I think it's really important. So in the middle of one of my classes, it was being taught by this very neurotypical man who was just kind of like, you know, talking about sex stuff. But there was a class that we were taking about, like, you know, what happens when sex gets interrupted, what happens when, you know, like, you fall off the bed or something goes wrong, and he very cavalierly said, you know, You just don't have to worry about it, the moment is not precious. It's not you don't have to worry about it, you can just laugh it off, come back. And I was like, that is so counterintuitive to everything that I know and understand about sex because like, Yes, I agree, you should be able to just, you know, laugh it off and come back. But if I fall off the bed, you know, like, I run the risk of noticing that the carpet needs to be vacuumed, or like looking out the window and realizing that the UPS truck is here, or whatever it may be. And so I asked, and I said, Well, what about people with ADHD? You know, like, what about people who do get very distracted, or like, task initiation or that kind of stuff, and I really got blown off. And that was one of the first moments where I realized how much of the conversation about sex and intimacy surrounds the assumption that both or all parties involved, I guess, just to say, are neurotypical and able bodied. And once I started really thinking about what I had learned, and really started unpacking what I had learned, I realized that like, there weren't conversations happening in like, a large scale way. And I thought, well, I have the platform, and I have this very vested interest in this topic. So I guess I'll become the lady on Tiktok, who talks about sex and ADHD? Viet?

    KC Davis 6:14

    I love it. Okay, so I actually binge watched a bunch of these tech talks recently to prepare for us talking. And that was the one that stood out to me the most, where the guy said, like, well, the moments not fragile.

    Catie Osborn 6:27

    Yeah, yes, it is.

    KC Davis 6:29

    And I was like, oh, no, yeah. I mean, I get what he's saying. But also, like, I definitely more relate to what you're saying, where like, when you get in that zone, there's this like, Okay, I'm in tune with my body, I'm in tune with my partner, I'm feeling my sensations. I'm enjoying myself. And it's almost like you have these like really fragile blinders on. And there's this tightrope of like, okay, if I think too much about how it's going, well, if I think too much about how I'm in the moment, then I will take myself out of the moments.

    Catie Osborn 7:13

    Yes, that happens to me all the time.

    KC Davis 7:16

    And I was like, it is fragile, like being in that sort of, like, erotic zone, where you have to pay a high Oh, no, but you're right. It's fragile.

    Catie Osborn 7:30

    Yeah. And the thing that I think is fascinating is that there have only been a handful of studies because I'm like, I'm very, like, I'm the academic one, or I'm just like, I'm gonna go research. But there's only been a couple of studies done, but like, they all kind of agree that about 40% of everybody with ADHD, irregardless of gender struggles in some way with sex or sexual dysfunction. But the other thing that I think is really interesting is that one of the most frustrating things about having conversations about sex and sexuality is the terminology of sexual dysfunction. Because what is actually more accurate for a lot of people is what like I would say is like, sexual disappointment, right? Where it's not like there's anything medically wrong with you. It's not like there's something that is not working. It's just not how you want it to be. And that can be even more frustrating, right? Because like, if you know, a person with a penis goes to the doctor. And they're like, oh, no, I'm having trouble with sex. The doctor can say, Oh, you have erectile dysfunction, congratulations, and like, move on with your day. But with like ADHD, where like, symptomatically, it's I'm checking out during sex, or I'm having a hard, I like the Bailey founder square your toy, right? When I got to most serious discussion. I got a dog listeners. And I regret giving her squeaky toys. That's what I learned. But you know, like with ADHD, it can be really hard to look at it and say, Okay, well, I'm checking out during sex, or I'm struggling to stay focused during sex, or I'm struggling to get in the mood during sex. That is not a dysfunction. That's not something that is like clinically wrong with you. It just means that there is like a struggle there or like extra work that you have to do. And so sometimes the first step, and even having a conversation about sex and about intimacy is like unpacking the toxic ideas that we have about sex and about intimacy and like that it's supposed to be this one way or it's supposed to be easy, or you're supposed to be, you know, turned on at the drop of a hat. And that's just not the case. And I think that is, that's a big part of it is in the conversation about neuro divergence is also just really starting to unpack the expectations versus sort of like reality of intimacy as a whole. So it becomes very large very quickly.

    KC Davis 9:51

    One of the things that you talked about one of your tic TOCs that I thought was really meaningful was that when you talk about quote unquote sexual dysfunction or sexual troubles. You mentioned troubles getting aroused, but then you specifically mentioned trouble staying aroused. And that's something that I feel like it's not talked about a lot when we talk about sex and problems with sex, because the focus is so much on penetration in sort of a heteronormative view that we focus on getting aroused as being like the most important thing because like, if you have a penis, like you have to get aroused for, like the mechanics to work, and if you're a woman, you have to get aroused for the mechanics to not be painful, right, like, so we sort of focus because we have such a penetrative view of sex, it's like, well, as long as we can get the P and the V, like the, which should be smooth sailing after that. But the reality is, I think, especially as someone with ADHD, that feeling of kind of needing to stay ahead in the game to really be in the experience. But also, you know, if you get into a stretch, where you're thinking, like, Oh, God, I'm losing it, I'm losing it, I'm losing it. Because you know, there's something that changed in the environment, or in the move or in the position. And if you're not in a place where you've worked and talk with your partner about being able to vocalize at that moment, hey, position change, or like, hey, Nope, we're gonna go left, not right, we're gonna go up, not down, we're gonna go, whatever, whatever, because you feel like it should always just flow, it should always just be this magical, you know, like, whatever is that then you find yourself in that spot where as you feel the arousal waning in the middle of the sex act, you get into that like meta headspace of like, it's okay. Okay, oh, God, get it back, get back, get back, get back. In my experience, like, once you get into that space of almost not overthinking it, but almost like having like meta thoughts about the experience, it's like it's over. So one of the things

    Catie Osborn 11:53

    that I find to be really interesting, and really sort of like, along with that is that in working with a lot of neurodivergent, people, sort of like, regardless of what your neurodivergent it is, a lot of neurodivergent people struggle to know what they want, or struggle to articulate their needs, or feel like they can't, and that is like a really big one. And a lot of that comes out of trauma, it comes out of living with an undiagnosed neurodivergent See, or feeling like there's something inherently wrong with you, or feeling broken or feeling guilty about it, or all of these sort of like, very negative emotions that are associated with, you know, the experience of late diagnosis. And so then it wants to be missing where the conversation is never just about ADHD, it's never just about intimacy. It's never just about this, like one thing. It's just like massive, sort of like tangled yarn ball of like, the effects that ADHD has your on your, you know, attention span, but also then the trauma of not being able to articulate what you want, or having gotten in trouble a lot for asking for stuff over and over again. And so it can be really difficult for a neurodivergent person to even start to like find, you know, the thread to pull on. That's like, Okay, well, how do I get into my body? How do I figure out what I need? How do I figure out what I want? And that I don't have a good answer for. But one of the things that I talk about a lot is that is that specific experience of struggling to articulate needs and struggling to articulate wants, because I think it's important for other people to hear that they're not alone. They're not the only person who struggles to articulate or struggles to know what they want. And that I think sometimes can be, I don't wanna say more important, but I think it's a really important part of the process, when you're starting to think about sex and sexuality as it relates to your neurodivergent SE. Does that make any sales?

    KC Davis 13:55

    Because it comes to my mind is like when you spend the majority of your life particularly as a sort of person socialized as a female living as a female, like, you and your neurodivergent? Like, you basically have a history of being told You're too much. Yep. Right, you're too much Calm down, wait, your turn, quit interrupting. And not only that, you're told that you're too much, but you're told that you're too muchness is relating to a character defect, like you're selfish or self absorbed, you're an attention whore like, and so we develop this shame about our personalities and we learn how to perform at such a young age. So that you know whether I'm in the classroom or with friends, like I learned to constantly have this meta narrative dialogue about my behavior and about my experience. Okay, when was it okay for me to talk? Okay, wait, wait, wait, okay, and go right or like, Okay, I just set a thing. I just did a thing. Okay. Was that too much? Was it enough? Do they think this? And one of the things you talk about a couple of people, I think you read come As you are the book, and come as you are as a great book, if anyone wants to read up on sex, and then there's another figure, did you study Esther Parral at all? Okay, so both of these figures I am obsessed with, and they really represent what I think as a therapist is a much better way of thinking about sex. Because if anyone's listening, like if you've ever been to like old school, like sex therapy, it's very weird. And it's very old. It's very based in like, Well, men have needs and men need sex to feel intimate, and why don't you just schedule sex and and God help you if you were ever in like a religious context where they talked about like duty and sacrifice and serving. And I think that this idea that they talk about income as you are, and that Esther Perel talks about where sex, to be, like good sex to be intimate sex, it requires that there not be that meta narrative dialogue, that you just are authentically yourself, and you're coming to claim your pleasure, and you're coming to interact with this other being, and there's this freeness and this abandon and the surrender. And obviously, there has to be trust and safety and all of those things for that to happen. But it makes sense why someone who is neurodivergent would really struggle because not only do we have trouble sort of paying attention, but it's not as though paying attention has to do with distraction. I mean, it can as much as it has to do with like, we did have not had practice turning off that meta narrative Nair, like a dialogue that we constantly have about our behavior.

    Catie Osborn 16:45

    Yeah, absolutely.

    KC Davis 16:46

    To just focus on experiencing, I'll say this, I was the most like, helpful thing I ever heard from a sex therapist, that is kind of like up on the new research about sex is he said that the first thing he does with couples that come in, that are struggling with intimacy is he says, He tells them to stop referring to sex as a need, and stop referring to like drive like, oh, low drive, high drive all these things. But he said that because as I stare, Pearl says, like, obligation is the opposite of eroticism. Like, if you are just trying to do you're good little, you know, neurodivergent girl thing and like read the room, gain the expectations, get the rules, and then perform like you might perform well, but you're not going to experience it in a way that's fulfilling for your view, at least eventually, right? And so yeah, he says, I want to get rid of these words like need and drive. Because when you say to your partner, I have a high sex drive, and I have a need, and I need you to meet my needs, it automatically puts your partner in the seat of obligation and duty and service. And particularly if you live life, as a woman, we're already told that our whole lives are about obligation and duty and service. He said, It is so different. He said, you don't have a need for sex, you have a desire for sex, but I'm not downplaying it. Like it's an important desire. And it's such a different experience to go to your partner and say, I have a deep burning desire to have a passionate, intimate sex life with you. Yeah. And inviting them into a space where you're asking them to unfold, you're asking them to abandon you're asking them to meet you in this place that only the two or three or however many of you, right can be in this intimate space where you are invited to turn off this meta narrative, you are invited to surrender and be authentically just who you are and lose yourself in the experience. He's like, how much like, that'll get your panties wet. Right? It's such a different way.

    Catie Osborn 19:00

    It's so much better. I mean, and maybe I'm working too hard to like, shoehorn it into like a tight little point. But like, for me, a lot of times that conversation around like sex drive and like this, like idea that like, oh, I need sex or whatever. A lot of times, like, especially with sex drive, and like libido, I related a lot like when I'm talking and like doing like speaking stuff, to the idea of like high functioning versus low functioning, because I hate that. And it's such like a problematic take on support needs. But like high functioning, low functioning, high sex drive, low sex drive, according to who, according to what measure according to what metric, are we deciding that? Well, you have, you know, your low functioning or you have low sex drive or whatever, because and this is like, honestly, I'm not even embarrassed to say this. This is something I didn't know until I was literally 30 years old is that sex drive is as defined by the individual sex drive is not there's not like a board of sex drive guys who decided, like, if you think about sex four times a day, that's Hi, you know, and if you like, it was one of those things where like, I just always disliked thought that there was just this understanding that sex drive is like a readable metric one through

    KC Davis 20:21

    10 There's like a valid scale, like out there. Yeah,

    Catie Osborn 20:25

    yeah. You know, it's like the smiley face chart at the hospital. But it's like, no, like, your sex drive is entirely based only on you, and only on your experience, and sex drive weights, it waxes and wanes, you know, like, it is very, very natural and very, very normal to have peaks and valleys in your desire, especially when you're in a safe and supportive and healthy relationship. Because like, sometimes, you know, you got to just deal with like, the in laws or whatever, and there's not time for intimacy. And sometimes it's like game on, you know, with this idea that there's like, one right way to live and experience sex drive. And there's one right way, you know, for, like, whatever it may be, that I think is also one of the most damaging things that I like, a lot of times, that's what I have to start with, like, I don't even have start with the questions about ADHD or neurodivergent. Se, what I start with is questions like, well, you know, my partner needs to have sex three times a week, but I want sex one time a month, what do I do? And I'm like, have a conversation about your mismatched desires, and don't do anything you don't want to do? Like, that's step one. And that's what I think is really interesting, because again, it's we're talking about socialization, we're talking about, like, patriarchy stuff, we're talking about, like white supremacy stuff. And it gets so large, so quickly, that it's like, I love talking about this. But I always have this little bit of dread, because it's like, I can't fix everything. And I can't talk about everything all at one time. But that's like, that's where my brain goes, is just really thinking about that a lot. I don't know what I was going where I was going with that, but it's fine.

    KC Davis 22:07

    No, but I'm glad that you went there. Because here's what I think like, I also come from an evangelical background, I still practice in the Christian faith, but I do not belong to a church. And I would consider myself a somebody who has deconstructed that evangelical vein. And I think that because I've had a lot of experience with marriage therapists in that world. And I think a good bit of sex therapy, in general is really heavily influenced by those Puritan values. And those ideas that like, Well, men need sex and men's brains are like waffles and women's brains are like spaghetti, and all of this fucking junk science about how we have gendered brains that are so different. And you know, men need sex to feel loved, and they need respect. But women need love to feel it. It's just it's so wrong. But one of the things is, is like if you are someone who is going to go to therapy to talk about sex, and the first thing your therapist starts talking about is sex. They don't know what they're talking about, yes, 100%, because we are so influenced by white supremacy. And we are so influenced by capitalism, and we are so influenced by the trauma of being neurodivergent, or the heteronormative sort of values. And like, there's so many things that are affecting our sex lives, that we don't know, that we have to unpack or at least investigate before we can even get to a place that answers the question of what do I do if I'm, you know, I want it once a month, and he wants it three months, you know, three times a month or a week or whatever. Like, there are so many layers here. And just I mean, as everything in our lives is complicated, like we don't check those things at the door when we go into the bedroom.

    Catie Osborn 24:01

    Yeah. And one of the things that I struggle with the most is that is, I think, just like the fundamental misunderstanding of how ADHD affects adults, because like, I mean, honestly, the reason why I started doing all of this and doing what I do is because I just got fed up with reading literature that like seemed to imply that like, on your 18th birthday, when you become an adult, the ADHD fairy comes and you're cured, you know, and like, just like the insidious way that like ADHD is discussed, where it's like, oh, you know, like, I don't know 15% of kids have ADHD, but seemingly only 3% of adults have ADHD. It's like no, those people still have ADHD. They just learned strategies and coping mechanisms and their ADHD is such that they can exist without like needing medication that doesn't make ADHD go away. But because there is so much like fundamental misunderstanding about what neurodivergent see is What ADHD is what autism is whatever it may be that then you immediately start running into stuff like, well, ADHD is just a school thing, or it's just a work thing, or it's just a keeping your house clean thing, or it's just a that thing, but it's like, no ADHD is, like I said earlier, it is entwined in every single aspect of everything we do. And then on top of that, you have a lot of like those universal experiences, like rejection sensitivity, and struggling with, you know, like you said, the trauma of neurodivergent. Se. And so, when you start having conversations, like I agree, like, I really don't think you can start with sex, like you have to start with the individual and the individuals experience of navigating through the world. But it's so much easier to just go, oh, well, you could schedule sex for Thursday's. And it's like, that's not getting to the root of anything. It's, you know,

    KC Davis 25:56

    and like, anytime a therapist, or somebody gives the advice of like, well, you know, you just have to maybe do it sometimes when you don't want to as an act of love. It's like that's not the answer. Because truly, truly, truly one of my favorite phrases is that neurons that wire together, fire together. And it just means that like, if you're doing a behavior in a specific emotional context, enough times, your brain will begin to associate that emotional context with that behavior. And it will get to the point where even if you're not in that emotional place, you will not be able to do that behavior without bringing on those emotions. Yeah, so if the more times you have sex, when you don't want to, the more times your brain will associate sex with something that is not something you want to do. And so even if you're in a position where Oh, no, I want it you hid in the bedroom, or the kitchen or the backseat of your car or whatever, and your brain will start to shut things down, it'll shut your body down, it'll shut your mind down. Because your brain, you fed your brain, this script, like you've literally given it a piece of code that says, sex is something that we just get through sex is something we distract ourselves to get through sex is something that isn't about our pleasure, it's about their pleasure. And you can't just decide that you're not going to use that piece of code without like a good bit of debugging. And every time you do obligatory sets, you reinforce those neural pathways, and random swing, and here, but I was thinking about how the reward, motivation interest of somebody with ADHD is different than someone who's neurotypical. And I'm sure people have heard this before, if they've looked into ADHD, when they talk about having interest based motivation systems we talk about, I think it's like interest, competition, novelty and urgency. One of the things that occurs to me is that I think that you when you're young, when you're dating, you may not have had any sexual issues. But then you get with a partner. And if you decide to be monogamous with that partner, fast forward months or years, and all of a sudden, you're struggling with things with sex that you never have before, and you're going what's wrong with me? Do I not love this person and do it like all these things. And to me, it's just so obvious that it dating, or in your that honeymoon phase, or you have multiple partner, whatever, like your sex is naturally going to have a sense of novelty and urgency and interest to it. And then fast forward, if you're in a monogamous relationship, or maybe it's not even a monogamous relationship, you just have a committed partner, even if it's an open relationship, or a poly relationship. And all of a sudden, like, sex is familiar. It doesn't have those qualities anymore. And as somebody with ADHD, like you actually have to then create those qualities again, and you're in the bedroom.

    Catie Osborn 28:59

    Yeah, I mean, and it's, I mean, this is the point where I always feel bad because I'm always just like, I swear, I'm not trying to recruit anybody to my team. But like, it's one of the reasons why I got so invested in like, educating about kink, because I I really do think that kink is one of the most powerful tools that a person with ADHD has in their toolbox for things like the novelization of ADHD, you know, or like intimacy with ADHD or you know, the, I don't know the shaking of things up with ADHD and it's so funny to me because like a lot of times I think people hear kink and they think like, you know, whips and chains and signing contracts and going to dungeons which like if you're into it cool. But when I talk about kink what I mostly just mean is exploring things since orally because that is very much like you know, if you boil it down and boil it down at its very core kink is simply a, I think, deeper exploration of the individual senses and how they tie into the intimate experience. And so, you know, things like, you know, the one that I always, like wind up giving an example of is like, you know, a lot of people say, well, it's really hard for me to stay in the moment during sex, because, you know, I look around and I see like, the messy bedroom, or I'm looking at the dusty ceiling fan or whatever, and I go cool, wear a blindfold. Problem solved, you know, and people go, Oh, that's so this is so kinky. Oh, my gosh, oh, and I'm like, but try it. See what happens. You know, for other people like me, especially like this is one that I do is I really like wearing like wireless earbuds during intimacy because like my neighbor, most his lawn 97 times a week, it is the weirdest I don't know what that dude is doing. But he is retired, and he is living his best grass mowing life. But it's so hard for me because you know, we'll be in the middle of something. And then the lawnmower starts and I'm like, Well, there's a noise, you know, but it's like, you know, what, this is that having music that I'm just listening to, that is technically considered cake, like now that's like the most, you know, cool with you, you know, vanilla cake ever. But you know, stuff like that. And so it's like finding, there's no shame in finding clever and creative and resourceful workarounds. When it comes to feeling like that novelty is wearing off or feeling like that urgency has worn off, because like, I don't want to speak for every person with ADHD. But I can say, personally, I sabotaged so many good relationships, because I didn't have an understanding of what a healthy stable relationship look like. Because my frame of reference, especially when I was younger, was movies and TV. And you know, I talked about this on tick tock the other day, but like, movies and TV, there's never a scene where the couple sits down and says, Hey, I love you so much. But like, oral really doesn't do it for me. And it's awkward when you do it. And I feel weird. So like, could we find that, like, that scene doesn't exist on TV, you know? And so it's like, there's this idea that like, for true intimacy, or, you know, by extension, true love to exist. Intimacy and sex is this act of mind reading it is this act of like, immediately being ready to go with a drop of a hat and being able to turn on and you know, whatever parts you have the arousal, is there enough and good and working and functional, and everybody's in the mood and there's, you know, no laundry that needs to be, you know, put into the dryer. It's very, I don't even say sanitized, but it's a very sensationalized idea of what intimacy really is.

    KC Davis 32:42

    What's really cinematic like, yeah, like, never is there the scene where, like, you know, you crawl into bed with your partner, and they go, I love you, but you smell Yeah. Will you take a shower before we do this? And yeah, it's just, it really is so huge, because so many people I think, that are struggling, are locked into this, they think it's a foregone conclusion that if they're struggling with this, it has something to do with their partner, or they are broken. So like, we immediately go to either I as a person and broken or I don't want to share any of this with my partner, because I don't want them to think it's their fault. Like, I don't love them, like, I'm not attracted to them. And I think that it's so important that we normalize having these conversations. And the other thing that's wild, like, we think that having those kinds of conversations is going to like, be really not sexy, like, Oh, it's so administrative, it's so whatever. But here's what I have found, like, intimacy is so much more than just sex, like intimacy has to do with connection. And I was so surprised to learn that having those conversations was very intimate for me. And I don't mean intimate, like, you know, candlelight, like, Ooh, I have butterflies in my stomach. But especially with a long term partner, having those kinds of conversations are very connecting, like just talking about your relationship talking, like the feeling of, we're on the same team, and we're like, we're in the trenches, and we're gonna figure this out, we're gonna have the best sex I've ever we're gonna eat like, that is the camaraderie that happens there. If both of you approach it in that way, is like builds a lot of intimacy. And that intimacy helps you in the bedroom and I just love I love when you talk about kink. And I think that for a lot of people, like you said, they hear kink and they go right to like whips and chains and dungeons, instead of really having this or they go to like, if they have a background from church, they go to like perversion, like that's the word that they associated with it. Instead of like, play like that should be where our mind goes when we hear kink is play.

    Catie Osborn 34:55

    Oh, I have so many thoughts. But I mean, I do want to say one thing about what you just said is I think that there's like a third component that sometimes happens is like, you know, people either think it's a commentary on me or I don't want to hurt their feelings. But the third option, and this is one that I get a lot in the work that I do is that having to have that conversation is some kind of red flag about the relationship. And that the need to sit down and discuss, I shouldn't have to ask for him to tell me that I love that he loves me, I shouldn't have to ask him to bring me flowers, I shouldn't have to ask her to you know, remember to load the dishwasher, whatever it may be. There's this idea. And again, I think it I really think it goes back to like, I always hate saying the media. But I think in this case, it is applicable. Like I think it goes back to like the media and those sort of like patriarchal standards of like communication is somehow bad. Communicating somehow implies a problem having to sit down and talk about, you know, whatever your needs may be, that's not an intimate thing. That's a thing to be feared. And that's like, one of the biggest things that I constantly fight against in my work is like, why shouldn't have to ask for him to tell me that he loves me. It's like, well, it should be automatic. And it should always be exactly what I need it. And you know, I always kind of look and it's I try to be very like, you know, non judgmental, because that's important. But I find myself looking at at a lot of people and saying, Well, how will he know that you need to hear I love you. Unless you tell him that you need to hear I love it. Well, he should just know. Well, he just told you that he grew up in a house where you know, people didn't say I love you. So that's not a behavior that he knows, and that he appreciates the same way that you do. And then they look at each other and go, Oh, well, that makes sense. But that that immediate jump to having to talk about it implies a problem, I think is so indicative of like, the culture that we're living in this culture of like, we especially like people who have been socialized as women, like articulating our needs, somehow makes us a less than partner or a worse partner. And it's exactly the opposite. It is exactly the opposite. In like having those conversations breeds intimacy, it breeds vulnerability. It breeds trust, it breeds communication. And that makes for better sex. Because when you feel connected and trusted and able to be open with somebody, you're gonna have better sex. That's just that's just that's science.

    KC Davis 37:27

    I think, you know, we've sort of been talking a lot about from the perspective of somebody who is female, presenting or socialized as a woman. But when I think about somebody who was raised as a man or presents as a man, or who's been basically living under the male script of patriarchy, I think that a lot of men have been socialized to be uncomfortable talking about emotion, uncomfortable talking about something that's in progress, right? Because they're supposed to fix it. And it's not supposed to be emotional. And so they look at the act of sex as their one way to get emotional closeness or intimacy. And so when you say, well, we can have this conversation and this conversation for one party might feel very intimate talking about the ins and outs and the nuts and bolts, whereas like, I can definitely see someone living under a patriarchal script of masculinity, being extremely uncomfortable in those conversations and feeling vulnerable and feeling like I don't feel close. When we talk about this, I feel laid bare. I feel insecure. I feel like we're talking about things that I have failed at. And I have been told culturally from a white supremacist culture from patriarchal culture that if I fail, I am worthless. And so they're just again, it's hugely powerful things to unpack before you even get to the bedroom, if you will. I want to ask you about one of your most popular series, which I have thoroughly enjoyed, and is probably the reason that I realized that I am I too am.

    Catie Osborn 39:01

    Oh, do you want me to do it? Is it a burnout gifted and talented semester? Brat with price kink?

    KC Davis 39:05

    Oh, yeah, I want you to do it. Haha. Yes. Okay, just talk to us about this.

    Catie Osborn 39:10

    Well, what would you I don't know what you want me to talk about. For the listeners

    KC Davis 39:15

    at home? What does it mean to be a burnt out talented gifted kid, submissive brat with a praise kink?

    Catie Osborn 39:21

    So do you like how I always cleverly managed to bring it back to neurodiversity? Like it's just I'm shoehorning it in so hard, right? Like I think one of the more interesting things that I have learned and also experienced in my own life is that for a lot of again, I'm talking about the socializes woman experience in this capacity, but for a lot of people who have lived that experience with undiagnosed neurodivergent sees they often get thrown into the gifted kid program, because neurodivergent kids tend to be really good at like certain stuff. Now there are certainly there's also the experience of neurodivergent kids who unfortunately get You know, the remedial behavioral problems? Yeah, remedial, which is also like just as unfair for its own set of reasons. But my experience was being an undiagnosed neurodivergent kid who got thrown into gifted programs because I was extremely good at school. So already off the bat, like my experience with ADHD was not that I was failing out of school where I was struggling at school, school was my time to shine, school was the thing that I had, and the place where I would get the accolades and I would get the recognition and I was in every club and every, you know, straight A's and all that stuff.

    KC Davis 40:31

    Do you want to know how I refer to that I would love to being smart, was the driftwood that I clung to in a sea of insecurity.

    Catie Osborn 40:40

    That's how I know that you've written a book, because that's a good author wordings, but like, but that was it was like, and for a lot of people, you're exactly right, that is the driftwood that they cling to. And so a lot of people develop this sort of like identity as like, I'm good at school, and I'm smart, and I'm gifted, I'm the gifted kid or whatever. And then this thing happens, where you graduate, and or, you know, you do what I do, and you go to grad school three more times, because you just feel like you can't get enough. But then like, at some point, you don't have anybody to tell you that you're doing a good job. And you don't have anybody to say, Oh, my God, you're so smart. And this is amazing. And you're you have so much potential, because now you're like, 35, you know, you're like, What am I doing. And so like I jokingly started talking about, like being a burnt out gifted and talented submissive brat with a price cake. And it turned out that there is a hell of a lot of us out there on the old tiktoks. But I think that I make a lot of jokes about that series, because that's kind of like my fun, you know, like, silly series. But I also think that there's something like deeply truthful about that, living that experience of being, you know, somebody who comes from that world of, you know, gifted and talented programs, and now feeling older and feeling more grown up, but still wanting to hear that good job and still wanting to hear that like, Yeah, wow, that was you did a good job a plus. And so for a lot of people, so just shows up as a praise cake, or just, you know, enjoying praise. And so yeah, and so I started that series very facetiously. But one of the things that has come out of it is honestly just like a profound appreciation for the community of people who sort of like identify along that line, because it's like, it can be really, I don't want to say hard, but it can be really challenging to navigate the world and have these places where, like, you really want to hear the good job, and you really want to get the accolades, but like, where do you get them now that you're 35? And so it turns out that turns out the answer is Bucha. Jobs, answers blow jobs, and no, like, you know, occasionally go on to the next budget, or whatever it may be for you. Yeah, but yeah,

    KC Davis 42:51

    every time I hear you talk, I just have this overwhelming sense of like, are we the same person? We

    Catie Osborn 42:55

    might be? I've been, I've been thinking about it. You have cooler tattoos.

    KC Davis 42:59

    I also went to grad school, literally, because I finished college and thought, Oh, God, I am not ready to be an adult. I will just keep going to school. Yeah, so I had a similar experience in school. And my was interesting, because I was very good at school, I was very intelligent. I was one of those like, oh, let's pick you out at seventh grade to go take the SATs, like that kind of thing. But I never ever did homework, because ADHD, like, like, go home. And I just can't make my own structure around those things. But I loved to learn. And so for a lot of people with experiences, they do really well in school, and then they get out of school. And then they have this disappointment of I'm not changing the world. Actually, I didn't amount to anything, I just am a normal person with a normal job. And my experience was a little bit different. Because what happened, my drop off was high school. Because what happened was, I went to a school where the way that they weighted grades was that tests, quizzes, participation, and like classwork were the majority of your grade. And your homework was like a very small percentage. So even though I never ever, ever, ever did my homework, I was the girl whose hand was always raised, I could sit there and listen to the lecture, not take any notes. And then a week later, take a quiz or a test and get 100 on it, because I would retain all of the information. It made sense it was this interconnected web of concepts in my mind. But what happened was, even though I did get in trouble about the homework, I'd never gotten too much trouble. I was still making straight A's. When I went to college, I went to an all girls private prep school, and two things happened. Number one, they started testing us on things that they didn't teach us in class. Now we'll get you right like I'm gonna teach chapters one through three and then you're gonna go home and read and learn chapters four and five, and then we're going to get a test over all of it when you come back. And because I wasn't doing homework, and I didn't know how and I had no Gill's to figure out how to structure myself for that, I quickly started failing tests. And they also changed the way that they weighted grades. So now the work you were doing outside of class had a much bigger impact on the class grade. And so I started failing, literally failing. EFS, DDS, I ended up having a lot of behavior problems, addiction problems, I got expelled from that private school. And so, you know, whether it's that experience, or like your experience, but it's the same thing, it's this, like, you get identified early as just being inherently better than everyone else.

    Catie Osborn 45:38

    And it's so damaging, it's so damaging. And when that eventually

    KC Davis 45:43

    falls off, you, you're like, Well, this was all I had, I was the smart girl, I was the competent girl, I was the girl that was better than everybody else. And then all the sudden, like you said, you're in grad school, or you're in the workforce, or you're just like a regular adult. And we don't know where to go anymore. Yeah.

    Catie Osborn 46:02

    And I love like, your story is so interesting to me, because like, I feel like we are, we're the same person. But like, we literally took the two paths that we see undiagnosed neurodivergent, especially girls go through where you where there's that point of change, there's that point of the structure has broken down. And for a lot of people, it's going into college, for a lot of people, it's when they get married, or they you know, they move out and they're like, on their own for the first time. You know, for some kids, it's high school, but for for like the vast majority, it does tend to be college. But it is exactly what you just said, like you, you know, left school, you're dealing with addiction you're dealing with like behavioral stuff. And then I went the opposite way, I was the person who threw myself in with this, like desperate clinging on to this idea that I had to be the best and I had to be perfect and whatever. So I'm gonna go earn two degrees that I don't really need, you know, and like all of this up, just to keep proving myself over and over and over. But that is like that's kind of like the path, you know, you can either

    KC Davis 47:10

    because perfect is the only option. And so it actually creates two paths, you can continue to pursue perfect, or you can go anti perfect, and I'm going to be the most perfect drug addict, I'm going to be the most perfect, like Kurt Cobain feeling, you know, like, just tragic. I'm going to embrace this tragic beauty Fallout, I'm not even going to try anymore. Because if I try and fail, I'll have to own up to me being a failure. But if I don't try it all, if I don't try it all, Katie and I just go use a bunch of drugs, then I just get to tell myself, while I'm, you know, the failure of society, but then I get to tell myself, it's just because I didn't try. I mean, I am smarter than everyone. I am better than everyone, but I'm not participating in society. Yeah, that's why, right. Okay, so this is the burnt out, talented and gifted part. And then the next part is the submissive part. And I will tell you this, like it folds right in because I find that if you're someone who has been sort of labeled, competent, strong, extrovert, like those things, if you've just always sort of been in control, there is something about being in a position and being allowed to be safely submissive. That is, like, so relieving.

    Catie Osborn 48:36

    Yeah. Well, it's for me, especially like, it's like, I think, again, people here submissive, and what they sometimes like, fill in the blank is like perversion, you know, or like trauma, or like, whatever. And it's like, no, like, I always explain it, like, a lot, like, and I think a lot of neurodivergent people get this, but it's like, at the end of the day, I'm exhausted from making decisions, because every decision that I have to make throughout the day, is just another like, you know, emotional expenditure. It's another spoon that I'm spending on whatever. And sometimes, I don't want to have to do that I'm tired, I'm exhausted or whatever. And the safety of having a partner who I trust and I, you know, I've communicate with and that kind of thing, but just looking at and being able to say, I just want to turn my brain off, you know, it doesn't even have to be a sex thing. Like the majority of you know, what I would say is, you know, my submissive right with a price tag is like, I let Chris choose what he wants for dinner. Like we just if you pick where we're going for dinner, I don't care, you know, like that kind of stuff. Like it doesn't have to be like overtly sexual, but sometimes it's nice because like circling all the way back to kind of the beginning of the conversation, it can be so hard for me to turn off my brain it can be is so deep to call for me to get into my body like that is one of the hardest things for me is to just be present and be there in the moment and be like, okay, like, I'm going to experience this intimacy with you. And so being able to just kind of look at a person that I love deeply and trust and say, and I'm sort of giving you the keys because I don't want to drive like that it can be, it's such a relief, it feels like a sigh, you know, like that kind of thing.

    KC Davis 50:26

    The sigh and I also to me, it's also connected to like being told my whole life that I'm too intimidating. Yeah, for the people that I'm attracted to. And so like, and like you said, it doesn't have to even be sexual or in the bedroom or any of that like, but to have this moment of being told, it's okay to wilt. Like, you're not too intimidating for me, like, I will step up to the challenge. Like you're and it's, there's something deeply affirming about for me the messaging of your worth stepping up to the challenge, I see you where no one else sees you, right. Everyone else is intimidating. But I see, I see someone that will I can turn to putty in my hand. So there's this aspect of intimacy of like, I see you.

    Catie Osborn 51:15

    Well, that's also I feel like that's like, that's where we get to like the next one, which is like the brat, right? Because for me, like, you know, like, I feel like, I don't know, branding. I think it's like a bad rap. Because like, a lot of times a lot of like there are a lot of I will say it, I can say what I want. I'm an adult. Like there's a lot of toxic brats in the kink community who really like foist that onto people like their branding, non consensually, and I don't get down with that. But what I do, like, what will absolutely like drop my panties Is that is that notion of like, you are worth it, like you're worth the work, you're worth the investment. And like for me, I think it is it is reinforcing to myself, that like I am desirable, and that I am valid as I am, you know, but that looks like presenting a little bit of a challenge because like I want to feel desired. And I want to feel like my asking you to take the keys, you know, and drive isn't an inconvenience. And I think a lot of that ties in also with like rejection sensitivity in a major way. But I've spent so long I've spent so much of my life, apologizing for my existence, and apologizing for taking up space, and apologizing for you know, my accommodation needs in my and just like how my brain is and how I am that being able to look at somebody and be like, not only am I not going to apologize, but I'm going to make it a little bit hard for you because I know that you want this and that you think I'm worth it. That's been one of the healthiest things, for me as an adult is just that feeling of being able to like look at somebody and have that amount of trust, and that amount of intimacy and that amount of vulnerability. And it just but it comes in being silly, and it comes in being goofy and it comes in you know, being like a little bit sassy and sarcastic or whatever, you know, your version of brat looks like. But for me, it's about that trust. And it's about that intimacy and having that with somebody, it sounds trite to say it, but it's powerful. It's powerful, and it's meaningful. And it's you know, talking about, like needs versus wants, but like, I don't necessarily think I need it. But like it's something that I want to have in my life because it is so good. It's just good.

    KC Davis 53:35

    So I have two thoughts, and I don't want to forget them. But for anybody who's sort of clutching their pearls and doesn't actually know what a brat is. Can you give us an example of what that means? Or a definition of what that looks like?

    Catie Osborn 53:48

    Yeah, I mean, I think like, the best sort of like shorthand explanation is like in a traditional power exchange dynamic, there is a dominant partner and a submissive partner. And traditionally, you know, the DOM says, you know, like, I don't know, like, go drink some water. And the submissive says, Yes, sir. Or, you know, whatever honorific there is, and drinks water in a submissive brat relationship that might look more like, why don't you come over here and make me you know, where there's like, a little there's like a rise to the power, there's a rise to like, I don't wanna say the occasion. But there is there is a push back there, but the pushback is based on the understanding that this is play that this is a sort of, like exploration of the power dynamic, because you know, we talk a lot about like, you know, the dog having all the power, but in a, I think, truly healthy kink relationship. There is an absolute power balance, where the DOM is agreeing to take the keys and you know, drive, but the submissive says, and I trust you and I'm along for the ride. And so a brat sort of is like in that like middle ground where it's like they're not necessarily dominant, but for me, like I've literally just Switch. So I go back and forth. But the brat moment is sort of about that moment of like, well, yeah, like, you want me to drink water, we'll come over here and make me and then whatever that looks like happens, but then ultimately, they drink the water. And the dog goes, Ah, you're such brat, like, does is that a good enough explanation

    KC Davis 55:20  

    I think it's a great explanation I do. And I think that when we talk about people who want to, like dip their toes into the water here, you know, if you replace drink water with take your clothes off, it's like, there's nothing Dungeoneering about that for somebody that sort of like, Oh, I could never ask for that. But it's like, yeah, that's something that even the most sort of vanilla couple would be like, Oh, well, that's an exchange that we

    Catie Osborn 55:44  

    might have. Right? Yeah, you know, or you have 30 seconds to take off your clothes, or I'm taking them off for you. Like, that's high. Like, that's high, you know, but it's also like, but then like, you're not having to be like, Oh, my gosh, are they in the mood? Like, am I being an inconvenience? Like, what if they don't really want me to take my clothes off, like, all of that is sudden, all of those like rejection sensitivity, voices are suddenly silenced because this person is looking and going. And if you're not done in 30 seconds, we're gonna have a problem, you know. And that's like, that's so powerful like that is so powerful for somebody who is accustomed to feeling like a burden and accustomed to feeling broken and accustomed to feeling like an inconvenience. Having that. I don't want to say subliminal, but that underlying message of and if I didn't want this, I wouldn't be telling you to get it done in 30 seconds. Like, it's the first like, kick changed my life like it did. Like I'll say, I don't care. kink absolutely changed my life, because it allowed me to the for the first time ever, to be the one who was calling the shots being the one who was getting asked if I was okay, being making sure that I was safe and supported. And that's why I'm such a big sort of like, advocate for all of the potentialities that kink holds in those spaces where you might feel insecure, or you might feel less than or you might feel broken. Because I think over and over and over in a relationship like that, you're being told no, I want this, I want you in a way that I think sometimes we aren't accustomed to communicating if that makes any sense.

    KC Davis 57:22  

    Yeah. And I think it directly scratches that like itch, or like heals that wound of like being too much. Like, if you're told that you're too much your whole life, there's something that about you that comes to yearn for someone to say, not just I want you, but you're worth the work that it would take to want you that, because I know how to perform. I know how to be docile, I know how to be a good girl, you know, in the sense of like, oh, I laugh at his jokes and all talk quietly, and I'll be quiet and submissive, like, but I also know that that's not really who I am. And there's this fear. And this experience, frankly, of when someone sees my real personality, and it's too much, they won't want that. And so there's something really healing about that. In our play that exchange of, but if it's hard to love me, will you still want to? Yeah. Will you still pursue? Will you still push Will you still? And you know, what's funny is like, we really do have this idea that kink is this like, perverse thing. But when I look back in my life at the characters and movies and fiction that I relate, not related to the most, but that I gravitated towards, that were like the most acceptable PG G character like Elizabeth Bennet, right? Or like any character that is saying to and that's why I was always obsessed with J not like really looking back and realizing that the reason I was obsessed with Jane Austen is because of kink was because like she would do these characters of women that would say to a man, I hate you, and the man would go, Well, I hate you. And she's this like, difficult person. And then all of a sudden, this man's like, Wait, actually, I'm in love with you. And even if you push me away, I'm going to keep pushing because that's how fucking maddening I am with how amazing you are like, looking back and realizing that like, even in like my most like innocent identification of characters, it was this same dynamic.

    Catie Osborn 59:37  

    So okay, I have one really silly story about this. So speaking of going to grad school way too many times, I have two master's degrees in Shakespeare, and my thesis advisor for when I was getting my MFA, we were like going through my resume and he was like, looking at me he's like, okay, so you got like, You got Beatrice. Okay, you've got K K. You've got Rosalind K got Lady Macbeth K. At some point he's like going down the list. Seems like have you ever noticed that all you play as brats? And I was like, I mean, there's a reason why I play like a very limited scope of roles in Shakespeare, but it's like because but I think like Shakespeare is a little bit the same way, like a lot of the women that he writes like, the really good lovers like Beatrice and and Kate are absolutely do that, too. It's that sort of like, Austin dynamic of like, I'm going to push back and I'm going to like talk shit. And I'm going to like, make you prove that you want this. And I love, like, tame like, I mean, Tammy has is problematic for its own reasons. But like, Kate and Beatrice are my two characters to play. And I play them quite frequently. And it's, but I love those characters. I like I love those roles because of that, because it's that same. Like they're both burnt out gifted kids like they're brilliant women who are stuck in these dole sort of scenarios. But yeah, like, it's the same exact thing.

    KC Davis 1:01:04  

    It's funny, because I've been watching the second season of bridgerton.

    Catie Osborn 1:01:07  

    I haven't started it yet. Well,

    KC Davis 1:01:10  

    let me tell you, there had been some audible like, yes. From me in the moment, because it is exactly that story of like, Oh, she's difficult, and she's too much and she doesn't fit in. And she's too smart.

    Catie Osborn 1:01:26  

    She's so hot. Right?

    KC Davis 1:01:30  

    And I must know. Well, that's awesome. Well, listen, Katie, this has been the coolest talk ever.

    Catie Osborn 1:01:40  

    Hooray. Thanks for having me. I'm so happy to be here. This is great. You're so cool. I like you so much. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I just think you're so great.

    KC Davis 1:01:49  

    Thank you. Oh, I like you, too. When I went to rehab when I was 16, we had to do these like various treatment assignments to like build our skills or whatever. And some of them were really intense about like journaling about your trauma and things like that. But some of them were like, very, like basic level, not really had a treatment assignment called like making friends. And this is so funny. So you had to like write about friendship and like, do all these things. There's like several things. But one of the things that you had to do swear to god is you had to pick two people in the community is 16 Girls, that's how big this treatment center was. We were 16. If we were between 13 and 17. That was the age range. And so at group every night, because we'd group every day and like you had to do this assignment, you had to walk up to the girl in the group, and you had to cross your arms, and they had to cross theirs and you had to hold their hands in that criss cross position. And you had to say these words. Are you ready? Katie?

    Will you be my friend? I do want me to make more friends. And literally the person will be like, Yes, I will. And that is the funniest fucking thing in the world to me that they had us do that. And for years and years and years to this day, like girls that I went to this treatment center with, we will like that's like one of our funniest inside jokes.

    Sara, will you be my friend and help me to make more friends. So every time somebody has or like it's you always always like fellow neurodivergent has that moment they're like, will you be my friend? I know that's awkward. I'm gonna be like, Haha, are we telling you? I am the master of explicitly asking someone if they want to be my friend to help me make more friends. So I find that endearing and awesome. We are friends. All right. Well, Katie, can you tell people where they can find you?

    Catie Osborn 1:03:34  

    Oh, I do lighting. So I go by Katie Soros on all social medias. I also have a podcast. It's called Katie and Eric's infinite quest in ADHD adventure. We talk about life with ADHD and neurodivergent it and living life with depression, all sorts of stuff. We talk a lot about relationships and kink and that kind of stuff. And I have a website now because I'm fancy. You can go to kT a source.com. And you can see all the cool stuff that I'm doing. Or you can go to infinite Quest podcast.com. You could go to all three, it whatever you want to do is fine.

    KC Davis 1:04:04  

    If you want to if you want to I mean, if it's not a bother.

    Catie Osborn 1:04:07  

    I'm not. It's just It's fine. There's you could if you wanted to I wouldn't be bad. It'd be fine.

    KC Davis 1:04:11  

    We will link that in the show notes for everybody. Hey, awesome. Well, thank you, Katie.

    Catie Osborn 1:04:16  

    Yeah, thanks so much for having me.



KC Davis
35: Discouraged with Self-Care with Taylor Elyse Morrison

Self-care is a term we hear EVERYWHERE right now, and you’ve heard me talk about it over and over again. Today’s discussion is around the disillusionment of the self-care industry that I’m feeling, along with many others. I’m joined by Taylor Elyse Morrison, the author of Inner Workout: Strengthening Self-Care Practices for Healing Body, Soul, and Mind. Taylor is a founder, facilitator, coach, and serial entrepreneur, and she uses her coaching, mindfulness, and movement training to meet people where they are and offer actionable steps toward avoiding burnout. I’m putting Taylor on the spot by asking questions and picking her brain about common self-care struggles, and she is up for the challenge! Let’s see how this turns out!

Show Highlights:

  • How the consumeristic quality of today’s self-care movement ignores the marginalizations and barriers that many people experience that bring distress and hopelessness

  • Why Taylor urges us to ask, “Is it the Self, or is it the System?”

  • Why Taylor created a self-care assessment to give people “practical starting points”

  • How Taylor’s self-care assessment is based on the five yogic dimensions

  • Why self-care is often confused with pleasure as the hard work of self-care is overlooked

  • Why part of self-care is holding onto yourself in the presence of other people

  • Why wisdom is a part of self-care, along with the components of presence, self-trust, and aligned action

  • How curiosity and self-compassion play into effective self-care

  • Why Taylor is satisfied with the feedback she is getting from her book

Resources and Links:

Connect with Taylor: Website, (Buy her book, take the free self-care assessment, and join her newsletter group.) TikTok, and Instagram.

Find Taylor’s book on Amazon:  Inner Workout: Strengthening Self-Care Practices for Healing Body, Soul, and Mind.

Find Inner Workout on TikTok and Instagram.

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient balls of stardust. I am your host, KC Davis. This is Struggle Care. And today we're going to talk about self care and the disillusionment of the self care industry. And I have Taylor Elyse Morrison with me. She's the author of a new book called Inner Workout: Strengthening Self Care Practices for Healing Body, Mind and Soul. And Taylor, I'm glad that you're here with us. First of all, thank you so much for coming. And thank you for writing such a wonderful book.

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 0:33

    Thank you for having me. I'm super excited to get into this conversation always. But like, especially with you,

    KC Davis 0:39

    okay, so I didn't tell Taylor this. But well, here's what I'd like to do, I want to tell you something that I have been struggling with, and maybe you can give me back some hope and encouragement. Let's do it. All right, I hope you like being put on the spot. Here's the thing when I was reading your book, I was reading even just like the intro, and one of the things that obviously stood out to me is that early and often you talk about how the self care industry has really focused on this idea that we can all just sort of bubble bath our way into a great mental health and excellent life. Like there's this real consumerism behind self care. And you talk really beautifully about how that doesn't really take into account people's intersecting kind of marginalization, and privileges, and community, and all these things that actually affect our lives. And so here's something that I wanted to ask you, because of you writing this book. And so not everyone can see you, but you are a black woman. And that's a really unique perspective that I think you bring to this book. And so, you know, I know, we don't know each other, but I'm just gonna sort of word vomit on you for a minute, I have been doing this work around self care, and trying to make content that can really help people that are experiencing real barriers in their life, recognizing that so many of people's problems is happening because of this intersection of where they are in society, the barriers that they have in society, that marginalization that they experience. And I've honestly kind of found myself, like swung so far away from the idea that individual choices can just self care our way out of distress, that now I'm experiencing discouragement. I'm experiencing almost like a little hopelessness about like, well, what can we do anything? Like how can we help somebody have self care in the midst of things in their life, they cannot change that is absolutely creating this difficulty and this distress in their life. And I can feel myself shifting that far, and feeling that hopelessness. And I think that it came from a pretty like a good place of me looking at my own privileges and recognizing like, you know, I can't just go half cocked and tell someone, well, I do this. And it's so helpful, because the reality is sure, that might be a helpful practice. But how much of my life's enjoyment is really coming from other things like being financially secure, like having a marriage that isn't abusive, you know, by not being afraid every time I leave my house. And so I'm kind of in this spot where I'm almost like, afraid to speak. And I don't know, it feels so hopeless. And so I'm hoping that maybe because of the book that you wrote, you can speak some to that about how do we reach people, and validate that the things in their life that are causing distress are real and in many ways are systemic? But is there any place for us to help ourselves in that?

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 3:33

    Yeah, who, I feel that so deeply, I appreciate you sharing that. And it's funny, because I'm like, how much hope am I actually going to be able to provide, as I start thinking about, like, I've been doing this work around self care for about five years now. And as I think about what I want for the rest of my career, and if I read another book, there's so much around community care, and the systems that need to change around care, like that's the conversation I'm really interested in having in the future and the decades and years to come. Because I do think that if you are a person who wants to think intersectionally, about the conversation around self care, you're inevitably going to end up at a similar place where we're at now. And also, I think, and I am someone who has consumed your content, and I know how useful it can be. I think that you're doing a disservice if you don't speak up and share your intersectional perspective. A question that I've offered up to people in my community in the past is, is it the self or is it the system? And sometimes I just do that as a check for myself to say, okay, is this like a mindset, a belief, a habit? That is really coming from me that I can shift and experiment and find something that better serves me, or is it this is happening because there's a system that I keep running up at And I need to accept it and not an accepting it that we should be in this place of systemic inequity. But accepting that this is the reality more from a mindfulness perspective, this is the reality. And instead of feeling like I have to contort myself to change into fit into this, I can just say, Okay, this is how things are right now, my energy can be better spent elsewhere. So when I talk to people, and I have this framework in the book of like the ecosystems of care, I believe that we are our own ecosystem, we exist within ecosystems, we're part of nature as humans, even though we like to forget that I talk a lot, especially in this book about the ecosystem of you. And then looking a little bit at your communities, because that's where we can have the most control it even for some of us listening here, like, I don't feel like I even have that much control in those ecosystems. But it can be helpful to from like a locus of control perspective, instead of getting. So zooming out so far that you feel helpless, sometimes it's helpful to zoom in and say, I can take three deep breaths right now. Or I can get up and stretch for a moment. And that can be really, I don't always like to use the word empowering, but that can be really satisfying, really nourishing to zoom in for a moment, your agency. Yes, exactly.

    KC Davis 6:21

    I love what you said about that. Because that piece of looking for where we can reclaim some agency really struck with me, because that's the piece that I think is different for everyone. And in your example about like, Is this me? Or is this the system? And the example I thought of is like, you know, when I go to the doctor, and they say, Okay, did you apply that ointment three times a week, and like I didn't, because I'm really awful with any type of like, repetitive routine, I always found myself being like, I have to lie, I can't tell them and then recognizing, like, I'm really blocking my access to health care, by not being honest with my doctor. And it was empowering. And it was agency for me to go, No, I need to start being honest, I need to own who I am and say, This is me, I didn't do it. And I need to care more about my getting good health care than I do about the doctor judging me. Because in that example, it was me. However, if I was someone else, that may not have been the same, like if I was someone who was disabled. Or if I was a black woman who have historically been treated really poorly within the medical system, I might be thinking, No, that's not me, that's the system that is if I don't look like a perfect compliant patient, I'm not going to get access to the health care that I deserve. And that's coming up against a system. And that really sort of turned a light bulb on for me when you said that. Because I think that first step isn't just jumping right to here's how you should talk to your doctor. But as acknowledging that question of Is this me? Or is this the system? Because if it is me, then maybe who I am, I get to press into that and reclaim some agency and some empowerment. But if I realized, no, this is the system, like you said, like, I don't have to contort myself, or spin energy there, I can look for a different sort of like carve out in my life to do that.

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 8:14

    Yeah, it just really, it saves a lot of energy. And then when you do want to do the work of changing systems, we could do that being supported by a community instead of constantly. Because honestly, the system is set up to make it feel like everything is your individual problem, and you are a bad person. And so it's really nice to be like, Oh, wait, that's not me. That's how you design this thing. And I don't have to take that as me being wrong. You're wrong. The system is wrong.

    KC Davis 8:41

    Yeah. And it can be validating. I think, like, I think that's the goal, right is if you validate, yes, this is happening to you because of a systemic issue. The hope is, is that in itself can be self care to someone of like, Oh, I'm not broken, I'm not wrong. I'm not just a screw up. And then finding those places of agency where we can do something small for ourselves. I took your self care assessment on your website, which I really liked, because again, it didn't point to specific things to be doing, which that's my other gripe about self care is like, okay, if I'm overwhelmed, I don't need another like to do list to fail at. And I really enjoyed the questions that it asked and it asked them questions that I didn't, that I was surprised by. So can you tell me how you kind of came up with this little assessment for self care? Yeah,

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 9:33

    so first of all, that's my favorite piece of feedback is like, Oh, I didn't expect that on his self care assessment. And I'm like, yes, because there's so many opportunities for us to care for ourselves, that we don't realize we don't accept that those things are caring for ourselves. So the way that this came to be is everything that I do the book the assessment, the company is rooted in this idea of the five dimensions of well being which are inspired by The yogic concept of the coaches. And for me, that was a big aha moment to realize that the way I had been sold self care was primarily about caring for my body. And really, it was about making my body look like what the societal standard of what a body should look like was. And so to realize there are all these different aspects of myself, yes, there's the physical dimension, but there's also the energetic dimension, the mental and emotional dimension, the wisdom dimension, tapping into my own wisdom, and the bliss dimension, which is all about connection. And I realized that there are all these instances, when I was feeling stressed, was doing the kind of treat yo self version of self care, which was often me buying something for my body. And I might feel really good in the moment. And then I, a day, a week later, was coming back to this place of feeling overwhelmed and burned out. And some of that was the way that I was structuring my life. And some of that was that I was doing these quote unquote, care things that were caring for the aspect of myself that didn't actually need care right now. So thinking about the five dimensions of well being really shifted things for me in terms of caring for myself holistically. And the assessment I built that at the beginning of the pandemic, I'm an assessment girly, I love having different ways to think of myself, not from a prescriptive way of like, you need to, again, I don't like being confined into boxes, but more I think of them as like conversation starters with myself. And at the beginning of the pandemic, I had just launched in our workout as a company, thought I was going to be doing a lot of in person stuff couldn't do in person stuff. But everyone needed self care a lot. And so an assessment seemed kind of like an a scalable way to get people in conversations with themselves and to give them some practical starting points.

    KC Davis 11:50

    I liked how much it focused, and your book talks about connection and meaning and the questions that asked about like, Do you have a sense of a higher purpose? Do you have a sense of connectedness with people, I would never consider those self care questions. But when I look at my life, and I think, okay, in what way do I feel cared for? And what ways do I feel strengthened to deal with things in my life, and a lot of it is this feeling of having meaning in life having sort of a connectedness to something that is bigger than me. And I also really appreciated the questions about like, do we allow ourselves to feel distressing feelings? Because when you mentioned like, Okay, I would buy something that would feel good. I think sometimes, I think there's a lot of room for a conversation about like, pleasure versus care. Because a lot of times I think self care gets packaged as just pleasure, like you need more pleasure in your life. And obviously, hot pleasure is a very important part of our lives. But not all self care is pleasurable. And so I thought that that was an interesting thing for you to bring out, which is, and then the other questions about like, do I make decisions that sort of align with my values? And so I was wondering if you could maybe speak to like, the hard work of self care?

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 13:06

    Yeah, I love that. You mentioned this. And I think, actually, one of my former teammates, this was this might have been who was first introduced to your work is because they sent me a video where you talked about like caring for yourself in the present, and thinking about past versions of yourself and future versions of yourself. And I think that speaks so well to the hard work of self care. Because when we are focused on pleasure, we and I can speak from the I do this, I want to feel good right now. And so I'm gonna eat something that I know, like, I'm lactose intolerant. I've known this for like three years, I still have more dairy than I should, especially when I'm feeling stressed out and I'm like, I know I'm gonna pay for this. My stomach's gonna be hurting. But in the moment, it feels good to have that ice cream. That's a very like, pleasure centric idea of self care. But if I was thinking more holistically about myself, I would think, Okay, is there another way that I can be with myself, I can tend to myself, the definition I use for self care is listening within and responding in the most loving way possible. When I'm thinking holistically, there's probably something else I could do besides have that ice cream that would be listening to myself, would be responding with love and would also respect a future version of myself who doesn't want to be doubled over and stomach pain for a while. So I think for me, it's going back to this continuing listening and responding with love. And knowing that like you said, love and care doesn't always feel like sunshine and roses. Sometimes it is sitting with yourself in the sadness. I'll like full disclosure, I was crying on my kitchen floor last night. And I was having this conversation with myself where I was like, I wrote a book on self care. I own a self care company. Shouldn't I not be feeling this sadness should may not be struggling right now. And that's actually part of the work. Part of the work was for me to allow myself to cry, allow myself to feel these feelings because there was a toxic positivity, spiritual bypassing version of myself who felt like I was bad and wrong, if I was having those emotions he was trying to kind of trickle out. So doing the creating, for me, a certain level of structure that I can play within is a way that I don't love structure naturally. But it actually is really good for my ADHD brain to have structure, or I don't want to have this conversation with my husband. But I know that on the other side of it, we're going to be stronger. Those are all things that don't feel good in the moment, but are supporting you for the long term.

    KC Davis 15:47

    Yeah, that's really good insight. I'm going to pause for a second have a word from our sponsors, and we'll be right back. You know, for some reason that word self care is so overused, that it almost like doesn't have meaning anymore. And it's like one word. And when I find myself, instead of asking, like, what self care can I do today, instead of asking that asking, like, how can I care for myself today? Because I think that puts a little more in perspective. And just like you said, like, if I think about how do I care for my animals, right, like, caring for my animals isn't like, a lot of it is pleasure, and love and affection, and those sorts of things. But some of it is also like stuff that is going to be really uncomfortable for them, but I know supports their health, sometimes it's going to be like not letting them go outside, right, like not letting my cats go outside, even though that would give them more pleasure. But that would, in fact, put them in more danger and sort of learning to look at self care like that for myself. And I have a friend that's a therapist that used to mentor me, and one of the phrases that she used, that I really loved was talking about being able to hold on to yourself in the presence of someone else. And so she would talk about, you know, when you brought up like having a conversation with your husband, so I'm like that too, I'm kind of conflict avoidant, especially if I know that I'm gonna say something that he's gonna have feelings about. And she would talk to me about, you know, part of what the goal of caring for self is, is so that, you know, you can stand in front of this person, and be honest and be authentic, and then hold on to yourself in the presence of his emotions, like not spend so much time trying to couch it a certain way, or avoid it a certain way so that you can control his emotional reaction. But instead, like, how can I address myself so that I can allow him to have the feelings that he's going to have? And I'm obvious caveat, like, I'm talking about like a loving, respectful relationship, I'm not talking about like, I have to do things. So I'm not abused. But that reminded me of what you were talking about when you were saying, you know, what do I need in this moment, to sort of do the things that align with my values that are going to set me up for greater like quality of life tomorrow,

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 17:58

    I love that perspective that your mentor offered, of being able to hold on to yourself, and as we were talking about in the beginning, like self care and community care, and being a human who lives in systems that have varying degrees of being able to support us, this idea of coming back to yourself and grounding in yourself, and holding on to yourself just seems even more important. And I think that's why the way that I talk about self care is a conversation with yourself, and being able to find these loving responses in the midst of all of these different circumstances, loving responses that consider all of these different facets of you is just really important. And I think I joke around sometimes I'm like, Why did I choose this career talking about self care? That is this nothing word right now. But when we get to these places where we're talking about caring for ourselves, caring for other people actually feeling cared for and experiencing care, I get teary eyed because it's like, if everyone were able to access this on a day to day basis, if our systems were set up for that, but also if we set up our life's for that, to the extent that we're able, like, how different would our worlds be? How beautiful would our world be? It gets me Yeah, gets me a little teary eyed.

    KC Davis 19:21

    I remember being in rehab, and, you know, learning about sort of this idea that things that like sort of your inner child, right, and that like things that you go through as a child really stick with you, and sort of shaped the way that you react to things going through this process of like, visualizing myself holding myself as a child, and comforting myself as a child. And I would come back to that visual like, every night as I was going to bed as things were so hard. And you know, I was getting a lot of feedback about my behavior and the ways I was showing up in the world and things that needed to change. And it was hard hard for that like inner child to hear even valid criticism about my behavior without feeling like, you know, oh, that means I'm worthless. And I kept coming back to this visual of like, now I'm the adult, I wasn't until I was like 16. But it's like, now I'm the big person who can consider this feedback. And like, it just was the reality that nobody was going to step in, and tend to that inner child for me, even though that's what I deserved. And I kind of had to learn to do it for myself through that kind of like visualization. And that's the memory that I came up with, as I was reading through some of your material. And then the last thing I really wanted to ask you about was you have a section on wisdom as self care. And I've never seen that before. So I'm curious if you could talk for a bit about the idea of wisdom as self

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 20:52

    care. Yeah, so the wisdom dimension of wellbeing, that's what it's talked about, again, like this was inspired by the coaches. And for me, what I kept coming back to is, so many of I mean, myself, first, I'm always patient zero, but also the people in my community, the people that I've gotten to work with one on one, one of the things that makes it so hard for them to care for themselves, is that they don't trust themselves. They don't trust their inner knowings. They, if they do get to the place where they can even hear what their inner voice, whatever you want to call it, their inner wisdom is telling them, there's a huge gap between hearing that and then feeling like they can do something about that. So the three sub dimensions of the wisdom dimension are presence, which is all of our focus, which is all about being present, and living in the present moment, which in and of itself is something that is so hard. And again, the systems, the software's everything around us is not set up to support that, especially if you have any type of neuro divergence. And then there's the self trust, and the aligned action. And those two go together a lot. Being able to hear yourself know that watching something doesn't serve you I think I talked in the book about how like, I couldn't watch skin squid games, because I'm a highly sensitive person, that's too much for me, and everyone was talking about it. And I kept being like, ooh, should I want to like watch what everyone else is doing? I had to be like, No, or it could be career decisions that you're making, or realizing that you need to read negotiate relationships or renegotiate how you structure a part of your day. And there's one thing to know that to feel wherever if you're ahead a heart or a gut person, but to feel that over time. And it's another thing to do something about it. And it can be so scary. When everyone else seems to be thriving, doing something that is not serving you to be able to step out. It is so caring, like right now. I'm back on like a sober, curious journey from alcohol. In the first time around I did it I was so uncomfortable being telling people like, Hey, I'm not drinking right now. And seeing a lot of times what was other people's reactions and perceived judgment of me making a decision. And so taking them out of line to action can be hard when you're in an environment where everyone else has a different status quo.

    KC Davis 23:24

    The I love it. It's always called sober curious, because one of my other like therapist mentors, he uses curiosity a lot, where he'll say instead of asking, like, why did you do that he'll be like, so I'm curious about that. Tell me more. And he talks about, like, even being curious with yourself. And he'll literally say, like, get curious, get curious with yourself, like, how is this affecting you what's going on with you? And I think that that has been, you know, I talk a lot about self compassion. And I think that it's like one of the most powerful tools at our disposal for caring for yourself. But I think that other aspect of curiosity, right, so whether that is a sober, curious journey, whether that is, you know, what would it be like if I were to quit this toxic job, not saying I am or I am not? Not, you know, instead of getting caught up in like, well, I can't, I can't because of this and that in the end. It's like, okay, like, I want to validate that for some people. That's true. However, don't let that prevent you from being curious about but what if I could What if I could in five years, what would I have to do today to be able to quit this toxic job in five years? Because I think sometimes, as we're validating systemic things, we can sort of accidentally get ourselves stuck in places where we're not recognizing where we can have some agency and being willing to be curious about like, what would it be like if when I said this hard thing, I just was quiet because I always want to over explain myself. And I think that when you pair that, like the wisdom of being curious with self compassion, that's when growth just skyrockets. Because, yes, I'm going to be self compassionate when I make mistakes. Yes, I'm going to be self compassionate when I come up to my human limitations. But I'm also really passionate about that curiosity of, you know, I got an email today from someone, and it was literally an email just cursing me out about my book and how they thought I did it wrong and how, you know, I had like, further traumatize them, because I hadn't structured it in this way or whatever. And like, of course, I want to respond to that and be like, Well, good thing. It's my book, not yours, right? Like, I want to defend, and I want to go with that gut feeling. But that curiosity of like, what would I lose? If I responded to this with kindness? And not permissiveness? Right, like, what would it be like, if I were to stand up for myself, and be kind? What would it be like if I because I don't want to be a doormat, and I don't want to roll over other people. Like, I don't want to be a doormat. But I also don't want to make other people a doormat. And I sat with it for a minute. And I responded, and I was like, first of all, thank you for your feedback. Here's some explanation as to why I did those things that way. And I ended the email by saying, like, you know, your email was really aggressive. And I can tell you're very upset. And I have to imagine, and I'm gonna give you the benefit of the doubt that maybe you're in a lot of distress in your life, and you're really struggling, and you came to this book, hoping that it would help you. And maybe it didn't help you as much as you had hoped. And I can imagine, if you're already in distress, being further frustrated by a book that is supposed to help you is probably pretty upsetting. That being said, you could have given me all this feedback without that rude and aggressive and mean basic. And I said to them in the future, I'm not going to respond to emails from you that are written in that manner. Your feelings are valid, but this behavior is not you deserve kindness, but I do too. And I think a lot of us struggle with the black and white of like, you know, standing up for myself means pushing over someone, but showing them grace or kindness or benefit of the doubt means laying down and being a doormat. And that curiosity of like, well, what if I just did something slightly different? Like, what if you could do those things at the same time? And when you talk about like being willing to feel those feelings? Like what if I just sat with this feeling for one extra minute? So I love I just all of that, I think is really helpful. Is there anything else you want to tell us about your book that you are really proud of?

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 27:28

    I appreciate that question. Because that's actually a lot of my inner work right now is allowing myself to be proud of things. I felt we could sit here for a long time and talk about all the reasons why it's hard for me to be proud of things. But that's been something I've been stepping into more. I think what I'm really proud of is I tried as best as I could to write a book that was practical and accessible and intersectional. And the feedback that I'm getting a people like, there are points when I felt this book was talking to me. Or I could see myself in this book in a way that I couldn't see myself in other books like that. I like speaking of inner child stuff, like the part of me who was like, on my little desktop computer as a kid writing stuff. And it's just like doing cartwheels that other people are reading this and seeing a positive impact in it. That means a lot to me that people can see themselves in it and that people feel like it's meeting them where they're at, because that's what I want. I like I'm not interested in being anyone's guru. I've been starting to sign a couple people's books. And the inscription I always write is that, like, maybe these words lead you closer to yourself, may they lead you closer to your inner wisdom. I'm not doing my job. If you're just like, oh, Taylor is really cool. My job is that you realize how cool you are and how worthy you are of care, and how much insight you have to offer based on your lived experience. So yeah, if you're looking for something that like talks about self care, but is not in a goofy way, then I think the book is a good fit for you.

    KC Davis 29:03

    I definitely think you should be proud of that. Because I know that feeling of I want to write something that's going to be helpful for anyone that picks it up. But how do you generalize something that is so personal, that everyone in different circumstances can come and walk away with something and I think that you've achieved that and I do think that that's something to be really proud of. So thank you for sharing that with the world. The book is out now where can they find it? Where can they find you? You know, go ahead and self promote for a bit.

    Taylor Elyse Morrison 29:31

    Yeah, if you go to inner workout.co not.com There's a button right there to buy the book. There's a button right there to take the free assessment if buying the book doesn't feel accessible for you right now. And then joining our self care Sunday newsletter is the best and most consistent way to hear from me and to hear from in our workout. I'm on Instagram at Taylor Elise Morrison and in our workout is on Instagram at and our workout, same handles on Tik Tok. luck as well. But honestly, speaking of things that aren't serving us, we don't do a ton on social media. The newsletter is where it's at and our podcast, but you'll find out that if you're on our newsletter,

    KC Davis 30:10

    Awesome, well, we will link all those things in the show notes. Taylor, thank you so much for coming. And I really recommend that you guys if you're a book person, check it out. Is it going to be on audiobook as well? It will be later this year. Okay, great. So check that out. Thank you for coming Taylor and we will I will talk to you guys next time.


KC Davis
34: The Problem with Professional Organizing with Professional Organizer Alison Lush

Can you afford the services of a professional organizer? Most people can’t, and that’s one of the big problems with the industry. Many professional organizers have come up with alternative ideas that allow them to reach more people with their services. Join us to learn more!

I’m happy to welcome back to the show Alison Lush, a Certified Professional Organizer who specializes in chronic disorganization. Alison last joined me for Episode 5 about Gentle Organizing. Today’s discussion is about the problems with professional organizing and how the industry is evolving to be accessible to more people. The good news is that there are different levels of help available more than ever before for organizing and decluttering your spaces!

Show Highlights:

  • Why a main problem with the professional organizing industry is that the services are not accessible for most people

  • How the pandemic massively impacted professional organizers in beneficial ways that are far more economical for clients

  • How Alison’s focus has changed to educating and empowering the individual to get unstuck

  • Why there is a spectrum of disorganization in which most people exist somewhere in the middle

  • Highlights of new gap-filling services that some innovative professional organizers are offering (See Resources and Links)

  • Why Accountability Groups and Body Doubling have become the cornerstone of Alison’s work with clients

  • Why the biggest question for professional organizers to ask regarding the client is, “What do they need?”

  • The difference between being unwilling and being overwhelmed in organizing and decluttering

  • Alison’s advice about finding a professional organizer 

Resources and Links:

Connect with Alison: Website and TikTok

JUDITH KOLBERG

Conquering Chronic Disorganization book – emotion-based decluttering and organizing strategies

https://www.judithkolberg.com/

HAZEL THORNTON

Go With the Flow!: The clutter flow chart workbook https://www.org4life.com/

SUSAN GARDNER

The Focus Project “If your possessions interfere with your quality of life, The Focus Project is a way to look at them through a different lens.” Frame, Value, Edit. Exercises that promote looking at your belongings from a different angle. Reflection, partnering, creativity are encouraged, along with curiosity about the root causes of clutter. – Self-directed

LYNNE POULTON

Declutter GO! by Lynne Poulton - Once you start, you’re on a roll. Declutter GO! GAME NIGHTS – Group body doubling – weekly guided activities, prompts – group body doubling or autonomous - 

JONDA BEATTIE AND DIANE QUINTANA

Release-Repurpose-Reorganize CARDS

https://releaserepurpose.com/?fbclid=IwAR3UkkdN6FdroVrQ260VV17XqvA2MnuMl5Hf9DHfzdMD_OaiYLz8tFbyYag - Self-directed – focused areas – systematic

VICKIE DELLAQUILA

Ophelia the Organizer – Follow her adventures and hear her organizing advice

https://www.opheliatheorganizer.com/

JULIET LANDAU-POPE

Organizing Bootcamp (5x15 minute sessions over weekdays) https://jlpcoach.com/

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website 

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sent to you balls of stardust. My name is KC Davis. I'm your host. Welcome back to Struggle Care. And today we have Allison Lush back in the studio with us, Alison Lush is a certified professional organizer who specializes in chronic disorganization. And if you hadn't, if you haven't caught Allison's first episode with me, it was a great one. So be sure and scroll back and do that one. But we wanted to pop in today to just do a short episode on the problems of professional organizing. So Alison, I just want to like open it up there, because you called me and we're like, you know what, let's talk about the problems behind professional organizing. Well,

    Alison Lush 0:43

    thanks for inviting me back. This is such a pleasure to be here. The sink, one of the primary issues with my industry is that it's not accessible for all that many people, the basic model seems to be approximately three or four hours on site in your home. And professional organizers cost more than a cleaning person and less than a psychologist typically. So it is not cheap. I'm not saying it's not worth it. However, many people don't have access to that kind of liquidity, and therefore it's not accessible for everyone. Many of us have developed alternative services over the last few years in particular, since the pandemic because we couldn't even go into people's homes for quite a while. And so I'm really excited about the different ideas that my colleagues and I have come up with in order to reach the public and deliver our services in ways that are more accessible.

    KC Davis 1:34

    Yeah, I will say that before I met you, my picture of what a professional organizer is and does was totally different. Like I almost exclusively pictured, like the home edit. And by the way, I love that book, I have it on my bedside table is anything in my house rainbow organized for more than five minutes at a time. No, but I did try. But I like it's a beautiful book. And they I love to hear their ideas on things. But like that was really the picture like the picture was, like nice ladies that come in and make everything aesthetically pleasing. And like I remember when I moved into this house, so I packed myself but in previous houses I've paid to have people pack for me. And typically moving companies will say like, well, whatever we charge per hour, we would will charge that for the packing. So they send for people for you know, $160 an hour and they pack up your house, usually like in a day. So when I moved in, I had this idea of like, okay, well, since I didn't spend money on packers, maybe it would be nice to have someone help me unpack, because this time I've got two kids and my husband was in the middle of a trial. So I was like looking up around the internet, like, you know, are there people that that's kind of what they specialize. And there were a bunch of professional organizers in my area that advertised, like, I'll come help you unpack so that we like we're like organizing as we put things away. And I was like, oh, okay, but that's expensive, but like that would be worth it. So I checked on her price. Just a cool $10,000 Which Listen, I am not even here to say whether that is or isn't worth her value. I'm just saying I cannot afford her value.

    Alison Lush 3:17

    Hmm, yeah, yeah, it's amazing how it can add up the services because it we work on an hourly basis, typically, and it's simply out of the reach of many people doesn't as you say, it doesn't mean that the person services aren't worth it. But I'm very motivated to deliver our services to as many people as possible.

    KC Davis 3:38

    So tell me a little bit more about what you said about how the pandemic sort of created this space where you had to get creative. Oh, the

    Alison Lush 3:46

    pandemic had a massive impact on our industry. So one of the things that happened, which is actually a huge benefit for our industry is that so many professional organizers learned how to deliver our services virtually as I did, I went to school at the very beginning of the pandemic and lurk got credentialed learned how to deliver my services virtually. And I've developed a whole business based on that. So now I have clients literally all over the world, which is phenomenal because I can find people who have a specific need for my services. That's one thing. Second of all, because I'm only working one hour at a time, it's far more economical for the client. There's so many advantages. I save travel time, I can work with people anywhere, the client is more in control of the process. The client does more of the work themselves and therefore it's far more economical, far more economical. And I discovered one thing is that when I'm working with someone, virtually my hands are kind of itchy, like I want to touch the stuff I want to move this stuff and help no no pick it up and move it over there, whatever. And I can't because I'm in my home. So what I do instead is I focus on transmitting to the person's brain as much education and insight and analysis as possible so that they become empowered to do as much as possible. So my focus has changed from moving the stuff around and developing systems to educating and empowering the individual so that they can do as much as possible. It's a complete game changer.

    KC Davis 5:13

    Yeah. So in this process of when you work with someone virtually, and you're helping them, you would mentioned like it's more economical. I also feel like, it's, I don't wanna say unfortunate, but like, it's interesting to me, that the people who go into celebrity homes, and make everything look beautiful, and put everything in these like clear plastic containers. And, you know, I think one of the Kardashians showed their, like pantry that was like, bigger than my house. And they had a professional organizer committee that like, when I got to know you, and the kinds of things that you do, where you really help somebody. Like, I would say that you are very person centered. You know, what do you need in your home, what's functional for you and your home? Don't worry about whether it looks good to other people, or whether it works for other people. Let's find things that work with you and your brand, which I think why we clicked really but what you offer. And what someone that does Courtney Kardashians pantry offers, like, they don't exist in the same universe in my head. And yet, you're both called professional organizers.

    Alison Lush 6:23

    That's one of the problems. It seems like they're. It is a total barrier. And I'm not I'm very uncomfortable with the title professional organizer, I have to tell people, that's what I do, because otherwise they won't get what I do. But I don't feel like a professional organizer. I know it sounds completely grammatically incorrect. But my instinct tells me what I do is I'm a professional unstuck or I help people get unstuck. That's what I feel like my job is that's my calling. When you said that we live in different universes. I absolutely agree with you and my particular education, I didn't create all this emotion based human centered stuff. I learned it at school, I went to school to become a professional organizer. I'm heavily credentialed, along with many of my colleagues. And our work is based on the work of Judith Kohlberg, who is the founder of the notion of chronic disorganization. And this book conquering chronic disorganization is available for the public. And it's got strategies in here that are emotion based. So although this has been out for quite a long time, this is absolutely an alternative way of delivering services to the public that are useful and person centered.

    KC Davis 7:31

    And you know, it's not that I've never seen shows or people out there that work on like the emotional basis, but they're only shown in the most extreme cases. So it's always like the hoarding shows where someone comes in to talk about like, their emotional relationship to their stuff, and how they got to the point where the house is unfunctional. And I think those two opposing pictures of like, Kourtney Kardashian is beautiful pantry, and someone who has been hoarding that animals. And so you have like, the average person sitting at home going, well, I can't afford that. And I guess I'm not that bad. But, man, I'm experiencing a lot of distress in my home.

    Alison Lush 8:13

    Mm hmm. Very, very much. So you explained it quite well. And I consider that to be sort of a spectrum, the spectrum of like, what professional organizing can help people with. And what the majority of us do is we work somewhere in the middle, I work a lot on nuance and functionality. So I'm really concerned about, I don't even really frankly, care about the stuff in a person's house, I don't care. I don't care how it's organized. What I care about is how does the person feel? Does the person feel comfortable? Does the person feel in control? Can they find their stuff? Can they put their stuff away? Can they reset their stuff. And when I work with people, as many of my credential colleagues do, our focus is not me teaching the client what I think that they should be doing, but teasing out of them and analyzing what's going on inside of their brain, their value system, their needs, their lifestyle, in order to make a fit with what we understand about good systems, and strategies and making the we create the bridge between the education and the client. That's what we do. And we're doing it really, really well.

    KC Davis 9:17

    Well, and it's a totally different skill set to like, I think that I wasn't aware beforehand that there was this pocket of professional organizers that were not only learning the skills of organization, you know, what kind of containers could go on these type of things, and how do you help somebody think through a room, but we're also invested in learning the emotional skills to work with people and to be curious with people around the emotional stuff and, and since then, I've talked to several people who have invested in those skills professionally, or maybe just have them personally or maybe even a couple that, you know, are clinicians and professional organizers. And I wish more people knew that that was out there. Because you and these other professional organizers you bring a gentleness, and a tenderness and a space of non judgment that is very different than sort of. And I'm not saying that like someone who would organize Coronae Kardashians closet wouldn't necessarily have that. But it's not advertised as part of the service.

    Alison Lush 10:18

    Yeah, so one of the things that I encourage people to do is to identify what their goals are. If your goal is to hire a professional organizer to help you have the Rainbow House, then look for a professional organizer who sells that service, they're out there. And there's nothing wrong with hiring that organizer if that's what your needs are. But there are a whole raft of other organizing specialties available. And for a person who just wants to figure out where the heck to put their keys so they can find them. There are organizers who specialize in that kind of functionality, I actually created a series of tiktoks 15 videos that I've put into a package and put on my learning website called How to choosing a professional organizer. And it's a public service announcement. It's just available for free to the public. And there's like 15, tiny little videos explaining. It's sort of like an insider's view of the industry, helping people identify what is important to them, and how helping them choose an organizer who would be a good fit for them.

    KC Davis 11:18

    Awesome. All right, let's take a quick break to hear from some sponsors. And when we come back, I want to hear about this new model that you have been creating to try and fill some of these gaps. Okay, welcome back, Alison, tell us some of these gap fillers, these like new creative services that you are coming up with to help people and make this kind of help more accessible?

    Alison Lush 11:38

    Well, I did a little bit of research asked around some of my colleagues, what are you doing this creative because I'm only one person, I've got some ideas, but and I'm really proud of my own services. But there are other organizers doing completely different things out there that I'm very, very excited about. So for example, I have one colleague, Hazel Thornton, who just published a book called go with the flow, the clutter flow chart workbook, this is available online, anybody can buy it and print it themselves. And it's phenomenal. It's a self help tool, all based on flowcharts. It's extraordinarily clever. And Hazel has like a whole career of professional organizing behind her to back it up because she knows how people think and what the issues are. And it's fun. It's an easy book to read and to pick up and to use. My colleague Vicki Dilek Willick created this alternate personality. Well, she's like a mascot called Ophelia. And Ophelia has a book and she has a Facebook page and Ophelia travels all over the world. And she is inspiring, and she helps families understand and little kids understand organizing challenges. And it's just a completely different angle to take to deliver. And Vicki is heavily credentialed. And it's just a different way of building a bridge between our education and understanding in the public. And that's what I'm very excited about. I have another colleague Lynn Fulton, who created a game called declutter, go it's six cubes. They're all beautifully made and colored and you got it today. You did. Well, I'm glad you found yours because mine's propping up my tablet.

    KC Davis 13:07

    Okay, so I'll and we'll post this little clip where we're talking because we are on camera. Okay, here I have it. Somebody holds it up to the camera. Ooh, so it's a box, right? You get the box, you open it up, and there's the six die, and they're kind of foam. I haven't really looked into how to play it. What did the thing here? What do we do what you

    Alison Lush 13:24

    roll the dice, there's simple instructions, you roll the dice, and it kind of it prompts you it says, like, spend this much time in this area. And this is your goal. And so it's just basically gamifying decluttering. So you go off and you reset that area or you do whatever the dice are prompting you to do. And another thing that Lynne added onto that which I think is just phenomenal. She created declutter GO game nights. So she sells a package where people can come and they sign up for like six weeks or eight weeks, I think. And they show up all together and they play the game together like live, like somebody rolls the dice, they all run off and do 10 minutes of decluttering or something and they all come back and it's like a party. It's so much fun. That's doubly taken to a whole other

    KC Davis 14:07

    level. Okay, so the first dice that you're supposed to roll is the Revive dice. It says before you get rolling, get energized, whatever you need, whenever you need a quick pick me up, take another roll to revive yourself. So this is amazing because this is like we were talking about like skills other than the organizing because basically whenever you need a break or you're feeling fatigued, or you're feeling overwhelmed, you can stop and you roll this dice. And this is going to tell you Okay, turn on some music or like change the aroma, get some fresh air, go get a snack, hydrate, like I love that idea. And then there's one you can roll that has a number for either the how many minutes or maybe how many items you're going to do. There's one that you roll to tell you what area to start in. There's one two roll just for paper People ask me all the time what to do with paper, right? There's one that is an action so whether you're going to discard something, put something away, recycle it, all that kind of stuff. And then I love this bill. Last one is reward. So you can roll the dice and give yourself a reward. This is so cool. This is the stuff that really gets me excited, like ways that we can make things creative and engaging for people in an area where I think in the past, we haven't put a big spotlight on, like, how can we make these things more accessible

    Alison Lush 15:20

    and fun? Why should it be boring and hard work, it should be fun. Lin, along with myself, and many of my colleagues are like I said it again, heavily credentialed. But what we're doing is we're bringing that big education and experience to the non judgmental interaction between the humans and their stuff in their space. We're toning down the stress, toning down the expectations, focusing on the human, to make it a completely, it's a completely different game. It's a completely different goal. Another colleague, I have created something called Organizing bootcamp, Juliet Landau posts, she does virtual organizing, and she sells a package where you sign up and you get five days in a row, 15 minutes a day, and you jump on and you do that your 15 minutes boot camp every day of the week. And it's just like a little quick check in another colleague, John Beatty and Diane Quintana, they created a game a set of cards, and the cards have prompts on them of 10 minute tasks that you can do to declutter your home. I don't think that it's created specifically for neurodivergent, folks, but it would totally work for people who don't know where to start. And they could just give themselves more time than the 10 minutes if that's what they needed. But it's a simple way to engage and overcome overwhelm. There's another one that I absolutely want to mention is Susan Gardner wrote a book a number of years ago called The Focus project, it's available on Amazon, make sure that you look for her as the author because there's a different focus project that's not hers. And it says, if your possessions interfere with your quality of life, the focus project is way to look at them through a different lens. And it's a workbook that's based on taking photographs of your belongings in order to interact with your belongings differently and analyze them and experience them in a different way. It helps. And again, she's got the same training that we do so Certified Professional Organizer in chronic disorganization, but her husband is a photographer. And so the two of them, they melded their experience together, it's a very beautiful book, I absolutely recommend that if it inspires people that they have a look at it. And that's something I wanted to comment on, if I may, is that these are strategies, these are tools, these are approaches, there's no one that's better than any other what is important for an individual is to look for something that feels comfortable, that feels inspiring that if you're looking for education, look for an educational thing, if you're looking for fun look for a fun thing, it's for the individual to find a good fit with what's being offered out there.

    KC Davis 17:42

    So talk to me more about you know, when you mentioned some of these ones that are like checking in every day or a group game, I think that's also a missing piece that I've seen is like, you'll have someone that says, Well, I don't necessarily need someone to teach me or maybe I do want a little bit. But like, my issue isn't just that I don't know, because even if you taught me what I didn't know, I'm stuck at actually doing it. And unless you can afford to have someone come up every day for hours and hours and do it for you or with you. There's not a lot of services that I know of that are offering that kind of community building accountability, even capabilities, you know, like we don't mean like Hardline, but like the body doubling and things like that. And I know that you've been working on some things that offer that to people at a more accessible rate.

    Alison Lush 18:28

    Absolutely. That's like it's becoming the cornerstone of my business, actually, because it is much more accessible for people even then the virtual organizing. So there's two branches of it that I've developed. One is what I call accountability groups, because my clients kept telling me, like, I need to have some kind of a regular check in and I'm crap at checking in with my clients. I hate phoning them up or emailing them and saying, Hey, how you doing? Because it feels patronizing to me. I hate doing that. So I created a system where people can register and its maximum six people. It's one hour on Zoom, and each person gets 10 minutes, unmuted with me. And it's like coaching one on one. So it's what have you been doing for the last week? How did you feel about that? And I tried to extract with my coaching skills, extract what they learned insights, did you get stuck anywhere? And what did you do and what can we celebrate? And then looking forward to the upcoming week, what's on the radar? What would they like to achieve? And then they come back week to week for a whole month. And people are saying like they're getting so much more accomplished than I was. So that's one branch. That's the accountability groups. But then there's this. I had this club a couple of weeks ago, and she was saying she had this huge backlog of reports to do for work. And she just couldn't make herself do it. It was so hard. And she tried to use focus, mate, but she found it too distracting. And she's like a focus mate veteran, but she couldn't do it for this particular task. And I really wanted to help her and I said, Look, Sunday morning, I'm going to be at my computer for like six hours or something. How about if I do body doubling with you? Because that's part of my training. It's part of my credentialing is that I'm trained to do body doubling. So we started doing it and she started plowing through the reports and then It was getting going so well and I was getting more done. So I said to her, okay, I'd like to consider developing this as a service as a standalone service. And so she and she helped me talk through it and figure it out. So now it's on my website as a standalone service. And I proposed it to another one of my clients who was also feeling stuck trying to get herself to do the things she knew how to do, which is such a classic ADHD thing, I know what I have to do, I just can't get myself to do it. And she said to me, I would want the body doubling, but I would absolutely need verbal processing afterwards. So we created a model for her, that's a Pomodoro. And then 15 minutes of debrief verbal debrief, because she ends up with a pile of stuff. And she says, then I get stuck. And I don't know what to do with the pile of stuff. So we examined the pile of stuff. And I helped her figure out what to do with the pile of stuff. And then she did another Pomodoro, which is 25 minutes of focused attention on a task. And so that's another new service that I'm offering. So basically, not using virtual using the client needs bringing, I'm building a bridge between the education I got for my CD, the Institute for challenging disorganization. I'm building a bridge between that education and the clients. And I am so motivated to help clients develop, what is it they need, and as long as it works out to be reasonably, you know, within my business model, I'm all over it. I think it's terribly exciting.

    KC Davis 21:19

    One of the things that I love and listening to you talk about this is that I can see so many people for whom this is a good fit. And I don't know why. But one sort of demographic that came into my head that didn't when we were talking about this. The first is like, I know so many people who their main struggle with cleaning or tidying or doing care tasks is that they didn't ever have a caregiver to teach them. Whether there was no caregiver present at all, or whether there was an overly critical one or a very aloof one. They never had, like a warm caregiver to actually walk them through the process of learning something like I'll never forget, like, when my daughter was three, and she had taken all of the diapers out of the diaper box, just one by one and spread them all over the place. And so I discovered it, and I kind of got frustrated with her. And I said, you know, you need to put all of those back, put them back, put them all back. And she went, I can't. And I'm thinking yes, you can. You literally physically can like, what did you did your arms break, since you took them all out? She and I kind of went back and forth, back and forth. And I finally was like, yes, you can and she just burst out in tears. And I can't there's too many, I can't hold all of them at once. And it was like a light bulb went off when I realized that when I said pick them all up. She thought I literally meant pick them all up at one time. And it never would have occurred to me that that's what she was going through. And then like a light bulb, I went, Oh my God, she's not unwilling, she's overwhelmed. And I'm so thankful that I had a moment to see that to have clarity around that. Because, you know, kids can't express and clear terms what's going on, they're doing the best they can to express what's going on. And thank God, I got curious with her and asked her about it. And I just it made me think like, how many of us, you know, we're putting a room with a trash bag and told clean it up, or I'm throwing it away. But just do it. It's not that hard. And I feel like you're kind of the perfect person. That's sometimes what people need is just like a tender figure, to walk them through it like they are not stupid. Like this is not something you are born knowing how to do. And then checking in not just this one time and part of information and then bouncing that that's like a huge group of people I feel like could benefit from this.

    Alison Lush 23:46

    Absolutely. And my accountability groups are very much focused on creating a task list of specific next steps and breaking it down and taking the notes and then giving the notes to the people. That's one of the things that I am really proud that is part of my accountability groups. But I have to tell you, that the methodology that you created, and that you shared, has gone such a far way to helping these folks because we're serving very much the same clientele overlapping, not identical, but very much overlapping. And I can't tell you how many people come to me and they say I was feeling overwhelmed. But I used Casey's method I went around and picked up just the trash, I went around and just picked up the dirty laundry. And that's, I mean, that's something that I've never heard put that way in all of the studies that I've done professionally. That's a different way of simplifying, taking away the overwhelm, giving a person a tool that they can fit in their hand and they can go with and that has been a game changer for a lot of people. It's been a very significant contribution to the knowledge that we have about how to help people who are overwhelmed with clutter. So congratulations and thank you for that, among so many other things but that's it really significant contribution really?

    KC Davis 25:02

    Well, this is such a cool, it's almost like things that you are doing that are kind of disrupting the industry in a very good way. Do you have any other things that you want to share with us? Well,

    Alison Lush 25:13

    I would encourage the public to look for credentialed organizers, people who belong to professional associations. I'm sure that people who don't belong to professional associations might be doing a fantastic job, but there's no checks and balances system. They're all by themselves. I believe that the people who are in a community have more opportunity to hear the better ideas and have their things checked out. And so I just think it's safe from give a continuing education, very much. So. Yes, yes. So when that little public service announcement course that I give, I talk about all those things, so people can, you know, get an insider's view of all the things you might want to consider if you're hiring a professional organizer?

    KC Davis 25:50

    Yeah, it's one of those things that, you know, there, it's hard. There are certain, as I'm trying to say this with, you know, honesty and honor, there are certain professions that are really important. But because there seems to be a lot of people getting into that, like, there's not a lot of entry barrier, right? Like, you can't wake up tomorrow and say, I'm a psychologist. Correct. You have to legally, but there are like, you could wake up tomorrow and say, I'm a professional organizer. Now, you could wake up tomorrow and go, I'm a nutritionist. Now. I'm a personal trainer. Now,

    Unknown Speaker 26:26

    it happens every day.

    KC Davis 26:29

    And they're not. And it's like, those are like needed people and expertise and services. But it's a difficult industry to navigate. Because you could get someone that has been doing this their whole life that knows it really well, that does all these things. Or you could get a super nice lady whose parents whose kids just went to college, and now she decided she wants to do something else. And she's always loved organizing. So now she's a professional organizer. You know what I mean? And like, maybe she's great, maybe she's not, but it's like, you don't want to spend the money to find out. That's really helpful to know that there are organizations out there that are offering membership that are offering training that are offering at least some degree of credibility to people. So that's wonderful. Well, Alison, thank you for stopping by. And I really appreciate these sort of extra tips and extra ways of looking at things and I hope it inspires everyone listening to not be afraid to reach out for help and to know that there are levels of help out there more accessible than hiring a nice lady for $10,000 to unpack your house for you.

    Alison Lush 27:27

    Thank you so much for having me here.

    KC Davis 27:29

    Okay, bye.

KC Davis
33: What Stress Animal are You? with Dr Lindsey Cooley

**Content Warning: This episode references school shootings and the murder of George Floyd.

Stress is a word we throw around regarding many aspects of life, and we all know what it is to feel stress, but how much do we truly understand about it? Stress can take any able-bodied, able-minded person and bring them to a whole new level, whether or not they have a diagnosed condition. As we break down the topic of stress, each person has different responses, personality styles, and primary goals. Join us to find out which stress animal you are!

 I’m joined by Dr. Lindsey Cooley, who posted a TikTok about stress, and I knew we had to have this conversation on the podcast. She is a Licensed Clinical Psychologist who specializes in school-aged children/teens, emotional and behavioral disorders, LGBTQ youth, ADHD, and autism spectrum disorder. 

Show Highlights:

  • Why we should be kind to ourselves–even if we don’t have a diagnosis

  • What is stress? (THE million-dollar question!)

  • The phases of stress (alarm, resistance, and exhaustion) and how prolonged stress can cause diseases of adaptation

  • How our culture normalizes “too much stress”

  • How stressful life events can affect executive functioning, relationships, energy, and more (The Holmes and Rahe Stress Scale and Adverse Childhood Experience are well-known measurement tools.)

  • Why we need to legitimize that most of our stress is caused by normal reactions to dysfunctional systems

  • The medical model of disease vs. the social model of disease

  • Common symptoms of being in a prolonged stress cycle

  • Differences in acute stress, chronic stress, and traumatic stress

  • How traumatic stress occurs when we watch something like the murder of George Floyd and school shootings

  • How the “stress animals” (eagle, turtle, chameleon, and lion) concept came from Lynn Lott's Top Card Activity

  • How your personality style and stress response help determine your stress animal

  • How we can learn to care for ourselves in the middle of stress

 Resources:

Connect with Dr. Lindsey Cooley: TikTok

Mentioned in this episode: Lynn Lott's Top Card Activity, the Holmes and Rahe Stress Scale, the ACE Scale, and "Kids Are Suffering from Toxic Stress" LA Times article

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website 

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

​​We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

KC Davis
32: Book Chat: Real Self Care with Dr Pooja Lakshmin

If you follow me at all, you know that I really don’t like the word self-care. But today, I’m giving you an entire episode about Real Self Care!

My guest today is Dr. Pooja Lakshmin, a perinatal psychiatrist, writer, and CEO of Gemma, a women's mental health community, has a fresh perspective on self-care. In her debut nonfiction book, Real Self Care, Dr. Lakshmin challenges the conventional concept of self-care, which is largely full of empty calories and devoid of substance. She argues that the game is rigged, and faux self-care only keeps us looking outward, comparing ourselves with others or striving for a certain type of perfection, which means it's incapable of truly nourishing us in the long run. Her insights on self-care are particularly relevant in the current times, when many people feel overwhelmed, overburdened, and burnt out.

Show Highlights:

  • The difference between a “system” and “philosophy”.

  • There is no one right answer, there are hundreds of answers.

  • Hope as a skill, not a new concept.

  • A boundary is the process you went through where you decided that you were worthy of standing up for what you want.

  • You know how to practice real self-care when you suffer from a mental health condition.

  • There is no one answer for recovery from religious trauma.

Links and Resources:

Connect with Dr. Pooja Lakshmin: Instagram, Twitter

Real Self Care, Dr. Pooja Lakshmin

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website 

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

​​We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • If you follow me at all, you know that I really don’t like the word self-care. But today, I’m giving you an entire episode about Real Self Care!

    My guest today is Dr. Pooja Lakshmin, a perinatal psychiatrist, writer, and CEO of Gemma, a women's mental health community, has a fresh perspective on self-care. In her debut nonfiction book, Real Self Care, Dr. Lakshmin challenges the conventional concept of self-care, which is largely full of empty calories and devoid of substance. She argues that the game is rigged, and faux self-care only keeps us looking outward, comparing ourselves with others or striving for a certain type of perfection, which means it's incapable of truly nourishing us in the long run. Her insights on self-care are particularly relevant in the current times, when many people feel overwhelmed, overburdened, and burnt out. In this text, Dr. Lakshmin discusses her ideas on self-care, women's mental health, and more in a conversation with Casey, the host of Struggle Care, a popular podcast.

    Show Highlights:

    The difference between a “system” and “philosophy”.

    There is no one right answer, there are hundreds of answers.

    Hope as a skill, not a new concept.

    A boundary is the process you went through where you decided that you were worthy of standing up for what you want.

    You know how to practice real self-care when you suffer from a mental health condition.

    There is no one answer for recovery from religious trauma.

    Links and Resources:

    Connect with Dr. Pooja Lakshmin: Instagram, Twitter

    Real Self Care, Dr. Pooja Lakshmin

    Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website

    Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

    ​​We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codesdc

KC Davis
31: Wait. Am I ADHD? with Dr. Sasha Hamdani

Many adults, like me, are diagnosed with ADHD later in life. It is fascinating to hear the stories of how this diagnosis is missed in their childhood years. I’m joined by Dr. Sasha Hamdani, a board-certified psychiatrist and ADHD clinical specialist who just happens to spend some of her spare time on TikTok. Let’s get the facts from an expert! Join us for this interesting conversation!

Show Highlights:

  • The basics: What is ADHD?

  • Why reframing is helpful for adults diagnosed with ADHD

  • Why many of us do self-diagnosis, especially in today’s social media-driven world

  • Factors that can cause a child to fly under the radar and go undiagnosed

  • Why ADHD can be described as “an interest-based nervous system”

  • How most people with ADHD have an “I’m dumb” moment because of how their brains process information and overlook details

  • Why ADHD diagnosis is overlooked in so many people because of the ways they learn to compensate for symptoms

  • Why people with ADHD mask their internal symptoms by learning to respond to their external environment

  • Dr. Sasha’s advice about educating yourself and learning more about ADHD

  • How to decide whether or not to take ADHD medication as an adult

  • Dr. Sasha’s advice about noticing red flags in dealing with your healthcare provider

 Resources:

Connect with Dr. Sasha: TikTok, YouTube, Instagram, Book, Self-Care for People with ADHD, and the Focus Genie App

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website 

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient little ADHD balls of stardust. This is Struggle Care, the podcast about self care by a host that hates the term self care. And today I have Dr. Sasha Hamdani. Did I do it right?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 0:18

    Yeah, it was beautiful.

    KC Davis 0:19

    Why don't you introduce yourself?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 0:21

    Hi. Okay, so my name is Dr. Sasha Hamdani. I'm a board certified psychiatrist and ADHD clinical specialist. And someone that intermittently fools around on social media.

    KC Davis 0:33

    Love it. Okay, so not only did I send you the link to log on, like three minutes before we started recording, I actually have not even really talked to you about the topic or sent you any question. That's fine. And I'm hoping that maybe you can just roll with that.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 0:46

    Yeah, that's what I do best random rolling with things.

    KC Davis 0:50

    Me too. People always like, Would you like me to send you some questions? And I was like, no, no, stressful. Okay, so here's what I want to talk about. I want to talk about adult ADHD diagnosis. Oh, my God love it. Okay, because I got diagnosed as an adult. Yeah. And I think it's really interesting to talk about how it gets missed as a child. Yeah. And like, how do you know when to go in? And like, there's just so many interesting things about it that like when I finally got in front of a psychiatrist, that understood, ADHD, and understood its adult presentations and understood its adult presentations and women. Yeah. She was like, Oh, I clocked you from the moment you started talking about it. And she asked me all these questions about my life. And I was like, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And then what really was wild to me was when because I was still like almost gaslighting myself. Like, am I making this up? Is this just because I had kids and now I feel scatterbrain. Like, you know, because I had a really successful career. I did pretty well in school with the exception of like, some addiction issues. But what really finally got me to stop feeling impostor syndrome was when she started asking me things about my childhood, and not things like ADHD symptoms. Would, she said, Have you ever been diagnosed with a learning disability? And I was like, Yes, I was diagnosed with auditory processing disorder, dyslexia and dysgraphia. She was like, Oh, well, there's a really high incidence of comorbidity with particularly auditory processing and ADHD. And I was like, Okay. She's like, did you have any addiction issues as a child? And I was like, Yes, I went to rehab at 16. She's like, Oh, because there's a very high crossover comorbidity between addiction and ADHD. And the one that really freaked me out was when she said, Did you ever have any vocal tics as a child? Hmm. And I was like, Yes, I totally did. It wasn't very long. It was like in a stressful period after my parents got divorced, but I developed this weird vocal tic, and this weird thing with light switches. And I can't remember there's anything else. And then I was telling her like, I just didn't think I was ADHD because like, I did so well, in school for so long. Now. I didn't do my homework, like ever. And she was like, Well, I mean, we're just on and on and on. So I know, there's probably a lot of listeners that either are ADHD or they're like, wondering if their ADHD and so I thought maybe we could just start with like, if somebody were to ask you what ADHD is, how would you like answer them on an elevator?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 3:28

    So this does happen to me on elevators. So if I was talking about what is ADHD, just like a little blurb about it, I would say it's a neurodevelopmental condition that presents with inattentiveness, hyperactivity, impulsivity, and it doesn't need to be all of those, but it can be like an amalgamation of all of them, or one specifically more than the other. But basically, this is something that you were born with, and this has progressed through your life and is in fact, you know, a lot of people have beef with the disorder part of ADHD. But I think that's really important, because I think that it causes dysfunction. And even if like, in your story, Casey, like going through your life that you did, well, there were other facets of your life that were like exploding, right? So there's a disorder part of it. It's not just smooth sailing. So ADHD causes dysfunction in some capacity.

    KC Davis 4:20

    Well, I also thought was interesting was like, Okay, so like, I went to school, and there were some bumps along the road, but like, also, like, went to college and went to grad school, but also, like, I changed my major, because like, the first one was too hard. And the first one had too much math, and the first one had too much reading or whatever. And so what was interesting to me was thinking about, like, number one, what could I have done? If I had actually had my full capacity available to me?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 4:48

    I mean, number one is a big thought in and of itself, right? Because I think a lot of people that are going through this process, especially people that have late diagnoses, there is a mourning period, right? Because you're just like, What could I have done? I wasted all of this time. And that's, I think that can be, that's something that should be acknowledged because it is a common experience. But also something that could benefit from a little bit of reframing, like, what you went through is like, if you had gotten a diagnosis earlier, yes, maybe life would have been different. But during that time, you were also building coping skills, and you were building like collateral circuitry and trying to compensate for some of these things. And maybe some of those alternative kinds of things that you arrived at, are really going to suit you now that you have a diagnosis that you have a possibly medication that you're addressing it appropriately now. So I mean, not last time, just different.

    KC Davis 5:43

    Well, what's interesting is that she said, like, so it happened, or the pandemic, so I was doing like a virtual visit. And I laugh all the time at how like, I wonder how different this would have been, if it hadn't been a virtual visit, if I had like, gone into the office, right, because I would have like woken up and gotten ready, gone to the office, like sat there, like had this calm conversation and been trying to like recount things. But what happened was, we were on a video call, and she says, What makes you think that maybe you have ADHD, and I was like, well, like, I feel like I can't remember things unless they're like visual to me. And and I started talking about my kitchen and how my kitchen is always messy, but I'm trying to get it functional. And I have to do these four things every night. But I can't remember the four things unless they're written down. And I like took her into my kitchen and started like explaining my system for keeping my kitchen clean. And she was like, you could like see her eyes like get wider and wider. She's like, looking at me pan across the kitchen and talk about my kitchen. And it's funny to me, because I feel like she probably wouldn't have had that experience of me if I was like sitting in her office. But her actually seeing my space. And the like nine I swear that I looked like that meme of the guy with like, all of the conspiracy board with all the strings where I was like, so I hang these here. And then I have to put this here so that the dishes go here. And if I don't forget the dishes, then I have this thing over here though. And she was like, oh,

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 7:04

    okay, okay. Yeah, I mean, that's part of the cool thing about being able to do telehealth because you're actually getting to see the patient in their environment, which gives you a huge amount of data also, which is great.

    KC Davis 7:19

    So I feel like so you know, you and I both do tick tock. And there's a lot of content out there about ADHD, some very helpful, some kind of random and maybe not that related. But what I think is interesting is that there are a lot of people right now sort of listening to things about ADHD and for the first time in their lives going, do I have ADHD? Like, I'm sort of relating to this? And I'm curious, like, how do you as a psychiatrist that works with ADHD? Like, how do you view that phenomenon? Like, are you on the now everybody thinks they have it because of social media? Or are you on the like, we have a, you know, there's been an epidemic of undiagnosed people that are coming out of the woodwork now, like, how do you see that?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 8:03

    I don't know. So here's kind of my two cents on that, because I think this is related to that. Right? So I think why people like the crux of what you were saying, like, if you boil down the two sides of that, it's like, how do you feel about self diagnosis? Right? Like, is that kind of like where people would go? And so my view is, I think self diagnosis is kind of something that we all do, like whether or not it's from social media or not, like you're trying to explain your own internal environment. So I actually don't really have a problem with self diagnosis, like, trying to get information and learn about yourself, whether it's through social media, or through a podcast or through, like talking to other people that, you know, what I do have a problem with is when people get overly entrenched in these things, and like, I'm telling you, like, I am a psychiatrist, I've spent my whole entire life working up to this point and spending all my effort into this kind of academic training. And there are days where I'm like, I don't know if I'm hungry or sad. I don't know what that is. I cannot adequately describe what's happening. So I think it's difficult when people are trying to self diagnose, and they get absolutely, like, entrenched in this has to be ADHD, and it can't be anything else. Because then I think what you're doing is you're limiting yourself because it could be a lot of different things. And ADHD is so nuanced. It could be anxiety, it could be a thyroid disorder, it could be like some underlying learning disability, it could be so many, many, many different things. And so I think that yes, if you have suspicions, learn about your brain, understand it as much as you can get from other resources. But if it's accessible to you find a way to corroborate that information or to discuss that possible diagnosis with a medical professional because I think that's where you're gonna get the most comprehensive thing. So whether or not it's like this huge burst and like, I think with COVID, we were all on our phones more. So I think that there was just a lot of time where people became more introspective, and they had this new information out to them. And they were like, Oh, this looks like me. Although we all had this seismic shift in what we were doing, right. We were previously like out and about and multitasking. Now we're at home and teaching our kids at home and doing all of that, like a lot more responsibility was thrown on us in a small period of time. So I don't think it's this epidemic, or I don't even know what you would call it. I don't think it's like this huge, rapid burst of people that like new diagnoses coming out of nowhere. I think these people probably had it. And it was just like, Okay, now we're starting to realize it more because of this unique spot in time.

    KC Davis 10:38

    Yep. So there are certainly a lot of kids that get diagnosed with ADHD. And I remember being 16 and being in a partial hospitalization program, because I had a lot of addiction issues and mental health issues. And there was a kid in there, that was ADHD. And I remember him like not being able to stop moving, he could not stop moving, he could not stop talking, it was almost like compulsive. And then like, the next day, he came in, and they had medicated him. And he like, was in he started crying and was like, I can't do anything. Now. I can't do anything now. And I feel like I've just always had this picture of what ADHD looks like as sort of a stereotypical, like, young white boy that isn't focusing in class, and is being really disruptive. And as always getting in trouble in class for not like, you know, getting really poor grades and not being able to pay attention. And so that was not me. So I'm curious if you have any insight into like, how so many diagnosis,

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 11:47

    we all thought that.

    KC Davis 11:48

    Yeah, like, why did we all think that and like, why is it we're like, are there other presentations that we're just like missing and childhood? Like, what factors could make a child go undiagnosed, or like fly under the radar despite having this disability, so think we're getting

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 12:03

    better? But yeah, like, I know, when I was growing up, and things like that, I was diagnosed in fourth grade, but it's because I presented like a boy, like I was super hyperactive, and I was off the wall. And I literally, like it came to my parents attention, because I started riot in my classroom, like, I got all the other kids to stand up on their desk. So like, as disruptive as one could be, that's what I was doing. So I think that clinically the presentation, that's what kind of stuck out and I thought about this a lot, because everybody has that like young hyper boy. That's what they think of with ADHD. And I think it's become problematic because a lot of practitioners grabbed ahold of it. I think what they were grabbing onto was the dysfunction part where they were like, if it is like they are disrupting the entire classroom, and they can't progress through learning, it's causing dysfunction. But they were skipping over all of these, mostly girls who were inattentive, they were sliding by their classes, but they weren't doing as well as they could. And they weren't, like, appropriately building relationships or doing things like that, that's going to aid them that when things actually get hard. And when they're like, maybe it's like middle school and high school. Now they're dealing with like social things to where now they're victims of impulsivity and judgment issues and other things like that. And they can get into like, bigger, scarier, problematic areas. But by that time, it's like you don't have as a kid, you're fine. And so like, then from that point onwards, girls go through puberty, and then they're gaslit. You didn't get it. You didn't have it as a child, when really they did. It just presented differently.

    KC Davis 13:41

    Well, and I remember listening to someone say that, like, ADHD isn't about not being able to pay attention. It's about not being able to regulate your attention. And that the way that shows up for a lot of people is like, the young, hyperactive boy that can't pay attention in class. And when I was talking to my psychiatrist, and she was asking me about my experience in school, I told her like, I remember liking school. Now I didn't like the structure of it. Like I was kind of that kid. That was a little bit, but I liked learning. And I found it really easy. And once they identified the auditory processing and moving to the front row, it was easy for me to pay attention because I thought it was interesting. And I would listen, the way that my school was set up is that if you listened to the lecture, and what was happening in the class, I would retain it all. And then when I go to take the test, I would remember it all and I would get hundreds 90s 95 on the test. However, I never did homework. Yeah, never did homework. I was so fast at my a lot of classes. The way they were structured was like, Okay, do this worksheet. And if you finish first then you can start on homework. So or they're saying homework is if you don't finish the worksheet and I was working so quickly, that I either always finished everything in class, or I finished it and then some other thing. But the work that never got done was anything I was required to do or structure on my own time. And what was interesting about it is I think about that age is like, and it was a problem, like I got in trouble. But nobody really pushed it that hard because I was still a straight A student. And I was like forging my parents signatures on the like, notes that I that I wasn't doing homework. And even if you would ask me at that age, why I wasn't doing homework, I don't think I would have been able to verbalize like I am today, because I can tell you today, what would happen is that they would say what the homework was, and I would think to myself, I'll remember that, and then I wouldn't, or I would think, Okay, I'm gonna write that down. And then I would shut the journal, and it would disappear from my life fine, I would never remember to take it out and look at it again. And there was after school, and even my little after school care, like, but there was nothing after that, that was like, and now you have to sit down and open it up and recheck the list and look at it, like it disappeared from my existence. And what happened was, I did well in school until we hit high school, where they restructured how they weighted the grades, when suddenly, you know, it used to be okay, we'll do a lecture on chapters one through three. And then the test is on chapters one through three, and then I got to high school, and it was we'll do chapters one through three in class, and you'll go home and read chapters five through 10. And then the test will be on chapters one through 10. And I was incapable of doing work outside of class.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 16:42

    So that's so common with ADHD, because, you know, we hate structure, but we've made it. So like within the confines of a classroom, you may be able to be like, Okay, I understand how this goes. And as long as you're adequately engaged in the material. And it's still kind of interesting to you, you can keep up and you can process a lot of information at a small amount of time. When you pull that structure away, and you're you go home, and you're expected to self motivate yourself or stay organized without those kind of structures in place. It's nearly impossible, especially if you don't know how your brain is working. It's really difficult to do that. And especially as a child, like how are you supposed to do that on your own heart. So as parents, like, if you don't know, your kid has ADHD, if the kid doesn't know they have ADHD, I think it's really hard to parent that kid and kind of lead them the right way to because their brain works differently.

    KC Davis 17:35

    Plus the impulse control of like, when I'm at home, the amount of like executive functioning skills it takes to be like, I could go watch TV, I could go hang out my friends, but I will sit down and do homework. I didn't have it. So it was so fascinating for my psychiatrist to go like, well, that's because you were interested, you could pay attention because it was interesting to you like it was like a weird, almost like a lining of the stars that you just happened to be interested. And then of course I was I never did well in math, because it was never interesting to me. So I thought that was fascinating.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 18:08

    I don't know how it's interesting to anybody. I think that there's, you know, with ADHD, to me, I feel like it's an interest based nervous system like you regulate and you turn on and activate and you turn off and deactivate based on what you're interested in. So if there's something that you're engaged in, you fire and your neurotransmitters are working and you can like process, a tremendous amount of information, maybe more so than a neurotypical person. But if you can't get to that spot where you're engaged, it's like nothing is happening, like things aren't firing.

    KC Davis 18:40

    Okay, so I want to ask you specifically about the criteria when we come back from this little break. Okay, we're back. And here's my question. So when I was looking over the criteria, when I was first trying to question whether I had this diagnosis, it talks about inattention. And it talks about often fails to give close attention to details or make careless mistakes. And I think what was hard for me was not understanding like at what frequency was considered clinically significant, because it wasn't like, that was happening so often that I was like, I remember the TIC tock of the girl like crying in her car and being like, I think maybe I'm just stupid. I can't remember anything like, that wasn't my life, like I was super successful. I was very responsible. But there are these like key moments in my life that I could point to where I would read something. And I thought I knew what it said. And it said something different. And it caused me to miss a midterm or not turn in a paper on time. And it wasn't like I'm not being responsible. It was like I had it planned out. I was going to do this on this day, this on this day. And then I go to class and say, Oh, it was do this Monday. Not next. It's Monday. And I remember like, at one point, I really wanted to get a PhD. But the programs I wanted to get into you couldn't make less than a B in your classes and your like masters classes. And the one see that I made was because of one class where I misread the syllabus, the date on the syllabus, and I remember being like, I don't understand how I'm doing this. And so again, it wasn't like a thing that happened every day or every week. But there was like, these handful of times in my life, where I would like miss an important meeting or or like that, and I never understood like how I could be so stupid.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 20:40

    Yeah, I mean, I can't even tell you how much I relate to that. And I think that's kind of why ADHD is such an important thing to discuss because of these lapses in executive function. And these like gaps. It just like, deteriorates your self esteem, right? Because you're just like, I'm dumb. There's literally no other explanation for this. But I think that what helped me. So when I was in medical school, like one of my very first exams at a neurobiology exam, and I was like, This is awesome. Like, I like it was cadaver base. So like, we were looking at, like, cut up the brain. And I was like, so I mean, it was gross, how much I enjoyed that like, like, I was like, This is so interesting. Like, I understand the anatomy, because it was visual, like, I'm engaged in visual stuff. I did the test finish before anybody else. I'm like, I'm fully a genius. This is great. Like, every question was easy to me. They posted the grades later that day, and I had gotten a 32%, which is like, I'm fail. I like, I don't know what I was doing. And I was like, what? I thought I did well, and it's because I didn't turn over the test. So I literally did not flip the sheet. And so I remember at that point, like I had been by myself for a little while. It's the first time I've been away from home. And I was like, I'm done. That's it. I don't know what this is like that stuff. And what helped me and like my parents were like, trying to help me make sense that and this is like I was diagnosed earlier, but like, I didn't really understand that it was ADHD. So finally, around that time, like I was starting to put together the pieces. And so my poor dad was like trying to like, help me understand this better. And he was trying to understand better, and he's like, your brain just moves too fast. And so you're processing way too much information. And so things fly by. So it's like, we just have to figure out a system that works better for you. And I literally did not figure that out until I was well into residency. But like, that was so helpful for me because I'm like, Okay, it's not dumb. It's just I'm doing too much. My brain is doing too much. It's processing too much too quickly. And so obviously, if you're doing it so quickly, you're gonna make mistakes.

    KC Davis 22:50

    And I feel like I guess I always thought to my head like, oh, well, like everyone makes mistakes. Like, no, maybe, but it looks like I mean, but I have like a handful of them. And I guess I was under the impression that it had to be something happening to you, like daily or weekly to be like clinically significant. But then when I was telling my doctor, like, I mean, there was the time that I missed the midterm, there's the time that like that she was like, yeah, that's like clinically significant that you have like four or five instances in your life where something that really mattered to you was like, bungled, because you like missed a detail. And I think what was hard for the grumps around me is that I'd never went home and did my homework. And yet, like, I was a theater kid, who would prep, prepare, nail the star role, and then have the entire script memorized. And they were like, well, you know, it must be that you don't care enough, it must be in your trunk. Because if you can do that skill in this area, why aren't you doing it in this area? And so there was like, That mismatched? Like, is that part of it? Like, is that a thing? Like, I feel like if I had been consistently in deficit across like every area that maybe that would be something else? Or if I was like, consistently performing, but it was almost like the patchwork of when I was able to excel. And when people were like scratching their heads? Like how could you not be able to do this

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 24:17

    interest base nervous system, you were interested in the other stuff, and you weren't in that, like, so there are those like, with patients I hear all the time, where they're, you know, I'll have like, the kid and then the parents in the room and the parents are arguing in front of their kid, like at me. And it's just like, they can't have ADHD because they can focus on their video games for hours. And I'm like, Yeah, cuz that's interesting to them. Like that is something

    KC Davis 24:46

    on their neuro slot machines, right?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 24:49

    I mean, like, this is stuff that is releasing a tremendous amount of dopamine they are able to engage in this. If you are like, Would you like to play Minecraft or would you like to read out of this algebra textbook? Which one do you think you're going to do a better job focusing on? Like, it just doesn't like, I think, to me, it's a little bit different because I have ADHD. So I kind of understand that flip side of it of like having it and also treating it, like interactions like that, where parents are so frustrated. Like, I understand the frustration, I understand how this may seem so contradictory. But like, if you can boil it down to like, what are you interested in? And what are you not? And the stuff that you're not interested in? How much dysfunction is that causing you? Is it like I can kind of get by? Or is it this is non functional, I can't get by this is not going to happen. That's going to indicate where what the clinical level of severity is, like, do we need to address this or not.

    KC Davis 25:49

    And what's interesting is like, when I the first time I started reading through the criteria, I had a hard time relating. But then when people who either had ADHD or were experts in ADHD, would talk about what the experience of ADHD is like, then I would start to relate. So like when you talked about, your brain is moving too fast. Like all the sudden, I have 1000 sort of memories and experiences that come to mind. And one of them is like, I don't know if your school ever did this. But they used to tell us in school, when we had a test, like first read through the whole test, then come back and start to take it and I was incapable. And they weren't even, there was one time when they did a test where it was like the last question was don't do any of the questions because it was like a little like, see if you can whatever. And it wasn't just, I don't have time for this, I'm too smart. For this. It was like, it was almost like painful to slow my brain down enough to like read each word without like I didn't. It's like it worked. It didn't work as well. And so like I had to move fast. And I've had that experience with like, if I'm interested in something, I can read about it for hours and hours and hours. But then I'd have like one form for something that I needed to fill out. And it was almost like, I can't make my brain. Like look at each word. You know what I mean? And so all of a sudden, when people are talking about that experience, I'm going oh, that's it shows up here. It shows up here. And I remember one time taking the like self rated score. And actually, let me let's take a break. And I'll tell you about my the existential crisis of my self rated score when we come back, okay. Okay, so let me tell you about myself credit score. So I remember getting to the questions. And there was one where it was like, you have difficulty finishing projects, like you always leave projects undone. And I had recently redone my third floor, we have like a game room slash den slash and I had redone and I got so into it. And I mean, there were so many steps involved. And like, I did it, and I completed it. And I remember thinking like, No, I don't leave projects on time. And so I said, like, No, I don't do projects, I'm done. And then I would like needed to go get a drink or something. And I walked down my stairs. And on the landing of my stairs, were all of the tools and supplies that I had used to redo my third floor three weeks ago, okay. And I looked at it, and I was passing by every single day. And I realized that the Oh, like, okay, in my mind, I completed the project, because the room looks the way I want it to look now. But I never, I always struggled to like clean up after myself or to like, put my hammer away, or like figure out what to do with those two frames that I didn't hang in the room. And it was like an epiphany where I was like, Oh my God, I don't finish things. Like when I'm over it, I'm over it. And it just sits there. And then the other part of it was I like went down, I got my drink. And like you can pick it I was like, like opening my little soda, thinking about it and walking up. And then I like looked in the room. And I remembered that. I mean, I had my mom come in town to help me with this room. And part of that is because I think it's fun to do things like that with my mom. But the other part of it is because I've learned in my life, that when I'm in the middle of a big project, I hit this like lol in the middle, where I don't want to do it anymore. But if my mom's there, she'll be like, Let's just hang the pictures. Let's just hang that we could just do it right now. And I won't want to do it, but I'll do it cuz he's like, let's just do it right now. And then I was like, Oh my God. I do have trouble finishing projects. It's just that I've created all of these like compensatory behaviors. And I didn't even realize like that's why I like my mom to come over when I'm unpacking. That's why I invite my mom when I want to do some big project that when I am doing little projects, I'm never putting things away afterwards. That that's all that same behavior.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 30:01

    Yeah. So recently I started working on an app like an ADHD app. And like, I don't know anything about that, right? I don't know, I don't know anything about tech. I don't know anything about data. I didn't know where to start. And so I had all this big ideas. And I was researching into this and like, figuring out what I wanted to do, and like, in my brain, I was like, Minority Report, I was like, everything is like, moving around, and I'm like, I am a genius. And I, like, couldn't execute any of that stuff. I'm just like, I can't do this. And like, because it gets like, you get so interested in everything. And then it suddenly gets overwhelming. And then you're like, recoil. And so what helped me is exactly what you were doing with your mom, I got my sister involved. And she's the one who's like, a secondary brain doing that executive function for me like, Okay, you made it this far, what are the finishing steps? Let's do this. Let's do this. And like trying to keep yourself balanced. So I think that a lot of people, especially people diagnosed later in life, they might have difficulty looking through that initial criteria, because they're like, their variables are confounded by their compensatory mechanisms. You know, it's like, yes, maybe you would have met criteria, but you do this really well. And so I think that, especially for women, we are very good at masking symptoms. And like societally, it's just not, you know, I think boys get a lot more latitude. And so like, girls, we just have to kind of toe the line and figure out how to make it look like it's working. And so like, a lot of it gets get

    KC Davis 31:32

    when I can see how if you were to go to a psychiatrist that maybe still even with all that expertise, just has that picture of that little hyperactive white boy, like they don't even know enough experientially to ask you past the do you finish projects? Anyone? Oh, yeah. Okay, but do you really like let's talk about what does it look like when you like any, like, it's hard because not everybody that is trained is like really actually super knowledgeable and ADHD. And I remember the other one was the when it talks about the fidgeting, like often fidgets are taps with hands or feet, squirms and seat and I remember being like, No, I don't do that. Like, I don't fidget, I don't tap. And, again, because I was thinking like somebody, some little boy that like, literally can't stop moving. And I remember laying on my couch one time, and I was like, massaging my job, because my job is always really, really tight. And the reason it's really tight is because I tend to tap my teeth together all day long to the beats of songs that get stuck in my head. So I'll be like concentrating, I'd be like, there's like all day. And again, I had another lightbulb moment where I was like, Oh, my God, I can't stop moving. It's just that I had learned as a girl who no doubt had been told, like Casey stop moving. Yeah. And I developed a way of doing it that wasn't visible to others that I wasn't even, like totally aware of. And then I have this one other one, where, because I went to rehab at 16, I went to what was referred to as a therapeutic community. And one of the things that they did there, there's a lot of great things I learned. And there were a lot of things that were like not super helpful. And they tended to take all of my behaviors and make them like a moral issue. And and I learned how to basically like stamp out a lot of behaviors during that time of being institutionalized. And so, when it got too often interrupts or intrudes on others has trouble waiting their turn blurts out a question before it's been answered, talks excessively. So I remember reading those, those are like the social component ones. Yeah. And initially answering note, almost all of them because I don't do those things often. And then I started thinking about my time in rehab. And about like, every week, we got concerns. And they're supposed to be like, addressing behavioral concerns. And the concerns I always got, were like, I never forget, the first one was take the cotton out of your ears and put it in your mouth. And then I got a concern about like, you won't stop interrupting people. And you're so self centered. Like you're answering questions, you'll hear someone ask a question across the room, what time did the van leave? And you'll answer it, even though they're not talking to you. Like you need to mind your business. Or the biggest one was that like, when people would ask me questions, I would answer them before they were done asking the question, and they would say, Casey, you need to stop. You're not listening. You're not listening. And I would say I am listening and they say, Why are you interrupting? And I'd say because I already know what you're going to ask. And they're like, well, that's really egotistical of you, like you're such a No at all. And so all of these behaviors were or couch to me like I was being selfish, self centered, egotistical, arrogant, and don't get me wrong, I was in fact all of those things as a kind of like a shitty drug addicted 16 year old. But actually, it was just ADHD. Like I did talk excessively, I do interrupt people. And so as an adult, I'm sitting there going, Okay, I don't interrupt people when they're asking me a question. But it's because I've learned to bite my tongue, I'm still answering their question halfway through and not listening to the rest of what they're saying. Because if I don't get what's in my head out of my mouth, I'll forget it. And so I have to concentrate on it. So that I don't forget what I'm going to say. But in concentrating on that, I now can't hear what you're saying. And I'm trying to find the socially appropriate time to interject it. And I did not realize that wasn't neurotypical like, I did not realize that that is what that criteria is. I just had learned to stamp out the external behavior, but like, I wasn't actually changing what my mind was doing.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 36:10

    Yeah, I mean, that's so common. And I think that's why so like, when you're looking at masking or obscuring your symptoms, for whatever reason, like whether it's purposeful or not, a lot of times, what you're doing is you're not changing that internal behavior, you're just changing how you respond externally. And so I think that's kind of what what becomes problematic in terms of diagnostic kind of things. Because if you've been masking for so long, it's hard to know, like, Is this a real thing? Is this what I do? What? Because you're looking at your internal symptoms? And so I think that's, it's difficult sometimes for a provider to truly get to the bottom of things, right? Because you're, what there's appreciating and getting data on its external criteria.

    KC Davis 36:52

    So what would you say to someone who is maybe listening to this, or they've seen other things, and they're going well, I kind of relate to those things. Like, what should next steps be at that point, because I think the other thing is like, this is really sad to me, but I've had a lot of people tell me, I brought this up to my doctor. And they said that, you know, because I'm not in school, it doesn't matter. Or because I'm you know, because I am doing okay, at work. Like it doesn't matter. Or if that's just a thing that kids have, like, I've heard that a lot. And so I feel like people are a little bit hesitant to know who they can actually talk to you about it.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 37:34

    So you know, and that's part of the reason like even getting to that spot where you can talk to someone that's such a privilege in and of itself, because a lot of people don't have that access to care. So I say the first step is just educate yourself as much as possible, like, at the base of everything is a better understanding of yourself and your brain. So learn as much as you can about that. And there's so much that you can kind of learn about an ADHD brain and how it's working in how it's functioning, and try to work on behavioral modification that's independent of medication, maybe you're going to be someone who needs to be on medication, maybe you need to do both. But I always like doing that behavioral kind of imprinting and working on those stemming from understanding what your patterns are, because of two reasons. One, it's going to eventually kind of help functioning. But two is just like such a number one validating experience. And two, it gives you a little bit of grace, like, This isn't me, this isn't a moral failure. This isn't like a problem with intrinsically me, my brains moving too fast. And this is what it's doing right now. So I think that gives people I don't know, I think it gives people just this level of comfort and understanding so that they have this judgment free place to grow and expand from.

    KC Davis 38:52

    And then my last question is, if somebody finds that they do meet criteria, or they do they get this diagnosis, and sort of the next question posed to them is, you know, do you want to try medication? And a lot of the feedback that I get from people is, well, I'm not in school anymore. And actually, there's this like, very specific demographic of people. And it's like, stay at home parents, that will say, Well, I'm not in school, and I don't even like go to a job. So like, they kind of feel like that's what medication is

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 39:26

    for. Since when is parenting not a job, right? Like,

    KC Davis 39:29

    I'll never forget my doctor telling me you like to do a tolerance break on Saturdays and Sundays, and up by medication, just like not taking it. And I remember I had to come back like three weeks later and be like, I'm sorry. I'm a mom. I actually have more to do on Saturdays and Sundays, that I need, like my executive functioning for them, like when I'm sitting at a desk. So I'm curious if you could speak just maybe generally about, you know, how do we make those sort of decisions about medication and what can medication help with outside of that sort? a stereotypical like studying,

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 40:02

    I'm not the one who can make that like, right as a practitioner, your job is to educate the patient. But it's like surely like ego, if I'm saying like, I know better when to start medication versus you like the patient is the one whose internal experience really matters. So if they're like, this is what I'm having dysfunction with, I am really having issues kind of moving forward, as long as there isn't anything barring or I'm worried about any, like comorbidity or like medication addiction issues or anything like that. They should be able to say like, Hey, I think I need to start medication because I've done these behavioral modifications, I'm not able to sustain them or keep them up or, or I'm not able to, I have sustained them, and I can't see enough benefit from them. And by the way, like with medications, I think everybody is so like laser focused on stimulants as being the only medication option. There's so many other things besides stimulants that you can treat ADHD with. So I think it's worthwhile having a conversation and just being open and honest with your doctor, like, here's where I am, this is what I've done. This is where the dysfunction still lies, what are my options, and just having that collaborative back and forth.

    KC Davis 41:14

    And I think for me, a big part of it was okay, there, it wasn't a matter of like, I can't do this thing. And so I need medication. So I had this idea in my head that like, if I can't do something, then I deserve or then I like could qualify as someone who can try medication. But it didn't occur to me that like, okay, I can do the thing. But it is taking me so much time, energy and effort. And I'm using three times as much effort to get this thing done, whether it's getting my household tasks done, or paying my bills or returning phone calls that like Okay, I'm getting them done, but at what cost? Like, is it just my baseline productivity that I should be judging? Or, you know, is there room therefore? Wait, you mean, other? Like I said earlier, like wait, other people just decide to do their laundry and then get up? I know, like some it's, like, efficient of water, like you don't know what wet is, if you've been in the water for so long?

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 42:20

    I think it is a matter of just kind of understanding. And honestly, even prior to having discussions with your physician, it's having discussions with yourself and figuring out like, what is this? What am I experiencing? What is this level of dysfunction? Because it's not your job to figure out if it's normal or not, it's a practitioners job to figure it out. But like, deciding within yourself, is this something that I want to discuss and find out more about like, I've had my own suspicions. Let me see if this is worthwhile to me to talk about.

    KC Davis 42:49

    Okay, so this is my actual last question. What could you tell people like, do you have like maybe provider red flags? Like, let's say that they go to their provider? Is there something that if like, let's say, if I came to you as a friend, and I was like, I saw my provider, and they said XYZ? That would make you go? Oh, I think maybe you should go find a different provider. Because I feel like a lot of people are getting really discouraged. And they don't know whether it's Oh, I'm not a doctor, I should just listen or whether it's like, I need to go ask someone else.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 43:21

    So a couple of things that come to mind are stuff we've talked about, like if they're saying you did too well, in school for this to be factor, like, theoretically, I think they're trying to indicate that it's not causing dysfunction. But school is not the only metric for that, right? If they're saying, You're not a kid, red flag, if they're saying things like, you've gotten this far, does it really matter? At this point? I've heard that before. Like, that's dumb. Don't listen to that. Those are kind of some of those things. And again, it's really difficult because like, these are all hypothetical situations, and you don't know what kind of led up into this case. But those are kind of the things that if you're hearing that or if that's kind of the undertone, that you should be like, that may not be accurate. And that might be more reflective over like an underlying, like, either knowledge deficit or just like a bias. Yeah, they might just feel that way.

    KC Davis 44:19

    Yeah, that's kind of those are like the ones where it's like, context couldn't really help a provider saying that,

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 44:26

    like the only thing I could think were was maybe like, it's like, if you had another comorbidity that could be explaining like ADHD symptoms, but even that and like,

    KC Davis 44:38

    yeah, I found that, especially in the realm of really any neuro divergence, like whether I was looking for someone to talk to about a possible autism diagnosis for a kid or my own ADHD diagnosis. Like, I found that I really needed to ask a lot of questions on the front end of the provider and I know not everybody has this privilege. But if you do, really asking for someone and like, how much ADHD do you work with? How what do you know about adult diagnosis? You know, like asking some questions about that, because I found that when it came to neurodivergent issues, I had to find someone that had specific experience in like, current.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 45:25

    Yeah, and also looking on like their websites and things like that. A lot of people they talk about that stuff, if they're passionate about treating it.

    KC Davis 45:32

    Awesome. Well, where can people find you if they want to follow you learn from you tell us everything.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 45:40

    So on social media, so I'm on YouTube, I vine, at tick tock, I'm on Instagram, it's the psych doctor, MD. I'm Dr. D, OC, T, or a book about ADHD is coming out January 3, and I didn't know you hated the term self care, but it's called self care for people with ADHD.

    KC Davis 46:02

    I love it. I don't hate it from you, I only hate and the thing is, is that there's no other term. That's kind of what I hate about it. Like there's no other term. So I do use it, I hate what it has, like come to represent.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 46:15

    So basically, that's kind of like the Oh, because I get it. I'm a psychiatrist, and I'm supposed to talk about medications all the time. But at the same time, I think going through this journey with ADHD, I really understand the benefit of one understanding your brain and to the behavioral modification, because I think that's really important. And so that's kind of the basis of the book. And then that's kind of the bones of of the app, which will be released cut in winter. And that's called Focus GT. And so it's the focus Jamie on Instagram and Tiktok. But basically, that is something that is like just behavioral modification in your hand. So it'll it teaches you about your brain and teaches you about here are things you can actually do. These are areas of dysfunction, what is the term procrastination, like all these different things, and then tools you can use with it, like how to break down your To Do lists, how to do a task timer, how to do body doubling, how to do like having all of those options, so it's, it's like, it's what I created that I should have used in medical school. Like if I had this, my life would be so much better.

    KC Davis 47:22

    I love that. Okay. And the release date for the book is January 2023.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 47:25

    Yeah, January 3, and then the

    KC Davis 47:29

    app. Okay. So by the time people are listening to this, the book will be out. Okay, great. So go buy the book.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 47:36

    If you want to,

    KC Davis 47:37

    please don't hate it. They're not going to hate it. It's going to be good.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 47:41

    Yeah. And then the app will be. So if the book will be out, then the app will be out too. So the app is I've just I'm like, so proud of it. It's so cute.

    KC Davis 47:48

    And what's the name of the app? Focus GD o focus Genie, I already love it. It's so cute. And

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 47:55

    it's got like this little dude, this little focus, Genie. And it's, it's cute. And so like, part of the thing is when I was doing research, and like I for myself was trying to find an app I liked and for like to help me and then to refer to my patients, and every single one I used, I'm like, oh, so boring. Like, I couldn't even get through the trial period. I'm like, I cannot maintain this. This is painful for my brain. And so this is like fun. It's colorful. It's engaging. It's like little hits of dopamine as you're going through, but you're learning at the same time. It's, it's great.

    KC Davis 48:27

    I'm picturing like, you remember the old school like Clippy, the paperclip and Microsoft Word that would show up? I mean, look, can you imagine like, it's like, he shows up and he's like, looks like you're trying to do your homework. We're like, looks like you're trying to do laundry. Do you need some help? I love that.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 48:44

    It's like essentially that there's like a little cartoon Genie that kind of helps and guides you through the process. It's it's the cutest.

    KC Davis 48:53

    Okay, that's amazing. So everybody go out, download the app, get the book. Thank you so much. And this was wonderful.

    Dr. Sasha Hamdani 49:01

    To Well, thank you for having me. I'm so excited. Of course.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

KC Davis
30: Fat Talk with Virginia Sole-Smith

Do you agree that we live in a world that equates body size with a person’s value? What is our society teaching our kids about fat, body size, and a person’s worth? If you experienced body-size shaming as you grew up, don’t you want to do a better job with your children? Parenting around these topics is not easy, and my guest today wrote a book to help us understand more. I’m excited for this conversation with Virginia Sole-Smith, author of Fat Talk: Parenting in the Age of Diet Culture and host of the Burnt Toast podcast. Join us to learn more!

Show Highlights:

  • Why parents struggle with fears and concerns around their kids’ body sizes

  • Why the goal is to have kids who don’t feel anxious about their relationship with food

  • Why we need to think about health as MUCH more than a number on the scale

  • Why, to embrace body diversity, we need to challenge what we’ve been trained to think about health, beauty, and morality

  • How weight distribution matches up with “thin privilege” and anti-fat bias

  • How focusing too closely on our personal weight struggles causes us to reinforce and perpetuate fat bias in the world

  • How our children receive messaging around body types and sizes from healthcare providers, sports coaches, etc. 

  • How to have healthy conversations with kids about bodies, fat, diets, etc. 

  • Why parents need to give counter programming to the default settings our kids receive from society about topics such as body shaming and racism

  • Why Virginia included in her book a chapter called “Straight White Dads on Diets”

 Resources:

Connect with Virginia Sole-Smith: Website, Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, Burnt Toast podcast, and Fat Talk book

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website 

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to Struggle Care. I'm your host, KC Davis. I'm here with Virginia Cole-Smith. And she is an author. She's written a book called Fat Talk. And I got an Advanced Edition. And I'm so excited to have her here on the show today, hi Virigina. Yeah. Hi, thanks

    Virginia Cole-Smith 0:20

    for having me.

    KC Davis 0:21

    I loved your book. Okay. So let me I'll just read back so that people kind of get caught up, okay. Since by the time they reach kindergarten, most kids believe that fat is bad kids learn as we have all learned to pursue thinness and survive in a world out to survive thinness and a world that equates our body size with our value. And there's more here. And so in the subtitle is parenting in the age of diet culture, which is amazing. So I had to tell you that this book was so much more than I expected, because I am someone who I've been on my own journey with diet culture, and my relationship with food and all these things. And I do a lot consciously, to help cultivate a healthy relationship with my children to food. And main ways that I'm doing that now is like making sure I don't comment on their bodies, and implementing like a different way of approaching food, like we don't do clean your play, we don't do eat your broccoli before your dessert. And you talk about both of those things in your book as like, things that we maybe our parents did that aren't helpful, and you tell stories, and you give data to back that up. But what's so interesting to me was like, That is like the whole of the advice. And like the general conversation when you're reading blogs and listen to podcasts, like that's kind of where it stops when it comes to like thinking critically about how we were brought up around food. And I'm curious, like your book goes into so much more, we'll go into that. But I'm just curious if you have thoughts about like, why does it tend to stop there?

    Virginia Cole-Smith 1:51

    You're totally right, it does stop there. I think it's because those feel like two very actionable things that people can kind of wrap their brains around. But even more, I think it's because just making a simple rule of okay, I won't make them finish broccoli in order to have dessert, I can see the research that supports that. That's very cut and dried. That is great. It's important. I really do recommend people do it. But it doesn't ask you to reckon with your own anti-fat bias. It doesn't ask you to go deeper and think why am I pushing the broccoli so hard? Why does the broccoli matters so much? Why is the dessert so scary? Like, what is this actually about? And once you strip away, but it's actually about, it's about the fear that if you are a parent in a larger body, if you have a kid in a larger body, that society will treat you differently and worse than if you were thin. And that having a kid in a larger body especially is going to reflect back on you as the parent as some kind of failure. And so dealing with that, and like pulling up all that by like, oh, super uncomfortable, super hard to look at super difficult work a lot of unlearning, like, yeah, I get why a lot of the blogs and like the kid food, Instagram keeps it to like, Oh, don't make them finish the broccoli.

    KC Davis 3:06

    Yeah, and I also wonder if a part of it is like, every time I've read about like not restricting dessert, it's always about how because when you restrict dessert, dessert becomes taboo, and then it becomes wanted, and then that's what we crave. And we can't have moderation. And we talk a lot about how that can start binge eating or that can start quote unquote, overeating. And a part of me wonders if like in our effort to, like, give our kids a better relationship. Part of why that's like the advice is because we're hoping like, well, then maybe this will work for them to not eat too many Oreos.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 3:41

    Oh, I think that's a big part of it. I mean, very often the way that advice is framed, and I have been guilty of this, I have to be clear in my own content at times, is people will kind of hold up like the bag of Halloween candy a week later, that's still like overflowing with candy. Or, you know, the box of doughnuts that came in the house and your kid actually only one of them or whatever. And they'll be like, see, this is why getting easing up restriction is so great. Because look, my kids can take or leave sugar. And then where does that leave the parent of the kid who actually is always gonna want three doughnuts, and always is going to be the kid who eats their Halloween candy all in one city. And that's just how they're wired. And we don't actually need to demonize that either. And so it's really important to understand that like, actually, the goal for this kind of advice is not to have a kid who has like no emotions in the face of sugar and never craved a cupcake and couldn't like, totally take it or leave it. The goal is just to have a kid who does not feel anxious and frocked about their love of these foods that they can just enjoy them. Like, Yay, it's cupcake time. I'm having one cupcake or four cupcakes, whatever I'm actually feeling in the moment, and then I can move on with my day and nobody made me feel like shit about it and I don't have to feel a whole bunch of complicated feelings about the cupcakes. I can just like have that joy in the cupcake and whatever that looks like for me, which is gonna vary for all of us on any given day,

    KC Davis 5:03

    and you do a good job in the beginning of your book of laying out that for all of the concern we have about our children's physical health, that like fatphobia kind of gets mingled with that, you know, there is a real damaging effect to their mental and emotional and physical health through things like restricting putting kids on diets, making these kinds of body comments to our kids. Because it's not just like, oh, let's do it this way. Because I'm being virtuous. It's like, oh, no, like, if we really cared about our kids health, like we wouldn't be doing these things.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 5:42

    Yeah, no, that's completely apt. We know that the number one risk factor for eating disorders is weight based shaming, and dieting in childhood. And a lot of the way we're taught to engage with kids around food and bodies is both of those things at once. So we really need to reckon with like if health is truly your priority, and so often, health is sort of a dog whistle, it's kind of a coded word for like, actually, I just prefer it than this. But if you're like, No, no, it really is about health, then you have to think about health as much more than just a number on a scale or point on the growth chart, you have to think about health as mental well being emotional health, felt safety, all these other things that really matter and really impact this and the impact the physical health outcomes as well. So it's much more comprehensive way of thinking about kids and health and food. And it's just removing so much shame. It's removing so much pressure. And when you step out of it, it's sort of wild to think that people think that the other way is going to be health promoting, like how would making someone feel like they can't trust their body and can't trust themselves around food and that their body is a problem to solve, like, how would that promote health. And yet that is, like so many of our systems and larger culture built on that model.

    KC Davis 6:59

    I want to read this little excerpt here, it's in the very beginning, an introduction, you say unlearning this core belief about the importance of thinness means deciding that thin bodies and fat bodies have equal value. To do this, you have to know that humans have always come in a variety of sizes, that body diversity is both beautiful and necessary, you have to believe that being fat isn't a bad thing. And that means you have to challenge a lot of what you think you knew about health, beauty and morality. That was such a beautiful passage, because you do this thing in the book where you say, like, Hey, this is like the part of this that's just like, right, in a moral sense, like bringing more justice into the world. And then you also speak to us as parents, when it comes to like, Hey, this is like how to actually promote health with our children. But you also like you don't stop there, you actually go and you have data, and you have the research and you dissect why it is that we think that fat must equal unhealthy and skinny must equal healthy, and you give really good data for that. And I think that's really cool. And then in that I'm going to flip pages, you're gonna hear it the whole time. Here's what I thought was so amazing about this book, like I wrote some notes. I'm all over the place today, but my listeners are used to it. Okay.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 8:16

    I love the notes. I love the flipping.

    KC Davis 8:19

    Okay, so I feel like so for listeners who have never maybe seen me, I am five, two, I'm currently like, maybe 160 pounds. Over the past two years, I have been in the 160 to 180 pound range. And as someone who's five to like, you know, I'm in this weird spot, okay. And I don't consider myself someone who is skinny. And I don't consider myself someone who is fat with a capital F. And what I mean by that is, I don't experience the discrimination and the bias in the medical field. In the social arena. I don't get harassed on airplanes, like I don't experience the kind of discrimination that fat people experienced that are in larger bodies than mine. And what I loved about this book was there were several points that I read, where I really realized, Oh, my God, you have pinpointed how anti fat bias in our culture has harmed me, has hurt me as a child, and has created all sorts of issues in my own relationship to food and my own health and my own sort of relationships there. And one thing that you talked about a couple of times that I've never seen anyone talk about before, and I'm sure they do, and I just have never been exposed to it, but you specifically talked about weight distribution.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 9:40

    Yeah, so that's the concept of Aaron, Harrop, I think is the source in the book, who elucidated that really well for me, and they talk about how, depending how your weight is distributed, you may have more or less thin privilege than someone of an equal body size than you so and I hate this terminology, it comes from women's magazines, which is also where I come from. So I have a lot of feelings about it. But I am someone who has an apple shape for lack of a less ridiculous term. You know, I am I wear plus sizes, I identify as small fat, which is again, in reference of the fact that I don't experience the more extreme forms of fat discrimination, I can fit into an airplane seat, like public spaces are built for me, I can order clothes, I have to mostly shop online in person stores not so much. But like I can get clothes that fit my body, I definitely do experience some weight stigma doctor's offices, like it comes up in different ways. But I have a lot of thin privilege. But having that Apple shaped body means that someone else who's my same way with the hourglass figure is going to have a different set of privileges and ability to access clothes, because their body is much closer to the thin ideal, or the sort of larger beauty ideals we have, which is that like, you know, you can have curves if they're in the quote, right places, but not the wrong places. So yeah, that's the weight distribution piece of that. And it is really fascinating to sort of see it also often intersects quite a lot with class and with race and interesting ways. And so all of these different aspects of fatness, you know, become these kinds of intersecting identities with whatever other marginalization you might hold. And yeah, you know, I mean, and then on the flip side, I'll say like, even though I'm an apple shape, I'm also someone who like, has skinny legs and like skinny or skinny face, that's a weird term, but like, so there's also ways that like, when I post a picture on Instagram, I might present as thinner than I present in a doctor's office. So this is where it can get really maddening. Because you can feel like your body is like this sort of moving target, if you are so focused entirely on like how to other people perceive it. And how does this enable me to move through the world? And I think what's important to take away from that is like, it's of course useful to sort of understand it for ourselves. But it is most important to understand it in the context of the spectrum of fatness. And to sort of take it in, sort of analyze where it shows up in your own life, but then think, Okay, where am I benefiting? And who is not benefiting? When I'm benefiting? You know, who's being pushed out? Because we prize thin rest are small phenolic, all these other weird things that like fall into, you know, how this shows up? And so I just think that's yeah, it can feel like you're really down the rabbit hole. But it's also like definitely happening all the time.

    KC Davis 12:24

    No, that's exactly my experience. And reading your book was, I felt like you pointed out ways in which I had never had articulated that, like, I never was a kid that struggled with weight. But I have always struggled with weight distribution, I felt like my body wasn't the right shape. And so pin connecting that to anti fat bias and some other things was kind of a moment for me of going, Oh, this is how anti fat bias has affected me. But at the same time, he did a really good job of routing me kind of understanding like where I am on the continuum of harm, intersecting with where I am on the continuum of privilege. So I am sort of in that space where the primary impact of anti fat bias in our culture creates emotional distress for me, but with the exception of maybe like mean online comments, like, which is still emotional distress. I don't experience barriers to parts of society that kind of said this early, right. Like I've never been discriminated against for health care. I have never had someone tell me that I can't ride a park ride that I've never had someone discriminate against me for a job, which we know that data shows that fat people are discriminated against for jobs. And so that was really helpful because it was like, okay, validating, totally cool to recognize like where your own wounds are, and important to recognize I am not the one most harmed by this and that this is a systemic justice issue, not just a personal self esteem issue.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 14:00

    Yeah, and I think that's where a lot of the online discourse really loses the plot. I mean, I just did a whole thing on my newsletter about the mid size queen trend on Tik Tok. And it's a lot of straight size women embracing their midsize status, which is to say they're not assigned to, and sort of talking about how this creates perceived barriers for them. But we just have to step back and say like, your personal struggle is real and valid. And you're, you know, any one of us feeling like we don't feel safe in our bodies, like we deserve that safety. We deserve to work on that, and to be, you know, supported through that. But when we leave the conversation there with the struggle of the sort of emotional struggles specifically of thin to small, fat white women, we are really ignoring this larger constellation of issues, and who is really being harmed the most by this and I would also say like for me personally, and I don't know if this will resonate with you, is really helped me let go of my own shit to understand the larger spectrum of this because I don't want to be that weight lady, you know, I don't want to be like pushing other people out of the conversation and centering myself over and over. Like, I can see the harm that causes and so that makes it sound then feel like an act of radical self acceptance, but also a form of social justice and form of activism to say, I'm going to wear you know, like, right now I'm wearing like a sports bra, and my stomach is out. And I am totally, like, fuck that beauty standard. And also, like, that's great for me personally. But that's also like some work I can do on myself that's like, on behalf of this larger thing, I don't want to be a part of that system.

    KC Davis 15:37

    Well, I think it taps into, like, a lot of what my audience resonates with, which is like, we talk a lot about like, Why do I struggle so badly to care for myself, but then I can go do all those same tasks for someone else. And I'm with you, like all of the areas where like, despite really trying to unpack fatphobia, and anti fat bias for myself, and like getting to a place of acceptance for my body, like some of that stuff just won't budge, right? Like, at the end of the day, it's like, just there. However, when I think about what me existing in the world without trying to change myself, how that can push dialogue, social change atmosphere, like how that can push it forward, it's like it's easier to care for others more than for yourself, right. And so I think that that was cool as a parent reading that because you're right, what you said at the beginning, which is like we have to unpack our own stuff while trying to avoid giving it to our kids. Oh, I know what I was gonna say. The other thing that I think is really helpful about the way you rooted us in that intersection of privilege and discrimination, or bias is that a lot of times what I've seen with that mid size, and I guess mid size is what I would say I am as well, is that when we're not aware of what anti-fat bias really is and what it looks like and we're up rooting that we end up using, like the ways in which we try to soothe ourselves and heal ourselves and tell ourselves we're okay. ended up hurting people that are fatter than us. Yes. Yeah. Like we ended up saying, you know, I'm not fat. This is just how like women's bodies were meant to look, we're supposed to have fat around our belly. And it's like, Well, okay, but like some people are fat,

    Virginia Cole-Smith 17:24

    or fat. Yeah, you're still making fat. The thing to avoid this comes up all the time, when I hear from my readers, I'll get these furious emails from parents, because they've just been to the pediatrician. And the pediatrician made a big fuss about their child having a high percentile on the growth chart. And they'll be like, it's so discriminated Tory, it's so wrong, blah, blah, blah. And he's not even fat. Meaning like, this is happening to my like, stocky, athletic kid or my tall daughter, you know, who's big boned. And like, how terrible. It's like, no, not what's terrible about this BMI, what's terrible about the way we you know medicalized way that what you've just experienced is like a tiny taste of what fat people are experiencing. And that's what's terrible. What's terrible is the way that gets weaponized against fat people. And you were just saying me that you don't want your kid to be in the fat kid club. And so that's another way of and that's what it really comes down to is when we stayed too focused on our own personal struggles. Without this larger awareness of our privilege, and the system we're operating in, we will only end up reinforcing and perpetuating the bias more, because we aren't seeing who's not there.

    KC Davis 18:29

    Great. Okay, let's take a quick break for a word from a sponsor, and then we'll come back. Okay, so we've talked about like, kind of some heavy stuff. And you do like, again, you firmly root us in the bigger picture. But you don't stop there. Like, it's not just this heavy read, like you give really practical advice. And one of the things that I think is helpful is that you talk about how much of an impact us talking to our children, about bodies, about their bodies, about other bodies. And there are lots of things that I think we would recognize as harmful. But I think you do a good job of saying even like innocuous comments that you think you're making, that is no big deal, like, are creating these issues, and you do a really great job of once again, making this a book that is not just for parents of fat children, like you talk at length about how this paradigm harms even thin children who will always be thin. And I wanted to just read this little part that you have, okay, and it says, When the adults in my life told me that I can eat as many treats as I wanted as a thin kid. While policing themselves I learned that I was getting away with something there was a certain thrill. But it also gave those foods more power, which made me more obsessive about wanting to eat them. And when I did say eat an entire box of fudge in one afternoon and didn't immediately gain weight. It reinforced my sense that fitness was some sort of innate superpower that I could eat whatever I wanted without gaining weight and was therefore superior to people who couldn't thinness gradually became wrapped up in my sense of self as a talented and successful person. It felt deeply tied to my other achievements, like getting good grades and winning my High School's playwriting competition three years in a row, even though those were goals that I had worked for, and my childhood body size required no such effort. This made it much more difficult to come to terms with my less than and later small, fat adult body. Because I wasn't just buying bigger clothing sizes. I was untangling my identity from thinness, even though the roles that make up my identity now, what writer mother obsessive gardener should not have a body type that is, to me was one of the more powerful things because I resonated with it, I understood it. And it helped me and thinking about talking to my children getting away from this, well, we just don't want to hurt fat people. And it's like, no, we don't want to hurt anyone. And like everyone is really harmed by this. So I thought that was really interesting, because you also talk about how you can engage with medical providers to protect your children from that kind of stigma that kind of weighed, taught that kind of fat talk, and how we should re examine sports for children and how that can be a breeding ground for this kind of messaging. Because it's true that like, there's only so much that we can do with our children, but like the world has an influence. So we need to know how to integrate in whatever that word is. Last point, I have heard so much advice about how to talk to my children about bodies in a good way. You're the first person that I've heard talk about how to teach my children how to think critically about the way society talks about bodies. And it just hit me like, oh, that's the much more important thing that I need to be doing with my kids. The story about the brothers and they were calling one of their brothers, a fat idiot. And the mom says, you know, why do you say that? What do you notice about fat people? What do you notice about why that's an insult? And it was like a lightbulb moment?

    Virginia Cole-Smith 21:52

    Yeah, I mean, I think there's so many layers to this. But I think what often happens is, once parents start reckoning with oh my gosh, diet culture is everywhere. Oh my gosh, anti fat bias is everywhere. You of course want to protect your kid, right? And so you think like, How can I keep them in a bubble? How can I and you know, I'll get emails like, I'm not gonna let my three year old watch Peppa Pig anymore because they make jokes about Daddy Pig's tummy. And I'm like, I agree. It's really annoying that you can't watch a cartoon with your toddler and not having anti fat bias show up. Like I also cringe at the daddy pig scenes. But what if instead, it was a chance to be like, Well, I don't think there's anything wrong with Daddy Pigs. Tell me why is Peppa being so mean to her dad? What do you think? And like, just start having those conversations? And like, Absolutely. When I did it with my three year old, it was like, blank stares, what? I don't know, you know, like we didn't. It's not like my child responded with a thoughtful dialogue about, but now that that child is almost 10, I am having her. You know, she brought me her iPad recently, she was playing some like penguin Island game on her iPad. She was like, Mama, check this out. And it was an ad that popped up in the middle of this children's video game for keto weight loss drugs. And she was like, What is this doing here? And again, I had the instinct of like, I want to like throw your iPad into the sea, like, this is why video games, you know, like I had that I just want to protect you from her. But I like took a deep breath. And I was like, Oh, what do you think of that? What are you seeing here? And now it's become this great thing. Whenever that ad pops up on her game, she brings it over? And she's like, can you believe it says expert approved? What experts approving these trucks? How? Why are they thinking kids should take this, you know, and like it's become this opportunity to build skills. And so and I want to be clear, like my parenting is often incredibly flawed. And this is like one victory I've had in the last six months that I'm really dining out on. So don't think of all the answers because I don't. But on that front, I feel like okay, we're building some skills. And both my kids have thin privilege right now. They are in straight size bodies. And I still know how important it is to be interrogating this with them, because they may very well take after me and not always be straight sized. Or they may take after my husband and be straight size forever, you know, Jury's out. Either way, I don't want them to think that thinness is pivotal to their identity, that thinness is something they have to fight to hold on to. I want them to not live because if you think about it, like fitness, and fatness only exist in opposition to one another, as long as we're continuing to pit them against each other. That's where all of these issues come from. And so the more we can do to use fat as a positive term, you know, they're used to me describing myself as fat. They don't think fat is a bad word. It's used in a totally innocuous way in our household all the time. That's what I'm trying to work towards so that it doesn't feel like the scary thing. And again, the rest of the world is out there. They're going to encounter the anti-fat bias in all of the different ways they encounter it. But they're developing the skills to question that and to reckon with that. Another thing I'll say is like even if you have 10 kids, it's important to talk about this stuff. The same way white parents need to talk about racism, right? We need to talk about anti blackness because when we don't do it, we are going to raise kids who have the you know, the culture will fill in the gaps for you. And you want to be out there. Yeah, they're gonna get the default setting, right? And we want to, we want to give some counter programming to the default settings and help them build those skills.

    KC Davis 25:10

    So I know that if someone's listening, and they're maybe hearing this for the first time, or they're, you know, they're maybe they're not as exposed to this kind of push back on diet culture, I'm sure that there is welling up in them that fear of what about their health? What about their health? I don't want us to go into that. Because that's, that can be a whole podcast, there's a lot of resources, I just wanted to bring it up to say that you do address that in the book, like what about their health, like you do a very good job of that. Here's really the last question that I wanted to ask you. In this conversation, I noticed that I am thinking a lot about moms and mothers, even when you say how parents talk to their kids in my head is like moms and mothers, the conversation in the culture is dominated by I used to see my mom talk negatively about her body, or my mom used to always point out my weight, my mom put me on a diet. And there's this really huge emphasis on the impact that moms being screwed up by diet culture, screw up their kids. And that's why I thought that it was so fascinating and amazing. When I got to your chapter, chapter nine, that's called straight white dads on diets. And so can you just talk to us for a minute about this chapter? Why did you include this chapter? And what is this chapter about?

    Virginia Cole-Smith 26:27

    Yeah, I included this chapter. Because exactly as you say, the default setting is to think this is entirely moms and daughters that show. So I also made sure throughout the book to include some stories from boys as well so and gender queer kids like I tried to include a diversity of genders just throughout the book, and kind of a more natural way that I decided we needed a chapter on dads, because I don't think we talk nearly enough about how much damage dads can do in this conversation. And it plays out in a couple of different ways. And I want to be really clear, I'm not shaming any parent in this. I mean, I also talk a lot in the book about how mothers are unfairly blamed. And given all the responsibility for our kids bodies, and like that really needs to change. So I'm not saying like, Okay, now we need to blame dads instead, like everyone's fault. I'm saying, I don't think our culture is giving men like against us straight white men in particular, but all men in some ways, I don't think they're being given a script for how to talk about their bodies in a way that would let them do this work. And so what that plays out as is, men doing things like CrossFit, or counting macros, or doing intermittent fasting, like there is a male diet culture diets that are marketed to men, that is distinct from the diet culture we see marketed to women often. And it's given a kind of gravitas that a lot of the diets are marketed to women are not given in quite the same way. It's often like more science backed and it's, you know, it's people like Jack Dorsey like he's a billionaire tech CEO, talking about intermittent fasting, or, you know, it's these doctors. It's Michael Pollan, who has been given like about like, optimizing yourself as a human. Right, right. And like you're doing it in this like smart, very, like Brainiac kind of way. But it's the same, it's the same thing. At the end of the day, it's rooted in anti fat bias. And all those diets do is teach restriction, which is everything every woman learned in Weight Watchers, it's the same goddamn thing. And I think stripping that back is so important, because when we're giving men only that language to talk about bodies, they then can't talk about the feelings, right? They can't, they don't have the scripts for talking about hating their bodies, and how that's making it hard to function or do you know, the distress that's causing, they're only sort of staying in this very, like, you know, practical, I have to do XY and Z to achieve this body and maintain my body way. And we really see the fallout of that on kids, because they're, of course, you know, looking up to their dad, just like they look up to their mom, they're getting this model set this template aside. And the other piece of it that I think is really interesting is how gendered our labor around food is so that in most heterosexual relationships, it's often the mom who's running point on the feeding and the meal prep, and the cooking and all of that. And that means she's more likely to have started to do some of this work. Because if she's following food influencers, and you know, she's gonna start reckoning with diet culture there. And then meanwhile, the dads are less engaged, right? They're not judged by how their kids eat in the same way. They don't have the same pressure on them. But it means they're not really engaging with this conversation. So then they're showing up to the dinner table and being like, No, you do have to finish your broccoli to have the cookie and not and like expecting that to be given some weight and authority when they aren't actually like they don't have receipts to back that up. And I just think that's also another layer to this that we need, in particular heterosexual men to be taking a much more active role in the labor of family feeding and like management of family bodies and all of this labor and And we need to be working towards being able to have conversations where they can do their own emotional work around.

    KC Davis 30:05

    Yes. Whenever I talk about care tasks, and cleaning, one of the issues that comes up is when it's almost always women that say, this will say, like, I just can't sit down and relax if the house is messy, and there are just certain like seasons of life where like, you can't like if if you never sit down unless the house is perfectly clean, you'll never sit down. And one of the things that I talk about a lot is how I believe that there are lots of women out there with undiagnosed generalized anxiety disorders, because the way in which they are carrying out those anxiety behaviors is culturally accepted for women. Like it's acceptable for a woman to never sit down for her always to be about cleaning for her, you know, and sometimes it's like jokey, and there's a difference between like, Oh, I like to Potter, I have ADHD. And the joke about like, mom never gets through a whole movie, she has to get up and fold laundry. Right, right. And because like, it's socially acceptable for women to be anxious, even in distress and pain, as long as the way they're carrying that out is like cleaning the home. And I feel like this, in some ways, mirrors that like, this is the way like men, I feel like are massively under diagnosed when it comes to eating disorders. Because so many times their disordered eating habits show up as socially acceptable gendered behavior, like you said, like masked as this, like, I'm just optimizing my mind and body and I'm counting my macros, and I'm getting stronger.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 31:39

    I'm training for an Ironman, you know, like, I'm just a triple sport athlete. And that's a normal thing for a 46 year old man to like, I mean, it's not that it's not normal, but like, what about the larger? Like, what about the work that goes into that, and the amount of mental bandwidth that takes for you to do and yeah,

    KC Davis 31:56

    and there's an interesting intersection between those two people when they marry each other. Because what happens is that she becomes very angry that she's carrying the whole load of the house. And he is leaving for four hours every Saturday to go bike. Yep. And so it's this combination of, you know, yes, I'm over burdened as the woman but also some of the overburdening, I'm giving myself because I can't relax and everything's perfect. And then he's in this space of like, yeah, like, I'm kind of avoiding. I'm going biking, you know, and so I should be here for my family. But it's like this, the idea that, like, I can just leave my family to do this without, you know, a reciprocal conversation for four hours. Because leaving to do this healthy thing is like the trump card. Like, who could argue with that I'm going to exercise when it's like, Ooh, maybe there's something else more obsessive going on.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 32:59

    Right? Why are you exercising at that level? Like, what is this? What need is this meeting? And why does it feel similarly? Like, why can you not just sit down? You know, like, it's another version of that I can't sit down until the house is clean. Like I can't I talked to men who are like, one guy in the book, who was like, I can't relax. It's 9pm at night, and I haven't closed my ring on my Apple Watch. I'm gonna go for a run. Like, that's something that's something to look at. But, you know, that's, I mean, he identified it as an obsession. And I think that feels pretty right. But yeah, because especially because it's Amanda. And you know, and you think if your teenage daughter was doing that, you might be like, Oh, I don't know, if my teenage daughter is going out for runs at nine or 10 o'clock at night, I'd be worried. But I'm not worried if her dad does that,

    KC Davis 33:39

    or like your 14 year old going to spend four hours on the treadmill, right? But he's

    Virginia Cole-Smith 33:44

    training for a marathon. So it's fine. Like, and I just want to be clear, because probably there's a lot of like marathon people listening who now want to like, send me hate mail. Like, I'm not saying you can't have a healthy relationship with Rene. I'm saying, in general, in our culture, we are not interrogating these things. And it shows up in a you know, there's things that show up that are worth looking at.

    KC Davis 34:05

    Yeah, I think that's interesting, especially when you find yourself putting that it's not like, you know, biking for four hours is bad. But if you're beginning to put it above priority over other things that maybe should be the higher priority. That's when the conversation happens. Okay, so just to wrap up the book is fat talk, the fat talk parenting in the age of diet culture. The author is Virginia soul Smith, and when does the book come out? It is out

    Virginia Cole-Smith 34:31

    April 25. So anywhere you buy books, there's also the audiobook version is out. And the UK, Australia and New Zealand edition will be out around the same time. So yeah, you can get it anywhere you buy books. And you know, you can also follow me on my substack newsletter, Bert toast, which is at Virginia soul smith.substack.com or subscribe to the burnt toast podcast and I'm on Instagram, Twitter and Tiktok although I am not as good at Tik Tok as KC and all of those is at V underscore colesmith. So,

    KC Davis 35:03

    come hang out. Amazing. Thank you again, thank you for sending me the book and go out and get this book or read it or you know, listen to it while you're doing your care tasks. I feel like it is a really helpful resource for parents.

    Virginia Cole-Smith 35:17

    Thank you. That means so much

KC Davis
29: How to Get Dope Therapy with Shani Tran

Getting therapy and finding the right therapist is super intimidating! Most people aren’t even sure how to begin the process. Besides the fear and stigma associated with seeking help for mental health, therapy can be scary when you don’t know what to expect. One of my friends from TikTok has written a book with tons of practical information and advice about the basics of therapy. Join us to learn more!

Shani Tran is a licensed therapist in Minnesota and Arizona. She wrote the book, Dope Therapy: A Radical Guide to Owning Your Therapy, to validate the anxiety that can arise around seeking counseling. Through her book, she offers guidance for navigating the uncomfortable conversations that can come up in therapy. In her professional work and on TikTok, Shani focuses on education around cultural humility and helping people of color, who have historically been underserved by the mental health community. 

Show Highlights:

  • Why Shani wanted to write her book to make the therapy process less intimidating

  • How Shani’s book breaks down the therapy process, including all the financial information that people need to know

  • Why it is important to be direct in your questions to a therapist

  • How to reframe your thinking around, “Therapy didn’t work for me.”

  • Why it’s OK to tell your therapist how you really feel (they WANT you to advocate for yourself!)

  • Shani’s advice about firing a therapist (Hint: Ghosting them is OK!)

  • Why the therapy room is a great place to practice new communication skills in a safe place

  • Why your relationship with your therapist is different from every other human relationship

  • How teletherapy brings new elements to the therapy process to improve accessibility

  • Why Shani wants to be noticed for her diverse skills as a clinician and not just her work with the BIPOC community

  • The difference in cultural competency and cultural humility

 Resources:

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website: www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes

Connect with Shani: Dope Therapy book (also available at other booksellers), TikTok, and Instagram

Mentioned by Shani: The Gift of Therapy by Irvin D. Yalom

Connect with KC: TikTok, Instagram, and Website 

Get KC’s book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • Unknown Speaker 0:00

    Oh

    KC Davis 0:05

    hello you sentient balls of stardust. This is Struggle Care, the podcast about how to get dope therapy at least that's the episode that we're doing today. I have Shani, with me. And she and I know each other from Tik Tok. And then we you tell us what your qualifications are? Because I don't actually know them off the top my head?

    Shani Tran 0:21

    Oh, yes. So I am a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor in Minnesota. And then I'm a licensed professional cancer in Arizona, same thing, just different letters behind the name. I don't know why every state, they just can't get on the same page. But basically, I have a master's and I am qualified to do therapy.

    KC Davis 0:40

    Excellent. Yeah, I know. In Texas, we call them LPCs. So I never know what to call anybody. And I am chronically underprepared to interview people on my podcast. So thank you for being here. So you wrote a book called How to Get dope therapy. And let me just say off the bat, the thing that I love about your book is how practical it is. Like you spend a good part of the book just explaining the basics. What is a copay? Where can you go to search for therapists? What types of therapy? What do they mean? And I feel like as therapists, we take for granted that people don't know the basics. And

    Shani Tran 1:17

    you know, it's funny that you say that, because if I'm being honest, when I actually had to condense that chapter down, that's chapter two, I had several people read it, and they were like, This is so much information. And I was like, I know what I feel like people need to know this. And it really comes from people coming into my practice working with me, and then me having to explain deductible and then being like, Wait, what are you talking about? I pay my insurance monthly. What do you mean, I now have this bill that's like, 130, I don't understand. And so I was like, I cannot write this book, and not go in depth about what a copay is, what a deductible is how that changes yearly, it starts over yearly, because I feel like I would be doing people a disservice. And then I was like, I can't put this chapter at the back of the book, if people can just get through this chapter. It's so good. Like, I know, it's so much like business and like money, but I'm like, I just need you to get to chapter two.

    KC Davis 2:18

    Well, I think about so many things that can prevent someone from going to therapy, and I am someone who like my whole life, I am chronically insecure about things that I don't already know how to do. Like, if I don't know how a workout class works, like simple stuff. Like I don't know what I'm supposed to do after I walk in. I don't know what I'm supposed to bring. I don't know exactly what everyone's gonna be wearing. I don't know if I'm supposed to wait over here over there. Like, it gives me so much anxiety. I just won't go unless I can bring somebody with me.

    Shani Tran 2:48

    Yeah. And I think that that's important to recognize is because especially if you're someone that is actually no, I want to say I was about to say if you're someone that's going to therapy for the first time, but then I'm like, no, because you can go to a different therapist, and it'd be completely different. So I mean, it can be this anxiety provoking thing, because you're about to be vulnerable, you're about to like lay all your shit on the table. And hopefully this person in front of you creates a safe place. That's so scary.

    KC Davis 3:17

    So when I was in college, I got a theater degree. And in your like, senior class, you had to take this one class, I don't remember the name of it. But it was famous because it had this thing called the wildness project, where you were encouraged to go do something absolutely wild, and then write about it. And it was kind of this idea that like as an actor, you need to be able to sort of get beyond yourself. So all of my I mean, you know, theater students, like we're all so depraved anyways. And so the kinds of things that people would do for this wildness project is like, they go take mushrooms, or they go skydiving, or they would go sit for like a nude art drawing, or they do have an origin. And he had specific rules that like it does not matter. I don't care if it's illegal, I don't care if it's unethical, like go do something, just wild. And so what was funny is like I show up at this point in my life, I've been sober several years. And I'm thinking those things aren't actually wild. For me, I've done most of things. And what I ended up doing for my wildness project was going to a ballet class. And the reason that that was so wild for me is because I always wanted to do ballet, but I hated the fact that I was like 21 and didn't know how to do it. And I felt like I didn't know enough about like, am I gonna be in a class with little kids? Am I gonna look stupid because I don't know how to do it and like, I just won't do things like that if I don't already know how to do them. I don't and so I signed up and I made myself go and I went to several of them and that was my wildness project of like pushing myself beyond my limits. But anyways, it just reminded me of that because I feel like a lot of people are in that boat like they don't want to go to a therapist because they don't understand what it's going to Do you like? And I feel like you lay that out so well in your book?

    Shani Tran 5:04

    Yes. Thank you so much. I wanted to comment, I love that you sort of said that because I think that we, as a society sort of see wild as like drinking and like drugs and like doing these things that could lead to death, like skydiving. And no, my wild is like, being in a ballet class. Because wild essentially is mean, like, unknown. You can do anything wild. If it's unknown to you.

    KC Davis 5:34

    Yeah, and wild is vulnerable. Exactly. I love it so much. Thank you. So what made you want to write a book like this?

    Shani Tran 5:42

    Okay, I'm gonna have to be honest, because I'm trying to think Has anyone asked me this question yet? Okay. So, honestly, I was approached by the publisher, and they were like, Hey, have you ever thought about writing a book? And I was like, yeah, definitely about myself. And so the publisher was like, oh, okay, what about anything else? And I was like, Oh, well, I don't know. And they were like, think about what you do? Well, like, think about what you do well, and I was like, Okay, so like, I literally took like, two weeks. And I remember, I was so nervous the entire time, because getting a book deal has been on like one of my dream, like vision boards. And I was like, I can't screw this up. And I was like, What do I do really well. And I was like, oh, therapy. That's what I do really well. And then I was like, How can I write a book that is unlike any other, like, literally going, diving into the things that I'm not going to lie, some of the things that I wrote in the book, I was very nervous about writing, specifically, the business chapter about co pays and deductibles. Because I don't think that that's often talked about. And what made me fearful of writing about it is I was like, what if I don't know, some insurance company is like, you can't write about this, we have to, like, Take this, but you can't put this information, you know, because knowledge is power. Right? And so I just was really like, I want people to know, as much as they possibly can to be able to make an informed decision about stepping into therapy, and what that looks like,

    KC Davis 7:21

    I love that. And that's only a part of the book is like the business II stuff. The rest of it is like how to get the most out of your therapy journey. And I really appreciate this a couple of years ago, I had someone asked me, How do I find a therapist, and I did like a series of tiktoks, that would like broke it down to like, okay, here are some places you can go in search, here's how you look it up on your insurance. But then the most important thing that took people by surprise was talking about how, for the most part, now, there are definitely people in circumstances where they don't have a choice about what therapist they're seeing. But when you have that choice, recognizing that they might be the expert, but those first sessions are to like you are interviewing them, you are seeing if they're a good fit for you. And people have never heard anyone talk about here are the questions you can ask because there's nothing worse than getting several sessions or several months in with a therapist, and realizing, Oh, this is not the person for me.

    Shani Tran 8:16

    Yes. And I provide a list in the book, there's a list in the book to talk about, like finances. Like I don't think people think to ask the question, okay, I might be coming to you using insurance. But if I lose my job, people don't often think of the financial questions to ask a therapist, for instance, I might be coming to you right now. And I have insurance. But what happens if I lose my job? What happens with us? What does that look like? Do you have a payment plan? What is your self pay fee? If I can't pay that, because I'm in the middle of losing a job? Will you help me look for insurance? That's something that I actually do as a therapist, where if a client loses their job, I'm like, Hey, let's get you on state insurance. You know, you can qualify for that. Now, let me show you how here are the websites. Sometimes I may even do where we sort of have video. And then I share my screen. And I'm like, if you're comfortable giving me your information, I will fill it out for you. People don't think to ask those questions. Because if you lose your job, you lose insurance. And that disrupts the therapy process.

    KC Davis 9:19

    Yeah. And it's good to know ahead of time, whether you have someone and sometimes it's not personal, it might be someone who they're running a private practice, and they just can't afford to do six free sessions. But knowing ahead of time, man, I could probably give you a session to close us out and then refer you to somebody else. Or hey, my sliding scale is full right now. All those sort of things are really important. I always like to ask therapists, when you are looking for a therapist for you personally, what are some of the questions that you ask? Oh, that's a

    Unknown Speaker 9:49

    good one, man. I gotta update my book.

    Shani Tran 9:53

    That's a really good one. If I wouldn't answer that question as a therapist, I think it depends on what I'm going for. So, I talked about my experience when I lost my dog. I mean, you had the pandemic going on. And I remember saying, You know what, I can handle all of this, just don't take my dog. And I lost my dog, the end of 2020. And I had never, this was my first dog. I had never, like put a dog down before it. They don't tell you what that process is like, let me tell you. And so I remember I was like, Okay, I'm not okay, I need to go see a therapist. Now, for me as a person. I've always worked well with sort of like, tell me Stern, you know, that's just how my brain has worked. And then I realized, I was like, Johnny, do you want that while you're grieving? Do you want someone who's stern while you're grieving? I was like, Oh, shit, no. And so for me, and looking for someone that could help me I was like, I actually don't want to feel like I'm working with a therapist, I want to feel like I know a person. And so it actually helped me choose my therapist was I remember in her profile, she mentioned that she loves running, and she was Hufflepuff. And I was like, sold. Sold, I'm sold there. And then I remember going in and seeing her for the first session. And one of the things that I asked her is, it was during the time we were starting, because by the time that I saw therapists, it was around the time of the election. So a question at the time, for me that was important as a black person was, who did you vote for? And I remember feeling scared as hell to ask such a personal question. But at that time, that's what I needed. I needed to feel safe as a black person. And my sessions, and I remember my therapist responding with, well, depending upon how I answered that question, what is it that you're trying to get at? And that's what helped me say, I need to feel safe in this room as a black person. And then I remember, she told me and I was like, okay, okay, actually, what I meant to say was, did you vote for Trump? But I think I asked it a roundabout way, because she was like, she didn't vote for Trump. And I was like, oh, so I immediately recognized, sometimes we ask questions, and we aren't direct, but we know what the answer is that we're looking for. So I learned something through that process. She gave you

    KC Davis 12:05

    such a good therapist answer of like getting curious about what was going on internally with you and wanting to know that, I love that. It's also like one of the first therapist hacks I was ever taught was like, if somebody asks you a direct question, particularly if it's like a challenging one, or one that makes you have some feelings to like, lean into, let's get this communication more direct, like, what are you feeling? What are you worried about? What fears do you have about how I might answer this question? And when that's done genuinely, it doesn't feel like they're like dodging the question, because they do eventually give you the answer. Oh, my

    Shani Tran 12:34

    God. Yeah. And she did. I feel like in school, I really wish they would teach therapists not to dodge answers. Like, I get that it's not about us. But I feel like if a client is genuinely asking you a question, and diving deep and figuring out what are you trying to get out is very important and not dodging the answer.

    KC Davis 12:53

    Yeah, I think one of the things that can be really difficult about sort of interviewing a therapist is figuring out what their biases may be knowing that they're not going to be able to directly tell you that. Yeah, I know what I mean. And so you kind of have to know what to ask. I know that one of my big ones was because I like I went to seminary, that's where I got my counseling degree. I'm not evangelical or conservative, I don't even go to church anymore. But I still consider myself as like, a scribing, to that faith. And so I didn't mind if my therapist was a person of faith. But I needed to know how that was going to impact the way they did therapy with me. And so I found that the question that really helped was, like, I'd say, like, this is what I'm struggling with. And I would say to them, Do you believe that this is a problem that can be resolved outside of issues of faith? Or do you believe that ultimately, I cannot fully recover from this unless there's faith involved? I love that. And, and most counselors will be honest with you, like they'll say, You know what, at the end of the day, when I'm looking at this, I think there's a lot of progress we can make. But at the end of the day, I kind of believe XYZ, or they'll say, like, No, I think we can go this entire process, you know, you can get better. And so it's kind of hard to suss out those internal biases, I think. But it's important, because you don't want to be six months in with somebody before they walked out on you.

    Shani Tran 14:20

    Now you do not. And that can be challenging, too. Because sometimes I feel like when people have negative experience with therapy, it may not be the therapy itself, but the person that was performing the therapy. And so then we sort of take this like, oh, therapy doesn't work when it's like, no, therapy doesn't work with that person or so people are some different. There's so many options out there for therapy, that if it doesn't work for that person, try finding someone else try and then reflect why didn't it work? Was it something they said? Was it how you felt in the session? There's so many different things As to that can lead to why therapy didn't work.

    KC Davis 15:02

    And this brings up another sort of question common I want to bring up, but I'm gonna pause this for a second. And we'll be back after the break. Okay, we're back with Shani, who wrote how to get dope therapy. And I think that it brings up this really interesting like your book fills a really important gap, which is that I think as therapists, we don't talk to clients enough about the therapy process, we don't teach them how to be a participant in therapy. They're just supposed to kind of passively show up and talk about whatever and will steer the ship. But I find that when I bring up things like ask them, what they think about faith, ask them if they've ever worked with this issue before, ask them what would happen if this especially if you bring up they'll say like, Well, I really hate that my therapist did XYZ. And if you say like, Well, did you talk to them about that? Yes. They're like, Well, I'm allowed to do that. It's like that is a therapists failure. If they did not make you understand that you are allowed to push back, you are allowed to ask questions you are allowed to, and this is what's so sad. And I feel like you will totally agree with me is that the heart of the therapy process is not I'll talk about my problems and get advice. It's I'll experience a relationship, we'll all learn to tolerate that sort of rupture and repair.

    Shani Tran 16:20

    Yes. Oh, I completely agree with you wholeheartedly. I mean, I can think of moments throughout the moments that I reflect on, I feel like as a therapist the most when I'm learning to be, as I say, I'm on this continuum of learning to be a therapist, because life is always transitioning, where there was a rupture in my early career days, and I didn't repair it, like those are the moments that I reflect on. And so now when I am working with clients, let's say if for some reason I say like, here's the homework this week, and they're like, Sure, I'm like, do you agree with that? And they're like, I mean, it sounds No, no. Do you agree with the homework? What do you think about the homework? Let me tell you why I'm assigning this homework. Let me tell you why I think this will be beneficial to your process. And I've had clients that are like, actually, I don't really agree with it. I'm like, Cool. Let's talk about why you don't agree with it. Let's talk about what you think might be helpful. I love when clients tell me how they feel. Because I'm like, yes, they're learning how to

    KC Davis 17:25

    advocate for themselves. That's the real work sometimes that's the real word and how

    Shani Tran 17:31

    to, because if I'm being honest, I think that some clients view me as like an authority figure, right? And so being able to challenge that, I love it so much, because as kids, you know, for me, you know, you don't say why you just sort of do what parents say they're the authority, and then that leads in adulthood to not speaking up in meetings, not advocating for PTO. So I love it when a client is like, no, actually, I don't like that great, tell me, because I can't be wrong. I'm just taking an information that you're giving me I can be wrong, your therapist can be wrong.

    KC Davis 18:06

    And I do think that sometimes, you know, I agree with you. It's like, it's not the therapy that didn't work, it was the therapist, that didn't work. And sometimes that therapist wouldn't have worked for you no matter what. But I also know that as a therapist, I'm capable of being more than one way with a client, like, I can be direct, and kind of, you know, I'm that person that you want to have those come to Jesus meetings with, you know, I can do that. But I can also not do that. Like, I also know how to be a therapist that is more a little more passive, a little more curious, a little more soft. And we do the best we can to sort of Intuit what that person needs. But we don't always get it right. And so it's totally okay for a client to say to me, you know, I don't actually like that you are meet you kind of ask challenging questions. I don't like that you interrupt. I don't like that. You always prescribe homework, right? Whatever it is. I remember having to tell a therapist recently, she was working from an act perspective. So it's Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and therapy. Yeah. And a lot of what goes on to that as talking about, like, our expectations, and those sorts of things. I won't go into the whole thing. But she kept talking, I was having some struggles. And she was talking to me about like, well, what are your expectations there? What are your expectations there? And it was really bothering me like I was getting irritated. And it took a couple of sessions for me to sort of identify and bring up to her. Can I talk about the word expectations? And she was like, Sure, I said, it really bothers me when you say that. She was like, okay, and she like got that look, but I know what just like, Oh, I'm so excited, like this is the real work. And I shared with her like I grew up in a really really cultish 12 Step environment for about seven years. And part of what they would talk about is how like, you know, your resentments or just unmet expectations and expectations or just pre resentments and how, like, any time I had a legitimate grievance about the way I was treated, People use expectations like as a weapon of like, Well, did you expect to be treated a certain way? Well, that's on you for your expectations. And I just kind of got gaslit with that concept. And I realized that the reason I really was disliking the approach he was using with me is because not because there's anything wrong with her or with that concept, but because I was feeling that sort of resurgence of my own sort of like triggers around that. And she heard that and was like, That makes perfect sense. And then at like, do you want to talk more about that experience. And then she was able to use different language, she was able to explain it more what she means when she says expectations, and that's not her intention. And she was able to be way more validating because she realized, oh, Casey needs her reality validated heavily. Before we walk into a let's look at what we can control in the situation.

    Shani Tran 20:52

    Yeah. And I think that that's important, too, because I think of it Yalom I don't know if you've ever read the gift of therapy? Oh, it's such a good book. And it's, it's,

    Unknown Speaker 21:04

    I think it's yellow. Oh, my God,

    Shani Tran 21:06

    I might get this wrong. Okay. So in it, he says, the therapist has many clients, but the client only has one therapists. And I think that that is so true. And I often try to recognize like, maybe this is I feel like I've had comments on my tic TOCs, where people are like, what is it about theater and therapists, like there's so many therapists that have been involved in theater. And I think that this is a great example, where theater was my first major, let me say that right now, I am multifaceted in that I can switch it up to my style can be switched up to meet the client's needs. So there are some clients that, you know, I might say, like, how are you doing? And as a formality, they might say, Well, how was your weekend? And I can totally tell that they don't want to know how my weekend is. They're just doing a formality. But there are some clients that are like, how was your weekend? And I can totally tell, they're like, no, please tell me how was it? I'm like, oh, yeah, chill with my kids. And I'm like, okay, great. And then they sort of want to get started. So I can be what the client needs. However, this is recognizing as a therapist, when I am out of my scope of practice, when maybe I recognize for instance, if a client may need EMDR. So I'm explicit and telling them, hey, I want to let you know, I've recognized as a different type of therapy that might be needed here. But don't worry, I can still work with you on some things. But I do think that this is coming up a lot, that I would recommend a different type of therapist, and I will help them find that type of therapist. So it's a juggling act. And I love it so much. Because maybe for me, as a therapist, I just don't want therapy to be so blah, you know, sort of like the person sitting in a couch. No, I've had where I've gotten up and danced with clients. What do you mean, in this moment, we've done puzzles, we've done games, I would love to actually go hiking with clients. But it's definitely something that the client only has one therapist,

    KC Davis 23:03

    I worked with a couples counselor way, way while back. But he was one of the best counselors I've ever worked with. And one of the things he did before he would even see us was, first of all, I want to normalize couples counseling for everyone, it can be so life changing with a good therapist, and you do not have to wait until your marriage is like on the rocks are in trouble, like this should be one of your first lines of defense, if it's in your budget, when you come to that sort of like this is something we can't get past. Because what I find is that the thing you can't get past is the thing you're never going to get past in your whole marriage. Like you don't go to therapy to learn how to get past that issue. You go to therapy to learn how to stay in a loving, respectful dialogue with someone and make a livable life with someone that you love knowing that this might be the issue that kind of comes up for us over and over. Like how do we learn how to do this in a way that doesn't erode our relationship over time anyways, but one of the things that I think made him so good was that he sat me down and was like, I have some questions to ask about. And because I was a therapist, he was kind of direct with me about like, where you feel some of these issues were coming from and basically what it amounted to was, he was trying to discern if any of our issues were trauma related, like, you know, a sexual trauma or domestic and he basically said I have an approach, and it's super efficient and successful, but it is outside of my scope to work with someone who has like certain types of trauma. This approach will not be helpful if someone has this certain types of trauma. And I so appreciate and respect to that he understood his scope of practice. He was proactively trying to make sure that he was going to be the best therapist for us. And I think a good therapist will always be open to being pushed back on to you asking questions. We'll be asking their own questions. I want to pause right here because I have another subject I want to get into after the break. Okay, we're back from the break. And I have well, it's really two questions. Well, it's a question and a comment. The first one is, this is like one of the number one questions that come up on my page is how do you fire a therapist?

    Shani Tran 25:17

    Oh, okay. Let me give you all the details. Okay, the first thing I want to do, first thing I want to say is, why do you want to fire therapists? I know that's not answering the question right away. But I really want people to reflect on why you want to fire the therapist, after you figure out why it is that you want to fire the therapist asking yourself, Is this something that I can talk about with the therapists why I want to let them go after you figure that out? And you're like, Okay, nope, I don't want to talk to my therapist about it. I don't want I just want to fire them.

    KC Davis 25:46

    You can ghost Thank you. That's my answer.

    Shani Tran 25:49

    I know that like ghosting has like a sort of, like, negative connotation to it and sort of like relationships. But those are different than a therapist relationship. And I say that ghosting is okay, because maybe something happened in the session that you feel as a person cannot be repaired. And that is absolutely. Okay. I also want to say, it is okay that if you go see a therapist, and later on, you're like, Oh, I think I might want to go back. Please do not feel any shame. With reaching back

    KC Davis 26:23

    out. I have never had hard feelings about never,

    Shani Tran 26:25

    I have never I'm like, Oh my God. What happened? What's the team? Where have you been? wasn't something I did, like. So it's okay to do that. I just want to normalize that. That's okay. The other ways to do it is if you feel like it's something you're like, I want to let them know, I kind of want to talk about it. But I don't really want to do it in the session, you can email them. I did that. I tried to fire my therapist, I emailed her. And long story short, it had to do with her scheduling. She wasn't the type of therapist that you get on the schedule. And then it's sort of like a rotating schedule. You're always on the schedule every Tuesday at 2pm. And when I had asked her in the session, I was like, Yeah, I'll just take every Tuesday at 2pm, I saw her face change. And she just had never been put in that position. And so I was like, Oh, what is it about me getting on your schedule that your face change, and I. And so like, I sent her emails like, Hey, I don't think we should work together. And then my therapist, because this was like our second meeting, she then called me and was like, Hey, I'm gonna give you a free session. So we can talk about this, because I want to explain what happened. And I'm sorry that you felt that way. So knowing that email is acceptable, and that's okay. The other way that you can do it is if you want to call them or you can do it in the session, or texting, I don't know if some therapists do texting. But that is an option as well. And also knowing to, let's say, if you feel like you're someone that needs emotional support, it's okay to bring someone to the session with you for support to talk about that. I just want to like, I don't think people think about that, like, Hey, I might need my support person here, you can do that.

    KC Davis 28:07

    I love that answer. That is exactly the answer I give I say that, like, if it's the difference between you, like continuing to go to therapy that's not working for you. And getting a therapist that does work for you just ghost them. And then I think just like what you said, recognize that if you are ready, if you're in that place, being able to communicate to them can like that you want to sort of wrap up the relationship, it can be such an incredible opportunity to practice those skills in a safe space. Right like a most of us need to practice those skills of sort of, you know, distress tolerance and being okay in conflict and standing up for ourselves and advocating and, you know, we don't want to walk away and feel shame about it. Like that is one of actually the perfect places to do that. Because it's a relatively safe, even if your therapist has a reaction that you don't like, chances are, it's not going to be some sort of totally off the wall unsafe reaction. And it's just such an invaluable moment to practice those skills. And so I encourage people to look at it that way. And then say, but if you're not in that place, if doing that is going to be what stands in the way of you going and getting therapy that works for you just goes to them. I also say like you can just go get your new therapist and then work with your new therapist about how to talk to your old therapist.

    Shani Tran 29:30

    Yeah, that's totally valid too. I mean, there's so many different things that you can do when it comes to finding a therapist. But one thing that I do want to say is that you might have unhealthy relationships with people but the relationship with your therapist that is supposed to be healthy. So if there's anything in that relationship that is unhealthy, figuring out what made it unhealthy, and if it has to do with the therapist, then it's okay to go stem but knowing that I want to say that the relationship with your therapists, it's supposed to be healthy.

    KC Davis 30:01

    Yes. And it's supposed to be explicit. That's one of the like, going back to like, we don't do a good enough job teaching clients what therapy is supposed to look like. Most relationships are not explicit, like, if you and I were to become really good friends, and we were to go to lunch sometime. And if something were to happen, where one of us felt some type of way, like, we would probably bring that up, be like, I felt some type of way, when you did this, can I check in? I felt awkward about it, or what were you thinking, and like, that would be really comfortable. I mean, it's not a comfortable situation. But we could both really tolerate that. I even did a recording with another therapist who we had, like, disagreed about something online. And we had this conversation about what did you feel when you saw my messages? Well, I felt angry. Well, I felt annoyed. Well, what I felt was, and we were able to talk about that sort of thing, in the confines of sort of still extending respect to each other. So like, that's totally normal for us. And I don't think we do a good enough job of explaining to clients like, that's how your relationship with your therapist should be, like, you shouldn't be having this. Like, I kind of thought she said this, or I kind of didn't like that, like, she's the person that you go, or she or he or they, they're the person that you go to, to go, I was talking to my mom, and I kind of thought she said a certain way, like that's that person to make everything explicit to say, I'm so nervous to say this, I'll never forget, talking to a therapist, I was made to go to therapy when I was in therapy school, did you want to do that too?

    Shani Tran 31:34

    You know, it's funny, I did not have to do that. But we had a class. So it was group therapy. And I remember the, the way that the professor taught the class was like an interpersonal relationship, it felt like therapy, because I remember, like, I was like, every time I leave that class, I was like, Oh, this, so we had to do group therapy for the class, and the professor would call you out on your bullshit. weren't being real within the group. And she called me out a few times. And I was just like, I remember I was like, I'm gonna fail this class.

    KC Davis 32:08

    Well, they made us go to six sessions. And I didn't really need therapy at the time, and I didn't want to pay for it. So I just went for someone on my insurance, just someone off the list. She was not very good, bless her heart. But at one point in the session, I was talking about, like a really important relationship in my life. Remember, it was like a best friend or something. And they were like, Hmm, sounds like and then they made a comment about my friend. And she was attempting to, like, validate me be on my side. But I didn't like the words that she used. And I didn't say anything at the time. But when I came back, and I remember having this perspective of this is not really a great therapist, I'm not getting a lot out of it. But you know what, I'm going to take this opportunity to, like, do this slightly uncomfortable thing, because that'll be good for me. And I remember saying, Hey, I wanted to bring up that in the last session when I was talking about my friend, like getting into an argument. And you made that comment that my friend was, you know, I don't remember what it was. I said, that really made me uncomfortable. I felt in that moment, defensive of my friend. And she was totally receptive. She was like, interesting. She was like, Well, I think sometimes. And she gave what, oddly was some pretty insightful feedback about some I don't even remember the feedback now. But it was something helpful about, you know, we can be angry with someone, and sort of possessive of them at the same time. And it can be really difficult to navigate relationships where you feel like you have to protect everyone. Yeah. And I remember being like taking,

    Shani Tran 33:37

    I mean, it feels that way. Because if you think about it, it essentially, like you're telling the therapist what's happening, it's like, but you don't know my friend, you to call my friend out. It's kind of like, I feel like the protective relationship where it's like, only I can make fun of them. You cannot. So if I'm coming to you, you laugh, that's all you do. It can feel very, like protective and defensive. But knowing too, that the relationship with the therapist is not quid pro quo. They're not your friend. It's one of the few relationships in your entire life where you get to take take, take take, take, take take, take as much as you need, take as much as you need, and not expect anything in return. Not Oh, is it okay that I use that word? Is there a different word that you would like me to use instead of expect?

    KC Davis 34:24

    No, you're fine. I'm great with expect in this context,

    Shani Tran 34:29

    okay. I just wanted to make sure that's the one relationship where take all you need. Go ahead. It's the therapist is job and I say this to my clients, because I feel like sometimes clients are like, I don't want to burden you with like, my stuff. And I'm like, it's my job to take care of me to take care of you. That's why I take vacations. So don't you worry about what you say and whether or not is burdening me don't worry about that. I got me and you

    KC Davis 34:56

    that's why that emotional health piece comes in. It's so important and you know, It made me think also of when we're talking about like, you know, she responded that way about my friend, which didn't work for me, but might have worked for someone else. Maybe somebody else really needs to be validated because their whole life they've never been validated. And it makes me think about when I love talking about like, has a therapist ever done something that made you uncomfortable? I like to ask that question sometimes. Which by the way, I think as a therapist, a great first question to ask in a session is Tell me about your past therapy experiences? What did you like? What didn't you like? Yeah, let's talk about so I can know off the bat, what doesn't doesn't work for you. What's so interesting to me is that I will always get this same comment. And I get both sides there for every person that says, I told my therapist about my trauma. And they cried, and it made me so uncomfortable, like this is now I feel like I have to take care of your feelings. And like, it didn't work for them. But what's interesting is for every comment like that, I also get a comment that says, When I told my therapist about their trauma, my trauma, and they cried, like, they didn't make some big blubbering mess, but they tears came to their eyes. And they just asked for a moment, it was the first time I realized what happened to me wasn't normal. Like, I had never actually been in front of someone showing me human empathy. And that human empathy sort of rocked this normalization of the way I had been treated. And was what made such an impact and was so helpful to me. And that's like the perfect example of like, both sides of the coin, because some clients need that and want that, that someone cares for me. Wait a second, especially if they're laughing about it, and you just refuse to laugh with them? Yeah, yeah. And you give them not refuse. Like, I'm gonna hold it out. But you just give them a moment of what would it be like, if I didn't laugh with you? If I was like, You're laughing, but gosh, that makes my heart hurt. Like some people really need that humaneness. But then other people probably as a result of their trauma, like, they don't need someone else's emotions in the room, because they can't have their own emotions in the face of somebody else's. Like they need that blank slate therapist. Yes,

    Shani Tran 37:05

    yeah, it might take them out of their window of tolerance, it might say, and I think that that's important to recognize. So something that I like to do sometimes if I can see a client, sort of, because I all of my sessions are held through telehealth is, I might say, Would you like me to turn off my camera? Because I feel like sometimes they want to not see me. And that's one of the benefits of telehealth for them to tell their story. And I can say, Hey, I see you do you want to turn off your camera? Because sometimes, you know, like, when you're looking, you're looking at yourself, too. And so that's helpful. And the other thing too, is that I don't think people understand or not understand. That's not what I want to say, I don't think people sometimes know that therapists can be uncomfortable and nervous to like, when I get the first time I have a first session with a client. I'm always very nervous. And the reason why I'm very nervous because I'm respectful that what did it take for this client to get here and make this step to come to therapy, and oh, my God, I don't want to fuck this up. I don't want to screw this up. I don't want to take this. And then I'm getting to know someone. And that can be very sort of like, I'm respectful to the vulnerability of someone coming to therapy, but also in that too. Sometimes, for me, as a therapist, I'm okay with being uncomfortable. Like, if we're in a session, and I'm like, Whew, I know what I need to say here. Like, there's so much that's going on. I feel like in my brain where it's like, okay, I could take it this way. But can they handle it this way? Maybe I just need to stop check in. And sometimes I can feel uncomfortable to with just restating what they said, like, oh, my gosh, I'm gonna restate. So you said that hurt your feelings? What are you gonna respond to that? Like, I mean, it's a very sort of like, beautiful, messy, uncomfortable, unsure, uncertain, but validating, there's so many words that you can use to describe therapy, and it's up to the two people, the therapist and the client or family, everyone in the room to figure out what is going to work for this relationship.

    KC Davis 39:14

    It's really a practice relationship. Like at the end of the day, it's not really that much about what you're talking about, or what issue you come in with or like advice that they get, like, it's truly a practice relationship for most therapy modalities, like it's a person to practice on that is going to be safe that is going to hold your space that is not bringing their needs into the room, so that you can figure your own ish out and I I will say like, the pandemic added some things around teletherapy that I hope stay. The first therapist I worked with in the pandemic was a postpartum specialist. And she did hers via phone call. All Okay, not even like with a screen. I've never even seen her. And so I would literally be and my kids were so young, like so young. They didn't understand what I was. Saying, and so I'd be at the park, pushing them in a double stroller with Apple air pods on, or air buds or whatever they're called right? And I'd be moving, I'd be walking, I'd be keeping my kids comfortable and not screaming, and she'd be talking to my ears. And there was something about that. That was like, Man, this is actually really nice.

    Shani Tran 40:23

    Yeah. And I think that that the accessibility, that's what it really gives people, you know, not having to sort of like, okay, let me shift my schedule around. Because sometimes some clients I see on their lunch breaks, it just really allows it to be a part of your day and not having to be sort of at the beginning, or at the end, whatever works for you, you can have, I don't even think that people know that you can actually, if you want, you can have 30 minute sessions, if some therapists offer them mostly self pay, I don't think insurance covers over 60 minutes. So you can have like 90 minute sessions, you can have 45 minute sessions. Yeah, it's sort of like, I want 30 minute sessions with this client, or sorry, with this therapist, maybe 45 minutes over here, maybe like you really get to curate what you want therapy to look like.

    KC Davis 41:09

    And as often like, it doesn't have to be every week, some people go over to some people go once a month to check in. I feel like accessibility is something we don't talk enough about in counseling school, particularly around like, a lot of the way we talk about connecting to clients, is really neuro typically cold coded, like we should be offering to clients and the outset, like, are you comfortable with eye contact? Would you be more comfortable without eye contact? Would you rather sit next to each other? Would you rather do telehealth? Would you rather do phone call. And there is something to be said about like, when I have a person in front of me, I can observe their nonverbals. And sometimes that gives me a better picture of what's going on. But that should never come before what that person needs to be actually vulnerable and do

    Shani Tran 41:55

    work. And that's so important. I mean, I'm hoping I've been out of my grad program for like, what is it 12 years? Well, I'm hoping that it really has changed, because I remember having that one multicultural class. And that was the thing that was like, yes, now you can work with everybody. And it's like, no, not really, that's not how this works and operates. And that's been a part of like, just my learning journey. Like I remember in one of my jobs, I was one of the only black clinicians and I remember, I ended up asking my supervisor one time, I was like, Are you only giving me black clients? Because I feel like yes, I get that, you know, you want to give them someone that looks like them. But what about my skills, I really want to be noticed for my skills, all the other therapists get clients based on their skills. But then when you sort of present the client, to me, the first thing you say is yes, they're a person of color. I don't think that's fair to me as a person of color and as a clinician, because just because I'm a person of color doesn't mean that that's what's going to connect us. And I get how important that is. And so that honestly, if I'm being very truthful, that was very hard for me to speak up, because it almost felt like the one thing that I stand for is the bipoc community. But also at the same time, that's not what I want to be only noticed for, I want to be noticed for my skills as a clinician, that's how I grow. And so I remember that experience and being like, that doesn't qualify me to work with every person of color, because I'm the only person of color on the team. That's so great.

    KC Davis 43:29

    Yeah, turning, like taking a client or not taking a client, like referring a client out from bias is different than referring a client out from humility. And the same thing, like referring a client to someone because of your own stereotype is different than referring someone to someone because you have intimate knowledge of their skills, where like connecting from a marginalized community is just like one spoke on the wheel, right? Like you can't ignore all the other spokes be like, oh, yeah, they're a good fit. Yes,

    Shani Tran 43:59

    yes. And I think what you said is important. So one of the things and I talked about this in the book is like the difference between cultural competency and cultural humility, cultural competency, you know, that sort of shine, or I don't want to say shines light that sort of pays attention to the differences, whereas cultural humility pays attention to not only the differences, but how to also communicate with those differences. And cultural humility is a lifelong process. Whereas cultural competency, often sort of is like, we taught you this class, we have this diversity inclusion meeting. Now you're culturally competent, and it's like, now let's talk about cultural humility. And I feel like that's a term when I was in grad school, that term wasn't even used. It was mainly cultural competency. And I remember having like, I remember reading in a book and there was a section on Asians there is a section on LGBTQ plus there is a section on black people and it was like, This is what you're giving people as their training. And then every other class is about how to therapy as white people, yes, exactly. And it's like, I remember being so just like, anxious in my multicultural class because as soon as a topic for, you know, a person of color came up, everyone's like,

    KC Davis 45:14

    Oh God,

    Unknown Speaker 45:15

    and I'm just like, hi. Oh my god, like

    Shani Tran 45:18

    I remember so, short story. I remember for one of my papers, I wrote, I was like, it's great that we're talking about our experiences. But this isn't enough. We now have to figure out how to take action. And I'll never forget my professor wrote on my paper, we're not ready for that. And my multicultural class, and I was like,

    KC Davis 45:37

    Who? You said the quiet part out loud?

    Shani Tran 45:39

    I was like, oh, so why am I why are we taking this class?

    KC Davis 45:44

    Yeah, that's sad. Oh my goodness. Well tell everybody where they can get your book. Yes.

    Shani Tran 45:49

    So you can get the book at Barnes and Noble you can get it@walmart.com And of course if you would like to Amazon that is where this available

    Speaker 3 45:58

    Walmart I'm not even in Walmart. Oh, yes. Yes.

    KC Davis 46:02

    Oh much a big good yes.

    Shani Tran 46:04

    I Google it. That's how I find out like I recently found it on Urban Outfitters.

    Unknown Speaker 46:12

    How does this even like work?

    KC Davis 46:15

    That's amazing. And where can people find you online? If they want to follow you on your socials?

    Shani Tran 46:19

    Yes, if you want to follow me on my socials, everything is the Shawnee project. I would say if you want just sort of like the mental health videos, you can find me on Tik Tok. If you want to know me personally, you can find me on Instagram. And if you want help throughout your mental health journey, you can join me on Patreon where I actually give you printouts homework, how to navigate therapy, like actual talking videos, Tic Tac is more like, that's where I have fun dancing.

    KC Davis 46:45

    Awesome. Well, thank you so much. I thought this was a great conversation. And you have written a great book. So thank you again.

    Shani Tran 46:52

    Thank you so much for having me.

KC Davis